Petaluma Pie Company

Delicious pies and great service! We had the Jamaican beef pie and the Chinese pork bun pie.

dude- blackberry cobbler/pie was warm and just out of the oven________ unreal,,,

Apple pecan crumble. Best pie ever.

+1

I used to eat birthday cakes…not anymore. This place has forced me into a full 180. Birthday Pies only, and only from Petaluma Pie. Call me traditional but their apple pie is incredible.

Perfect pie shop with different size pies including small personal pies, friendly staff. Parking can be kind of difficult

This quaint little store offers amazing pies. Definitely worth the stop for an afternoon delight, salty or sweet!

Perfect spot to bring home food your family will love. Awesome and creative flavors.

One of the best pies I ever had. As a former baker, you really need to buy two pies a person, my only regret. Also, the ladies working there were very nice and even offered to hold our pies if needed.

I loved this place!!! The pie is great, service was good and its in a very nice location. I recommend the lemon meringue pie.

Everyone that works here is so kind and personable. The banana pies are amazing. They have an awesome selection of vegetarian hand pies which makes it a go to for lunch downtown when I'm not able to bring something from home. I love coming here

Savory and sweet delicious pies!! Pear/ginger/cardamom was amazing and all flavors rotate through. Super friendly and kind staff. Excited to see what flavors surprise us during our next visit!

Love both their savory and sweet pies! Love!

+6

Love this little gem tucked away in Putnam Plaza. Always a good variety of sweet and savory pies, at great prices in a quaint ambience. They specialize in individualized sized servings for both savory and sweet pies. Store is tiny with limited seating, but has great outdoor seating option in the plaza. Love the menu options, with core favorites and new seasonal offerings to keep things interesting. They always offer vegetarian choices on their menu. Business is environmentally conscious and generously support the community. Owners are very nice. I personally love the mushroom, or cheese burger hand pies. Order full sized dessert pies in advance for the holidays or special occasions.

My first time here I got the banana cream pie to go. Loved it so much that I went back a few days later to try the chicken pot pie. Phenomenal. I will be a frequent customer!

Came to this place and it never fails to statify my sweet cravings. The pies and service is amazing and the banana cream pie with toasted coconut is just made to perfection! I took the picture after the 1st bite realizing it is worth making the review.

This establishment is truly one of my most cherished, not only due to their exceptional pies, but also because the staff consistently demonstrates remarkable kindness, friendliness, and helpfulness towards their patrons. Furthermore, its location in such a picturesque setting provides a wonderful opportunity for relaxation and enjoyment, regardless of the weather.

Definitely turn into this plaza when you see the Petaluma Pie signs. We tried the apple pecan crumble with caramel and the Elvis pie. Both were excellent. I live about an hour and half away and would consider driving up to get the apple pecan crumble for a special family gathering. Fantastic pie shop

Amazing pie with great ambience! We tried their Elvis pie and it was delicious! Would come back again. The porch to enjoy the pie was beautiful and enjoyable!

Very good pies (abit too sweet for our taste); fresh and flavourful. Fast service and I can imagine on sunny days it would be so nice to sit outside. I’d recommend it to anyone who wants a sweet bite.

Best pies. My favorite is thr lemon meringue pie. Strawberry rhubard lemonade is DELICIOUS and really packs a punch, makings your lips pucker (just the way I like it). Worth the trip and stopping by, especially if you're in the area.

Best pie you have in this state. I had the key Lime and she ordered the apple pecan crusted. It did not disappoint. There was live music in the courtyard out front so we sat outside and enjoyed our pie with one hell of a guitarist. Can't wait to come back and try more.

Fantastic pie shop in the sweetest little corner of Downtown Petaluma. We fell in love with this shop during our fist visit to Petaluma. Fast forward a year, we celebrated our wedding in Tomales and instead of traditional wedding cake, ordered a bunch of delicious pies from Petaluma Pie. The pies were absolutely perfect and a huge hit with guests. We were going for a "rustic chic" vibe for our wedding so pies played perfectly into that theme. Prices are vey fair and the Staff is excellent to work with figuring out the correct quantities, sampling, etc.. Would highly recommend this place for a quick bite to eat or for any large event.

I really enjoyed the pie I ate. The crust was hands down near perfect. I'm looking forward to going back because I want to try some of their savory pies. A Curry pie sounds fantastic for dinner.

Hiliana Gutierrez

This establishment is truly one of my most cherished, not only due to their exceptional pies, but also because the staff consistently demonstrates remarkable kindness, friendliness, and helpfulness towards their patrons. Furthermore, its location in such a picturesque setting provides a wonderful opportunity for relaxation and enjoyment, regardless of the weather.

Jasmin Gonzalez

Came to this place and it never fails to statify my sweet cravings. The pies and service is amazing and the banana cream pie with toasted coconut is just made to perfection! I took the picture after the 1st bite realizing it is worth making the review.

Michaelpone Sufian

Amazing pie with great ambience! We tried their Elvis pie and it was delicious! Would come back again. The porch to enjoy the pie was beautiful and enjoyable!

Jeff Downing

Definitely turn into this plaza when you see the Petaluma Pie signs. We tried the apple pecan crumble with caramel and the Elvis pie. Both were excellent. I live about an hour and half away and would consider driving up to get the apple pecan crumble for a special family gathering. Fantastic pie shop

Ati

Very good pies (abit too sweet for our taste); fresh and flavourful. Fast service and I can imagine on sunny days it would be so nice to sit outside. I’d recommend it to anyone who wants a sweet bite.

Gloria Sit Lewis

Best pies. My favorite is thr lemon meringue pie. Strawberry rhubard lemonade is DELICIOUS and really packs a punch, makings your lips pucker (just the way I like it). Worth the trip and stopping by, especially if you're in the area.

Hans Hammond

Best pie you have in this state. I had the key Lime and she ordered the apple pecan crusted. It did not disappoint. There was live music in the courtyard out front so we sat outside and enjoyed our pie with one hell of a guitarist. Can't wait to come back and try more.

Jessie Simerlein

Fantastic pie shop in the sweetest little corner of Downtown Petaluma. We fell in love with this shop during our fist visit to Petaluma. Fast forward a year, we celebrated our wedding in Tomales and instead of traditional wedding cake, ordered a bunch of delicious pies from Petaluma Pie. The pies were absolutely perfect and a huge hit with guests. We were going for a "rustic chic" vibe for our wedding so pies played perfectly into that theme. Prices are vey fair and the Staff is excellent to work with figuring out the correct quantities, sampling, etc.. Would highly recommend this place for a quick bite to eat or for any large event.

Mmmmmm. Lemon meringue pie is absolutely the perfect mix of flaky crust, lemon filling, and meringue. Not too sweet, just the right size, and exactly what will make your taste buds dance with delight. Everything here is yummy.

I pre ordered a sweet potato pie with a side of whipped cream. The owner was very kind and went above and beyond accommodating me. The pie and whipped cream was incredible. Definitely will order more in the future.

Last night we had our annual family Christmas dinner and gift exchange only to be treated to two wonderful Petaluma Pie Company pies. Never heard of this place or had there pie before but they were delish. See you shortly.

Hand pies are delicious for breakfast! Different fresh pies and had pies every day! Yummy!

This is a fantastic pie shop!!! The owner is always there with a smile on his face. He's so incredibly friendly and willing to make pies that work for everyone!! Run don't walk to try this place, you will not be disappointed!!!

This was THE best lemon meringue pie I’ve ever had in my whole life and I’m an old person!!! Lightest crust, lightest filling and fluffiest merengue EVER!!! Had to hold it down to keep it from floating away! PLUS…a fabulous cool jazz trio playing in the little outdoor dining area. Just a groovy scene in every way.

Metadata

Hand pies are delicious for breakfast! Different fresh pies and had pies every day! Yummy!

Caitlin G.

I pre ordered a sweet potato pie with a side of whipped cream. The owner was very kind and went above and beyond accommodating me. The pie and whipped cream was incredible. Definitely will order more in the future.

Paul Bottler

Last night we had our annual family Christmas dinner and gift exchange only to be treated to two wonderful Petaluma Pie Company pies. Never heard of this place or had there pie before but they were delish. See you shortly.

Richard Conley

I love the savory meat pies. Sometimes the fruit pies have too much of a gelatin substance and not enough fruit so now I avoid those.

Rebekah Chang

Mmmmmm. Lemon meringue pie is absolutely the perfect mix of flaky crust, lemon filling, and meringue. Not too sweet, just the right size, and exactly what will make your taste buds dance with delight. Everything here is yummy.

L S

This was THE best lemon meringue pie I’ve ever had in my whole life and I’m an old person!!! Lightest crust, lightest filling and fluffiest merengue EVER!!! Had to hold it down to keep it from floating away! PLUS…a fabulous cool jazz trio playing in the little outdoor dining area. Just a groovy scene in every way.

Faune Towery

Awesome local place for savory and sweet pies. Had the cheeseburger pie and it was delicious. Cute outdoor seating and dog friendly lawn for a picnic outside.

Jackie Ho

We ordered pies for our wedding and the team at Petaluma Pie Company (Taylor) were super easy to work with and helpful! The pies were a hit! People loved the different flavor options.

Got Japanese curry pie, yummy. Got one coconut chocolate pie to go and hope is as good. Little cute shop with a quite a bit character.

+1

I was told about this place by a local. Had to try it. The pies come in personal size but you can order a full size pie as well. Good selection of sweet or savory pies. Strawberry rhubarb, apple, chocolate cream to cheeseburger pot pie, shepherd's pie, and chicken pot pie. I bought the chocolate cream, strawberry rhubarb, and cherry pie. All were great.

Apple pie was good but a little too sweet for me and very pricey

Tasty on some of the flavors others not so much it was hit and miss for me, i really enjoyed the Jamaican pie the most

I have been wanting to try this place out as many of my friends recommended it. Up front let me say I do like this place. I can see some room for improvement but they knock out some pretty tasty fruit, cream and savory pies. The pies are all individual based, with hand pies for some of the savories, some of which resemble empanadas. Of the savory pies I tried I think I like the Jamaican Beef one the best. It had a unique blend of spices that I found worked quite well together. I also tried the Cheeseburger Pie, the Beef Bourguignon and the Pork Bun Pie. All a good mix of flavors and textures. The Pork Bun Pie, to me, is more of an egg roll pie…which is awesome by the way!!! When I think “Pork Bun” I think BBQ pork in a soft chewy bun. The fillings for this pie are pork, carrots and cabbage which are the main ingredients for an egg roll so If you go in expecting the Pork Bun to be BBQ Pork that is not the case….although it is a very good pie nonetheless! One that I would get again!! The Cheeseburger pie needs more cheese, and the seasoning is a little sweet but this is still a good showing. Maybe add some caramelized onions or something. Of the sweet pies I tried a few fruit pies and a cream pie. I had the strawberry Rhubarb, the Peach Berry Crumble and the Chocolate Coconut Cream pies. All were good. The Strawberry Rhubarb was good but kinda basic. The Peach Berry Crumble was amazing as was the Chocolate Coconut Cream pie. You need to really like coconut to enjoy this pie as it is LOADED with it! I love coconut so I thoroughly enjoyed this pie. All in all a very nice place for all kinds of pies!

Fabulous as always. Tried the savory pie, was not super impressed. Jamaican beef was the best so far. Chocolate coconut cream is mind blowing!

I had the Strawberry Rhubarb pie and it was a 5 out of 5. The pastry was well made. Very flakey, great flavor and baked perfectly. The Strawberries and Rhubarb inside of the crust were tart but sweet at the same time. Not overly sweet or gloopy. One of the best I've ever had. The chocolate hazelnut pie my Bestie had was nowhere near as good. It wasn't sure if it was a brownie in a pie crust or a chocolate lava pie and it was very, very dry. The tables were super small but there was a place to sit outside. It's Spring outside and gorgeous out so we were happy to sit outside. All that being said, we'll be back for the Strawberry Rhubarb pie and maybe to try something new.

The Elvis pie was everything we wanted it to be! Mini dessert pies are perfect for two. Salad was a bit strong on the dressing and Cornish pasty was not bad. Will be back to try the cheeseburger hand pie!

John Rodgers

I have been wanting to try this place out as many of my friends recommended it. Up front let me say I do like this place. I can see some room for improvement but they knock out some pretty tasty fruit, cream and savory pies. The pies are all individual based, with hand pies for some of the savories, some of which resemble empanadas. Of the savory pies I tried I think I like the Jamaican Beef one the best. It had a unique blend of spices that I found worked quite well together. I also tried the Cheeseburger Pie, the Beef Bourguignon and the Pork Bun Pie. All a good mix of flavors and textures. The Pork Bun Pie, to me, is more of an egg roll pie…which is awesome by the way!!! When I think “Pork Bun” I think BBQ pork in a soft chewy bun. The fillings for this pie are pork, carrots and cabbage which are the main ingredients for an egg roll so If you go in expecting the Pork Bun to be BBQ Pork that is not the case….although it is a very good pie nonetheless! One that I would get again!! The Cheeseburger pie needs more cheese, and the seasoning is a little sweet but this is still a good showing. Maybe add some caramelized onions or something. Of the sweet pies I tried a few fruit pies and a cream pie. I had the strawberry Rhubarb, the Peach Berry Crumble and the Chocolate Coconut Cream pies. All were good. The Strawberry Rhubarb was good but kinda basic. The Peach Berry Crumble was amazing as was the Chocolate Coconut Cream pie. You need to really like coconut to enjoy this pie as it is LOADED with it! I love coconut so I thoroughly enjoyed this pie. All in all a very nice place for all kinds of pies!

Shamsun Nahar

Fabulous as always. Tried the savory pie, was not super impressed. Jamaican beef was the best so far. Chocolate coconut cream is mind blowing!

Lisa Speroni

I had the Strawberry Rhubarb pie and it was a 5 out of 5. The pastry was well made. Very flakey, great flavor and baked perfectly. The Strawberries and Rhubarb inside of the crust were tart but sweet at the same time. Not overly sweet or gloopy. One of the best I've ever had. The chocolate hazelnut pie my Bestie had was nowhere near as good. It wasn't sure if it was a brownie in a pie crust or a chocolate lava pie and it was very, very dry. The tables were super small but there was a place to sit outside. It's Spring outside and gorgeous out so we were happy to sit outside. All that being said, we'll be back for the Strawberry Rhubarb pie and maybe to try something new.

Ann

The Elvis pie was everything we wanted it to be! Mini dessert pies are perfect for two. Salad was a bit strong on the dressing and Cornish pasty was not bad. Will be back to try the cheeseburger hand pie!

Savory pies average..cherry hand held pie the best. Friendly staff .nice outdoor seating.

Beware, delicious pie filling, however, half of the pie was air. Unfortunately, the cashier only apologized. Will not return.

Zero stars. Can’t rate what they didn’t have. What kind of pie company has no pies? Close at 6 and at 520 had 4 meat pies yuck and one mini apple pie left. We are not from here but went out of our way to support. Not good business practices if your goal is to sell out when pie refrigerates just fine, at least on the weekends. Overall disappointed and unimpressed. Shout out to Hand Made Ice Cream across the street. Creme Caramel Toffee sundae was awesome.