We had Valentine's dinner here while in town from Phoenix. The service was impeccable, our meals were delicious, portions were large, and the atmosphere was incredibly romantic. I can't wait for another opportunity to dine here.

Went to Sinatras with a group of friends for dinner for the first time in early February. Food and service were excellent. Definitely a place to which my wife and I will return.

Amazing company, with a great history and terrific food! 👏 one of my top all-time restaurants always feel at home there.

We had an outstanding dining experience at Sinatra’s.The food was fantastic and our server, Danny, went out of his way to make sure our evening was perfect. We will definitely dine at Sinatra’s again!

My wife had the ravioli with meatball, I had eggplant parmigiana, and we each had the house salad dressed with Bleu cheese crumbles and vinaigrette. We are agreed that the quality was very good, and the portions were ample.

Outstanding establishment....!!! There are only a handful of restaurants in the United States that have customer service as good as Sinatra's. Sit at the bar and you will see for yourself.

This is fine dining at its best.Mark our waiter was very friendly and helpful.The food here is excellent.We had to take some home.The service was perfect, never rushed. there was a nice break between courses, as we were celebrating our anniversary there was no hurry just wanted to enjoy a nice meal and this was perfect. Definitely will go back It is nice to see someplace like this still around.

We love Sinatra’s the food is consistently good, we have never had a bad meal there. Service impeccable they treat you like royalty and make sure you are happy. I love the coppinata and there pizza bread. The greens and fave beans delicious. My only suggestion would be to have the calamari fried as well I’m a fan of calamari and prefer it that way than in sauce. But we love it at Sinatra’s

Amazing food, ambiance and elegance. A place for special occasions indeed. Pam and Mike are incredibly genuine people. 👍❤

OUTSTANDING food and excellent service. Waiters were very attentive, checked in with us frequently, remembered what we were drinking and offered refills, food arrived quickly, and everything from the main entree's to the salad/soup and appetizers were delicious and seasoned perfectly. Being a 5 star Restaurant, be prepared to pay more but it was so worth it.

Absolutely awesome! Great atmosphere with the remodel, very modern look. Food is outstanding, never a bad meal from this place. Service was also outstanding. Work function, family function or romantic night out, Sinatra's is a great option.

I went straight sea food, it was awesome

+1

While the old place had decent Italian food, what it had in spades was charm. The bar was intimate, almost from a movie set, the patrons looked the part, and the bartenders were welcoming and droll. I always looked forward to a glass of wine at the bar before our meal, just to soak in the vibe.The old dining room was crowded, but in a good way. While the food was always pretty good, you always got a large helping of obviously home cooked food.

Never had a bad meal here. Cozy atmosphere, great authentic Italian food. Good wine list and reasonably priced for the quality of the food. Best place for Italian in buffalo IMO. Can't wait for the new location across the street to open.

If it’s a very crowded night it can be very noisy & consequently difficult to have easy conversation. We sat in a room with brick walls which could have been part of the acoustical problem. Otherwise it’s a lovely space.

What a wonderful dining experience! The meal was absolutely delicious, I started off with the artichoke franchise (amazing) followed by the Chicken Piccalo entree and finally The tiramisu for dessert. It was so delish! Our waitress was really fantastic she made sure everything was perfect for us. This is always one of my favorite places for a special meal! Definitely give it a try, you will be glad you did!

We had an absolutely wonderful dinner. Everyone was so nice. The food was delicious.

We had a party of 15 at Sinatra's tonight! Excellent food and excellent service. From the guys taking care of the valet parking, to the bar tenders to the wait staff, everyone did a great job! A special shout out to our waiter Jake. Thanks so much!

The best lasagna I’ve ever had and I’m 71 years old. Outstanding service.

Wonderful the food is always delicious, service is excellent. The decor is modern wit a touch h of nostalgia. The only problem is the acoustics, they are terrific in the dining area and private dining room. You can barely hear the person across from you.

Excellent in every way! Celebrated a birthday for my dad there. We were all very pleased with our meals. And leftovers!

Went here Friday night and had a great evening. Apps were all very good, drinks were a little pricey, but thats been the norm lately. Dinners were excellent. Staff was attentive and friendly, would def recomend this place for a special evening. Food was reasonably priced for a high end Italian restaurant.

Amazing place!! Food is spectacular, staff is superior, ambiance is wonderful! Loved it so much that even though it's almost two hours from my home, I will definitely be making special trips here to bring my friends to share the wonderful experience I had here. Special kudos to Lenny the bartender.

This is outstanding authentic Italian cuisine. Cocktails are sublime

I recently, in error, rated Sinatra's a one star rating. Being as dumb as I am, I did it twice!! My apologies. Having eaten at this fine establishment many times over the years (I keep going back because it's so good), I can only rate the ambiance, the service and the food (oh, the food!) as outstanding. One of my favorite restaurants!!

Excellent food, though this is a high end restaurant so its a little pricy. Worth it tho!

A smashing place to celebrate an anniversary, long-time friends get together, or business meeting. Great foods, best service, and, yes, a bit priced, but worth every penny! My wife and I celebrated our 25th anniversary here, and the experience was exquisite! I will have to keep this on the must re-list list!

Fantastic food, generous portions and very friendly and efficient service!

Yummy food! Loved the gorgonzola sauce on the tortellini! All delicious!

+2

Hats off to the Culinary Team, entire Wait Staff & Valet Service for providing a 5 star dining experience! The restaurant is immaculate & tastefully decorated throughout, the ambiance is perfect for celebrating any occasion.

Food, service and atmosphere were all top notch. Called ten minutes out on a Friday night and we were able to accommodate a table for two. Our server Mark was outstanding in recommending wine and dishes. A tad pricey but worth every penny for the quality of food and service. We can't wait to come back.

Had a Phenomenal dinner and time at Sinatra's. Went there for our 32nd wedding anniversary. My Bride was ecstatic with everything from the drinks through desert. And if she's happy, I'm happy! On another note this was our first time there. I went over to another table where a couple was waiting for the rest of their party. When I inquired what they have had previously their response was "there isn't anything on the menu that we would not like". I believe that would be 100% true after we experienced the quality with just a few dishes... The beverages were excellent too.

Sinatra’s always delivers a wonderful and intimate experience. They were able to accommodate a rather large party, without a lot of advance. Our waitress (I believe her name was Jenny) was absolutely great and very attentive as were the serving assistants. Our food was all spot on without a single thing over done or served improperly. My friends and I will continue to dine here for years to come!

First time May 2023 Our group had a wonderful experience. The dining room was very comfortable. Our Server was especially tentative and courteous. All 5 of us enjoyed our appetizers, Salads, Dinners & Desserts. Enjoy a special occasion with family and friends you won't regret spending here. One suggestion I could make is to pamper the exterior garden beds. Doing that would really perk up the exterior of the lovely building this restaurant is located in. Best.

There were four of us at dinner tonight to celebrate our friend's birthday. Mark (I think that was his name. Could be Vinnie which shows on our receipt) greeted us and was very attentive throughout our meal. He helped us to make sure the birthday gal had her cake with a candle. Food was delicious; service very attentive, and as I wrote, Mark (or Vinnie) was extremely polite, attentive and helpful. Thank you. Sinatra's never fails to make our dining experience wonderful.

This was an overall great dining experience. The food and service were great. We had Sean as our server; he was super efficient, positive and very helpful. I usually don’t post reviews but with good food and good service, I felt the need to share. 10/10

We started w class corals at the beautiful lounge area, very accommodating and friendly, plus the cocktail menu had so many delicious options. Had dinner shortly after, and it was amazing! The lasagna is a happy to-die-for dish, for which I ordered, but don’t miss out on all Sinatra’s has to offer because everything is worth it. Very reasonably priced, service is impeccable and it’s just one of the best places for true Italian food in Buffalo. Highly recommend.

Best lasagna I have ever had! Will be back again. Picture of the burrata salad. Amazing!

First of all, the new re model is beautiful. I love how they incorporated pieces from the old restaurant throughout, still giving it that warm Sinatra’s feel. It’s fresh and modern, but with traditional touches. We have been multiple times now and have always experienced amazing service. We normally eat at the bar which has very comfortable seats, lighting is perfect, and it’s just a great environment overall. Last night, we had a party of 14 in the private room to celebrate my husband’s birthday. The service was on point, we received our food and wine quickly and didn’t have to ask for anything- not once. We felt completely taken care of in every way. Michael and Pamela Sinatra truly couldn’t have been better hosts. The food was great and the portion sizes are huge! I had enough leftovers for lunch AND dinner! I read a few other reviews, and completely shocked that anyone would have a complaint about the portions! Anyway- amazing and consistent experience every time.

The aroma that greets you as you enter is mouthwatering and the food is absolutely delicious! We had a delightful server and the restaurant is very attractive. The noise level made conversation challenging and I don't understand why they didn't create a back entry from the parking lot....

This was our first time at Sinatra’s, although now having been I do wonder what took us so long. The restaurant is gorgeous and impeccably clean. We were welcomed by a friendly staff and our waiter was attentive and helpful. The wine list was impressive, and the food was delicious. We enjoyed our evening very much and will definitely be back.

Start to finish excellence. Arrived on a Thursday evening and it was not very busy yet. Our server was very attentive and helpful. We had an excellent bottle of wine and shared a couple of appetizers. The calamari, and the clams casino are definitely recommended. For dinner, we had ravioli which had a really good flavor - a hint of mint. The meatballs that came with the ravioli were also tasty and had a good texture. For dessert, I had the berries and cream - an excellent finish to the meal. The wife had the cassata cake, which was reportedly very good. Overall, a definite recommendation. We will absolutely be back soon.

One of the best meals I have had in the area. Seafood was fresh, sauce was just as I like it and portions were huge. The new building is gorgeous, the bartenders and waitstaff were very friendly and made sure we wanted for nothing. I can't wait to go back with my boyfriend and share this experience with him!

Food was fabulous and drinks were superb and casada cake yummy!

Eggplant parm, short ribs, pasta and seafood bowl. Cassata cake was delicious.

+1

The best Italian food around. Staff are really good

Kim Wheatley

This restaurant is classy, from the service to the food. It’s not pretentious nor over the top but upscale casual with elegant dinners.

To The Point

We celebrated our marriage engagement here and it was absolutely perfect! The staff treated us like family. I haven't stopped talking about the lasagna with their (misspelled, ♥️"Brisol" sausage inside)❤️ The atmosphere lended to the romance, for sure! We're truly looking forward to visiting Sinatra's again!

Olena Sardo

Wonderful upscale restaurant. Food was good. The service excellent. Wonderful place to go for a date night or special occasion.

Greg D

Outstanding Experience! Sinatras’s is truly first class. The decor is beautiful & clean with soft music. Our server Dan and the rest of the staff were outstanding. All food was perfectly prepared and presented in a timely fashion. Highly Recommended!!

Nikki Cole

I had a fantastic experience dining at the bar at Sinatra’s. The service was warm, friendly, and perfectly attentive—everything you want when eating solo or on a date. I started with the banana peppers and followed with the lasagna—both were absolutely delicious. I finished with the gelato, the perfect sweet ending to a great meal!

Anthony Costanzo

Outstanding Restaurant, the food was authentic Italian Food and quality was 5 stars. We always try to stop here whenever we are in Buffalo. They expanded the bar area from last time we were in town. Bartenders are the best! Owners are attentive and truly make a point to check on every guest. Sinatras is Buffalo must go restaurant. 😉

Marcus W

Nice gem tucked away in North Buffalo. Remodeled restaurant looks awesome. Excellent service. Delicious food. You cant ask for anything else as a patron. Celebrated my anniversary here and my wife loved the choice so you're top of the list in my book.

How it is Liz

I've been coming to Sinatra’s since the days of their original location across the street—This place has long been one of the most well-known and consistently amazing Italian restaurants in Buffalo, and it continues to live up to its reputation! The service was excellent, attentive without being overbearing. I had a chocolate martini that was absolutely perfect, and we couldn’t stop raving about the meatballs and the artichoke francese. Both were cooked to perfection! My sister wasn't as wild about the stuffing in the banana peppers—just a personal preference, so it might be worth asking which cheese they use if you’re particular about that. On the flip side, I absolutely loved the new halibut special, which was beautifully topped with seafood. The portion was generous but didn’t feel heavy. It was really well balanced. The ambiance is elegant and upscale with a beautiful big bar and a well-mannered crowd. Parking is easy, too, with a decent-sized lot in the back. Sinatra’s continues to deliver outstanding Italian cuisine-definitely a Buffalo staple that I’ll keep coming back to!

+8

Roy Schukraft

Outstanding service, a beautiful Italian red wine recommendation from our bartender/server, fresh baked bread and a wonderful ambiance.

Gretchell Rogers

We are there two nights in a row. The food was exceptional.

+1

Ajinkya Buradkar

Excellent restaurant with great ambiance. Has plenty of unique vegetarian options. Cozy bar and prompt service.

Doug

Sinatra’s is such an amazing restaurant and you simply can’t go wrong dining here. Fantastic service, delicious food and a very upscale vibe. It’s always a pleasure dining here and can’t wait to go back again!

Monica Shepherd

My sons took me out for my birthday this evening. The service was great and the food was delicious.

Andrea M

Mother's Day dinner was delicious. Everyone enjoyed their meal. The restaurant is very upscale and the service was outstanding. I had their take on a caprese salad. It was done with watermelon and fresh mozzarella. Also, enjoyed bracole and my mom had chicken francaise. Not to mention the great blood orange perseco fizz I enjoyed.

Khristina S

What a great first time experience here! My companions & I had reservations right at opening and were seated immediately upon arriving. Our server Barbara was very knowledgeable and Anna was both patient and kind as she assisted with service & between courses. As a party of 7, we were fortunate to try a variety of starters: beef carpacio, clams casino (the special appetizer of the evening), the meatball with ricotta, and arancini. The entrees were well-proportioned and the desserts I'm told were divine. From Seafood Alla Sinatra to Ravioli, Chicken Parmigiano to a sizeable veal chop, everyone was extremely pleased with their meals. I personally chose a variety of appetizers as my meal (as I'm choose to eat keto-friendly) and I HIGHLY recommend the Artichokes Francaise. They were crisp without being oily and the combo of lemon & capers were the perfect foil to the egg, cheese & artichoke.

+13

Christopher Frankhauser

What more can I say about Sinatra's I absolutely love this place .I have heard people stay that it has lost its charm from when it was across the street I totally disagree. I think people have a hard time letting go .the food was absolutely amazing as usual and the staff is always on point and smiling and ready at a arms reach to make sure you have a great experience. We had the honor to have one of there best serve us last night Dan is a long time Sinatara's employee he has embraced what it is to fully commit to the upscale restaurant experience. Any questions with wine or food items he was very quick to answer . Overall I give the old and new Sinatras 5☆☆☆

+1

Reine H

Absolutely amazing experience- loved the old Sinatra but very impressed with the new space. The menu is as always delicious! The calamari is a must on the appetizer list. A MUST! It’s not fried, right amount of spice. The white clam sauce is to die for, my daughter agrees with their “best meatballs in Buffalo” claim and the eggplant parmigiana is 🙀😍. Great service, great food and lovely experience

Some entrees, were on the smaller side

What a beautiful restaurant! We’d never been (to the old or new location), so we decided to try it out for my birthday. Our starters (the basket of bread/pizza and arancini appetizer) were excellent! Sooo much flavor! For our entrees we got eggplant parm and the bolognese. I have to say, we were a bit surprised by the lack of flavor in the red sauce. Both entrees were ‘okay’, but we felt that the sauce was missing something - it was just very bland. To finish we got tiramisu for dessert, which was great. Waiter was very attentive and friendly. So overall I’d say we had a good experience, but again, the red sauce was just ‘meh’. Perhaps it was just that night?! We plan to return in the future to give them another shot!

It was a very cold night. Very few tables occupied. 3 or 4 I believe. Server was just ok. Never asked if wed like more bread. Food quality good but noticed artichokes were different than in previous visits. More of a mass produced look. Side of pasta was messily served. My partner was looking for a whole egg in his braciole but it was chopped up. Everything else was great. But not as good as previous visits.

5 of us for dinner. Everyone liked their meal. My linguine with white clam sc was excellent. Five stars for the artichoke app. Service was vanilla. Not bad but not personal either. Seemed like server was always running. Definitely did not like the $25 corkage fee. That is very high especially when most wine selections were upwards of 50. And most were Italian wines.

I made reservations for 530pm on a Monday. Our waitress was amazing. It was not busy. The food was delicious. My only suggestion is that their menu accurately displays what's in a meal. Their meatballs is cooked in their marinara sauce, so the sauce is truly not meat free. Their appetizer meatballs say beef when truly it's a mix of meat. This is important for customers like myself who do not eat pork or beef.

40th anniversary dinner at Sinatra's. Attentive service from Chad/Steve/Mark...and nice entree selections. Special thanks to our hosts: Kevin and Gavin. (Happy 44th Mark).

Thought was quite good and am looking forward to going back.

Went there for my wife's birthday. Table of 4 people. Everyone's food was good. Prices are reasonable. The only problem was that the host and waiter knew it was her birthday, and they couldn't even offer a free drink or dessert for her.

Our food was very good. We were just disappointed in the service that day. It took about 70 minutes to get our food and over 100 to get out the door and our server seemed stretched between too many tables. Maybe they were short staffed that day and it was a one off, but it was surprisingly slow

Steve Lane

It’s fancy, but not too fancy. The food was very good and the service impeccable. A nice place for a nice meal.

No salad no bread meatballs and sauce w/o any pasta and no water jugs on tables..food appeared mostly processed and not homemade. Was not impressed..but was a fundraiser so what can you do. I'm sure if you order a dinner it will hopefully be much better..but they lost me.

This is a tough one. The food and service were both superb. This was real Italian food..what my Sicilian children would call Italian food for Italians. The food and service both get an A+. Unfortunately, seating and environment get a C-. First, we had a 7:00 reservation, arrived at 6:55 and didn't get seated until 7:11.. that's just unacceptable. Second, and here's the deal killer. The NOISE in this place was horrendous. It was so loud that I had to turn my hearing aid off and then I couldn't have a conversation with my wife during our meal. Fine food, absolutely exquisite. Fine dining, not even close. For a few bucks more, there's Lombardo's around the corner with both fine dining and fine food.

Appetizers: 2.5, small portions where the quality didn't make up for the size. Clams casino rocked, the rest were average at best Entree: 4, I had the the mushroom stuffed pasta which was great!! Service: 2, we had a table of 6 that wasn't waited on particularly great. Certainly miles away from a hutches or tempo experience. Dessert took a fair amount of time. Atmosphere: 4, the inside is lovely. However we hated our table. It was too large and anyone on the other side stood no chance of hearing us. Tables are close together as well, two waiters backed into me by accident.

It was very good but I was a little mad that there are 2 sizes for meals one is 23.95 and the other is 33.95. I guess we were charged for the 33.95. we did not know this. Never asked by our server if we wanted large or small. I would have not ordered a large and that is a big difference in price. I think they should at least ask you. It was very good but not happy about that.

Food was overpriced for average pasta. Drinks were good but server did mess them up a few times. Atmosphere was good just the food did not match. We got gluten free pasta with an up charge but I’m pretty sure it was just boxed penne pasta. The gelato was good though.

Deborah Palazzo

I love eating at Sinatra's Restaurant. The taste of their sauce & Meatballs remind me of my own family❤️ So, when I ordered Tagliatelle Veal Bolognese, I was expecting a generous amount of veal with their fabulous, delicious sauce. It was just the opposite. Barely any sauce and barely any veal. I ended up ordering a meatball on the side. The waiter was so sweet. He offered to have them pour sauce over the pasta in my to go container. When I arrived home and transferred the food to my own container, it looked the same as when I ordered it. Disappointed......👎 I will continue to frequent Sinatra's, the other dishes I have ordered in the past were wonderful, just not "TVB"........

Waiter kept getting orders wrong, didn't think they needed to write down the orders but clearly they kept forgetting. They also overcharged us, listing some items twice that we only got one of. I didn't notice until we had already left because it was a large receipt for a group of 6. Am I gonna go back to seek reimbursement? No in fact I'm not going back at all lol.

My family and I have been going to the little spot across the street for well over two decades, and it was always consistently delicious. As of late, my fourth time in the new location has provided me with more inconsistencies. I loved the homey aspects of Sinatra’s. That is something my family and I were able to expect out of the old little spot across the street; this is something that has not been recreated in the new spot. The aesthetic of the new spot is immaculate, however the experience, and the consistency of the new location has been incomparable to the old spot across the street.

After being seated at our table we waited 15 mins before a waiter came over and greeted us. Although he apologized for the wait it felt he was rushing as well to get our order in. I was also given a dirty silverware when dessert was about to be served dried food was stuck to the spoon itself when it was placed in front of me. A table of 8 was sat next to us and was so noise heavy the yelling to each other I could barely hear my husband who was speaking to me. Also the menu online doesn’t match the menu that was given to us at the table. I reviewed the menu u before going and was disappointed the dish I planned on getting was not on menu that was given to me

Started out with low quality burrata cheese then had Peppers that tasted like soap. Poor excuse for bolognese. Cheap pasta with barely any meat. Overrated under executed.

Went there tonight for dinner. Was placed in the back to the left of the bar area. Food was good. At the end of the meal we were relaxing and drinking our wines. When the waitress came to clear our plates, she spilled my husband's 1/2 glass of wine all over him. It was a mess. Shirt and pants The! It was red wine also.The only thing she offered was a napkin so he could clean up best he could. When she brought the bill, there was no compensation or anything. We will NOT RETURN

We were a party of five. Had reservations for 6:30 on a Sunday. We were seated immediately and our drink order was taken right away. It was 7:15 before our dinner orders were taken at which time we had to ask for bread. I ordered Shrimp and Lobster pasta. There was LOTS of pasta, three HALF pieces of shrimp (REALLY, you have to cut the shrimp in half!) and six thumbnail size pieces of lobster. All of this for $29! We will not return.

Food was good but my wife and I came here for our anniversary last month and after being seated we were completely forgotten. No service for almost 30 minutes, I understand restaurants get busy but to not even take a drink order or bring bread to the table at such a high end restaurant is ridiculous. After the half hour a server eventually came and apologized, but did not offer any compensation for the mistake. After dining here we gave feedback on their website and never heard back. $240 dinner…

Walked in for reservations and was ignored by multiple servers/hostess to accommodate people that walked in after us. Maybe because we are young and look like we are broke? Waiter and service was terrible and so was the food. 2 people in our 6 party got sick that night. Sucks that we had 2 bad experiences both times we went cause they are local. Will not return after 2 strikeouts.

My husband has been wanting to go here forever so I made reservations for our anniversary at 6 pm. Arrived at 5:54 and was told it wasn't 6 yet so they couldn't seat us even though the dining room is mostly empty. We were told to wait at the bar.....for 6 minutes. Half the bar has reserved signs in front of empty stools. Two bartenders - one doing nothing and the other filled an order for a group of maybe 6 and then walked away. We tried again to get their attention and both start chatting with what I assume were the regulars. I would try and give the benefit of the doubt and say they didn't see us but when we approached the empty "reserved" stools they let us know we couldn't sit there. We left. There are too many good restaurants in Buffalo with amazing food and service to put up with this. Glad they have enough regulars to not need new customers.

Wow what a downfall I remember the old place. I remember the atmosphere. I remember a waitress named Barb. I actually did some digging and found out how the owners wife treated her. As someone who hosted birthday parties, my engagement party and my mother’s funeral dinner here,,,,,, never again. When you get too big for your britches you lose customers. absolute disgrace. Maybe concentrate on buying more Gucci shoes than running a restaurant. Money does not buy class.

Veronica Speich

A special shout out to the hostess who offered us this table (did we feel ostricized and uncomfortable?) instead of asking if we wanted to wait for a table in the dining room. Not another patron was seated in this room. What a great way to celebrate my husband's birthday. Definitely one to remember. If we hadn't driven 40 minutes to enjoy his day here, we could and should have left. Sinatra's is this how you really treat non-regulars? Shame on you.