Primo's Famous Pizzeria
Pizza · Avenel
About Primo's Famous Pizzeria
Primo's Famous Pizzeria stands as a beloved local gem in Avenel, offering authentic comfort food and exceptional pizza crafted with genuine pride. Guests consistently praise the friendly, respectful staff who ensure every dining experience is warm and welcoming. The menu features delicious signature...
Primo's Famous Pizzeria stands as a beloved local gem in Avenel, offering authentic comfort food and exceptional pizza crafted with genuine pride. Guests consistently praise the friendly, respectful staff who ensure every dining experience is warm and welcoming. The menu features delicious signature dishes that rival the best in Brooklyn, served fresh and hot whether you choose to dine in, grab a quick bite, or order for delivery. With convenient parking right out front and flexible hours open daily from 11 AM to 10 PM, this small but mighty slice joint caters to solo diners and families alike. Known for its reliable quality and heartfelt service, Primo's remains an absolute treasure for anyone seeking a quick, satisfying meal in a neighborhood that feels like home.
What Customers Say About Primo's Famous Pizzeria
Primo's Famous Pizzeria (aka Joe Joe's) is praised for delicious pizza, especially the sauce and crust. Many reviewers highlight the friendly and respectful service. Negative reviews mention inconsistent food quality, cold deliveries, and order issues.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Order directly from their website for fast service and easy ordering. Be aware that it's a small store, primarily for takeout and delivery.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Primo's Famous Pizzeria
Primo's Famous Pizzeria is located in Avenel, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Calvary Presbyterian Church (A 441m) — church building in New York, United States of America Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Religious Buildings
- Sacred Heart Church (A 301m) — church building in New York, United States of America
Parks & Gardens
- Lawrence C Thompson Memorial Park (A 163m) — park in the United States of America
- Walker Park (A 914m) — park in the United States of America
- Prall Playground (A 965m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Primo's Famous Pizzeria
Primo's Famous Pizzeria Avenel Reviews
Local neighborhood "slice joint." Good food, nice people.
Super friendly, super respectful, and the pizza is finger licking delicious
Not sure what the negative reviews are on about. First tried Joe Joe's through the Too Good To Go app and became a repeat customer. An absolute gem of a place. Pizza has always been consistently delicious and never had burnt bits, always an even bake. I'm usually a super thin crust girl but I guess you guys have converted me! Good balance of cheese to tomato for me (tho my husband would order extra cheese so it's all subjective). The Hawaiian is my favorite - lots of flavor. (I'm from New Zealand, we put pineapple on our pizza, get over it 😁). Garlic knots have plenty of garlic and not too dark or hard. Salad was fresh, no brown pieces and a good size. Price wise, you can't beat it: $16 for an extra large 18" cheese pie 1/2 pepperoni? Definitely recommend.
Food is always fresh and delicious. The service is great, and the workers and servers are very friendly and respectful.
The guys over at joe Joe's are great people you can tell from the first bite the food is made with love they put their pride in everything they make every dish I've had so far is great and their very fair ty guys for all the great food and pizza
I'm originally from Brooklyn, but just moved here to Staten Island about 5 months ago..Brooklyn indeed has the best pizza in the world.. However, Joe's pizza is right up there with Brooklyn's pizza in my book.. The sauce is mind blowing and so is the crust.. Plus you can't beat the great prices...If you're looking for the best pizza in Staten Island..Look no further baby.. Joe's Pizza Rocks!!!
oh my God, they are amazing. We are in a massive thunderstorm and they ordered for our hotel. They are amazing and great people. The food was amazing. We’re blessed to have had dinner tonight because they were open to the public and willing to drive through a whole snowstorm!! thank you we love you👏👏💕💕💕❤️❤️💯💯
If your in the area stop by Primo’s Famous Pizzeria. You can order on the website. It’s very easy to use. I appreciate the fast service. It’s a small store. Parking spots right out front. It’s right across the street from The school. This spot is perfect if you’re in the mood for Italian food. The pizza was good. Affordable. And the staff here was kind and generous. Thank you for satisfying my belly. It really hit the spot.
oh my God, they are amazing. We are in a massive thunderstorm and they ordered for our hotel. They are amazing and great people. The food was amazing. We’re blessed to have had dinner tonight because they were open to the public and willing to drive through a whole snowstorm!! thank you we love you👏👏💕💕💕❤️❤️💯💯
Super friendly, super respectful, and the pizza is finger licking delicious
If your in the area stop by Primo’s Famous Pizzeria. You can order on the website. It’s very easy to use. I appreciate the fast service. It’s a small store. Parking spots right out front. It’s right across the street from The school. This spot is perfect if you’re in the mood for Italian food. The pizza was good. Affordable. And the staff here was kind and generous. Thank you for satisfying my belly. It really hit the spot.
Food is always fresh and delicious. The service is great, and the workers and servers are very friendly and respectful.
Not sure what the negative reviews are on about. First tried Joe Joe's through the Too Good To Go app and became a repeat customer. An absolute gem of a place. Pizza has always been consistently delicious and never had burnt bits, always an even bake. I'm usually a super thin crust girl but I guess you guys have converted me! Good balance of cheese to tomato for me (tho my husband would order extra cheese so it's all subjective). The Hawaiian is my favorite - lots of flavor. (I'm from New Zealand, we put pineapple on our pizza, get over it 😁). Garlic knots have plenty of garlic and not too dark or hard. Salad was fresh, no brown pieces and a good size. Price wise, you can't beat it: $16 for an extra large 18" cheese pie 1/2 pepperoni? Definitely recommend.
The guys over at joe Joe's are great people you can tell from the first bite the food is made with love they put their pride in everything they make every dish I've had so far is great and their very fair ty guys for all the great food and pizza
I'm originally from Brooklyn, but just moved here to Staten Island about 5 months ago..Brooklyn indeed has the best pizza in the world.. However, Joe's pizza is right up there with Brooklyn's pizza in my book.. The sauce is mind blowing and so is the crust.. Plus you can't beat the great prices...If you're looking for the best pizza in Staten Island..Look no further baby.. Joe's Pizza Rocks!!!
For the most part, the food is good and the prices are right! I have had a few issues in the past, but they were resolved quickly and professionally.
Dimitriy died and went to pizza heaven! A pie for only $11! Very nice! I liked this pizza more than I expected to. Better pizza than Roadhouse. Be on the look out for a name change for this place. Not a great spot for dining in. 4 seats! Definitely a to go kind of place. They deliver! I rated it a 6.7. Disrespectful Doug gave it a 2.3. His scale is broken.
Dimitriy died and went to pizza heaven! A pie for only $11! Very nice! I liked this pizza more than I expected to. Better pizza than Roadhouse. Be on the look out for a name change for this place. Not a great spot for dining in. 4 seats! Definitely a to go kind of place. They deliver! I rated it a 6.7. Disrespectful Doug gave it a 2.3. His scale is broken.
I order from here all the time. I live 2-5 mins away. I always ask for extra crispy everything. Anytime I order mozzarella sticks, they are cold & half cooked. My fries half the time are soggy. No store credit, no refund, no we will send another order. I think the workers are amazing but when I’m hungry & my food doesn’t come right, I waste money throwing it away
I order from here all the time. I live 2-5 mins away. I always ask for extra crispy everything. Anytime I order mozzarella sticks, they are cold & half cooked. My fries half the time are soggy. No store credit, no refund, no we will send another order. I think the workers are amazing but when I’m hungry & my food doesn’t come right, I waste money throwing it away
It’s obvious the oil is old and dirty I have no idea why the cheese look like this.the pizza isn’t bad or price but these mozzarella was not edible !
You sick you guys don't know how to treat a food you don't know how to treat a customer and delivery boy not professionals
I ordered 3 large pies and 2 liter diet coke. The coke came unsealed and they add water to it to make it look full bottle It taste like water and when I called the store the guy told me that was my last bottle i have here i will call the company and tell them. SMH
DO NOT GO THERE I live close by from this pizzeria I am never going back! I called for a large pie 25 min in advance I show up they gave my pizza away they constantly do this. He said wait 8 min I am coming here from work tired that’s WHY WE CALL. I’m done wit this place.
I don’t know why I even gave them another chance.. the delivery always takes forever and the pizza needs to be microwaved to eat. Even in 80 degrees the pizza still came cold, the cheese didn’t even move, probably because the delivery guy took over an hour and wasn’t kept inside a heating bag.
This place makes the worst food ever. I called them to complain about fries, and they just said that next time you get free fries.. I don't need free food. All I want is an apology for the food. Those fries were old, and they warmed it in the microwave.
They don't keep their word. Don't trust them. My mistake to trust a shop in a very bad neighborhood. Police everywhere.
Just a friendly reminder how much reviews impact a business cause they always seem to be untouchable. I was on DD looking for pizza, saw Joe Joe’s; ok good prices. Searched on Google, terrible reviews. Instead of replying to every comment, how about actually do good on your part & fix the problem itself so you don’t get negative reviews?
So this is my local pizzeria, I’ve been ordering from them for quite some time... ALWAYS with some kind of inconvenience. I call today and place a order to find out that the owner is WRITING MY DEBT CARD NUMBERS ON PIECE OF PAPER! When confronted he simply gave me a sob story, even after on several occasions I told him I have had issues in the past with stole debt numbers. He just brushed me off with a “Have a nice day, Sir”... place is a joke! Good luck 👍🏻
I use to really love this pizza but now they pork pepperoni no thanks & don’t inform they customers
I use to really love this pizza but now they pork pepperoni no thanks & don’t inform they customers
They don't keep their word. Don't trust them. My mistake to trust a shop in a very bad neighborhood. Police everywhere.
DO NOT GO THERE I live close by from this pizzeria I am never going back! I called for a large pie 25 min in advance I show up they gave my pizza away they constantly do this. He said wait 8 min I am coming here from work tired that’s WHY WE CALL. I’m done wit this place.
Just a friendly reminder how much reviews impact a business cause they always seem to be untouchable. I was on DD looking for pizza, saw Joe Joe’s; ok good prices. Searched on Google, terrible reviews. Instead of replying to every comment, how about actually do good on your part & fix the problem itself so you don’t get negative reviews?
I don’t know why I even gave them another chance.. the delivery always takes forever and the pizza needs to be microwaved to eat. Even in 80 degrees the pizza still came cold, the cheese didn’t even move, probably because the delivery guy took over an hour and wasn’t kept inside a heating bag.
I ordered 3 large pies and 2 liter diet coke. The coke came unsealed and they add water to it to make it look full bottle It taste like water and when I called the store the guy told me that was my last bottle i have here i will call the company and tell them. SMH
So this is my local pizzeria, I’ve been ordering from them for quite some time... ALWAYS with some kind of inconvenience. I call today and place a order to find out that the owner is WRITING MY DEBT CARD NUMBERS ON PIECE OF PAPER! When confronted he simply gave me a sob story, even after on several occasions I told him I have had issues in the past with stole debt numbers. He just brushed me off with a “Have a nice day, Sir”... place is a joke! Good luck 👍🏻
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Jody's Club Forest
Oaxaca Deli
Express Pizza
Wing & Burger
China Bell
Forest BBQ
Brighton Bagels
Redemption Coffee
Castleton Farm-to-Bagel
Philly Pretzel Factory
9 Photos
Explore Primo's Famous Pizzeria's photos
About Primo's Famous Pizzeria
How to get there
739 Henderson Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
Avenel, NY 10310
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in the United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
church building in New York, United States of America
park in the United States of America
park in the United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Primo's Famous Pizzeria and other restaurants
Earn Points at Primo's Famous Pizzeria!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Primo's Famous Pizzeria
🏆 Rewards at Primo's Famous Pizzeria
10% Discount
At Primo's Famous Pizzeria
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu