Iun Chen

Absolutely delicious and will definitely be back! Had four people on a Monday night before happy hour ended. We got the following: - Appetizer olives - Nguyen wings - Emmy burger - Brender pizza - Emily pizza - Happy Hour cocktails, wines, and beer All items were so yummy and delicious! Good portion sizes and flavors. Would recommend everything on the menu we had. Service was efficient. There were only three-ish parties at the restaurant around 6:30pm on a Monday so they were attentive to our table. On their windows they have a lot of accolades. We can definitely see why… it was so delicious. Excited to go back and try their other menu items!

Andrew Li

Incredible burger that I’ll be thinking about for a while. I normally prefer smash burgers with thinner patties + more veggies, but this one won me over. The patty was impossibly juicy, the caramelized onions and sauce were dripping with flavor. And the pretzel bun was surprisingly a great addition. Fries were decent too. This city has plenty of great burgers, but this was stands out in both uniqueness and execution. Will be back.

Yannick Rohrbasser

The burger at Emily has been a fixture of top lists in recent years and it's easy to see why. Great beef, tasty sauce and sweet caramelized onions on a surprisingly soft pretzel bun. It's a very unique burger that does its own thing. A refreshing take which I really enjoyed and recommend to anyone who appreciates a good burger. Price a bit on the higher side. Chicken wings and fries were okay. Reserve your seats a few days early to make sure you get seating.

+2

Felicia Arriaga

We usually order the colony pizza for delivery but this was our first time going in person. It was great to get everything right out of the oven. We love the Caesar salad with real anchovies and the colony pizza is the perfect mix of spicy and sweet ingredients. The space is a little small so you might have a wait but the service is quick and pleasant.

Lift_Run_Eat_

Came to Emily with high expectations and a roaring appetite. Left feeling more satisfied than I can remember ever being and in a quandary over whether it was the best burger I’ve ever tried. If you like your burger sloppy and packed out with onion then it’ll be your winner. If you prefer a slightly less packed out piece then you’ll probably side for a more classic burger. The melting, dripping landslide of cheese is very special. If Emily put a Classic American Cheeseburger on their menu then I have no doubt it would be the best burger in the world. The Korean Sticky & Sour Fried Chicken was a surprise actually. Easily one of the best dishes we ordered. Start with the initial saucy flavour and then just the perfect amount of hard crisp before falling away into the soft underside of chicken flesh - truly something to get if you come. Colony Pizza was very solid, had pepperoni and hot honey. I don’t think it beats Village Square Pizza but it was an unexpected delight. The broccoli salad was also a surprise, really beautifully cooked chicken and balanced flavours in the salad.

+2

David Makris

I’ve been coming here for years, and would guess I’ve been here 25+ times total. It’s my absolute favorite burger & pizza in the city. Until you’ve eaten at this location, you haven’t had their best burger, considering the other locations have a diff style of burger, this is the pinnacle of burgers! Also the pies are so delicious, I’m partial to the Emmy & colony but I’ve tried just about every one of them and they’re all enjoyable. Also, the Korean wings were my personal favorite as well but they took them off the menu last year I believe, but now the same sauce is on chicken fingers (basically) and they’re still incredible. I’m so happy & thankful they’re back! The broccoli salad and watermelon salads are a nice add on since the more substantial dishes tend to be rich, but let’s me honest, you don’t come to Emily for salads. Burger, pizza and Korean chicken and you’ll love every bite!

+2

Everything on the menu at Emily is sooo tasty! We were drawn to the place for the famous burger and it did not disappoint but the pies, wings, apps, drinks and deserts are all good! It has an impecab…

Everything on the menu at Emily is sooo tasty! We were drawn to the place for the famous burger and it did not disappoint but the pies, wings, apps, drinks and deserts are all good! It has an impec…

Everything on the menu at Emily is sooo tasty! We were drawn to the place for the famous burger and it did not disappoint but the pies, wings, apps, drinks and deserts are all good! It has an impec…

Stopped in here on a Sunday with the family and had a chance to try out a couple of the pizzas and a burger. Had high expectations given how hard it is to get a reservation and living next to Emmy'…

amazing burger also loved pizza its the best burger in new york so go there and the service was superbe an dont get my started on the atmosphere

ambience was quaint and the Burger was delicious. Be warned it's a bit messy but napkins are handy.

Completely lived up to the hype. Very good burger and I understand why it has been ranked number 1 in NYC several times. The drinks were good as well.\n\nWould love to come back and try the pizza!

Super delicious! Got the burger and a spicy margarita, worth it! Small restaurant with a cute decor and staff was great!

The restaurant open at 5pm and by 515pm it was packed. Believe the hype because everything is delicious and tasty. The burger and pizza selections OMG you must try. The drinks are cute. Mine came…

The restaurant open at 5pm and by 515pm it was packed. Believe the hype because everything is delicious and tasty. The burger and pizza selections OMG you must try. The drinks are cute. Mine came i…

The restaurant open at 5pm and by 515pm it was packed. Believe the hype because everything is delicious and tasty. The burger and pizza selections OMG you must try. The drinks are cute. Mine came i…

The restaurant open at 5pm and by 515pm it was packed. Believe the hype because everything is delicious and tasty. The burger and pizza selections OMG you must try. The drinks are cute. Mine came i…

Best burger i ever had. Also their pizza's are very tasty. The staff was friendly and the location looks nice. I would definitely return.

Best burger i ever had. Also their pizza's are very tasty. The staff was friendly and the location looks nice. I would definitely return.

Best burger i ever had. Also their pizza's are very tasty. The staff was friendly and the location looks nice. I would definitely return.

Food is pretty good. I wouldn’t call it my favorite burger because the meat as practically rare and I like it a little more cooked, but that seemed to be their standard cook.

Ok hear me out… it’s a good burger. I love burgers, and it’s good. Maybe it’s high quality meat, the bun was a good bun. It is NOT mind blowing. I feel like the caramelized onions were a little overpowering. The menu politely tells you they will not customize the burger, outside of the temperature. I love bacon and I think adding the bacon would have given it the savory taste it needed. The wings were interesting. $18 but (in this world I guess I have to say “but”) you get 6 full wings which isn’t common. I did however love the lemonade. Ambiance and service were great. They even did a cool thing where they left postcards on the tables to roast your ex (I went on Valentine’s Day and I was SO tempted) which they displayed on one of the walls. All in all, $59 for a burger, wings, and a non alcoholic drink is a little steep, but don’t let me discourage you. Maybe it’ll be your favorite burger ever!

Everything was pretty good. Got the spicy pepepperoni pizza and the burger. Pizza was above average but not the best I’ve had. Burger was unique with a tasty Korean sauce. Not your typical burger, but definitely a well-executed “alt-burger”. Service average. Acoustics not the best. I enjoyed my meal but nothing really stood out that would make me return.

Helen S

We had a reservation for 3 on a Friday night and were seated as soon as we arrived. The restaurant is small and was really busy so would recommend booking, at least for weekends. We ordered the hot wings to start and then the Emmy Burger and the Trio House Pie to share for our mains. The wings arrived quickly and really packed a punch of flavour. The portion size was generous, enough for 3 of us to share, and overall it made for a great starter. We had a nice break between our starters and mains arriving, which we appreciated. When they arrived though all of the main dishes were delicious! The burger was so juicy and all of the flavours together worked so well, I can see why this is considered one of the best burgers in New York. Shoutout to the fries that came with the dish as well, they were so moreish and none of us could stop eating them. The pizza was more of a Neapolitan style pizza but the dough was tasty and we all thought it was an enjoyable slice. We ended the meal with some espresso martinis and the s’mores calzone. The martinis were great and the calzone was a great dessert, it was just a bit too much for us after all of the food (clearly had eyes bigger than our stomachs). All in all I would highly recommend Emily if you are looking for a casual restaurant with good food. We all had 3 or 4 drinks each, along with the food, and the total bill (including tax and tip) came to c$300. We didn’t think this was bad value for the quality of food (and being New York) and we all agreed we would return. Looking forward to trying more dishes in the future!

Fayanne Betan

Burger was amazing. Pizza was good. That night the AC might have not been working so it was hot.

Hong Phuc

The emmy burger was soo goood better than in and out for sure. Haha. They have this sweet caramalized onion. Bunch of them. The burger bun was nice it has a natural sweet fresh bread aftertaste. The cut was soggy and scrispy at the round edge. Yea i was surprised too. The sauce was good as well it helps the bun the meat soft and flavourful. The fries with it was crispy it is good enough to binge eating when you need some rest from the burger. But personally this portion was 33 something plus tax. This burger was good but the price was just a little pricey to what it offers. However a good nice experience. And a cold free tap water per person.

+7

We had a reservation for 3 on a Friday night and were seated as soon as we arrived. The restaurant is small and was really busy so would recommend booking, at least for weekends. We ordered the hot w…

We had a reservation for 3 on a Friday night and were seated as soon as we arrived. The restaurant is small and was really busy so would recommend booking, at least for weekends. We ordered the hot…

Service was good and so was the ambiance. The burger was pretty bland and seemed not that warm. Onions on top also seemed cold. The loaded fries were oddly sweet. Banana pudding was solid but the s'm…

Service was good and so was the ambiance. The burger was pretty bland and seemed not that warm. Onions on top also seemed cold. The loaded fries were oddly sweet. Banana pudding was solid but the…

Service was good and so was the ambiance. The burger was pretty bland and seemed not that warm. Onions on top also seemed cold. The loaded fries were oddly sweet. Banana pudding was solid but the s…

Service was good and so was the ambiance. The burger was pretty bland and seemed not that warm. Onions on top also seemed cold. The loaded fries were oddly sweet. Banana pudding was solid but the s…

service was good and so was the ambiance. The burger was pretty bland and seemed not that warm. Onions on top also seemed cold. The loaded fries were oddly sweet. Banana pudding was solid but the s…

Service was good and so was the ambiance. The burger was pretty bland and seemed not that warm. Onions on top also seemed cold. The loaded fries were oddly sweet. Banana pudding was solid but the s…

Service: 1/5\nFood: \n-Caesar 2/5 - $16\n-Ranch 0/5 - $2\n-Emmy burger with bacon 4/5 -$35\n\nBiggest issue of the night, the service. We came on a Monday night, restaurant was pretty empty. Ther…

Service: 1/5\nFood: \n-Caesar 2/5 - $16\n-Ranch 0/5 - $2\n-Emmy burger with Bacon 4/5 -$35\n\nBiggest issue of the night, the service. We came on a Monday night, restaurant was pretty empty. There …

service: 1/5\nFood: \n-Caesar 2/5 - $16\n-Ranch 0/5 - $2\n-Emmy Burger with Bacon 4/5 -$35\n\nBiggest issue of the night, the service. We came on a Monday night, restaurant was pretty empty. Ther…

Came here on a Saturday for a party of 2 for a 5pm reservation. We were seated immediately and the place was pretty empty. The space is tight and the tables are really close together. The service w…

A really good burger if you like a saucy drippy messy burger. The fries dipped in the saucy drippy mess were excellent. Good service. The lights were dim in the restaurant tonight so we really didn…

We ordered burgers and fries. Love the burger it was so juicy! Ambience was good, i think drinks are overpriced

Writing the review I wish I’d see before I went for everyone else with celiac. Despite what’s indicated on their website, there’s no gluten free pizza available at this restaurant. That said, we saw…

Writing the review I wish I’d see before I went for everyone else with celiac. Despite what’s indicated on their website, there’s no gluten free pizza available at this restaurant. That said, …

Writing the review I wish I’d see before I went for everyone else with celiac. Despite what’s indicated on their website, there’s no gluten free pizza available at this restaurant. That said, we s…

Oscar Monge

came here from a twitter post saying that it was the best burger in the city. drove from long island to try it. ordered the original Dan’s pizza and the Emmy Burger. we were starving, so we were ready to eat. Emmy Burger is an 8/10. great sauce, firm bun, and the meat was delicious. It is a top10 burger. absolutely not worth the price or the hype. for $31 you can make yourself a delicious burger at home, while watching a movie. The fries seem to vary from picture to picture—I got more of a white thin fry than other customers in reviews did (brown, crumbly fries). See photos for reference. pizza was 5/10. it is a vodka pie but it ate more like a white slice. Flavor lacked there wasnt the necessary amount of vodka for a vodka pie. in fact, there was a lack of sauce entirely. $20, but the mozz was good to bite into. you can get a better slice/pie elsewhere, 100%. in short—great atmosphere and friendly hostess. but i would not come back. This is the best way to explain my feelings about Emily— my friend and i said if we were to pick a Chili’s burger or an Emmy Burger, we would choose an Emmy Burger. If we were to pick between Chili’s or Emily’s though? = Chili’s 10 times out of 10 times. things are getting expensive nowadays, and i dont even have a recommended place for you to go elsewhere. but, staying home with your wife or girlfriend and making a burger would be much more worth it. save your money and make her happy.

The burgers were quite pricey. The fries were so tasty and lots of portions. Came there recently and ordered some burgers. They have lots of flavors and big portion size. Amazing pizza too and the …

Why did I only give a 3 well 3.8 because to pay $31 for a burger and fries is a little crazy. The restaurant is a bit uncomfortable. The staff is ok. Outside seating was terrible. The burger was g…

Why did I only give a 3 well 3.8 because to pay $31 for a burger and fries is a little crazy. The restaurant is a bit uncomfortable. The staff is ok. Outside seating was terrible. The burger…

Why did I only give a 3 well 3.8 because to pay $31 for a burger and fries is a little crazy. The restaurant is a bit uncomfortable. The staff is ok. Outside seating was terrible. The burger was…

Why did I only give a 3 well 3.8 because to pay $31 for a burger and fries is a little crazy. The restaurant is a bit uncomfortable. The staff is ok. Outside seating was terrible. The burger w…

Why did I only give a 3 well 3.8 because to pay $31 for a burger and fries is a little crazy. The restaurant is a bit uncomfortable. The staff is ok. Outside seating was terrible. The burger was…

Garvin

We had the brussel sprouts, Emmy Burger and Emily pizza. The Brussel sprouts were a bit tough, could have been cooked and caramelized longer. The Emmy Burger was bland and could've used more salt. The fries that came with it was good though. The Emily pizza reminded more of cheese bread than white pizza. The pistachio and honey taste were very light pretty much non-existent, we were thinking more honey would've helped a lot. 1/4th of the crust was also burnt black as you can see in the picture Overall we were disappointed with our dinner here.

I'm writing this literally right on my couch from getting home from dinner. That's how upset I am with the service tonight. \nI've been a loyal fan of this restaurant for years, and I've talked abo…

the worst sweet burger i have ever tasted, the pizzas are below average, it’s too expensive and let’s not forget the plastic plates

There are soo many good pizza places around here. This was terrible. I don't get the hype. Trader joes boxed pizza is better than this. The flavor of the bread was flat. The texture was a bit like cardboard. I mean doesn't it start w the bread? The sauce...you guys, there's this thing called garlic.. don't be scared of it. Is basil expensive? A couple of small pieces per slice, that's it. There's a place across the street from us that's 20 times better than Emily's.

Brian Gunderson

I usually have enjoyed this place, but the other day I went and it was perhaps the most disgusting horrid burger I’ve ever had in my life. My medium rare burger was cooked well done. The pretzel bun was rock hard stale. The Carmelized onions were cold. It was eating an old tire between stale buns with ice cold onions on top. Comically horrible. And service this time was pretty bad, they forget our drinks and were just at the bar scrolling on their phones not helping us.

Gina McDonald

We had the pizza delivered. It was completely burned and in trash. Shame on you. Who actually eats this. Would like to understand how you think you can get away with this.

Courtney Desmarattes

I'm writing this literally right on my couch from getting home from dinner. That's how upset I am with the service tonight. I’ve been a loyal fan of this restaurant for years, and I’ve talked about the Emmy Burger to anyone who would listen. I was genuinely excited to come back after some time away which made this experience even more disappointing. From the start, things went downhill. I ordered a mezcal margarita, and it arrived extremely bitter to the point of being undrinkable. I ended up having to ask for simple syrup just to salvage it. Then our burgers came out cold. Both of them. I sent mine back to be rewarmed, and when it returned, it still wasn’t fully warm, and it had been cooked well-done instead of the medium-well I ordered. At that point I didn’t even bother sending it back again. My friend’s Diet Coke was completely flat, which felt like another careless detail on top of everything else. To end the night, my banana pudding arrived in an actual plastic takeout-style container, which was honestly the last straw. For a restaurant with such a strong reputation and price point, this felt shockingly low-effort. I left feeling genuinely let down. I’ve supported this place for years, bragged about it, and looked forward to returning, and instead had one of the most disappointing dining experiences I’ve had in a long time. Lastly the amount of space from table to table is just rediculous. I felt like I was in a closet. Super disappointing.

Jason Ramirez

TL;DR: found a used stick-on fingernail in my napkin, the response to it was atrocious. Tbf the food was good. I'm really not one to give bad reviews, but the experience here was atrocious and unhygienic. Went out for dinner here with friends on a relaxed Monday evening, ordering the burger + 2 pizzas. The food itself was good but received an unpleasant surprise when a used stick-on fingernail was found among the provided utensils (see pic). When we reported to the server, she merely replied, "oh, that's embarrassing :)". There was no apology nor offer to remedy (I paid full price) from the staff. What an inappropriate response to finding a FINGERNAIL?!? The food is honestly good, but this response was "embarrassing :)". This place needs to get its operations in order and train staff to properly address these kinds of things. My friends and I will not be coming back here or their sister establishments again.