Delicious, local ingredients- that you know are as clean as possible. The smash burger is 👌🏼

The burgers were awesome. I love that they source ingredients directly from local farms—and even bake their own buns using local flour. It’s great to see classic American staples made fast casual with high-quality ingredients. Can’t wait to come back.

Great breakfast sandwich. Nice to see a good spot take over this vacancy after so long.

If you're looking for a fast, healthy, tasty, reasonably priced meal, this is your spot to stop into (they even have a drive thru window option!). Locally farm sourced ingredients with buns made in house, you can tell how much care goes into the food and experience. The owner and staff are friendly and helpful. The restaurant is spacious and clean. Tallow is a special and unique place. Instead of paying the same amount for fast food that makes you feel junky afterwards, stop into Tallow.

Incredible, healthy, farm-sourced food! 100/100

First time eating at Tallow, had the smash burger with bacon and fries. Everything I ate was delicious and I had no digestive issues or feeling heavy, which always occurs when I eat heavy food or eat out.

Met Austin & had a great chat, as well as a tasty burger, fries & burrata peach salad. Yum!! Definitely will be returning.

Exceptional service, food and ambience. I’ve come 3 times within the past couple weeks bc of how good the food is. Every server has been very welcoming and helpful. The food is great and so are the smoothies but the best part abt this restaurant is they cook and fry everything in tallow which is incredibly hard to find these days. I try to avoid seed oils for my health so this place has quickly become one of my fav spots in upstate ny. 11/10

You will not find a better burger. Every bite is an experience that has been curated from farm to your mouth. Get in line to experience anything Chef Nate makes with his meticulous and passionate abilities in the kitchen.

Food was great. Even the little one loved it. Great service and great space even just to break up a long drive!

Delicious food, enjoyed the smash burger and fresh fries. I also got the blueberry banana shake and it was delicious. Highly recommend!

Really great, well sourced food at extremely reasonable prices. I hope they make it and stick around for many years to come! Great food that supports our farmers, too. Win win.

Stopped here while out on the bike. what an amazing find. Everything was fresh and local which we love. Clean place clean food and if you like spicy ask for the chefs hot sauce 😋 omg made my hair itch lol

So good! Will definitely be back!!

I absolutely love this restaurant. I had their new mushroom burger, and it was fantastic! Not only is their food and service great, but they are also on a mission to help restore metabolic health, which I love :)

Great food with a purpose. Everything is carefully sourced and crafted to delight the palate and your belly. And you leave feeling happy to pay a little extra for the high quality you and your family deserve.

The best chicken sandwich I’ve had in a long time. Tallow also has my new favorites fries! Don’t miss this if you’re in the area.

Freshest most delicious burgers and fries I have tasted in a long time. Great service! Will definitely be back for more.

TALLOW is changing the game for fast food. You will get michelin quality food (yes, seriously) for fast food prices and speed - its honestly incredible. Can't recommend this place enough!

New restaurant in Millerton, great assortment of hot entrees including a deadly smashburger

We were on the way to the beach and stopped in on the whim. Great short rib sandwich and fries!! We will try it again soon!

Had a wonderful lunch after riding 15 miles on the nearby rail trail. I had a delicious burger and the wife had a grilled cheese short rib that she loved. I have a real respect for restaurants that offer more than just ordinary fries and this place nailed it. I presume it was from frying them in tallow, Great lunch spot that had us sitting outside under an umbrella.

We popped into Tallow and tried a couple of their unique offerings: the Steak and Egg, Blueberry Smoothie and the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese. The Steak and Eggs were impeccable, our teenager has high standards when it comes to this meal and this did not disappoint. My hubby went for the Bacon, Egg, and Cheese was a solid choice. It hit all the right notes for a comforting and satisfying breakfast sandwich, well-executed and reliably tasty. I went for a lighter but insanely tasty option of the Blueberry Smoothie. It hit the mark made with quality ingredients and a light refreshing taste. Overall, Tallow offers an interesting take on breakfast fare, with some traditional options alongside great healthy, LOCAL, ingredients. We chatted with the owner for a bit who mentioned the history of the building. It felt really nice to support a place run by local folks with the local community in mind. Thanks for a great breakfast Tallow!

The flavors of every dish we ordered on the menu were perfectly delicious. We love the cozy atmosphere and especially all the staff were friendly and attentive. Highly Recommended!

Food was delicious and tasty, the servers were super nice and attentive. They also had various games which was super entertaining! The quality to price range was superb. Overall the atmosphere was just very friendly. Would 100% recommend, even if travelling with kids.

Cool balance of savory , yummy burgers short rib and fried chicken, along with fresh fruits, smoothies, and delicious bevys incl. Bone Broth :)

Nice spot for a burger and fries. Above average smash burger, with excellent pickles. The fries were the real show stealer, though. Probably top 3 fries I’ve had in my life (maybe higher, but I’d have to give that more thought). They were fluffy yet crispy and perfectly salted. Highly recommend for the fries alone.

Service was really good. I think his name was Bill, he was very kind. Also this is one of the best burgers I’ve tried. Wow. I’m not from the area and was there just for 2 days but I wish I could be back soon to have these burgers again.

What a lovely experience! Their business model focuses on metabolic health and local regenerative farming. Their mission is to please the local customer. They spend ample time getting to know their clients and offer locally sourced ingredients and products. You will be pleasantly surprised with their menu and service. Don't miss this!

We love tallow! We live locally and we go to tallow frequently. Love the burger and fries. We’ve tried almost everything on the menu and it’s all fresh and fabulous! The steak is so good! Best steak we’ve had in a long time! The service is wonderful we love seeing the guys that work there and they remember our names! This place is worth a drive if you live far away. Check them out! You will be pleasantly surprised and satisfied with the quality of the food!

Came here this evening with my mom, and we both had the smash burgers. Very good flavor! I also really liked the fries! We grabbed a menu on our way out. More than likely I’ll be back again soon to try some other things as well. It’s a nice place to grab a quick burger, and it’s nice knowing it’s a healthier version of most regular ‘fast food’ places.

Great new spot for locally sourced and creative comfort food - grass fed beef, tallow fried french fries, bone broth, house made buns, hot sauce, ice cream, etc. A happy place where you feel good about what you’re eating - and it’s delicious! As former restaurant owners and current foodies, we really appreciate the commitment and effort that’s been made here. We will definitely be regulars!

Came by Tallow twice while in the area. The food was fantastic. The patty melt is wonderful - juicy, crispy, melty, just what you want. Fries are great. The dining room is really nice and there’s a shaded outside patio as well. On top of good food the service was exceptional. They were so friendly and went out of their way to make us comfortable. Absolutely stellar experience, well worth a visit.

Tallow is the absolute bomb. I’m so happy they opened up so close to me! It’s hard to find such good quality food at such fast service!! Shoutout to Bill for always being so accommodating! I love “ the bird” and the fries are absolutely addicting. Also tried their breakfast today and the Bacon Egg and Cheese and parfait did not disappoint! Highly recommend. Definitely worth the drive from CT! Also love the fact that they have a drive thru- so cool.

Tallow completely redefined my expectations of “fast food.” I have to admit, walking into a space that used to house a McDonald’s and a Burger King gave me serious pause—I wasn’t here for that kind of fast food. But once I stepped inside, I realized I was in for something very different. The interior is stripped down and sleek, with a minimal aesthetic that feels fresh and intentional. Everything was spotlessly clean, and the open kitchen gave us a front-row seat to the cooking process—a reassuring touch that emphasized transparency and quality. And then—the menu! Bone broth and French fries, together? Yes please. It’s a surprising combination that somehow works, like a collision of nourishment and indulgence. Every item we tried was bursting with flavor and clearly made from thoughtfully sourced, local ingredients. Nothing felt mass-produced—everything felt made for you. Tallow is the future of "fast" food—quick, nourishing, local, and created with love. Kudos to Austin and the entire team. I’ll definitely be back.

We tried Tallow tonight for the first time! We had a great experience from ordering to enjoying our meal! The melt was fantastic as were the fries! The Chef even brought us ice cream on the house as we finished ☺️ We will absolutely be back! GREAT job guys!!

The burgers and bone broth were delicious! The service was great as well, everyone was very friendly and helpful.

Great Food! The fries are the best I've ever had! The melt was fantastic and my wife enjoyed the bird. Smash burgers the next time I visit and that will be soon!

The melt is my absolute fav! Also some of the best burgers and fries I've had around here. Great vibe and friendly staff. Love the use of quality and local ingredients, and the values behind the place. I'm definitely be back soon!

Delicious food, delightful owner. Fresh, farm-to-table, casual.

While on a spur of the moment road-trip with my wife, we ended up 2 hours from home and starving. We are so pleased that we stumbled across TALLOW. What a great surprise! We both got smash burgers and we both loved them. The staff was super pleasant and the over all vibe of the restaurant was nice! My only complaint is that this really great restaurant is 2 hours from my house!

Absolutely by far the best burger I have had. All of the food was fabulous and we cannot wait to return!

Great experience! We ordered the burger, chicken sandwich, and kids grilled cheese and a bone broth. Everything was so fresh, flavorful and organic. Impressive that buns are made in house as well. Most of the time when I go out to eat I am left disappointed and unsatisfied because I know most places use seed oils for everything or get most of their stuff from Sysco. This is a great alternative! Hoping in time you guys get milkshakes.

Delicious burgers and chicken sandwiches. Fries also unreal. Can’t recommend this place enough.

Finally a clean, healthy place to get fast food! No seed oils, and their meat and ingredients are organic and come from small local farms. I have been waiting for a restaurant like this in the area and I’m so happy it finally exists! Food was incredible, and you don’t feel yucky or slow after because it’s such good quality and ingredients. Don’t walk here, run here. You won’t regret it.

The smash burger is the best in Dutchess County in my opinion. The tallow fries, delish! We had the dessert special, blueberry bread pudding with poppyseed crème anglaise…💥. The bone broth was a cozy treat on a cold day. Super kind staff, thoughtful service! It’s a farm to table fast food restaurant with ‘stay as long as you want’ type of vibe. The aesthetic is clean, chic, minimalist… good taste to go with good tastes. And not for nothing, even the music tracks were 90’s, 00’s, 10’s hits, prompting us to hum along while feasting. Pure bliss.

I just nearly crashed my car on the way home I was so ravenously attacking the fries. Best fries I've had ever, anywhere. fluffy on the inside crisp on the outside, perfect amount of salt. If my mouth could have an orgasm it did. the rest of the food is aweseome too, the smash burger is an easy 10/10, mushroom melt is bangin. and the pickled veg is actually quite nice and refeshing, cauliflower, green beans and carrots. Very fresh pickle, either they quick pickle the veg or they had just made a batch that day either way delicious. It was legit so good I had to write a reveiw as im sitting here eating it. Compared to some of the other options in Millerton this is a Freaking Dime!

Artisanal burgers, steak and other delicious food. Friendly waitstaff and nice décor. Tables al fresco when in season. There is a gorgeous hearth but it was not in use during this review. Ample parking out front.

+1

When this restaurant opened I was sad there were no vegetarian options. A few months later they’ve made some amendments and I am thrilled!!! We always need more restaurants around and this one is great. The mushroom melt was incredible but my favorite thing was the picked vegetables - vinegary and sour and a little spicy. 🥵 The staff was also so kind - thank you for the root beer! Will be back and definitely recommend

We had a wonderful day visiting Tallow for the first time. Very friendly staff and beautiful interior. The indoor outdoor fireplace is super super cool. And the food! Super delicious and perfectly portioned. My husband and I shared the Smash and the Bird, and our 8 month old daughter couldn't get enough of the bone broth (watered down for temperature). Since we went on mother's day, I was surprised with a delicious ice cream dessert. It was super tasty and super kind to receive. We'll definitely be back!

I love this place. Everything is delicious, ingredients are beautiful and locally sourced, even their ketchup is special. Burgers, chicken sandwich, and prime rib (reservation only), and fries are terrific! Thanks folks for making very tasty food.

Overall great experience! Food was amazing and lovely spot update. The quality of the food was spot on.

The service here is impeccable. Food is fresh and delicious the burger is my favorite yesterday I had it with bacon OMG what a game changer. The atmosphere is laid back and welcoming. We drive 1 hour to enjoy this place. Make sure to tell Austin I sent you enjoy 😉

Melts and burgers out of this world. Squash soup was the best I’ve ever had. Such a good vibe. A wonderful place

Amazing burger and fries and I’m not a fry girl. Staff was extremely pleasant. Burger, sauce and overall taste was 10/10….maaaaybe a few more fries could be included in the large. But will def be back. Curious why they changed the name…Tallow seemed much more like a burger place name (?)

