Menu
Tim Hortons
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Tim Hortons
Photos

Tim Hortons

Coffee shop · Elma

3.6 · 196 reviews Google

About Tim Hortons

Located in Elma, United States, Tim Hortons is a Canadian chain offering its signature premium-blend coffee, light fare, pastries, and breakfast sandwiches. We're open daily from 5AM to 8PM, providing convenient options like delivery, drive-through, and takeout, alongside dine-in service. Enjoy a gr...

Located in Elma, United States, Tim Hortons is a Canadian chain offering its signature premium-blend coffee, light fare, pastries, and breakfast sandwiches. We're open daily from 5AM to 8PM, providing convenient options like delivery, drive-through, and takeout, alongside dine-in service. Enjoy a great coffee or tea selection, plus breakfast and lunch options. We cater to solo diners and offer wheelchair accessible entrances, parking, and restrooms. With 196 reviews, we hold a 3.6/5 rating, and we look forward to welcoming you.

What Customers Say About Tim Hortons

Tim Hortons in Elma receives mixed reviews. Some customers praise the fast service, friendly staff like Janice and Brandon, and perfectly made food. However, many complain about inconsistent quality, incorrect orders, slow service, and cold food.

Popular Dishes

coffee (4) breakfast sandwiches hash browns (4) donuts

Best For

Quick Bite Solo Dining

Tip: The early morning crew is the best, according to one reviewer. Be prepared for potential inconsistencies in your order.

Features

📶 WiFi 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🌅 Breakfast 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner Coffee
🎯 Casual

Frequently asked questions about Tim Hortons

Tim Hortons is located at 661 Jamison Rd, Elma, NY 14059, Elma.
Tim Hortons offers coffee_shop cuisine.
Tim Hortons has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.
Tim Hortons offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.
The most recommended dishes at Tim Hortons based on customer reviews are: coffee, breakfast sandwiches, hash browns, donuts.
Tim Hortons is ideal for quick bites, solo dining.
Tim Hortons in Elma receives mixed reviews. Some customers praise the fast service, friendly staff like Janice and Brandon, and perfectly made food. However, many complain about inconsistent quality, incorrect orders, slow service, and cold food.
The early morning crew is the best, according to one reviewer. Be prepared for potential inconsistencies in your order.
196
Reviews

Tim Hortons Elma Reviews

3.6
196
5★
43%
4★
22%
3★
10%
2★
5%
1★
20%
Reviews (40)
C
Carl Sperrazza

Authentic Mexican food and live music on some nights

M
Mark Custard

Went through the drive today and was in store yesterday was pleased to see Manager Janice Oakes working who I knew from the EA store. No matter how early in the morning she is always energetic, friendly and efficient. Drive through has been quicker too.

S
Shari Vaudo

This is probably one of the better Tim Hortons shops in the Southern Tier area. I've only had a bad (burned) sandwich one time and they remade it for me. The early morning crew is the best.

E
Erin Zmuda

Love coming to this Tim’s it’s so convenient to go to while I’m at work and Brandon is the best! He starts working on my order before me even placing it since he remembers it.. it’s the little things like that that make me keep coming back. Thanks Brandon!

Carl Sperrazza
Carl Sperrazza

Authentic Mexican food and live music on some nights

Erin Zmuda
Erin Zmuda

Love coming to this Tim’s it’s so convenient to go to while I’m at work and Brandon is the best! He starts working on my order before me even placing it since he remembers it.. it’s the little things like that that make me keep coming back. Thanks Brandon!

Shari Vaudo
Shari Vaudo

This is probably one of the better Tim Hortons shops in the Southern Tier area. I've only had a bad (burned) sandwich one time and they remade it for me. The early morning crew is the best.

Mark Custard
Mark Custard

Went through the drive today and was in store yesterday was pleased to see Manager Janice Oakes working who I knew from the EA store. No matter how early in the morning she is always energetic, friendly and efficient. Drive through has been quicker too.

V
Vernon Robinson Jr

Stopped here while on the road and was given great service and the food was made perfectly. The store entrance is shared and that part of the store created an obstacle for entry and the employees seemed to not care as they were restocking their shelves. I think this could hurt the business of Tim Hortons but otherwise, I'd stop here again.

Vernon Robinson Jr
Vernon Robinson Jr

Stopped here while on the road and was given great service and the food was made perfectly. The store entrance is shared and that part of the store created an obstacle for entry and the employees seemed to not care as they were restocking their shelves. I think this could hurt the business of Tim Hortons but otherwise, I'd stop here again.

H
Harold Kleever

didnt get a egg on my sandwich it was sapose to have

Harold Kleever
Harold Kleever

didnt get a egg on my sandwich it was sapose to have

Jim Michalek
Jim Michalek

The food was good and the speed of service was excellent but they did not get my order correct even though they read it back to me correctly. I ordered two meals and when I received my order there there was no hash browns. I asked where the hash browns where and I was told that they ran out. I asked why didn't you tell me and they said because I did not order hash browns. I said but I ordered meals and they said but we ran out of hash browns. The staff and supervisor were very nice but I left confused and disappointed.

C
Cathleen Coveny

Normally we love stopping at T Ho’s for coffee and a sandwich for our drive home to Western Pennsylvania. This visit not so much. The only item we ordered that was hot was the coffee. The breakfast sandwiches and hash browns were cold. The cheese on the sandwich tasted like it was just slapped on the very stale biscuit that fell apart after one bite. The bacon was cold and rubbery. Very disappointed.

D
Drew

Usually a good place but they gave zero care today. Cold food and this is how the donuts ended after having nothing on top.

K
Kodi Miller

Consistent at being inconsistent. Ask for 3 cream 3 sugar, you’ll at least get 3 cream. But never both. Step your game up team.

Cathleen Coveny
Cathleen Coveny

Normally we love stopping at T Ho’s for coffee and a sandwich for our drive home to Western Pennsylvania. This visit not so much. The only item we ordered that was hot was the coffee. The breakfast sandwiches and hash browns were cold. The cheese on the sandwich tasted like it was just slapped on the very stale biscuit that fell apart after one bite. The bacon was cold and rubbery. Very disappointed.

Drew
Drew

Usually a good place but they gave zero care today. Cold food and this is how the donuts ended after having nothing on top.

Kodi Miller
Kodi Miller

Consistent at being inconsistent. Ask for 3 cream 3 sugar, you’ll at least get 3 cream. But never both. Step your game up team.

B
Bob Jones

Tried to go down the road to this location hoping it was better not at the manager was a complete jerk he had no care in the world whatever I can’t keep doing this I’m too old for it

H
Heather

Absolutely the slowest tim Hortons we’ve ever been to. It was brutal. I would drive ten minutes out of my way to avoid ever going there again.

T
T Johnson

25 minute wait and told us were were getting shorted one hash brown because they didn't have enough. They refunded one but actually shorted us two. I asked to replace the original one with a couple slices of bacon and they chrged me $3.80. Again, we didn't get all of our food after 3 tries and looked at like I had 10 heads when I asked politely for our two donuts. We finally had to leave because my son had a game. Still not refunded properly, still not all of our food. Called and no answer. Worst experience ever at our favorite breakfast chain.

R
Roy M.

Looked like this place is permanently closed, stopped there after a 15 hour flight to get a a snack but the place looked permanently closed!

J
Jason Roman

Still consistently sucks. Asked for a egg, sausage and cheese sandwich. Received an English muffin with nothing. But they sure knew how to charge that egg and sausage sandwich. That alone is surprising because nobody there can count change. Truly puzzling.

C
Carolyn Howton

I am an avid coffee drinker. I roast my own coffee from green beans, mostly from Costa Rica and Brazil. I rarely buy coffee out, usually when in a hurry. I am aware that most coffee bought from retailers is already old and out of date. Green beans last longer than roasted beans. Once roasted, the coffee stays fresh for only 10 days. I have only had bad experiences with Tim Hortons. Every time i went there (I've been to several locations), the coffee was like water. They are taking coffee out of the pot before it's done brewing and starting new pots while there's still coffee from the previous brew. This causes variances in strength and flavor. The different franchise stores do not follow the same procedures with respect to using and getting points on a Tim's card. An example of this is when asking for the senior discount. The store on Maple Rd. in East Aurora/Elma says they don't give a senior discount and the other Tim's I've been to do honor the senior discount. Almost all retailers honor some form of Senior Discount nowadays, except this particular Tim's. There is no continuity between stores, and that's not how a franchise works. Continuity between franchises is what keeps people coming back. That's why a Big Mac from McDonalds is the same no what McDonalds you go to. A whopper at Burger King is the same, etc. Because of these issues, I won't go to another Tim Hortons ever again. I'll go anywhere else or nowhere else to purposely avoid Tim Hortons. Starbucks is another great example of continuity between stores. My cup of coffee at any Starbucks is dependably the same every time. Also, it is absolutely ridiculous how many Tim Horton stores there are. Some are literally as far as a block away from each other. I live in Buffalo, NY. There are hundreds of these horrible coffee shops everywhere. Finally, the way points are earned is crazy. If I order an Ice Cap, I have to change the drink preference from coffee to specialty drinks. This is not only inconvenient but also stupid. I wish Tim Hortons would go out of business. Not many people know what a good cup of coffee should taste like. When I roast my beans and offer visitors my home roasted coffee, they are blown away by the flavor and smoothness that good offers.

J
J M

I went to get a HOT medium decaf coffee with two creams, and a chocolate chip muffin. The muffin was cold, but the coffee was colder, and it took 10 minutes to get both items. The customer service person was fine, but the delay without explanation was disappointing. I work at a nearby office, my day was done and as far I'm concerned so is my time with this location of Tim Hortons. Do better Tim, you ruined my day.

M
Mac

So this morning before work I went to go through the drive thru to get coffee. I do my regular coffee order that I’m used to getting when I want coffee. The man taking the order started to argue with me about what I wanted. I told him I just wanted what I order simply because that’s what I’m used to. He said “I’m trying to tell you” and I asked him why he wanted to argue with me and his response was “I’m trying to educate you”. Ended up getting out of line and not getting my coffee. Who knew at 6 in the morning a grown man would want to argue with me about a coffee. Extremely rude and disrespectful. This is the only tim Hortons that I can stop at that’s on the way to work and now I don’t even want to go cause I feel like I’m going to have to argue to get something that I AM paying for. Tim Hortons do better with hiring people.

a
alan ferger

One car in the line and you wait 15 mins to get someone on the intercom and then you get a coffee that’s tastes like warm milk. It’s not even just this location all Tim’s are run like no one gives a crap about anything they do. You need adult oversight on these children

L
Louie DePlato

Thanks for forgetting the egg and bacon on my breakfast sandwich. You need to hire more competent staff. If you aren't a good enough owner/manager to do that you should consider closing down

D
D W

EVERY I’ve come to this Tim Horton’s it is by far the slowest one of all. It’s like playing roulette of “do I go drive thru or in-restaurant?” My suggestion is NEVER go in restaurant at this location. This past time I saw a sign that said leave a review on google. Well with all the time I currently have waiting in line, here I am leaving a review.

Roy M.
Roy M.

Looked like this place is permanently closed, stopped there after a 15 hour flight to get a a snack but the place looked permanently closed!

J M
J M

I went to get a HOT medium decaf coffee with two creams, and a chocolate chip muffin. The muffin was cold, but the coffee was colder, and it took 10 minutes to get both items. The customer service person was fine, but the delay without explanation was disappointing. I work at a nearby office, my day was done and as far I'm concerned so is my time with this location of Tim Hortons. Do better Tim, you ruined my day.

Louie DePlato
Louie DePlato

Thanks for forgetting the egg and bacon on my breakfast sandwich. You need to hire more competent staff. If you aren't a good enough owner/manager to do that you should consider closing down

alan ferger
alan ferger

One car in the line and you wait 15 mins to get someone on the intercom and then you get a coffee that’s tastes like warm milk. It’s not even just this location all Tim’s are run like no one gives a crap about anything they do. You need adult oversight on these children

Bob Jones
Bob Jones

Tried to go down the road to this location hoping it was better not at the manager was a complete jerk he had no care in the world whatever I can’t keep doing this I’m too old for it

D W
D W

EVERY I’ve come to this Tim Horton’s it is by far the slowest one of all. It’s like playing roulette of “do I go drive thru or in-restaurant?” My suggestion is NEVER go in restaurant at this location. This past time I saw a sign that said leave a review on google. Well with all the time I currently have waiting in line, here I am leaving a review.

Heather
Heather

Absolutely the slowest tim Hortons we’ve ever been to. It was brutal. I would drive ten minutes out of my way to avoid ever going there again.

T Johnson
T Johnson

25 minute wait and told us were were getting shorted one hash brown because they didn't have enough. They refunded one but actually shorted us two. I asked to replace the original one with a couple slices of bacon and they chrged me $3.80. Again, we didn't get all of our food after 3 tries and looked at like I had 10 heads when I asked politely for our two donuts. We finally had to leave because my son had a game. Still not refunded properly, still not all of our food. Called and no answer. Worst experience ever at our favorite breakfast chain.

Jason Roman
Jason Roman

Still consistently sucks. Asked for a egg, sausage and cheese sandwich. Received an English muffin with nothing. But they sure knew how to charge that egg and sausage sandwich. That alone is surprising because nobody there can count change. Truly puzzling.

Carolyn Howton
Carolyn Howton

I am an avid coffee drinker. I roast my own coffee from green beans, mostly from Costa Rica and Brazil. I rarely buy coffee out, usually when in a hurry. I am aware that most coffee bought from retailers is already old and out of date. Green beans last longer than roasted beans. Once roasted, the coffee stays fresh for only 10 days. I have only had bad experiences with Tim Hortons. Every time i went there (I've been to several locations), the coffee was like water. They are taking coffee out of the pot before it's done brewing and starting new pots while there's still coffee from the previous brew. This causes variances in strength and flavor. The different franchise stores do not follow the same procedures with respect to using and getting points on a Tim's card. An example of this is when asking for the senior discount. The store on Maple Rd. in East Aurora/Elma says they don't give a senior discount and the other Tim's I've been to do honor the senior discount. Almost all retailers honor some form of Senior Discount nowadays, except this particular Tim's. There is no continuity between stores, and that's not how a franchise works. Continuity between franchises is what keeps people coming back. That's why a Big Mac from McDonalds is the same no what McDonalds you go to. A whopper at Burger King is the same, etc. Because of these issues, I won't go to another Tim Hortons ever again. I'll go anywhere else or nowhere else to purposely avoid Tim Hortons. Starbucks is another great example of continuity between stores. My cup of coffee at any Starbucks is dependably the same every time. Also, it is absolutely ridiculous how many Tim Horton stores there are. Some are literally as far as a block away from each other. I live in Buffalo, NY. There are hundreds of these horrible coffee shops everywhere. Finally, the way points are earned is crazy. If I order an Ice Cap, I have to change the drink preference from coffee to specialty drinks. This is not only inconvenient but also stupid. I wish Tim Hortons would go out of business. Not many people know what a good cup of coffee should taste like. When I roast my beans and offer visitors my home roasted coffee, they are blown away by the flavor and smoothness that good offers.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in Elma →
📸

Gallery

📸

No photos available

Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places

📍

About Tim Hortons

How to get there

661 Jamison Rd, Elma, NY 14059

Loading map...
Tim Hortons
Tap for directions

Highlights

💬
Many Reviews
196 reviews
💰
Budget Friendly
Price level
👨‍🍳
coffee_shop
Cuisine type

Services

🥞 Breakfast
🥐 Brunch
🍽️ Lunch
🍾 Dinner
Coffee
🍰 Desserts
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery
🍴 Dine-in

Dining Options

🍽️ Dine In
🥡 Takeout
🚚 Delivery

Restaurant Info

Status
Verified by owner
🕐 Hours Today
5AM-8PM
Rating
3.6/5
💬 Reviews
196
💰 Price Level
$
📞 Phone
+1 716-655-6790
🌐 Website
locations.timhortons.com

Amenities

📶 Free WiFi
🅿️ Parking
Wheelchair Accessible
🚻 Restroom
💳 Credit Cards
📱 Mobile Payments
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

661 Jamison Rd, Elma, NY 14059

📍 Explore the Neighborhood

Weather
24°
Weather updated hourly · Jobs and events refreshed daily
🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Tim Hortons and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Tim Hortons!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Tim Hortons

🏆 Rewards at Tim Hortons

💰

10% Discount

At Tim Hortons

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
Leave a Review on Google
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it