Oven Lovin'
Sandwich · Holbrook
About Oven Lovin'
At Oven Lovin', we're proud to serve up delicious meals that bring people together. Our restaurant offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere where friends and family can gather for lunch, dinner, or a quick bite. Our chefs specialize in crafting mouthwatering heroes, including the Main Street sliced ri...
At Oven Lovin', we're proud to serve up delicious meals that bring people together. Our restaurant offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere where friends and family can gather for lunch, dinner, or a quick bite. Our chefs specialize in crafting mouthwatering heroes, including the Main Street sliced rib eye steak hero that's worth the wait. We also offer catering services, catering to your every need from large orders to special requests. Our commitment to quality and customer satisfaction shines through in our attentive service, where our staff will work with you to ensure a delightful experience. With options for breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner, and solo dining, we have something for everyone. Whether it's a birthday party, a catering order, or just a night out, Oven Lovin' is the perfect choice for anyone looking for great food and exceptional service in Holbrook.
What Customers Say About Oven Lovin'
Oven Lovin' is praised for its fresh, delicious sandwiches and catering services, especially the heroes. Customers rave about the quality of ingredients and family-owned atmosphere. Some negative reviews mention inconsistent quality and poor service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Try the heroes, especially the Brooklyn or the Main Street. Catering orders are highly recommended for parties.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Oven Lovin'
Oven Lovin' Holbrook Reviews
The best in town by far! Always great hero's and dishes but better yet we ordered a 6 foot hero, 2 3 ft 1 American 1 Italian, get the pickle olive platter too you won't regret it. Here's the thing FRESH! Fresh cold cults fresh bread easy to chew, unlike so many other places when you get this super sandwich it will melt in your mouth. No kidding that monster slice was delicious because of it's freshness. I took some of this sweet peppers from the side platter and added it to the Italian side. The olives are as big as your eyes. Wiped out, nothing left, gone. Several people asked and when I mentioned I've Lovin several noted, that's why. Showing the excellent reputation they have in the area. Go an extra mile and order from here. It's the Freshness that matters. BTW pu before 11am on Sunday, mark it down. Great place Great food
I haven’t been here to eat in person but I order delivery ALL the time!! The food is delicious and on point and I don’t get killed from the price!! Great food great price and they deliver?! Can I give them 10 stars?!?!
I have been a customer since the 90's when I worked locally at a Real Estate office. Always great food and the owners were wonderful people. I have since moved quite a distance from Oven Lovin but whenever I'm it that general area I make a stop there and pick up heros for my wife and me. Never disappointed.
I placed an order for many employees. I had to change 2 times due to this preference, all off the standard menu. Was always a pleasant conversation each time; making multiple changes. Special requests were honored. Delivery was great! They helped carry above and beyond. We had a 20 person party with your delicious thanksgiving hero. Everyone was loving it!! You are amazing!! 15/10!!!
We ordered a large catering order for my dad’s birthday party. Everyone couldn’t stop talking about how good the food was and asking where we got it from. Oven lovin was by far the best place we’ve ever catered from. We will be ordering from here again in the future:)!
I ordered the Main Street (sliced rib eye steak) hero. It was worth the 15 minute wait. The portion was large enough to fill two hungry people. The bread was fresh and crispy throughout, and there was lot of rib eye. I like the vibe of Oven Lovin. Staff was friendly to me. I will return to try other things on the menu.
Been coming here for over 20 years from when they were a small shop just up the road from where they are now and it never gets old. Excellent quality and taste is what keeps me coming back. Real craftsmanship in their sandwiches.
The best sandwiches on the planet. The Brooklyn is perfect.
The food was absolutely fantastical; my taste buds were dancing on my tongue! This restaurant perfectly represents the tertiary sector of the American economy by its fantastic service and chefs. The food portions are absolutely marvelous, there was food to spare at a completely reasonable price. The owners were very affable and kind hosts. Our meals, consisting of a grilled cheese, a chicken noodle soup, and two eggplant parmaseans were delight to our paletes. Ten out of ten, would dine again. Fond regards, Lady Isabella, Thou's Royal Highness Katy, and Loyal Lord Layani
Amazing food and amazing people! We cater from Oven Lovin multiple times a year at work and everyone always LOVES it! Try the stuffed Garlic Knots, aka "Snackers," they are the best! Great heroes (Chicken Cutlet!!) and pasta (Penne ala Vodka!!) as well!
Just had their Herald Square thanksgiving special hero and it was amazing. Wonderful atmosphere (family owned and operated) which is a bonus.
FREAKING FABULOUS… Freshly cooked chicken cutlets fried when you order. So tired of getting the reheated dried yesterday cutlets from just about everywhere you go. Hot & fresh every time.
What a sandwich top quantity fresh bread and most of all killer service. Family run never disappoints.
I cannot say enough about Oven Lovin! We cater every party from here and they never disappoint! Always able to fulfill my requests for on theme, delicious and fresh hero’s! The food for our daughters 3rd birthday was incredible. The chicken francaise is out of this world- you will not find better. The eggplant rolitini is always cheesy and perfectly cooked! For days after our parties, everyone raves about the food and asks for the info. Oven lovin is our favorite spot for a quick lunch or a full catered event!
Nice place still reasonably priced. Nice that there is a designated person taking orders so they're not handling filthy money and credit cards then making my sandwich. We drive well out of the way to go here. Fresh. Delicious.
We were so happy with our Oven Lovin experience for my son’s first birthday party. Everyone there was kind and knowledgeable from start to finish. The food was amazing and they provided GF options for me and a few of my guests. I would hands down order from them again.
Sandwich was okay but very skimpy on the meat, it was all bread and not worth the price. I was very unimpressed for my first time wont return
Service is poor and very slow. Limited options. Didn't win on taste. Didn't meet NY standards for pizza either. A few chairs and tables. Felt uncomfortable inside. Chips are full of dyes. Limited drinks. Not recommended.
right concept, poorly executed. I rarely write reviews but this place has the potential to be really good. I had such high hopes aside from some bad reviews. I ordered the canal street hero. bread over toasted, completely disintegrated every bite, the flavors are there but more cheese than meat. had to throw it out. very disappointing.
The older woman I’m assuming is the owner was nasty and was like charge him extra for this and charge him extra for that and then at the end was like oh your using a card and my sandwich went from 13 to 15 bucks and I’m like ok what ever . Didn’t feel comfortable felt like I didn’t belong there. Her husband I’m assuming was an older gentleman and he was nice but what ever he said didn’t matter she went over him and even other employees were asking him advice and had nothing to do with her and she stopped helping me just to go over and look at what they were doing and told the employee to do what she wanted not what her hauled said then came back to me : I’m like this getting a little Rediculous over here but you know what there sandwiches used to be good so I was like deal with it get your sandwich and leave. I get to my car I’m Starving and can’t wait to sink my teeth into it and the bread was hard I mean really hard and I got the hot Holbrook supposed to be hot roast beef wit melted mozzarella and it was hard and cold so out the window into the garage it went and it’s not about the money it’s about the service and the food and both were horrible so they getting a one star rating and if your reading this save your money and go someplace else because it’s not what it used to be. I been a loyal costumer since they weee at the first location so to be treated like this and then get a really hard cold sandwich I’m Done with this place and so should you be. Just letting you know.
As a long time customer of this establishment I was very dissatisfied with the pizza I got tonight. I asked for well done not burnt like I always do. Instead it was undercooked. There was no customer service. Whoever I spoke to didn’t care that I was not happy with the pizza. They wouldn’t even give credit for one pie. Their solution was a 5 dollar credit after I just spent 28 dollars for two undercooked pies. Over the years I have referred people to their establishment but no more. Very disappointed.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Wendy's
Bagels & Such
Checkers
Islip Pizza and Pasta
Subway
School Store
Phayathai Restaurant
1940's Brewing Company
Smokey Bones
Mama Lombardi's
12 Photos
Explore Oven Lovin''s photos
About Oven Lovin'
How to get there
971 Main St, Holbrook, NY 11741
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
971 Main St, Holbrook, NY 11741
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Oven Lovin' and other restaurants
Earn Points at Oven Lovin'!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Oven Lovin'
🏆 Rewards at Oven Lovin'
10% Discount
At Oven Lovin'
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu