Fire Crust
Pizza, ice cream · Henrietta
About Fire Crust
En Fire Crust, te invitamos a disfrutar de nuestras pizzas al horno de cocción rápida, creadas a tu gusto con ingredientes frescos y deliciosos. Acompáñalas con una selección de cervezas artesanales y, para el final perfecto, prueba nuestros helados locales. Ven a vivir una experiencia culinaria úni...
En Fire Crust, te invitamos a disfrutar de nuestras pizzas al horno de cocción rápida, creadas a tu gusto con ingredientes frescos y deliciosos. Acompáñalas con una selección de cervezas artesanales y, para el final perfecto, prueba nuestros helados locales. Ven a vivir una experiencia culinaria única en un ambiente original y lleno de encanto.
What Customers Say About Fire Crust
Fire Crust in Henrietta is highly rated for its delicious and customizable pizzas, friendly staff, and clean atmosphere. Customers rave about the variety of toppings and the ability to create their own pizzas. The ice cream and milkshakes are also popular.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Customize your pizza with a variety of toppings and sauces. Consider trying the Indian fusion options or ice cream for dessert.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Fire Crust
Fire Crust Henrietta Reviews
Top notch pizza and service. Mac n cheese with pineapple and ham. pizza..I know. But it was incredibly good Cup n char pepperoni DELICIOUS from the first bite to the last. Perfectly cooked from the dough to the toppings.
In the mood for pizza, pizza AND icecream... needless to say, the icecream looked yummy but will require another day.
We mostly use the drive up and sometimes go in and pick up for delivery. It is our favorite thin crust pizza. Been going there for several years. Two thumbs up!!
Fire crust never disappoints!! I have never had a bad pizza here. Service is always friendly, and the quality of food for the price is phenomenal.
Very good Pizza and can get as many as toppings as you want. They have wings beer and ice cream.
Pizza was good, and loved how you could create whatever your heart desires. However, price was a little higher than we expected. Wouldn't stop me from dining in again though.
We came here a few times. The first time is just to try a fire. You know pizza like a little small personal pizza type thing that comes out of the oven fresh and it's great. It's thin crust, cooked perfect. Not too hard. Not too soft because we got a couple of pre-made pizzas. We we didn't build our own cuz I wanted to just go with something that was already balanced toppings and it was delicious. I mean we've been back. I pretty much get the same one every time. I like the Greek one. It has the feta cheese on it. My wife likes the Hawaiian and I've had some of hers. They're both very good so I can't speak for all toppings but the pizzas we've had the three times you went have all been very good, cooked great and I swapped my swapped something once so you can easily swap. If you like a pre-made one you can swap out. You know meats or and a meat. Seems like there's no problem
Pizza was really good and had a nice variety of options. They also have draft beer and ice cream! Milkshakes were reportedly good too according to my kid.
Super quick crew. All toppings can be designed as you want on various pizza sauces. The place is always clean and the staff are friendly. Busy most days I've been there but the wait is never long. Ice cream to top a nice meal off is great. Prices are reasonable as well! I'd highly recommend it there!
First time here and will definitely be coming back. I had the chicken pesto pizza and it was fantastic! Everything was just top notch. I was really impressed with the staff, so friendly and accommodating to changes. If you're in Henrietta and looking for some lunch, I recommend Fire Crust Pizza. It is worth it.
Update 4/2024: My son loves their ice cream sundaes. The staff know him and we're never disappointed. Love them all. Love this place. The pizza is made right in front of you. Our "chef" took down what we wanted, 1/2 meat lovers and 1/2 veggies. Then he created it, walking down the counter, choosing fresh ingredients laid out before us. Twelve minutes later, delicious pizza.
devoured in seconds, so delicious and easily customizable. stopped in here on a long road trip and it was super quick and surprisingly tasty for a random spot we picked. love the indian fusion elements, we got a half & half pizza— one half shredded mozzarella, paneer tikka, minced garlic, spinach, oregano and red pepper flakes— other half fresh mozzarella, roasted garlic, basil, arugula and balsamic glaze
Classic Marg and the Paneer Pizza! Also went with butter pecan ice cream! Pizza was delicious, worth the price for sure. My Paneer was spicier than I had anticipated but wasn’t mad about it. They had a nice list of draft beers too while I waited for my pizzas. Great staff there can see why I’ve heard so many good things from friends.
Pretty good place. Your pizza is made right in front of you and then placed in the oven. They are a little bigger than a personal pizza. All the pop is made with cane sugar so it has that snap to it, better than high fructose corn syrup. Also has a drive thru if you don't want to go inside.
Well I'm starting off with 4 ⭐⭐⭐⭐. I love enjoyed the thin crust. It has never been once of my favs..but let me tell you. It was nice and crispy, the sauce was a little bland and I should've got my garlic Parm wings cooked a little longer. The wings were cooked instead the fire over..hellll to da yeah 😂. So go try this spot out. One medium and 6 wings extra blue cheese a total of $25 bucks and the sell alcohol 😵💫
First time trying Fire Crust. The service is great from employees. I definitely believe that the portion size could be bigger considering its almost $18 for a medium 2 topping pizza. The pizzeria shares the space with Pittsford which is incredible. The feel of the pizzeria feels very "corporate" and not something comfy. Definitely feels like a franchise rather than a small business.
I’ve had mixed experiences with this restaurant. The service I received in person was always friendly and polite. I like that the transparency they provide by allowing you to see the process of how your pizza is made from start to finish. They are a bit on the expensive side, but compared to some of their competitors in the area, they are somewhat justified in their pricing. I recently had a not so great experience with an employee over the phone due to an error they made on my Door Dash order. I’m vegan , so I always try to notate that I would not like any cheese or meat on my pizza. When I order through Door Dash, it doesn’t have a “NO CHEESE” option. So I didn’t choose any cheese option - which “vegan cheese” is part of those options, in case you’re wondering. When I received my delivery, the pizza had cheese on it. After I had marked an issue on my order and received a credit for receiving the cheese, I called the store with the intent to pick up a new pie. I can’t remember the name of the young lady I spoke with but after I explained the situation to her she replied, “Oh yeah, in your note you said ‘vegan no meat no cheese,’ so we gave you vegan cheese.” I explained that I didn’t want cheese at all, she gave a sigh and then said she would just give me a refund. It was obvious she was annoyed, but I don’t understand why? I thanked her anyway and she quickly gave me a “mhmm” and hung up.
Hands down the WORST PIZZA I have ever had. 69 years under my belt. Ordered a thin crust, with sausage, onions and red peppers. Minuscule amounts of each topping. Little tiny balls of sausage. The pesto topping was good. The crust was literally unchewable. Hard, dry and texture like it was put in the microwave. Disgusting. It was take out and I was not going back. Will NEVER eat at this chain again.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
62 Photos
Explore Fire Crust's photos
About Fire Crust
How to get there
4843 W Henrietta Rd, Henrietta, NY 14467
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
4843 W Henrietta Rd, Henrietta, NY 14467
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Fire Crust and other restaurants
Earn Points at Fire Crust!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Fire Crust
🏆 Rewards at Fire Crust
10% Discount
At Fire Crust
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu