Menu
Irish Mafia
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Bloomfield

Irish Mafia

★★★★ 4.4 · 100 reseñas

At Irish Mafia, we invite you to experience a warm and welcoming atmosphere that's reminiscent of a classic pub. Located in Bloomfield, United States, our restaurant offers a wide selection of beers, delicious pub fare, and a menu designed to satisfy any appetite. From our signat...

Irish Mafia

Pub · Bloomfield

4.4 · 496 reviews Google
www.irishmafiabrewing.com

About Irish Mafia

At Irish Mafia, we invite you to experience a warm and welcoming atmosphere that's reminiscent of a classic pub. Located in Bloomfield, United States, our restaurant offers a wide selection of beers, delicious pub fare, and a menu designed to satisfy any appetite. From our signature dishes like Perc...

At Irish Mafia, we invite you to experience a warm and welcoming atmosphere that's reminiscent of a classic pub. Located in Bloomfield, United States, our restaurant offers a wide selection of beers, delicious pub fare, and a menu designed to satisfy any appetite. From our signature dishes like Perch Tacos and gangster garbage plates, to our extensive beer list featuring IPAs, sours, lagers, pilsners, and more, there's something for everyone at Irish Mafia. Our staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service, ensuring that your dining experience is nothing short of great. With wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, and amenities like NFC mobile payments, we strive to be inclusive and convenient for all our guests. Whether you're in the area or just passing through, come visit us and discover why Irish Mafia has become a must-visit destination for foodies and beer enthusiasts alike.

What Customers Say About Irish Mafia

Irish Mafia in Bloomfield is a popular pub known for its craft beers, delicious food, and friendly atmosphere. Customers rave about the beer flights, garbage plates, and poutine. Emily and Zach are often mentioned for their excellent service.

Popular Dishes

garbage plates poutine Mac and cheese (3) Perch Tacos pulled pork nachos

Best For

Families Groups Casual

Tip: Try the beer flights to sample a variety of their craft beers. The loganberry cider is also highly recommended.

Features

Accessible

Frequently asked questions about Irish Mafia

Irish Mafia is located at 2971 Whalen Rd, Bloomfield, NY 14469, Bloomfield.
Irish Mafia offers pub cuisine.
Irish Mafia has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
The most recommended dishes at Irish Mafia based on customer reviews are: garbage plates, poutine, Mac and cheese, Perch Tacos, pulled pork nachos.
Irish Mafia is ideal for families, groups, casual dining.
Irish Mafia in Bloomfield is a popular pub known for its craft beers, delicious food, and friendly atmosphere. Customers rave about the beer flights, garbage plates, and poutine. Emily and Zach are often mentioned for their excellent service.
Try the beer flights to sample a variety of their craft beers. The loganberry cider is also highly recommended.
496
Reviews

Irish Mafia Bloomfield Reviews

4.4
496
5★
70%
4★
16%
3★
5%
2★
3%
1★
7%
Reviews (100)
C
Collene Doney

Brought our kids in for lunch. My Husband and I thought about going a few times but didn't know how kid friendly it would be. Kids menu+ crayons + high chairs friendly. My husband had the Mafia 101 & tried a sample of the Incider and thought both were very good. We ate Hangover Melt, pretzel bites and mozzarella sticks. I had the gigantic Fish Sandwich.

D
Dan Kusnetzky

Expensive, but good pub food. Several family members frequently visit the Irish Mafia Brewing company and invited us to come with them. The service was outstanding. After visiting this restaurant, it appears that the big draw is the microbrewery. Since our first visit, we've returned several times. We've come to like the Irish Mafia more each time. The friendly atmosphere can win a person over in a very short time. The burgers are big and delicious. The fish and chips portions are huge. Maybe they should be called Moby and chips.

R
Rick White

I second all the other reviews. Great food and great beer. Service is on point. Fun atmosphere. Not a lot of other comparable places to grab food and beer in the area. Perfect apres ski stop on the way home from Bristol.

C
Cydney Badger

We’ve never had a bad experience here! Their Mac and cheese is delicious. We’ve always been able to have our kiddos with us, and they’ve accommodated us well. Always clean. Always good service.

C
Christine Knowlton

Delicious food in large quantities. I can rarely finish a meal. Great service. Good variety of tasty craft brews. If you are even a slight fan of beer, you're likely to find one that suits your pallate. Order a flight and choose a favorite or two, or three 😊 .

C
Catherine Datz

I've been there several times already. Super friendly staff. Great selection of beer and cider from both Irish Mafia and other local breweries. Loved the burger, poutine and pretzel bites. Will definitely be back!

M
Michael Brown

I have never been able to make it to The Irish Mafia Brewing Company. So you might ask why would I write a review? The answer is simple. The owner is a great human. I met him before he even had this business. We were strangers that met at a Twins game in Minneapolis. He had literally nothing to gain by befriending me. We have stayed in touch over the years and are still friends to this day. I can’t speak to the drinks or the food but if you want to support a family that would give you the shirt off their back then stop in and give it a try. Enjoy a nice time knowing you are supporting one of the good ones.

S
Sara Benham

The food is incredible, I have never gotten something I didn't love. The staff is amazing and super friendly and their ciders are the best I've ever tasted. I love that they have the one cider in a 4 pack so I can take some with me when I leave to hold me over till the next time I can go.

C
Cortney Ross

Great food selection, relaxed atmosphere, polite and knowledgeable employees (thank you Danielle!) and AMAZING beers!! The owner is a great guy to talk to. We will definitely be back many times in the future.

A
Alana Stevens-Firlit

Excellent service! Emily was our bartender and also took our food order. The food came out quick and was delicious! The staff works great as a team!

A
Anastasia Dudzinski

Bartender was really sweet! We got a flight of four beers and a glass of wine. Nice selection. The space is huge inside and has a huge lot. They're doing a bike night every Wednesday beginning the end of May. Looking forward to our riding back up for one of those!

C
Catie Marks

I love the Irish Mafia! My server Emily was amazing. Best server I have ever had. One of the managers Kole was amazing to talk to also. Definitely a place to come to have a good time. Would absolutely recommend this place.

E
Erik Mendoza

Heard about this place from family and friends. We were traveling through while on our trip from Florida. The service was great, food looked and tasted very good and of course I had to pick up some swag from the shop. I had the Amber and wished I had time to stay and guzzle down a few more. The location is easy to get in and out of and the interior was spacious and comfortable. Looking forward to visiting again on our next trip to New York.

J
Jennifer Baker

As if the food and atmosphere weren't enough to get me back in, Emily is hands down there best bartender and server ever! And Kole is also pretty chill. The food was great and they have standout service! Make sure to try the Ruby Rolls!

M
Michelle GP

I love this place! Very unique feel and great menu and friendly staff. We visited on their opening night and they were slamming busy and did an excellent job, I was amazed at how prepared they were on an opening night with such large crowds that just kept coming. We went there again tonight and we were pleasantly surprised that they maintain excellent service and great food. Such a fun menu. My kids love the fried dough. My husband really enjoyed his Irish poutine (yep, you read that correctly). I really liked my beef on weck. Yummy stuff, great prices, very little waiting time from order to eating which is exactly what we needed after a long day of skiing. We will be back!

J
Jareth Graves

Irish Mafia is a great little micro brewery with some very excellent food selections. The staff are always friendly.

J
Jason Reed

We were visiting from Maryland and visited based on suggestion from another friend. We were welcomed immediately by Emily. She was so sweet and helpful. She went above and beyond to make sure our experience was a good one. The food was all so good. We can't wait to return one day

R
Renee

We stopped in here for the first time and we were very impressed with the food and service. Danielle our waitress was amazing.. Atmosphere and food incredible!!! We will return!!!

J
James Hallahan

Visited several times and the service is always great. Nice beer selection, they carry their own stuff and selections from other breweries as well. Food is great, nice menu to choose from. I have also visited with my toddler and they had the proper accommodations. A very nice brewery that really has a little bit of everything.

J
John Spaulding

We picked this place for a family gathering. The craft brews were considered excellent by all parties. Wait staff was terrific. The food was really good and prices about right for the portions and quality. They closed at 10, but they never said a word and we lost track of time. Very open and spacious seating including a double sided fireplace and a very nice outdoor patio. Plenty of parking, albeit gravel. This was an extremely important gathering for us. Perfect venue.

C
Chris Badeau

A group of us from mini at the glen stopped in at the end of the weekends rally. Service and food was excellent..

L
Liam Santiago

The food was delicious Danielle was the nicest person there

J
Jeff North

Our server was bubbly and very attentive. All of the meals we ordered were fresh and hot. And Willy's Winter Jam is AWESOME. It was our first visit, and we might just have a new favorite place!

A
Arden Goodman

Went for lunch on Saturday. Fantastic service, quick and attentive. Pretzel bites were great, the soup hot, and homemade! We had flights to try the beer, and loved them all. Will be back next time we are in NY!

J
Jeff Cannon

If I could rate this higher than 5 stars I would. Our waitress April went above and beyond to make our experience awesome. It was a nice clean place, the Reubens and the wings were the best that I've ever had. Cudos to the cook on that one. The beers were pretty tasty too.. Prices were extremely reasonable. I will definitely be visiting again from Rensselaer N.Y

K
Kevin Drake

We always have a great time here! My niece and her friends had fun for their birthday. The apricot wheat beer and blackberry cider were awesome. Great service by Zach.

W
Wendy Young

What a fabulous place! We personnally found its google rating misleadingly low. It had a relaxed atmosphere and the staff was attentive and pleasant. Wide range of beerrs, all exceedingly well crafted. Food menu had great options and everyone in our party of six had something different, and it was delishious. Plenty of seating and parking. Highly recommend!

A
Alan Randolph

I came here for my birthday with my son and daughter in law and friends two years ago had an amazing birthday the food and service is excellent and have become a regular ever since the beers 🍻 are always great the entire staff is amazing and I do have some favorites such as Hanna

M
Mark Taber

Been here a number of times food is always great highly recommend. One recommendation please chill your draft beer. Or offer chilled glasses.

A
Alan Rifkin

Excellent service, younger blond server was super attentive and really took care of us! Food was great! Everyone loved their meal, the BBQ Sundae was outstanding! I didn't try the beers, but my companion diners did and said they were very good!

R
RITA Dreimiller

Emily was fantastic. Very attentive, checked back several times. Was a great experience and we will be back!

S
Susie Hewy

Nice place! The Mac and Cheese is Awesome and goes well with the IPA!

R
Rebecca Neal

All the Irish Mafia beers on tap. Everything was tasty along with the taco rolls and great service!

C
Carter Craig

Being from out of town we decided to stop in for lunch and have a few beers . The service was excellent as well as the food was very good . The bar tender was very nice she. We will definitely come again when we are back in the area. Great selection of beers on tap the IPA I had was delicious 🤤 Devoted IPA

C
Carole Jones

We enjoyed a flight of beers and a Reuben sandwich, and it was great. Good beer, good service, and a god meal!

M
Mary Mulligan

We have been to the Irish Mafia many, many times and have always had great service, great drinks and great food. It’s one of our absolute favorites!!

A
Anthony Berrios

Great food and a nice selection of craft brews. Nice and roomy, very cozy with very friendly staff. I look forward to my next visit.

A
Adriano Menezes

Great food, wait staff were very helpful and had great food and beer recommendations. Definitely a must go!!!

T
Ted Tucker

Hop passport brought us here. Friendly staff, some good beers and the food was delicious!

A
Alex Fisher

Great spot for beer and food. Ordered a beer flight and the Gangster Plate. Nice, quiet atmosphere.

J
Jessica Hill

My husband and I stopped here to eat! It was so nice , very loud but the food was amazing! We got the Classic Poutine Seasoned fries topped with Yancey’s Fancy Cheese Curds and beef gravy-HIGHLY recommended! Also their potato skins and I tried their raspberry cider! Very yummy and its sold at wegmans! Worth your stop!

F
Francesca Rosso

This establishment is so welcoming and friendly! I have been here many times and the staff is very diligent and accommodating to all situations. My husband and I have gone for date night and really enjoyed ourselves. We are also able to go as a family and bring our 5m old baby. This restaurant is versatile and overall maintains an amazing atmosphere no matter what brings you in. HIGHLY RECOMENDED!

J
Judy Peterson

Great menu...bar/pub selections but with their own take. They had some unique things and twists on traditional. Great atmosphere. I was there for lunch with an old friend and we had a great time. The bar is huge; I'm sure there's plenty of room even when the place is full and jumping. Totally enjoyed the place. Server was tremendous. She was the kind that doesn't have to write anything down, treats you like you've known her for years, giving the regulars the business, eager to please and never stopped moving. She helped make the visit the best.

G
Gregorovich Meyer

Love this place. Great staff. Great drinks. Great food.

C
Cathy LaValley

Food was delicious! We sampled several appetizers, tried some specials, and a few traditional menu items and we loved them all. Drinks were great-the loganberry cider was incredible and our server Danielle was fantastic!! The 45 minute drive was worth and already have plans to come back!

K
Kate Bluett

We have been to The Mafia more times than I can remember. Emily, our waitress this evening was beyond impressive. She was attentive in notifying us of the kitchen being behind (it wasn’t bad at all), apologetic about our food coming out late (we waited maybe 20 minutes), and found a hockey game for us to watch while we waited. She’s a keeper for sure! Of course, the food and beer are always great!

r
robert zavaglia

This place has gotten to be one of our favorite stops. Food variety is excellent and always delicious. People are wonderful and extremely attentive!

T
Tim Brown

On a recent trip to Canandaigua from Syracuse for an anniversary vacation, we chose to stop at the Irish Mafia after researching the best breweries in the area to stop for a quick lunch prior to checking into our hotel. This place is amazing!! My wife and I split a Reuben sandwich because neither of us is into a huge midday eating event. We have Irish restaurants in Syracuse that seriously can't compete with that sandwich. We met Mark, the owner. Should you stop by sometime, and you should, meet Mark the owner. He's a great guy running a very great place. The food is amazing, as is the craft beer. This was a great kickoff to a great anniversary weekend!

C
Caroline Callahan

Friendly and helpful staff! Helped find something dairy-free. Pleasant live music by a two man band. Outer and inside seating, and yard games. Great salad, even better tater tots!!!

M
Melissa Sieling

Great food, friendly service- i'm not a beer drinker but my dining partner loved his red ale and I found my new favorite hard cider.

C
Cassandra Borden

The Irish Onion soup was delicious. Enjoyed the beers as well. Worth the drive from Rochester and will definitely be going back! Great service as well.

H
Howie Hypnotize

Do the bbq sundae. So weird but delicious.

n
norman cooper

I’ve gone here many times as I’ve was told they had one of the best Rueben’s. From the first time I tried the food til now, I’ve always been blown away and happy. The atmosphere is great, service is awesome and food is one of my favorite ever. We will continue to be regulars at this place and recommend it to anyone looking for a small town, chill environment with amazing food across the board!

J
Jean Brault

We stopped by traveling from Buffalo to Penn Yan and had a delicious lunch. Highly recommend the Kirby and a Road Trip beer. Great combination! Emily was our server and she was friendly, helpful and seemed to go the extra to make us feel comfortable and well taken care of. We will be back with friends and family!!!

L
Laurie Ball

Great food, beer, and service. Our waitress Emily was very attentive. Definetly would like to go again!

J
Joe Lake

Amazing food and drinks. I had the pizza rolls and the shepherds pie with a chocolate cherry stout! I would have them again. My girl had the same beer with Reuben egg roll and the Reuben with turkey. She said the same! I would be back.

A
AmyLou

Great food, good beer, and love the fireplace too!

P
Pamela Rogers

Freaking awesome. The fish tacos are incredible!!!! And love the Stitches for Snitches brew. Great service, friendly and helpful. Fantastic outdoor seating and weirdly interesting bathroom fixture...I happen to admire kitchen sinks LOL four thumbs up!

J
Jason A. Richman, Esq.

From my wife: Today I placed a takeout order with Emily at the Irish Mafia Brewing Company in Bloomfield NY. Emily was very pleasant and helpful as I placed my order and when I arrived to pick up my food it was prepared and ready for me ahead of schedule. When I left the restaurant to drive home, my key FOB battery died. The car would not start and so I needed to eat inside the restaurant while awaiting rescue. Emily was very kind, offering to help me try to find a solution to my battery issue. She also suggested that I have a cholcate raspberry martini while I wait. It was delicious! Good people are the heart of any hospitality business. Thank you Emily and Irish Mafia for the good food, comfort, and kindness. I will be back again soon.

D
Diane Coe

Stopped in after skiing. Great food, great drinks, great service (thank you, Zach!). Second time we've been here. Wings are delicious as is the chili, pizza logs, reuben sandwich and onion rings. Looking forward to our next visit.

Natalie Strouse
Natalie Strouse

Great atmosphere. Super chill vibe. Unfortunately they don't have the liquor license to allow carry out sales which is disappointing because we are so far away. But we will keep stopping in when in the area until they can sell them for carry out and we can take them home

T B
T B

This place is great, food came quicker than my stomachs 2nd rumble. James the bartender is quick, efficient and good with conversion. I would give this spot more stars if I could. Will be back, best believe!

Alexandra O'Brien
Alexandra O'Brien

We stopped in on our way home towards Buffalo after the Steam Association Tractor event in Canandaigua. With a small child in tow, we sat outside in the large patio which was very nice with string lights and comfy chairs. My husband got the Pilsner and I had the Red Ale… both were crisp, cold and delicious. My 9yo son had the Buffalo Mac n’ Cheese which was creamy and flavorful without being too rich. My husband had the Kirby, which is unlike any other sandwich we’ve ever had… packed with flavor and really good! I had the Shepherds Pie… the mashed potatoes and gravy are homemade and the meat was flavorful with carrots and onions. We'll be sure to stop in again if we find ourselves out this way. Service was friendly, our food came out fast and prices were very reasonable and the place was nice enough for both a date night or an outing with the family. The only suggestion is to re-install the baby changing station in the women’s bathroom. It’s so high that I had to change the baby at eye level… but it’s nice that you have a changing station… not every restaurant (let alone a brewery) has one. Slainte! ☘️

Ken Kopper
Ken Kopper

Such a great place. Our waitress was friendly and patient. The owner had a chat with our group and shared a great story about his brother. And the food 🤤 mouth watering and absolutely delicious. I hope to return someday.

KC Conti
KC Conti

I love this place! Serious great food. Highly recommend the loganberry cider. And for all you booktok girls, talk to Emily! She is a great bartender. And has not failed me yet with great book recommendations!

Scott
Scott

This Is Such A Great Place With Good Food & Fantastic Craft Beers. Every Year We Come To The Finger Lakes From The Western NY Area, And This ALWAYS Our First Stop! Grab Some Beer To Go, You Wont Regret It!

Ashley Eberly
Ashley Eberly

Came here on NYE mid day, super quiet only a few people. We ordered the inciders and the gangster garbage plates. I am sooooo picky with my garbage plates but these were the best by far. Their cheese sauce is awesome and a twist on a garbage plate. Our server Zach was very friendly. We will definitely stop back again! The proportions are well worth the price.

Matt Ruffell
Matt Ruffell

Excellent example of a modern brewery serving craft beers and great food. Seems like it's located in the middle of nowhere, but the drive will be worth it. Soups and burgers are fantastic. Prices are reasonable for what you get.

Guy Smith
Guy Smith

Nice pub just off Rt 20 and just outside of Canandaigua. This place looks fairly new. It has a large indoor area and hosts bands on certain days. The bar is huge, with about a dozen or so brews and ciders created on premises. Brews are priced fairly, about 6-7 dollars. I had a cherry stout, which was a bit too sweet for me. Pretty large menu at around $16.00 per meal: salads, sandwiches, burgers, wraps, etc. Did not eat there, so can't comment directly on the food. I would highly recommend checking it out - especially if you have a designated driver so you can sample more beer! Oh, and staff were very pleasant. Lots of outdoor seating in nice weather. Parking lot is a moonscape, however.

Tammra Schiller
Tammra Schiller

Great atmosphere. Great food. Great service. My 13 year old loves the poutine. The beer is good as well. Many options to choose from. A definite must stop. Truly enjoyed the food - wings, french onion soup, and spinach & artichoke dip.

Tom Marasco
Tom Marasco

First time here, won’t be the last. Food was incredible (Perch Tacos and a burger). Beer was good, didn’t try too many, but the NEIPA was killer, low IBU but hoppy fruity and a great mouthfeel. This will be a regular spot for us. Well worth the trip from Webster.

Chad Edwards
Chad Edwards

Quick and friendly service! We didn’t have a reservation, but they managed to fit us in. The food was excellent - fresh and perfectly prepared. If you haven’t been, you should go. This is my new go-to place.

Sean Hanson
Sean Hanson

Went to eat with the family and had a great time. The flights are $7 so we got to try a lot of the beers and they are very good. They have IPAs, sours, lager, pilsner so something for everyone. The staff was also very friendly and entertaining. Emily was patient, knowledgeable and funny. Lainey has amazing beer balancing skills! The food was great. There were healthy options (ahi tuna salad) and comfort food (gangster plate!) so most people should have options to choice from.

Evonne Pomerantz
Evonne Pomerantz

Everything about this brewery is welcoming. We ordered 2 flites each with total 8 different drinks along with the delicious pulled pork nachos. Prices were awesome!

Jon Allen
Jon Allen

Our family happened by Irish Mafia while camping in the area. The atmosphere was inviting and themed toward the name. We were immediately intrigued by the menu, and were excited to try the food. We ordered flights, and enjoyed the local beers they offered. The food was fantastic, and left us wanting to return to try more. We bought some merch, and all decided we will return to try more. Highly recommend this brewery destination.

M
Martha Schwartz

We were a bit apprehensive about our first meal at the Mafia. We should not have been! We were very pleased with the service and food. We enjoyed the poutine, fish fry, perch tacos and deviled eggs. Our waiter was pleasant and efficient. What's not to like!

T
Troy M

It was really nice to relax in a place with such an open area. It was not crowded at all. All the employees seemed to be happy working there!

J
Jared Kierecki

The services was good. The food was good. The bill for 4 people for 3 beers and one iced tea, wings, a grilled cheese with tater tots and 2 burgers was $95.00. Seemed a little steep for the food but hey... food is getting more expensive. The beer was great I had the Irish Loyal and they had the mighty-ego and a devoted and we all enjoyed them.

T
Thomas Arias

Great brewery! The food was good, beers were awesome and our waitress was super cool and funny. My one complaint is the indoor seating. Not sure if it's a Covid thing but the tables were fold out tables with plastic fold out chairs. Those chairs are not comfortable at all. Other than that, great place.

S
Shannon Gracie

Delicious food... So many great choices we ordered way too much! My fruity flight was tasty. Would totally get again. I love the veggie plate! Zach gave us great service...

Michael Sheehan
Michael Sheehan

Great stop after leaf peeping or skiing! Third visit there. Fine selection of draft beers and nice casual food menu. Server was friendly and prompt. Food came out quickly and was delicious. Would rate 5 stars but Men’s restroom was a little messy and urinal was out of order.

MARISOL Barreiro
MARISOL Barreiro

Our waitress was awesome. Food was good, but Mac and cheese was delicious 😋. Sadly, we couldn't take a growler of hard cider because they aren't allowed to sell them any longer 😭

Attilio Lospinoso
Attilio Lospinoso

The food here was really good, I had the Gangster plate, macaroni salad with tater tots and a burger with cheese on top. It was amazing. I also had the thin mint stout, and it tasted exactly as you would expect it to, and it was not very thick! The second beer I had was their irish red, which was also very good. I would definitely recommend visiting, the only con was that their beer menu was only 7 deep of their brews, but other than that it was great!

A
Anthony Mock

My visit was on a Thursday afternoon so results my vary. Overall the atmosphere and building is pretty nice. Plenty of seating around the bar and a good sized area of tables and a fenced in outdoor space as well. There was a decent crowd for 3pm but was empty by 4pm. Service was good while people were there then the staff disappeared with the crowd. The beer is very average at best. None of it was bad but nothing I had made me want to get a full pint.

M
Michelle Parker

We have been here a few times and it has always been a great atmosphere, great food, and great beer. Today, however, one of the people behind the bar (who we assumed was an owner) had friends come in. He became obnoxious, loud, and was cursing with every sentence that left his mouth, along with inappropriate content. There were kids in the establishment (as it was a Sunday afternoon) and it got to the point where we decided to leave. We were definitely disappointed. Hopefully next time is a better experience.

C
Christine Judge

I have recently went to Irish Mafia for drinks and dinner. I really enjoy the beer and food. However I was not impressed with the amount of food you get for the price. The food has great potential like I said really really like it. But for a check for two people with 2 beers and and 2 dinners… . should not be near $80 dollars!

J
Jennel Justus

Was just there July 19th. Several of us classmates from the Class of 70' meet monthly for lunch. This month we chose Irish Mafia Brewing. We chose a window table for the 6 of us and I'm guessing the owner came to take our drink order. Several chose water with lemon, and I chose Ice tea. He apologized that they were out of ice tea so I chose water w/lemon. Brings our water back, and apologized that they were out of lemons. All the while, I'm right next to the window that had a hole from what looked like from a pellet gun, it was a double pane window. On the window ledge were all sorts of little dead bugs and a living spider. And there were several files flying around us. My Turkey Reuben was delicious, and the mac salad was good. One classmate got the corned beef Reuben, but was very salty. Prices were good. In sort, we will not be returning anytime in the future

H
Holly Andrews

We decided to try it for the first time. We looked at their menu and it all looked delicious! Well unfortunately, when the food finally came, that deliciousness that we were expecting, was not there. Our dishes were either very bland, too salty or not hot. For each dish we had tonight, we could literally say that another place was better.

S
Sergey Pisklakov

Once again I need to add in reply: no we did not eat your food, only tried. It was bad. Your server admitted it was cooked yesterday. Particularly she was proud she “cut salad cucumbers yesterday herself a night before and sorry it is not fresh”. She was not stiffed, she did not get tip because she brought food which was not fresh, greedy and tasted bad. Yes I drank the stout . What it had to do with serving poor quality food, charging extra for using MC and charging for salad you substituted French fries with?! No, I did not See original review below. Because business replied I would like to add: Your reply is not without a twist. I was brought glass of lager which I did not ask for, I asked for ipa. Yes I said I do not drink larger. I don’t. I offered your hostess/waitress to pay for it anyway. I did return salad and asked for one without onions? So what? I was suppose to eat it?I am allergic . I did not ask for carrots. Buy the way those carrots were bitter and stale. I indeed was charged for both salads though salad was a substitute for French fries. And yes the food was bad and she admitted she did it herself a day before. She did not get a tip because those who bring bad food and overcharge do not deserve it. It is simple. I did have a lady with me , my friend, she was a witness to this and said she never comes back. We felt bad after your food. That’s all. If you look on your cameras we barely touched your food - it was bad. Greasy . Ugly presented. But we still paid you money. And you did charge extra two dollars for using a card. It was not a discount. I wonder if it violates your NC or Visa agreement. Find out. I wonder if we got it like this from her and place because we both were not local? No? Regards I want to start with positive - beer and IPAs are good. Place is clean. Great atmosphere. Prices are reasonable. To regret food is dearly bad. Burgers are distastefully greasy, giving impression of being made from stake meet. Sales are made from stake dying tomatoes, frost bitten cucumbers. Hummus looked strange and tasted like a hummus paste from a cane. Hostess was nice and polite. I asked to substitute French fries for salad and was billed for salad, twice, $3 not a big deal. When we asked about quality hostess replied that Dhaka precut and precooked it herself day before and now it is old. But it is what it is she said. She also added $2 for using credit card. Sad experience , bad food, ipa was wonderful.

M
Mary Beth Bergeron

We stopped in yesterday after not having been there in MANY years. Unfortunately we were very disappointed in the food and drink. My meat on my beef on wick was spoiled and sour tasting. The ginger ale was so sicky sweet, that I couldn't drink it. My husband's ale was nasty tasting due to lines that need a good cleaning. Now for the good the lobster bisque was very good and the waitress was great. Unfortunately we probably won't be back

L
Laura Desmond

I've never given a "one star" review before but this place needs a warning sign. We just left after not being able to eat because the waitress refused to leave us menus and then when we did get menus from the bar she wouldn't stop at our table to get our drink or food order after sitting there 1/2 hour. She took the order of the group sitting at the next table, made eye contact with me, frowned, and detoured to walk across to the kitchen, pointedly ignoring my signal to take our order. No idea why we couldn't get served given we're a 40-ish professional couple with a quiet baby - - maybe because we weren't locals. There were other families with children in the restaurant so we assumed it was ok to try with our baby. We asked the staff at the bar if they could bring over a high chair, but they never did. The restrooms were disgusting (no toilet paper, over flowing trash can, wet floor) and there was no baby changing table. We were seated at a 2-top near the window which was a mistake because the window had a fly infestation (that alone should have raised red flags). Really disappointed because we wanted to eat and sample their beers. Honestly, save your time & skip this place.

R
Rob Potter

My wife and I visited Irish Mafia on 7/12/2024. I ordered a DIPA. The keg just kicked. She ordered a glass of wine, but was given a sweet blush rather than a rose. We both had fish fries. They were moist, not crisp, and neither of us could even get to a halfway mark. There was a game show reality tv show on a flat screen tv in front of us showing people eating what appeared to be raw intestines. Disgusting. The wait staff had little to do as the restaurant was nearly empty at 8 PM. We will never, ever return.

J
Jenn Yanez

One of my favorite things is researching and going to new places to eat and drink. Being in the industry myself, I admire places that can brew their own beer and serve food. This place had some good reviews, so whynot! Beautiful day for a drive and to get to know a new place. I went on a Saturday afternoon with a friend and sat at the bar and made eye contact with one of 4 servers at the bar. We looked over the beer menu, and knew immediately we wanted a flight and some food. Admittedly, a couple minutes after we came it, it started to get a little busier at the bar. Not one server made eye contact with us for 10 minutes after the initial look. Other people were starting to get served, but not us. I get it. When you get busy you gotta take care of everyone. All it would have took was some acknowledgement that we'd be taken care of soon, but we received nothing.At that point, we were being blatantly ignored. Not sure why, but it's not a good feeling. So, we left. If it took us that long to get acknowledged, who's to say how long it would take to get food, etc.

