Mike R

After having pizza in Naples, Italy this is easily the best Neapolitano pizza in the US. KESTE its sister restaurant in Brooklyn is equally as good. Make sure to get the classic regina margarita with buffalo mozzarella. It’s always the best. Also the KESTE pizza. We have eaten here easily 15 times and we live 3 hours away. We’ve also ordered online and had it shipped frozen which is also fantastic cooked at home.

maria

hot and fresh out of the fire Montanara Classica is a Cheese Pizza and home-made authentic Tiramisu. Still and Sparkling water has a fee but you keep the bottle ;) i also noticed their delivery service.

Matthew Wigney

Best gluten free pizza outside of Italy! Great authentic service and a fantastic cozy atmosphere as well. Would highly recommend here if you want good pizza.

Sven B

A beautiful American Italian restaurant in the heart of midtown. Gluten-free options are available and clearly marked on the menu. The gluten-free pizza is excellent, the dough taste just as regular one does. The restaurant can get loud when all tables are filled, the bar area is quieter, even though it’s at the front of the restaurant. The staff is friendly and the food is fast even when the restaurant is full.

+3

RBW

Amazing italian restaurant serving pizza and other italian dough dishes. They have a separate gluten free kitchen which makes this a truly unique place for families who want access to “real” pizza and gluten free pizza, both of which are really delicious.

NJ 4 Fun

I haven’t been to Don Antonio location in NyC but I just had their pizza at the NYCWFF and I’m obsessed. This was my favorite bite at the festival and hands down one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had!!!! I can’t wait to visit the restaurant and have more and more amazing 🍕🍕🍕 Update: I finally went to Don Antonio before my Broadway show and I ordered the same pizza I had at NYCWFF, the Fall in Love. Of course I feel in love again. It’s delicious! The restaurant was packed but luckily, I scored a seat at the bar. Great vibes and I had the best time!!

Lars_northerngermanbbq

One of the best pizza in New York. A cool location with great Service. Price and quality match very good. Have fun, enjoy and best wishes.

Yon Ant

Delicious, chewy Neapolitan pizza. Services is fast. Friendly staff. Good pizza. Only downside is seating is too close and limited space.

D Guo

A really great pizzeria with plenty of flavor options that showcase the chef’s creativity. The portions are generous, making it perfect for groups to share several pizzas and enjoy a variety of tastes together.

Kevin Wright

Staff is great. The pizza is wonderful. We went for the fried pizza. Did not disappoint. Kitchen staff were cool when I wanted a picture of the oven.

+1

Graham A

Amazing pizza. Great restaurant vibes but seating just okay. Service a bit pushy. Definitely worth going out of your way to visit. Walked by the place many times but finally decided to give it a go after seeing a show. We showed up 30 minutes before closing but they were happy to accommodate us. Pizza looked and was authentic. Not heavy. Absolutely delicious. “10 year anniversary” and “fall… in love” pizzas were just amazing. My girl really liked the wine menu. Overall top notch food experience. Staff were generally good but as it was near closing, they kept pushing us to order quickly and finish up. I get it but not so nice. Great atmosphere too but the wooden benches weren’t the best for a 4 person group. Would have given 4.5 stars for each if I could. Overall, totally worth going for the food.

Paolo Barone

Don Antonio is a must-visit for pizza lovers! Every pie we tried was amazing—authentic Neapolitan with that perfect light and crispy crust. The lemon pizza was my favorite—bright, tangy, and unforgettable. It’s run by the daughter of the owner of Kesté (another great NYC pizzeria), so pizza mastery clearly runs in the family. A true family of expert pizzaioli. Friendly service, cozy vibe, and top-tier food. Can’t wait to go back!

+2

Andrew Dabydeen

I like this place for the simplicity but delicious pizzas. Came here with a large group during the week and was able to get seated with a reservation made the day of. The pizzas came out quick once ordered and the staff were wonderful to work with. The margherita stood out the most to me - simple yet fresh and delicious. Would come back again if I’m looking for a meal nearby.

Got the montanara clasica. Unique pizza but sauce could've been better, it was a bit too tangy/bitter. The dough was interesting, it was a bit on the sweeter side almost like funnel cake.

Bustling place. Many parties were waiting on a Friday night. The food tasted good, we really enjoyed the pizza. Service was okay, atmosphere was good.

malhar kulkarni

Delicious Pizza, great vibe!! Plenty of neapolitan pizzas to choose from across all types of sauces: Red/White/Specialty! “10 years anniversary” was our favorite!

+5

Javier Kohen

The pizza had a great chew, though sometimes it turned into jaw exercise. I like string flavors, but the crust had a really strong flavor to a fault, because it overwhelmed the toppings. The Regina margherita could have more cheese to make up for that. The salad was pretty plain and not appealing at all.

Craig Parrish

Disappointing Experience at Don Antonio – Not Worth the Hype! I was genuinely looking forward to trying Don Antonio, given its reputation and prime location in New York City, but unfortunately, it turned out to be one of the worst pizza experiences I’ve ever had in the city. While the pizza came out quickly, that was the only positive. The crust was soggy—more like wet paper than anything resembling a proper crust—and the cheese was overwhelmingly greasy. The entire pie was a sloppy, inedible mess. I’ve eaten Neapolitan pizza hundreds of times, both in NYC and abroad, and this was nowhere close to acceptable. When I brought the issue to my server’s attention, I was brushed off with the explanation that “this is how Neapolitan pizza is.” That’s simply not true. I asked to speak with the manager, who was noticeably rude and dismissive. Although she did agree to remove the pizza from my bill, she never once offered an apology or showed any concern for the poor quality of the food. With so many incredible pizza spots in New York City, I strongly recommend skipping Don Antonio. Nearly any other pizzeria in the city would be a better choice.