We took out breakfast: eggs and cheese, lettuce and tomato on sourdough cooked sandwich and corned beef hash (could have eaten double the amount). Very tasty and delicious!

Great food!! Grass fed. The way all food should taste. Filling and able to move after you eat. Thank you for making fast food clean. Worth the stop!!!

Amazing meal. The french fries were the best Ive ever had. The melt was so crispy on the juicy on the inside.

Probably the best chicken sandwich I have ever had!! No joke, this place is a must for any foodie!! I'm looking forward to bringing my family back for dinner in the very near future. We'll done Pasture Kitchen folks. See you soon.

Went in with my family of four. Two adults two kids. It was a fantastic meal, and afterwards we all talked about the cooking quality, how good we felt after eating here, and how you could taste that every ingredient was homemade and of the utmost quality. My wife and I are both local farmers, who grow organic produce and flowers for a Michelin stared restaurant in NYC. For us, seeing and tasting all local products is really such a treat! And as farmers, being able to feed my whole family here for a reasonable price is a huge plus. I gotta say, the food here tastes like the region. It highlights the local producers and what is currently in season! The quality of ingredients leaves you feeling energized. All of this without sacrificing the flavor of indulgence. Rather, highlighting how much better local, mindfully raised/grown products taste and feel!! Go eat here, support this place and help them grow!!! I’m excited to come back and taste new and exciting things, and to get a fantastic smash burger anytime!!

Went here with a few friends and we all loved it. I got the chicken sandwich which was delicious. The service was also amazing (shoutout Bill), they were super friendly and we didn’t have to wait long for our food.

We got The Smash, The Bird and Tallow fries, they were sooo good! You can taste the quality of the ingredients, highly recommend if you’re craving fast food but care about what you’re putting in your body! And the service was great, the owner is super nice - they even split our burger on the cute smaller plates because we were sharing!

The tallow fries are incredible! I'm salivating just thinking about it. We got a chocolate banana smoothie and dipped the fries, WICKED GOOD! The buns were soft and fresh, the burgers were cooked perfectly The vibe was great, good music, they have mason jars with all the spices, everything is fresh and local. We had been driving for 2+ hours, so we were ready to sit and eat, and it was a good spot, we will be back. My only negative is that some of the chicken was raw, but Laurie made us whole, and overall we enjoyed our experience

The food here is seriously good. I had the smash burger and tallow fries. My partner, a vegetarian, the squash soup and grilled cheese (with mushroom). Both were very well made. I particularly liked the care they took in preparing the food. It’s an open kitchen so we could see everything. They tasted a fry after it was seasoned. Same with the soup after heating it in a pot. The plate was wiped clean to ensure a good presentation. No of it seemed performative. The people being the counter are clearly well trained. My only regret is that the menu didn’t seem to stretch their skills or talents. Maybe it’s the local market.

Don’t be put off by the buildings look! Burger was delicious. Fries were one of a kind and absolutely divine! Melt was also enjoyed. Great spot to stumble upon while taking a visitor on a mini tour of NWCT & the surrounding area. Will certainly visit again & look forward to trying more of the menu/introducing it to others!

THANK YOU!!! Amazing farm to table food. Grass fed burgers Beef tallow French fries Organic drinks Organic ketchup too!! And so many other delicious food! Andddd A DRIVE THRU!! You guys are the real deal. Super friendly staff. Clean restaurant.

This burger absolutely smashed it. From the first bite, this smash burger had me rethinking every burger I’ve ever had. Perfection. The bun? Buttery, lightly toasted, and just the right size to hold everything together without turning into a soggy mess. If you’re looking for a burger that’s fast, flavorful, and freakishly addictive. The smoothie was fresh, light and sweet. The chicken sandwich was equally as amazing! The food didn't sit heavily on stomach, it felt light and like I was properly nourishing my body. I will definitely be returning for more.

First time visit, and this is a great addition to the area. The food was fantastic. We had the Melt and a BEC sandwich. They hand-make the rolls in-house - we saw them rolling the dough. The tallow fries were excellent. Really positive experience. Update visit 2: Best steak and eggs ever, and a fantastic smoothie. I wish they had a food truck for local events.

Well done! 👏. The best burger & fries I’ve had in the area, maybe ever actually. Concept is amazing, tasty fast fresh & healthy food made with locally sourced products on premises. Even the buns are house made. Healthy drink options & wonderful wellness products & books for sale too. Owners & staff are incredibly welcoming & nice. Can’t wait to go back!

This place rocks and genuinely has the best french fries I’ve ever had in my life. Like, it’s not even close. Nate and Will+Bill are super cool and nice. Good beer selection. I got the standard smashburger, everything on it, and it was an incredible burger. 10/10. Love these guys.

IDK who gave this place a 1 star review but they must be out of their mind. I have ordered food a dozen times and it is absolutely amazing. I liked fast food as a kid. Anyone who can eat McDonald's or Chick-fil-A, you have a strong stomach because I feel terrible after. Tallow does "fast food" but when you're done eating it, you don't feel terrible about your impulsive eating decision. Everything is amazing, the staff remembered my name after my first order, and there is no seed oils, so you feel great after a burger and fries (that do not need ketchup) because the beef tallow flavor is incredible. They added a fried chicken sandwich that I just had for the first time and it is my new favorite.

Quality burger. The fries were outstanding. Star of the show. Had a cup of bone broth, love that they have that here. Ambiance is cool, great tame impala playlist going. Very very good service—attentive but not overbearing. Would definitely recommend if passing by.

Love the vibe and the food! Great spin on traditional favorites made with locally sourced ingredients and cooked with common sense! Best of all — I feel so good after eating the smash burger. Unlike other fast casual and fast food burgers. I can’t wait for the Summer Chicken Caesar Salad!

This place is so good. Bill was really cool. The food is 10/10. Great music. We had a great time.

This was our first visit to Tallow and cannot stop mentioning how great it is. From the second we walked in, the staff was very welcoming and friendly. The smashburger was juicy and on a perfectly paired bun. Their brisket melt was great as well, it came on a nice toasted bread with savory brisket inside and a white sharp cheddar. The steak that comes with the steak frites was so tender and barely needed to be cut. The garlic aioli on the side was delicious and great for the steak and fries. Their fries are a nice thick cut and have great dry seasoning on them. Wherever you are, make the trip and you will be coming back. We also got a lemon tart for the road and the oatmeal crust is great with tart.

Beefy! I had The Melt which had slow cooked short rib / brisket which had a rich beefy flavor, and was complemented nicely by the melted local cheese and sourdough bread. It was simple but rich, and tasted amazing. Paired with the salty hand cut fries, it was an appropriately sized portion given the richness. Service was friendly and efficient. Will definitely be back!

Best burger I’ve had in ages. The anti-industrial/processed foods vibe is refreshing and timely. Went back the next day to try the sour sour bacon eggs and cheese and it was equally delicious.

Tommy Shi

The food here is seriously good. I had the smash burger and tallow fries. My partner, a vegetarian, the squash soup and grilled cheese (with mushroom). Both were very well made. I particularly liked the care they took in preparing the food. It’s an open kitchen so we could see everything. They tasted a fry after it was seasoned. Same with the soup after heating it in a pot. The plate was wiped clean to ensure a good presentation. No of it seemed performative. The people being the counter are clearly well trained. My only regret is that the menu didn’t seem to stretch their skills or talents. Maybe it’s the local market.

Mr E

The tallow fries are incredible! I'm salivating just thinking about it. We got a chocolate banana smoothie and dipped the fries, WICKED GOOD! The buns were soft and fresh, the burgers were cooked perfectly The vibe was great, good music, they have mason jars with all the spices, everything is fresh and local. We had been driving for 2+ hours, so we were ready to sit and eat, and it was a good spot, we will be back. My only negative is that some of the chicken was raw, but Laurie made us whole, and overall we enjoyed our experience

Natalie Harding

Don’t be put off by the buildings look! Burger was delicious. Fries were one of a kind and absolutely divine! Melt was also enjoyed. Great spot to stumble upon while taking a visitor on a mini tour of NWCT & the surrounding area. Will certainly visit again & look forward to trying more of the menu/introducing it to others!

Nancy Black

THANK YOU!!! Amazing farm to table food. Grass fed burgers Beef tallow French fries Organic drinks Organic ketchup too!! And so many other delicious food! Andddd A DRIVE THRU!! You guys are the real deal. Super friendly staff. Clean restaurant.

A SV

First time visit, and this is a great addition to the area. The food was fantastic. We had the Melt and a BEC sandwich. They hand-make the rolls in-house - we saw them rolling the dough. The tallow fries were excellent. Really positive experience. Update visit 2: Best steak and eggs ever, and a fantastic smoothie. I wish they had a food truck for local events.

Benjamin Cornwell

This place rocks and genuinely has the best french fries I’ve ever had in my life. Like, it’s not even close. Nate and Will+Bill are super cool and nice. Good beer selection. I got the standard smashburger, everything on it, and it was an incredible burger. 10/10. Love these guys.

Michael Martin

IDK who gave this place a 1 star review but they must be out of their mind. I have ordered food a dozen times and it is absolutely amazing. I liked fast food as a kid. Anyone who can eat McDonald's or Chick-fil-A, you have a strong stomach because I feel terrible after. Tallow does "fast food" but when you're done eating it, you don't feel terrible about your impulsive eating decision. Everything is amazing, the staff remembered my name after my first order, and there is no seed oils, so you feel great after a burger and fries (that do not need ketchup) because the beef tallow flavor is incredible. They added a fried chicken sandwich that I just had for the first time and it is my new favorite.

Hannah Daniel Williams

Quality burger. The fries were outstanding. Star of the show. Had a cup of bone broth, love that they have that here. Ambiance is cool, great tame impala playlist going. Very very good service—attentive but not overbearing. Would definitely recommend if passing by.

kevin b

This was our first visit to Tallow and cannot stop mentioning how great it is. From the second we walked in, the staff was very welcoming and friendly. The smashburger was juicy and on a perfectly paired bun. Their brisket melt was great as well, it came on a nice toasted bread with savory brisket inside and a white sharp cheddar. The steak that comes with the steak frites was so tender and barely needed to be cut. The garlic aioli on the side was delicious and great for the steak and fries. Their fries are a nice thick cut and have great dry seasoning on them. Wherever you are, make the trip and you will be coming back. We also got a lemon tart for the road and the oatmeal crust is great with tart.

Isaac Borowiec

Love the vibe and the food! Great spin on traditional favorites made with locally sourced ingredients and cooked with common sense! Best of all — I feel so good after eating the smash burger. Unlike other fast casual and fast food burgers. I can’t wait for the Summer Chicken Caesar Salad!

Paula Green

This burger absolutely smashed it. From the first bite, this smash burger had me rethinking every burger I’ve ever had. Perfection. The bun? Buttery, lightly toasted, and just the right size to hold everything together without turning into a soggy mess. If you’re looking for a burger that’s fast, flavorful, and freakishly addictive. The smoothie was fresh, light and sweet. The chicken sandwich was equally as amazing! The food didn't sit heavily on stomach, it felt light and like I was properly nourishing my body. I will definitely be returning for more.

Robin Roman

Well done! 👏. The best burger & fries I’ve had in the area, maybe ever actually. Concept is amazing, tasty fast fresh & healthy food made with locally sourced products on premises. Even the buns are house made. Healthy drink options & wonderful wellness products & books for sale too. Owners & staff are incredibly welcoming & nice. Can’t wait to go back!

Ken Prince

Best burger I’ve had in ages. The anti-industrial/processed foods vibe is refreshing and timely. Went back the next day to try the sour sour bacon eggs and cheese and it was equally delicious.

Daniel Donnelly

Artisanal burgers, steak and other delicious food. Friendly waitstaff and nice décor. Tables al fresco when in season. There is a gorgeous hearth but it was not in use during this review. Ample parking out front.

Chris L

Beefy! I had The Melt which had slow cooked short rib / brisket which had a rich beefy flavor, and was complemented nicely by the melted local cheese and sourdough bread. It was simple but rich, and tasted amazing. Paired with the salty hand cut fries, it was an appropriately sized portion given the richness. Service was friendly and efficient. Will definitely be back!

Ally Lyons

Finally a clean, healthy place to get fast food! No seed oils, and their meat and ingredients are organic and come from small local farms. I have been waiting for a restaurant like this in the area and I’m so happy it finally exists! Food was incredible, and you don’t feel yucky or slow after because it’s such good quality and ingredients. Don’t walk here, run here. You won’t regret it.

Really good food, pleasant seating area and diligent service. Not terrifically expensive either. Shared a burger and a chicken sandwich along with fries. Relatively quick service although I could see it taking a little bit if they get busy. Burger was cooked pretty well and good quality. Ditto for chicken. I liked the purple slaw they used on the chicken sandwich. Nice vinegar zing. Tallow fries were good if not spectacular. They had an ice water dispenser on the counter which was really nice. I took that and my partner got some Harneys ice tea. I think this is a new place so it’s nice to see this sort of fast casual food making it to the northwest corner. Fast, simple, clean, reasonable prices and good service. A decent share of the existing local joints are good but far too many seem a bit grubby. On the other end of the spectrum are nice places that are too pricey or slow to make the regular rotation. Anyway, we both left full without being stuffed. Spent about $40 on two people. Definitely will be in the rotation here forward.

Lebbeus Art

I just nearly crashed my car on the way home I was so ravenously attacking the fries. Best fries I've had ever, anywhere. fluffy on the inside crisp on the outside, perfect amount of salt. If my mouth could have an orgasm it did. the rest of the food is aweseome too, the smash burger is an easy 10/10, mushroom melt is bangin. and the pickled veg is actually quite nice and refeshing, cauliflower, green beans and carrots. Very fresh pickle, either they quick pickle the veg or they had just made a batch that day either way delicious. It was legit so good I had to write a reveiw as im sitting here eating it. Compared to some of the other options in Millerton this is a Freaking Dime!

Arthee Jahangir

The smash burger is the best in Dutchess County in my opinion. The tallow fries, delish! We had the dessert special, blueberry bread pudding with poppyseed crème anglaise…💥. The bone broth was a cozy treat on a cold day. Super kind staff, thoughtful service! It’s a farm to table fast food restaurant with ‘stay as long as you want’ type of vibe. The aesthetic is clean, chic, minimalist… good taste to go with good tastes. And not for nothing, even the music tracks were 90’s, 00’s, 10’s hits, prompting us to hum along while feasting. Pure bliss.

Tallow is a promising new addition to the Millerton dining scene that's still finding its footing. They already have my vote for the best fries in town. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through. The hamburger patty, bacon, and pickles taste noticeably fresh and are apparently from local farms. The patties are what keep this from being a perfect score. Both patties we tried lacked the essential crispy edges that define the style. Instead, they fell apart as if they hadn't been properly pressed on the griddle. For comparison, local favorite Willa nails their patty technique at a similar price point, while Sundaze in Poughkeepsie remains the valley's gold standard at half the cost. That said, Tallow is worth visiting if you're seeking a more upscale burger. Be sure to check out their specials. The watermelon gazpacho was particularly delicious. Pro tip: substitute the cabbage for lettuce on your smashburger to improve the texture.

The Fries were great. The melt not as good. The fries are really tasty.

Finally got to try this new place! The burgers and fries were very good! The buns were my least favorite part of my meal. It feel apart and did not seem fresh. In addition please add a way to get ketchup instead of having to open those packets. The service and atmosphere of the restaurant were great. Congrats and welcome to the area!

Fries are phenomenal! Deeply appreciate the compostable packaging, we got our food to go and nothing went into the trash.

Place was pretty cool and very welcoming. Had a great ordering experience and food came out quick. The smashburger itself was pretty great, but unfortunately the bun was cold and seemingly not toasted or warm. I feel like a toasted/warm bun would have made the big difference. The fries however, probably the best I’ve ever had. Overall a great experience just wishing for a toasted bun!

Jaron Zimmitti

Place was pretty cool and very welcoming. Had a great ordering experience and food came out quick. The smashburger itself was pretty great, but unfortunately the bun was cold and seemingly not toasted or warm. I feel like a toasted/warm bun would have made the big difference. The fries however, probably the best I’ve ever had. Overall a great experience just wishing for a toasted bun!

It’s a new place in Milton that changed names twice. Got a $36 steak. That was the size of a small hamburger. Another expensive restaurant in millerton is that will not last. Should have invested the money into a grocery store and kept the McDonald’s .

It's set up well, though in the winter figuring out the entrance and exit is difficult. Service was great, you order at the counter and food comes to you. My husband had a wonderful steak and my hamburger was a bit greasy. The winter cheese sauce on it was light and tasty.

I really wanted to give this place a 5 star review, but I just can't. I ordered the smash, the bird, and some tallow fries. The burger was just plain dry. I think the juices are all smashed out of it in the cooking process. Everything seemed to be lacking flavor. The tallow fries were soggy and greasy. I know everyone is different, but for me the tallow didn't sit too well and I burped for a good 6 hours tasting those fries over and over again. Things fried in vegetable oil sit much better with me. The guy working the counter was very friendly, the atmosphere was good, and the place was clean. Food presentation was good, but I wish it tasted as good as it looked.

This place has a lot of potential, but it’s still finding its footing. The staff is consistently friendly and welcoming, which honestly goes a long way and keeps me coming back. You can tell they care about the customer experience, even when things behind the scenes aren’t quite dialed in yet. The biggest issue is inconsistency with the food. On a good day, the burgers are really solid—juicy, well-seasoned, and worth the stop. On other visits, though, the quality just isn’t the same: overcooked patties, uneven seasoning, or sides that feel rushed. When you’re paying restaurant prices, you want to know what you’re getting each time. Unfortunately, the recent name change also adds a bit of confusion. The old name had recognition, and switching things up makes it feel like the restaurant is still trying to figure out its identity rather than building on what was already working. Overall, it’s a decent spot with friendly service and flashes of greatness. If they can lock in consistency and settle into a clear brand, this could easily become a local favorite. For now, it’s a solid but uneven experience. Still looking for the “wow” factor.

Stefan Roche

This place has a lot of potential, but it’s still finding its footing. The staff is consistently friendly and welcoming, which honestly goes a long way and keeps me coming back. You can tell they care about the customer experience, even when things behind the scenes aren’t quite dialed in yet. The biggest issue is inconsistency with the food. On a good day, the burgers are really solid—juicy, well-seasoned, and worth the stop. On other visits, though, the quality just isn’t the same: overcooked patties, uneven seasoning, or sides that feel rushed. When you’re paying restaurant prices, you want to know what you’re getting each time. Unfortunately, the recent name change also adds a bit of confusion. The old name had recognition, and switching things up makes it feel like the restaurant is still trying to figure out its identity rather than building on what was already working. Overall, it’s a decent spot with friendly service and flashes of greatness. If they can lock in consistency and settle into a clear brand, this could easily become a local favorite. For now, it’s a solid but uneven experience. Still looking for the “wow” factor.

The smash burger was not a smash, it's a pass. We got one made with all the suggested toppings, as offered, and one that was just a burger with cheese. They were equally terrible, and the plain one made it easy to figure out why. The rolls were mis-proofed and tasted both bitter and sweet, while feeling old, tough, and stale, and the beef had no seasoning. None. The fries, absolutely amazing. Crispy, dense, yet fluffy. A masterpiece if you like huge fries. Not worth the trip for just fries, and not worth the money for their signature food staple, so, it's a pass from us. Sorry. Also, it's clearly an old fast food joint, and feels like one. Replace the floor.

Saw ads on FB, read reviews and saw reviewer photos - time for a food adventure! Sadly disappointed. Wish I took a picture of my smash burger - it was mostly bun despite the 2 patties. Originally thought I should get a single because all the photos made the original smash look so big. A single must be essence of meat. The fries were great. For a semi-self serve (you order at the counter, they bring your food, you bus the table) it is expensive when the 15% tip shows up automatically and if you’re not careful, is added to the bill. There is also a tip jar for the more astute who just wants to throw a couple of bucks. People were nice. Disappointed.

They ran out of fries! C'mon. Maybe it was an off day, because the burger was nothing to write home about. Overall, quite disappointing. I really wanted to like it. Yes, you did run out of fries. The person at the counter took our order, then after telling us about burger and chicken sandwich explained that you'd run out of fries and were prepping for the dinner crowd. Felt like something you'd want to tell customers upfront. He said you'd have fries in a few hours if we wanted to come back. We were hungry so made do without fries. Your team member even told us to tag you on Instagram if we post photos. Overall, really disappointing and not much effort made to make it right. It felt more like 'oh well' than 'we are sorry.' I write this in hopes that you learn. Everyone there looked pretty young and honestly I know you could do better. As I said before, I really wanted to like it.