A
Ayse Lewis

Sorry to say but not so good! Brought friend for the Ruben witch turned out to be bread with a lot of grease and no corn beef, one small slice, I did mention to the waitress that it need meat! She brought a few more slices and ended up charging me $2.00. I was so embarrassed with how this was handled! I have had several wonderful Ruben’s there in the past. Will never go back

L
LuvaHug Alldatime

Found this place through google and thought we’d try it. Beer was good but the food was mediocre. My food came lukewarm almost cold…should have been hot! I should’ve asked for it to be reheated but didn’t want to go to the trouble. The server was very efficient and very speedy. She was very hyper! When we went to pay, no one was available. When she finally got there, she was in such a rush, she practically threw my credit card back at me along with the receipt. Upon leaving, we noticed two employees outside right near the front entrance smoking and making out. Looked like they needed to get a room. Gross. If we had seen that when we first arrived, we would’ve gone elsewhere. Smoking by the entrance and then having a make out session in front of customers is not good for business. Yuk.

D
Danielle Hobart

This is a long shot but... I really hope Gordon Ramsay considers bringing Kitchen Nightmares to the Irish Mafia! I've been living in Bloomfield for four years, and my first visit to the Irish Mafia was fantastic. Unfortunately, the quality has significantly declined since then. My boyfriend's grandmother experienced food poisoning, and I couldn't even finish my ruby egg rolls because they were so dry they stuck in my teeth. To make matters worse, my boyfriend's grilled cheese was served cold, with unmelted cheese. Honestly, a frozen meal from Dollar General would have tasted better! Additionally, the bathroom sink looks like it hasn't been cleaned since my first visit.

L
Luciano Sarver

Some worker yelled at me and my friend for throwing darts at the dart board?? Then she said I’m going to hit somebody like what?! It’s was some chubby braided girl never coming here again

C
Caylin

If I could leave no stars I would based on the service. I have always loved this place since it opened, the food is outstanding. However you should hire competent staff that know what they are doing. My Moscow mule was made with lemonade not ginger beer. The bartender asked if I wanted my jamo shot chilled and then didn’t even pour a full shot. When the rest of our group joined we were told they can’t split the check with a party of 6 or more. Which I understand but we had been there for an hour before they arrived and our bill was already at $100. To be told the best they can do it split 3 cards equally is insane. Why should the rest of our group pay for our bill when they only had one drink. I’ve been a server and bartender for 10+ plus years, I know it’s not hard to make a new check. Go above and beyond for your customers. I will never return to this establishment after being a frequent customer from the day they opened.

David Tarana
David Tarana

My coleslaw burger was undercooked, and the coleslaw was mostly water that just saturated the bun. My wife’s chicken wrap was not what you would expect. The Mac & cheese was actually very good and the beer were excellent. Very grossed out of the conditions of both men and woman’s bathrooms. Broken and filthy. We will not be returning after next year’s grape Fest. Very disappointed.

Jake
Jake

Went for my son's 21st birthday, young kid that was our waiter didn't even welcome us to the establishment just told us we couldn't split the bill. We continued to the bar to order a beer where we where told by the same kid that we couldn't order separately from our table, this is a brewery right? We went back to our table after having to argue to get a beer, we continued to wait in a very hot dining room while our waiter started taking an order at a table that arrived probably 10 minutes after we did. After waiting a little longer we decided this wasn't going to get any better and just left.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Bloomfield →
📸

78 Photos

Explore Irish Mafia's photos

Irish Mafia
Irish Mafia
Irish Mafia
Irish Mafia
Irish Mafia
+73 More
📍

About Irish Mafia

How to get there

2971 Whalen Rd, Bloomfield, NY 14469

Loading map...
Irish Mafia
Tap for directions

Highlights

Good Rating
4.4/5 stars
💬
Many Reviews
496 reviews
👨‍🍳
pub
Cuisine type

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
11:30AM-9PM
Rating
4.4/5
💬 Reviews
496
📞 Phone
+1 585-257-5172
🌐 Website
www.irishmafiabrewing.com
📋 Menu
View Menu

Amenities

Wheelchair Accessible
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

2971 Whalen Rd, Bloomfield, NY 14469

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Irish Mafia and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Irish Mafia!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Irish Mafia

🏆 Rewards at Irish Mafia

💰

10% Discount

At Irish Mafia

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it