Pie-O-Mine / Greens
Pizza, salad · Buffalo
About Pie-O-Mine / Greens
At Pie-O-Mine / Greens, we're passionate about serving up delicious comfort food that caters to all tastes. Our cozy atmosphere invites you to relax and enjoy a great meal, while our friendly staff will take care of everything else. We offer a variety of healthy options to satisfy your cravings, inc...
At Pie-O-Mine / Greens, we're passionate about serving up delicious comfort food that caters to all tastes. Our cozy atmosphere invites you to relax and enjoy a great meal, while our friendly staff will take care of everything else. We offer a variety of healthy options to satisfy your cravings, including build-your-own salads, vegan and gluten-free choices, and mouthwatering pizzas made fresh in-house. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a satisfying dinner, we've got you covered. Our welcoming space is designed to make everyone feel at home, with wheelchair accessible facilities ensuring accessibility for all. Come visit us and experience the perfect blend of flavor and comfort that's made us a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
What Customers Say About Pie-O-Mine / Greens
Pie-O-Mine / Greens is loved for its customizable salads and pizzas with fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the crispy pizza crust and the wide selection of salad toppings. Some find it pricey and note inconsistent execution of orders.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Order ahead for lunch or dinner to save time. Customize your salad or pizza with the many topping choices.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Pie-O-Mine / Greens
Pie-O-Mine / Greens Buffalo Reviews
I’ve been to Pie-O-Mine multiple times and have never been disappointed, not in the food, the service, or the cleanliness. Every visit has been consistently great. Yesterday (2/28 around 1 PM), the young woman who took care of us was absolutely top notch, friendly, attentive, and on point the entire time. And the Buffalo pizza we ordered? To die for. Perfect flavor, perfectly cooked, just incredible. I can't stop thinking about it actually. Highly recommend. We’ll definitely be back!
Great salads and pizza. The staff are very nice as well. I highly recommend giving Pie o Mine a try!
The best salads ever! Ingredients is always fresh, service is fast. You can create your own salad and choose from dozens of vegetables, fruits and other toppings.
Every order is a collaboration between you and the cook on the other side of the counter. The salads and pizza menu is a natural fit. Those in the know order ahead and bring home a lunch or dinner. And it's healthy when you consider the many choices for toppings.
The wrap here was amazing. You can custom make a wrap with anything you like! Once it was all together it was huge! I feel it was a nice meal for the price.
Very good big salads. Can easily split a large and be pretty full. Pizza is pretty good too. Thin wood fired style. Overall real, good food.
This was our first visit and we were thoroughly impressed. We got a small salad and pie and the selection of Ingredients was incredible.. if you miss old school salad bars, this is the place for. We got the classic pizza and the crust was so good, had the perfect crisp. We will definitely be back! Drove all the way from depew to try it. It's well worth it.
My sister and I usually get the build your own Salads. But we recently tried the pizza. Being vegan, dairy free and gluten free it's hard to eat at restaurants now. But the young ladies who was preparing my food was very knowledgeable on what items actually had gluten and dairy. They were mindful about changing gloves and they also had the gluten free crust completely separate from the rest. I would definitely recommend trying them out. Especially on Sundays lol it's not pack at all.
Great salads! I love that they chop it very thin. I got the create your own salad packed with veggies, no cheese, extra protein and EVOO with lemon as my dressing. They have large variety of dressings too. I Haven't tried the pizza but heard it was awesome! Loved the food so much i went back a second time the next day !
Had dinner at the new Pie-O-Mine on Sheridan last night with my sister and cousin. I have been enjoying their food since they opened Transit Rd and have now converted my cousin and sister into fans. I loved the decor, from the tables and chairs to sayings on the wall (I even over heard another pair of diners making sure they read them all). I made own Pizza with Vodka sauce , olives , feta and artichoke hearts then topped off with the Balsamic glaze (a favorite combo of mine) and they each ordered one from the menu (BBQ Chicken and Pesto Chicken). All three of us ate all but one slice of our pizzas - yummy doesn't do them justice. All the ingredients are fresh and the pizza's cook in 3 minutes making it the best fast food around.
This is my second time at this restaurant the wraps are amazing. My personal favorite is the Turkey club. Wrap.. The Pizza is really good and their prices are really really It's affordable
The place is great but it’s too open to seat and eat like you need booths the door opens you feel the cold 🥶
My girlfriend and I recently ate here a friend at work told us about this amazing place where you can make your own pizza or salads we both had the idea of making our own salads but when we soon arrived we decided to do pizzas the pizzas were phenomenal flat thin crust crispy tasty toppings the workers were in Good Moods with great attitudes we will definitely be back actually affordable with good size portions!
We were really excited about discovering this place. They did an amazing job creating our salads. For some reason this time around things weren't as thorough. My wife ordered dressing on the side-(no dressing added) my wife asked that that her salad be chopped and protein added after, it looked as if the person remembered half way through what was kindly included in the meal prep directions. My complaint is the cleanliness of my container, come on guys nobody wants what was on the counter on the bottom of their bowl. So, a Lil more awareness of the serving containers and directions would be greatly appreciated. Overall these make a great salad. It's just that if I'm going to tip AFTER paying 40-50 bucks for a couple salads and we blindly tip foe your efforts, please try to give a better effort for the details. Thank you for your time and attention to this concern
Ordered takeout- the salad experience here leaves a lot to be desired. Upon first glance it looks like a lot of lettuce. But on closer inspection the double order of avocado I paid for was just a small normal portion (of what tastes like underripe Florida avocado and not the regular kind too), the add-on chicken was nonexistent (I honestly thought they forgot, but it turned out it was just a teaspoons worth of minuscule chicken), and the beets were just shredded up stuff that didn’t look like fresh beets. My husband did enjoy his pizza, hence one extra star. I’m bummed because it’s hard enough to find a good salad place in Buffalo, but oh well. Better luck somewhere else!
Restaurant nice and clean. Ordered on website for pickup. Got there and it wasn't even acknowledged yet that they had online orders. They then immediately started both pizzas. Both pizza's were requested to be well done. Both were so undercooked they couldn't be eaten. Sad that we pay these prices for something noone would eat.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Tin Tin
Home Taste
Nowhere Lounge
Olisi's New York Style Pizza
Tap That Tap Room
Chan's Wok
Moe's Southwest Grill
The Gateway Cafe & Grill
Bar Gonzaga
Romeo & Juliet's Bakery & Caffe
29 Photos
Explore Pie-O-Mine / Greens's photos
About Pie-O-Mine / Greens
How to get there
1725 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda, NY 14223
Buffalo, NY 14223
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
Buffalo Bisons vs. Lehigh Valley Iron Pigs
29 May 2026, 18:05
Sahlen Field
Lespecial
29 May 2026, 20:00
Buffalo Iron Works
Cake
29 May 2026, 20:00
Terminal B At The Outer Harbor
Live Band Karaoke 90s Rock and Pop Edition
29 May 2026, 22:00
Rec Room
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Pie-O-Mine / Greens and other restaurants
Earn Points at Pie-O-Mine / Greens!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Pie-O-Mine / Greens
🏆 Rewards at Pie-O-Mine / Greens
10% Discount
At Pie-O-Mine / Greens
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu