Yosef Rosenfield

The Holy Toasty is absolutely incredible. I've had it on multiple occasions, and it simply tastes amazing - plus they're basically giving you two sandwiches: it's around a foot long, cut in half.

Simcha Goldish

Incredibly over the top food. Fast service even on a busy night. They'll even clean a table if you ask. Robust portions and tremendous flavor. 10/10 would recommend.

Bryanna Jordan

Today was my first time ever trying Holy Schnitzels food. As a matter a fact, today was my first time ever eating at a kosher restaurant. I am an African American and I wanted to try something new. I was greeted with respect by the cashier. My order was made very fast, I did not have to wait long at all. My opinion on the burger I had is, it was good. It was way different from what I am used to since I’ve never eaten at a kosher restaurant. The food was good and I will most definitely come back. It is a bit expensive but I understand why. Their pastries filling was delicious as well. I highly recommend this place.

Dmitry Kreslavskiy

Had a great time here last night. We were in town around 9 pm and walked in for a late dinner/early midnight snack :-). Misjudged the portions (they are larger than it seems) and over-ordered somewhat. Falafel platter was excellent, - tasty falafel and nice chummus was liked by everyone. Buffalo chicken fingers also great - soft chicken and nice crunchy coating, excellent all around. Shwarma tasted regular-grilled and not from a traditional shwarma grill you see often in the Middle East, but was good. My little one was less enamored with her kids meal hamburger - meat was good but bun overburnt slightly - it was still quite edible. The kids meal also came with a toy heart that my kid was super-excited about :-) Likely one of the best fries around (both spicy and regular). Paid about $75 for everything with the drinks included. Very good deal, polite people and a good place for a late snack. Very happy to come again.

Food was great! Service needs improvement. Condiments were very limited.

Mandy

For a kosher business, I am shocked that they don’t have a sink to wash your hands before you eat. I ordered a brisket burger. I suspected it would look more like a burger, just with brisket flavoring. Boy I was wrong. The sandwitch has fatty brisket on the bottom of a thin sliced piece of chicken cutlet and onions. I wish the chicken was thicker and onion were crispy. The bun was soggy. The cashier didn’t understand me. I was speaking English. I ordered around 2:00.

Gavriel “Gavi” Hoffman

The food is great here, the staff is very helpful, but have to take off a star as this is almost always a long wait for food, many times without telling the customer (or being very wrong after telling the customer) Update: my original review was 5 years ago and nothing has changed. You can. Order 2 hours in advance and still food won't be ready. The hot dog was completely burned, they ignored all the order requests and I had to fight for a credit for their mess ups. Have to deduct 2 stars since they clearly have no interest in customer service.

This was a long time ago. So I cant say it's bad now but a long time ago I came here when my grandmother was still alive and we had dinner here. The chicken made me really sick and I ended up with food poisoning. I promised myself that I wouldn't come back here. But service back then was great. This was in 2011 2010. A really long time ago. Maybe things have changed since then. Who knows.

Jennifer Goldberg

Terrible place! Placed an order for over $75 and asked for 2 sauces per sandwich and they still charged me for those sauces since some come with sauce inside. What absurdity, with any order it shouldn’t be an extra charge (especially when spending so much)

Dan Erfan

Showed up to pickup food on Oct 16, 1030pm and the place was closed early. No warning or heads-up. Couldn't get a refund from Uber Eats. On Google the place closed at 11pm and Uber Eats the time listed is 1130. Arrived at 1030 and the place looked like it had been closed for hours.

Revi Ewis

Horrible service, complete lack of care. I'm a regular at Holy Shnitzel, and I recently tried their New Orleans Chicken sandwich. It's a delicious sandwich. However, when I ordered it tonight, I got the opposite of what I've been ordering lately. I understand it's a Saturday night, two days before Passover, which can affect the quality due to the rush, but there's something called decency. I received nothing of the New Orleans sandwich. Instead of two thick, delicious, crunchy, flaky pieces of chicken, I got two thin pieces of burnt cornflake chicken. Additionally, I didn't get any of the special sauce or coleslaw, only a few pickles. Basically, it's a dry sandwich. The least they could have done was call me and let me know they couldn't make the sandwich for me or just cancel the order, instead of giving me something so bad that bears zero resemblance to the sandwich I ordered. Attached below are two photos: one with the correct sandwich and one with the incorrect sandwich. You can see for yourself.

Joshua F

During my recent visit to Holy Schnitzel, a restaurant that I had previously considered a favorite, I encountered a deeply disappointing experience. Despite explicitly requesting a 7:00 pickup time for my sandwich, I received a text notification at 6:30 stating that it was ready. When I called to address the discrepancy, the staff claimed they hadn't prepared it yet. Eventually, when I received the sandwich, it was disappointingly soggy, with the meat slightly cold. This lack of timeliness and subpar quality left me feeling dissatisfied and questioning the attention to detail at Holy Schnitzel. The disheartening aspect of this encounter was further amplified by the manager's dismissive attitude during our conversation. Instead of offering a genuine apology or seeking a resolution, the manager seemed indifferent to my concerns and showed a lack of empathy. Such behavior not only failed to address the issue at hand but also displayed a lack of professionalism and customer-oriented approach. The soggy sandwich, resulting from the substantial delay in preparation, significantly impacted the overall enjoyment of my meal. The bread had lost its desired texture, becoming unappealingly soft, and the meat lacked the warmth and freshness one would expect from a made-to-order item. This discrepancy between the requested pickup time and the actual preparation time highlighted a lack of attention to customer preferences and adherence to basic quality standards. Considering my recent experience, I am left with reservations about recommending Holy Schnitzel to others. Until they demonstrate a commitment to timeliness and address the issue of dismissive managerial behavior, it is difficult to have confidence in the dining experience they provide. I sincerely hope that the owner of Holy can take this into account.