Jimmy John's
Sandwich · Ithaca
About Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's in Ithaca is a counter-serve chain known for its delicious sub and club sandwiches, complemented by their signature potato chips. With a 3.7 rating from 94 reviews, we strive to provide a satisfying experience. We offer convenient options to suit your needs, including no-contact deliver...
Jimmy John's in Ithaca is a counter-serve chain known for its delicious sub and club sandwiches, complemented by their signature potato chips. With a 3.7 rating from 94 reviews, we strive to provide a satisfying experience. We offer convenient options to suit your needs, including no-contact delivery, takeout, and dine-in. Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a comforting lunch, or a late-night dinner, we're open daily from 11 AM to 9 PM. Our location is wheelchair accessible and welcomes solo diners.
What Customers Say About Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's in Ithaca is known for its exceptionally fast delivery and consistently good food quality. Customers appreciate the friendly staff and convenient location, especially for late-night eats. However, some report inconsistent service, skimpy portions, and issues with restroom access.
Best For
Tip: Order directly through the Jimmy John's website to save money and get faster service compared to third-party apps.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's is located in Ithaca, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- Jamieson and McKinney Block (A 282m) — historic building in Ithaca, New York, United States Propiedad contribuidora
- Ithaca Gas and Electric Corporation Building (A 288m) — historic building in Ithaca, New York, United States Propiedad contribuidora
Religious Buildings
- First Unitarian Church of Ithaca (A 146m) — Unitarian church building in Ithaca, New York, U.S.A.
Parks & Gardens
- DeWitt Park (A 270m) — park in Tompkins County, New York, United States of America
Other Points of Interest
- Cornell Free Library (A 57m) — former public library and office building in Ithaca, New York
- Griffin Block (A 60m) — building in Ithaca, New York
- Finch Block (A 109m) — building in Ithaca, New York
- Brooks Block (A 185m) — building in Ithaca, New York
- Ithaca High School (A 225m) — historic high school building in Ithaca, New York, opened in 1915
- Ithaca City Hall (A 268m)
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's Ithaca Reviews
Food quality is always good, as well as consistent, and the delivery time is exceptional.
Love these sandwiches. My only complaint is finding a place to park.
Splendid place! Delicious, nutritious food at reasonable prices. Friendly, hospitable employees. A clean, neat store. A good selection of menu items. Convenient location. Highly recommended!
Its a very small store thats located on a 1 way street. Very friendly staff
This location constantly delivers a solid sandwich, and usually faster than any other option in town. I consider it a hidden gem and its become a regular lunch go-to. They have never screwed up an order and the rewards are pretty solid.
Very fast service and quality is good as expected. The biggest upside is that it does not burn a hole in your pocket and they deliver for almost no delivery fees. Pro-tip: use their website to order food rather than using third party apps. You save a lot that way and it’s much faster as well.
This is my favorite late night sub shop. On the Commons so very easy to get to after a night of drinking before you Uber home. Their subs have saved my girlfriend many times after she finished up at work so I'm very grateful of that. The staff are fun and friendly and make it a fun time while they make your sub
Never before had I experienced a lettuce wrap. The best in gluten free for a fast food establishment. Service is outstanding. Laura thank you for delivering on time
Splendid place! Delicious, nutritious food at reasonable prices. Friendly, hospitable employees. A clean, neat store. A good selection of menu items. Convenient location. Highly recommended!
Love these sandwiches. My only complaint is finding a place to park.
Food quality is always good, as well as consistent, and the delivery time is exceptional.
This location constantly delivers a solid sandwich, and usually faster than any other option in town. I consider it a hidden gem and its become a regular lunch go-to. They have never screwed up an order and the rewards are pretty solid.
I always get Jimmy John's delivered for lunch at work. The food usually comes in 7-10 minutes after ordering. Crazy fast AND crazy good! 😊
Never before had I experienced a lettuce wrap. The best in gluten free for a fast food establishment. Service is outstanding. Laura thank you for delivering on time
Very fast service and quality is good as expected. The biggest upside is that it does not burn a hole in your pocket and they deliver for almost no delivery fees. Pro-tip: use their website to order food rather than using third party apps. You save a lot that way and it’s much faster as well.
This is my favorite late night sub shop. On the Commons so very easy to get to after a night of drinking before you Uber home. Their subs have saved my girlfriend many times after she finished up at work so I'm very grateful of that. The staff are fun and friendly and make it a fun time while they make your sub
Super fast food prep. NO wait. Great veggies sub. Expected the avocado spread to be more generous and not hidden between the cheese slices. Expected it on the bread like the usual mayo thing.
Super fast food prep. NO wait. Great veggies sub. Expected the avocado spread to be more generous and not hidden between the cheese slices. Expected it on the bread like the usual mayo thing.
This place is hit or miss depending on the crew that happens to be working at any given time. There was one time I went in and placed my order and one of the workers was dressed in unbelievably filthy clothing while another worker stood against the wall either very sick or very high. I asked for my order to be cut in half and they couldn't figure out how to do it saying that because of the way it's packaged It couldn't be cut in half. I know that particular point may sound like nitpicking but it's not often you have a service industry worker tell a customer no when they make a simple request. Jimmy John's serves its purpose. I guess when you're very hungry and in a hurry it could be an acceptable choice. I just don't often find myself Jonesing for a Jimmy John's sandwich.
Order through the Jimmy John App for delivery and it took 2 hours to get my food! I would have picked it up had I known!
Order through the Jimmy John App for delivery and it took 2 hours to get my food! I would have picked it up had I known!
This place is hit or miss depending on the crew that happens to be working at any given time. There was one time I went in and placed my order and one of the workers was dressed in unbelievably filthy clothing while another worker stood against the wall either very sick or very high. I asked for my order to be cut in half and they couldn't figure out how to do it saying that because of the way it's packaged It couldn't be cut in half. I know that particular point may sound like nitpicking but it's not often you have a service industry worker tell a customer no when they make a simple request. Jimmy John's serves its purpose. I guess when you're very hungry and in a hurry it could be an acceptable choice. I just don't often find myself Jonesing for a Jimmy John's sandwich.
The food is good, the rolls are fresh, but we had a delivery for a big function and there was a quarter of a piece of lunch meat and every sandwich, very skimpy. I've had them before and been happy, but today was very disappointing.
Never been to Jimmy John's before, and this wasn't a very thrilling first experience. Very small hole in the wall that doesn't offer much of anything. The prices are through the roof considering what you get.
I’m a big fan of Jimmy John’s. I’ve been to most of the locations in New York. I’ve never been to a Jimmy John’s that didn’t have public restrooms until now. There’s a restroom in there but they won’t let you use it.
Never been to Jimmy John's before, and this wasn't a very thrilling first experience. Very small hole in the wall that doesn't offer much of anything. The prices are through the roof considering what you get.
I’m a big fan of Jimmy John’s. I’ve been to most of the locations in New York. I’ve never been to a Jimmy John’s that didn’t have public restrooms until now. There’s a restroom in there but they won’t let you use it.
The food is good, the rolls are fresh, but we had a delivery for a big function and there was a quarter of a piece of lunch meat and every sandwich, very skimpy. I've had them before and been happy, but today was very disappointing.
Tried to go last night at 6pm. Google said they were open. They weren't. Went down the street to Shortstop and had a GREAT sub. I like JJ but they are inconsistent.
Tryed calling for a delivery at 9 pm when the web site says they close at midnight. They never answered. I have been ordering from them for years. What type of bs is that. How do u run a sub shop like that and expect people to keep ordering from u. Will I ever order again, I don't know. I guess I will have to order shortstop tonight.
Disgusting worker. No sense of customer service. Rushed my friend and I. Didn’t follow instructions.
This location started pulling phantom charges on my card. I started getting random $10 charges on my card from here even though my order was never that expensive. Also there were repeated instances when employees would just be ragging on customers in the back and it just felt like a rude and unprofessional environment.
Absolutely awful service. Store closed down and left Uber eats on. Uber Eats said they couldn’t resolve the issue since jimmy johns uses private drivers. Placed order at 5 pm, waited for three hours and no one bothered to cancel the order or reach out. Voicemail not set up in order to resolve issue.
I'm sorry, I know this is a big franchise and it has a huge following, but I will never buy a sub from this place ever again. I went in with high expectations. what I got: (I ordered a turkey sub) No cheese (why should i have to ask for cheese??) shredded ice burg lettuce, public cafeteria grade "turkey" and this thing could not have been longer than 8 inches and 2 inches wide. for 7 dollars. Even subway can do better.
Disgusting worker. No sense of customer service. Rushed my friend and I. Didn’t follow instructions.
Tried to go last night at 6pm. Google said they were open. They weren't. Went down the street to Shortstop and had a GREAT sub. I like JJ but they are inconsistent.
Absolutely awful service. Store closed down and left Uber eats on. Uber Eats said they couldn’t resolve the issue since jimmy johns uses private drivers. Placed order at 5 pm, waited for three hours and no one bothered to cancel the order or reach out. Voicemail not set up in order to resolve issue.
This location started pulling phantom charges on my card. I started getting random $10 charges on my card from here even though my order was never that expensive. Also there were repeated instances when employees would just be ragging on customers in the back and it just felt like a rude and unprofessional environment.
Tryed calling for a delivery at 9 pm when the web site says they close at midnight. They never answered. I have been ordering from them for years. What type of bs is that. How do u run a sub shop like that and expect people to keep ordering from u. Will I ever order again, I don't know. I guess I will have to order shortstop tonight.
I'm sorry, I know this is a big franchise and it has a huge following, but I will never buy a sub from this place ever again. I went in with high expectations. what I got: (I ordered a turkey sub) No cheese (why should i have to ask for cheese??) shredded ice burg lettuce, public cafeteria grade "turkey" and this thing could not have been longer than 8 inches and 2 inches wide. for 7 dollars. Even subway can do better.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Shi Miao Dao Yunnan Rice Noodle
Asempe Kitchen
Souvlaki House
Mercato Bar & Kitchen
Tian Jin Foods
Tacos CDMX
Sushi Osaka
Sangam
Capital Corner
Authentic Jerk Restaurant & Grill
4 Photos
Explore Jimmy John's's photos
About Jimmy John's
How to get there
122 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY 14850
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
122 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY 14850
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
former public library and office building in Ithaca, New York
building in Ithaca, New York
building in Ithaca, New York
Unitarian church building in Ithaca, New York, U.S.A.
building in Ithaca, New York
historic high school building in Ithaca, New York, opened in 1915
park in Tompkins County, New York, United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Jimmy John's and other restaurants
Earn Points at Jimmy John's!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Jimmy John's
🏆 Rewards at Jimmy John's
10% Discount
At Jimmy John's
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu