Papa John's
Pizza · Elmont
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Papa John's
At Papa John's in Elmont, we're dedicated to serving up classic and specialty pizzas, wings, sides, and desserts that are made with high-quality ingredients. Our commitment to customer satisfaction shines through in our management team, who work closely with you to ensure a smooth experience, even o...
At Papa John's in Elmont, we're dedicated to serving up classic and specialty pizzas, wings, sides, and desserts that are made with high-quality ingredients. Our commitment to customer satisfaction shines through in our management team, who work closely with you to ensure a smooth experience, even on busy days. We pride ourselves on delivering hot, fresh food quickly - just ask about our 10-minute gluten-free crust veggie pizza! With late-night hours and convenient delivery options like no-contact delivery, we're the perfect spot for a quick bite or a satisfying meal. Our wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking lot make us welcoming to all.
What Customers Say About Papa John's
Papa John's in Elmont receives mixed reviews. Many praise the pizza's taste and fresh ingredients, especially the cheese pizza. However, some customers report issues with order accuracy, rude cashiers, undercooked pizza, and delivery problems.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Management is responsive, so speak up if something is not perfect. Also, be aware that it is a busy spot.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Papa John's
Papa John's Elmont Reviews
Papa John's Cheese Pizza is so good
So far so good. Management works with you very well if anything goes wrong. It is a busy spot so you should keep that in mind. That is not a bad thing, that just means you should speak out and speak up if something is not perfect. They are good people, they make things right. 9.5/10 orders are perfect. If not, management addresses it, just call the store.
Great service! We order for pick up often.
the pizza is very very good and with well ingredients i like the pizza of papa john 😍
We went for a quick take out, the 10 inch gluten free crust veggie pizza was tasty. They prepared it within 10 minutes of us placing the order. It’s not gourmet pizza, standard Papa John’s and this location does a good job.
Placed an order on Uber eats for wings and a 20oz soda. Got my wings but they forget my soda. When I called to inform them, Steve apologized and sent out an upgraded 2 liter with their delivery driver. He also called back to make sure I received the soda. Very pleasant and well mannered. Awesome job Steve and staff.
Food was well prepared and ready when I was told it would be
The pizza was very nice and well cooked. The atmosphere and the staff were very nice and good.
I’m only reviewing because I believe it’s a health hazard for a driver to walk in from making deliveries and be immediately walking into the pizza area and start boxing pizzas, touching utensils, the pizza by crust part without washing his hands. That disturbs me.
This place is a hit and miss sometimes then have great service or bad like this time I open the sauce and I get this, some times it's full and the food is eh not so great other locations are worst that's why I come here cause it's 50 50 has its good parts and bad parts in one order mean while other places it's just bad smh
$41 for ONE large pizza delivered...They don't even follow online order directions and just do what they want. No sauces. and they guy brought my pizza here on a bike in 35°... I haven't ordered from here in a while.. and won't ever again.... NEVER AGAIN
I bought pizza yesterday and the cashier was really rude. He asked us what we wanted, and then walked away dismissively without taking our order. He did this TWO times. We eventually asked a girl behind the counter to help us out, and she actually listened to us and took our order. Staff has 50/50 chance of being completely rude.
I waited 3 hours for a pizza. Three. Hours. That is completely unacceptable. No updates. No call back. The manager refused to answer the phone. This is beyond poor customer service — it’s straight up disrespectful. If you can’t handle orders, stop taking them. I expect this to be addressed immediately.
After waiting 4 hours for my order, it finally arrived — and there was hair in my food. This is disgusting and completely unacceptable. Waiting that long just to receive contaminated food is beyond unprofessional. On top of that, the manager would not answer the phone when I called.
Pizza has no flavor. It's made horrible.. the pizza looks un able to eat looks horrible. Undercooked. Taste like cold fridge cheese..
I waited 1 hour for my pizza and wings, driver claimed he came to my house and left because I did not answer my phone, but I asked for contactless delivery and left instructions on not only how to get to my house but to leave my food at the door. Manager gave me the run around and said he would send the driver back, driver said he couldn't find my house the second time. DO NOT RECOMMEND TERRIBLE SERVICE!!!!!
I ordered a plain pizza and they sent me one with pepperoni on it. For religious reasons i dont eat pepperoni, so i called back and they sent me another pizza w chicken. The delivery driver had the audacity to ask for another tip ontop of what i gave him for the wrong pie. 0 stars if i could absolutely horrendous.
Me and my co worker Bradley ordered a pizza and it was delivered completely swished .like it was dropped and balled up , then when I call I ask to speak with a manager and have something done , they deny me speaking with a manager , I ask for corporates number because they were real rude on the phone as well. This is completely unacceptable . I took pictures as well
Not worth it. I have ordered three times from them and all three times I get under cooked pizza. The dough is still raw on the top and little toppings on my pies. Even after telling them, nothing was done yo correct the issue. I was not waiting another hour for new pies. Stay clear of this place.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
7 Photos
Explore Papa John's's photos
About Papa John's
How to get there
1552 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
1552 Hempstead Turnpike, Elmont, NY 11003
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Papa John's and other restaurants
Earn Points at Papa John's!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Papa John's
🏆 Rewards at Papa John's
10% Discount
At Papa John's
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu