Reilly's Cafe
Diner · Marathon
About Reilly's Cafe
At Reilly's Cafe, nestled in the heart of Marathon, we invite you to experience a warm and welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Our menu features an array of delicious options, including our signature burgers and fresh seafood dishes, all prepared with love and care by our skilled chefs. Enjoy...
At Reilly's Cafe, nestled in the heart of Marathon, we invite you to experience a warm and welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. Our menu features an array of delicious options, including our signature burgers and fresh seafood dishes, all prepared with love and care by our skilled chefs. Enjoy great coffee and decadent desserts, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth. Our friendly staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service, making you feel at ease in our cozy establishment. We also cater to solo diners and those with mobility needs, ensuring everyone feels included. Whether you're in the mood for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, Reilly's Cafe has something for everyone, all at affordable prices.
What Customers Say About Reilly's Cafe
Reilly's Cafe is a comfortable, family-run restaurant known for its friendly service, generous portions, and delicious food. Customers rave about the excellent waitresses and homey atmosphere. Many highlight the great value and reasonable prices.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Stop by for a comforting breakfast or lunch. The specials are often a hit, and the fries are highly recommended.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Reilly's Cafe
Reilly's Cafe Marathon Reviews
Reilly’s Cafe is finally opened for breakfast, lunch and dinner and the food is fresh and excellent ;) I will be coming here often.
We stopped here on our way through on vacation. We had looked up a couple of other places that may have fit our criteria: good food, relaxed, family friendly, and this seemed to fit that. We arrived around 4-5p, and there were 2 other tables full. We picked our seat and started looking at the menu. We had our 1yr with us who had some energy. No one seemed to mind. They had high chairs, too. The server was quick and made helpful offers. Our food came out fresh and hot. We got the lasagna with applesauce, chicken Philly, and chicken Florentine soup. All was delicious and seemed homemade. We were expecting the chicken Philly to be like a chicken cheesesteak but it wasn't though it was still tasty. We were very pleasantly surprised to find this gem in a small town. My husband and son went to the nearby park while I checked out. At this time, all the tables were full of people. It did take a little too long for someone to come back and check in, offer boxes, etc. I was patient as I saw it was busy for 2 wait staff. That was my only complaint, but I finally got checked out. Overall, great experience, family-friendly, and delicious food. Unfortunately, no pictures were taken as we were distracted and hungry!
Nice, calm quiet atmosphere, FANTASTIC steak and eggs breakfast. Best prices around, and good staff. Perfect for slow Saturday breakfasts. Would love to meet the owner.
Had lunch here and absolutely loved it. The staff are really friendly and the food was terrific! I had the fresh haddock. It was fried and so very tasty. The Mac and Cheese that came with it was very creamy. I decided to add a cup of the clam chowder and that was a great idea. It was warm, creamy, yummy and filling. I left knowing I ate too much (the portions were very generous), but I would do it again. I highly recommend Reilly's.
Absolutely wonderful place. My first time here and definitely won't be my last.Excellent waitress, cook ,food was amazing 😋. And even my unsweetened tea was brewed perfectly. I'm very picky on my fries and these loaded chili cheese fries were OUT OF THIS WORLD!!!!!!! Great job guys keep it up!!!!!
Visiting from out of town, 1st time there. Excellent service and great breakfast, thanks!
It’s an old time feel with good food reasonably priced and excellent waitress. Im sure we will stop there again when visiting our friends in Camden, NY We got off 81N and it was easy to get back on again also to continue our trip. Highly recommend this place 👍
Comfortable restaurant with great food and excellent service - a perfect stop for our family lunch
In town for a wedding, so found this place on google, and with 4.6 stars we had to give it a try! SO GOOD! Perfect little breakfast joint, waitress and staff were so kind and the food was so comforting. If we are ever back in the area would definitely come back to try for lunch!
Best prices I've seen anywhere in quite some time. Country Fried Steak with salad, mashed potatoes, dinner roll, and spicy pickles fries ALL for just $16.16 🤩 The "spicy"pickle fries were phenomenal. Don't be intimidated; they are not spicy, but full of flavour! Good quality. Great value. 👌
We went here today. We are visiting from Massachusetts. What a wonderful cafe. I had the biscuits and sausage gravy it was delicious. Everything was fresh (I never had such freshsausage)homemade. My husband had the eggs, sausage home fries with toast. Coffee was good too. I loved all the pictures I believe from Ireland. Prices were amazing and portions! Keep up your hometown hospitality. It shows you love your cafe!
Excellent food; a maple syrup glazed pork chop (unfortunately, only served during the once-a-year Marathon Maple Festival), done to perfection, not overcooked or dry, as pork chops too often are. Best kitchen in the area. Didn't order any of the dishes this algorithm allows you to click on, but I'm sure they would be great.
We really enjoyed our food and the service at Riley's Cafe. All the service people seem to be friendly . Our waitress Jennifer was just so friendly and also very thoughtful. Our breakfast was just delicious and very generous servings. Sadly we won't be in town for the delicious sounding specials for lunch today. We really enjoyed looking at the mural which seem to be places in Ireland and it was just lovely all around.
Great find just off the highway! Homey cafe with delicious food. The burgers appear to be very popular. My son had an order of boneless bbq wings that he thoroughly enjoyed. I had the panini special with Greek chicken in a pesto sauce. Even without the cheese sauce it was plenty moist. It came with a side of homemade pesto mashed potatoes and sautéed summer squash. All were absolutely delicious. Everything tasted fresh and homemade. The service was also terrific.
Ok this was bad..... the hash was definitely out of a can. Ordered it crispy came back wet soggy disgusting, the fried potatoes were boiled and just warmed up. Sausage patties felt pre cooked warmed up in microwave. Service was good warm friendly. Never go again
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Dunkin' Donuts
Dark Horse Tavern
Mikes Mr. Subs
Taco Bell
Lisle Pizzia
Denny's
Kalash Kitchen
The Elm Tree Inn
Little Caesar's
Gorgers
51 Photos
Explore Reilly's Cafe's photos
About Reilly's Cafe
How to get there
8 E Main St, Marathon, NY 13803
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
8 E Main St, Marathon, NY 13803
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
historic library building in Marathon, New York, United States
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Reilly's Cafe and other restaurants
Earn Points at Reilly's Cafe!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Reilly's Cafe
🏆 Rewards at Reilly's Cafe
10% Discount
At Reilly's Cafe
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu