Tony's Pizza
Pizza · Herkimer
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza is a Pizza restaurant located in Herkimer, NY. Rated 4.4 out of 5 by guests. Known for: Serves local specialty. Popular for lunch, dinner, solo dining. The menu features comfort food, quick bite. Offers dine-in, takeout. Casual, cozy, quiet atmosphere.
What Customers Say About Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza is a local favorite known for its delicious, thick-crust pizza with generous toppings. Customers rave about the friendly service and the quality of the food, especially the pizza. It's a popular stop for travelers and locals alike.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Stop by when traveling on I-90. The pizza is worth a quick stop off the highway.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza is located in Herkimer, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- The Reformed Church (A 983m) — church building in Herkimer village, New York, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Parks & Gardens
- Myers Park (A 582m) — park in Herkimer County, New York, United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza Herkimer Reviews
Best pizza ever...consistent style and taste for over 20 yrs
The pizza here is great. Great sized slices with quality toppings. The people here are even better. After only a few stops in they remembered my name and my order. Always welcoming.
Great place to get real food for your $$$
The customer service was great. The good was the best in Herkimer
In the middle of a roadtrip we stopped off strictly because the reviews were awesome. Man, so glad we did!! I got the chicken cesar salad and the garlic pizza. These portions lasted me for like 3 days!! Service was so attentive and they are experts at what they do. It was clean for the most part, but right before closing so I figured no biggie. The bathroom was very decent. Prices are reasonable and you're supporting a small business so why not. Will visit again when in the area!
The pizza it's delicious. I had 3 slices 1 upside-down sausage 1 everything. All very tasty
Visiting from Chicago. I ate here because it was SO HOT outside I didn't want to walk far from my hotel. It was unbelievably good. I tried a slice they had already sitting there and it was so good I ordered a whole pizza. I had an unusual pizza with hamburger,sausage,cherry tomatoes,jalepeno and a lot of ricotta cheese! It's among the best I've ever had anywhere. Cool people working there too. The dining atmosphere is plain Jane and nothing to write home about, but most folks were just getting it to go. This is really really good!
While staying In Herkimer,NY for a night i decided to try this pizzeria on the advice of the desk clerk at my hotel and her advice was correct Tony's Pizzeria makes a great pizza and there garlic bread is very good also. The pizza is what i would call a thick crust but not pan style. I ordered a small pepperoni and sausage with extra cheese and an order of garlic bread. I got it to go, but the pizzeria looks like a great place to eat in at with plenty of seating. My pizza and bread took about 20 minutes, and It was ready to go back to the Red Roof Inn with me.
After a day of riding the Empire State trail we were ready to EAT. Tony’s Pizzeria was recommended by our hotel staff and we were very very pleased by the quality of their pizza and salads. This was not your super thin crust NYC pizza but instead had an amazing thick chewy crust with completely generous toppings and cheese. Highly recommend Tony’s…GRAZIE, Tony!!!
Friendly service in a locally owned business. Pizza is delicious! Pan style, toppings to the edge. Really tasty pizza! We stop here when driving between Boston and Western NY. Well worth a quick stop off the highway.
Really great restaurant! Me and my mom got pizza as we were waiting for my road test right across the street. Staff were super nice and seemed to have a strong passion for pizza. I got the chicken bacon ranch pizza, and god it was so good. There was a piece of chicken in every bite and the garlic sauce in the pizza was amazing
I was traveling from out of state with my family and we got takeout there. All the food was great, thicker crust pizza, great fresh toppings. I have a dairy allergy and asked if their pizza without the cheese is (bread and sauce are both hit or miss). It was safe but the owner went out of his way to clean all the surfaces and utensils when preparing my pizza and said he takes it very seriously as his fiancé has food allergies. They are a small local place with great food and great attention to detail. I highly recommend them!!
Some of the best pizza I've had since moving to central NY. The service was pretty good, too, for being younger kids. We will definitely be going back. If you haven't tried them yet, give them a shot!
Stopped here on our way by on I-90. A little pricey when going for multiple toppings, but the pizza was loaded and good! Worth the price in my opinion. Staff was friendly, no complaints! Shared the pizza between three of us and still had some leftover.
Roast beef sub was real good. Pizza is ok but a bit greasy in my opinion
Thick style pizza, great sauce, and stretchy cheese. Hits the spot when dipped in mild sauce and a cold fountain soda.
The restaurant was very clean. I believe they are an order and go shop more than Dine-in. Greetings were minimal, but acknowledged you were present. They were very busy around dinner time. Very confusing who you should give your order to. Beverages are limited to just bottles. No fountain. Food seems very fresh and tastes great. The Dine-in area is booths and tables and is great for a date night if you want privacy and chance to talk
I ordered 20 wings and a large, everything but anchovies (EBA) pizza. The food was incredibly good but I had to pick my jaw up off the floor when they told me it was $65. I learned my lesson. Next time I'll order a small or medium-sized pizza.
Address in Yelp seems wrong but found via Google. Good thing we did because the pizza was very good. Crust was nice, thick but light and crunchy, a la Sicilian pan pizza but not square. Fresh veggies, sauce wasn't too sweet or heavy and ok cheese (maybe a little bland). Great little road trip find.
Was surprised there wasn't a bigger menu to choose from. On vaca from Pa this place was recommended cause it's open on Sunday. Very limited choices on where to eat. Plenty of fast food.. The girls were super nice the place was clean. Very hot in there not sure they have any air. 96 today so sitting in there was tough I'd suggest ordering to go.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Green Acres Drive In
Arby's
Dunkin'
KFC
Asteroga Alehouse
Sunny Restaurant
Babe's
Ina's Pizzeria
Utica Coffee Roasters
China Garden
7 Photos
Explore Tony's Pizza's photos
About Tony's Pizza
How to get there
435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
435 Mohawk St, Herkimer, NY 13350
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
park in Herkimer County, New York, United States of America
church building in Herkimer village, New York, United States
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Tony's Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Tony's Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Tony's Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Tony's Pizza
10% Discount
At Tony's Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu