Sandi Mitchell

Went for dinner with seven friends. There was plenty of room at our table; we were very comfortable. Friendly and attentive staff, large menu with something for everyone. Food came out quickly, and everyone's dinner was delicious. Big portions, all but one of us took half home. Prices are reasonable for quality and quantity of food. Highly recommend this BYOB restaurant!

Robyn Goldenberg

This restaurant is one of our favorites. We order out and love the food but it’s even better at the restaurant. Daily specials are amazing. Calamari is one of the best I’ve ever had! This is a must go to!

angie

My first time here! Service was excellent. Everyone is super attentive and welcoming, they constantly check to see if the entire party is satisfied. Food was flavorful and portions were generous !

Bob Rodgers

Great atmosphere and a wide variety of delicious Italian food. Service was excellent, can't wait to go back. One of the rare places that makes cacio e pepe (yum.)

+1

Colleen Donahue

This may have been the best pizza I have ever had. The crust was perfect, the flavor was delicious, and the ingredients seems high quality and fresh. Also, the service was very friendly and the place was clean and comfy.

William Fyler

Excellent food. Even better service. They were busy but the little wait was well worth it. The chef is putting out food that you would expect at a high end restaurant. Everything from the appetizer to the desert was amazing. We will defiantly be back as this it’s a hidden gem in the area.

Steve Baranek

Great food, very friendly staff and owner. I have lived here Marlton for most my life. There are only a few places I would rate top tier for pizzas, steak sandwichs. I have a severe food allergies to milk products, I ordered a pizza without any cheese and extra sauce. They were extra careful with my order, even going as far cleaning the pizza cutter without me having to ask.

+8

Michelle Curreri

The bread & oil were great! The meatballs & arancini were decent. The carbonara was different from the kind I am used to but it was tasty nonetheless! Big portions so I got to eat it for lunch the next day :)

#Hashtag SteveJ

Very good Italian restaurant and pizzaria. Great selection of appetizers, sandwiches, pizzas, pastas. There is something for everyone. The red and white pie is delicious. Great wings. The lasagna is delicious. Fast friendly service when eating there. Indoor and outdoor seating. Delivery is also usually fast.

+10

Casa Nostra has a beautiful, classic Italian look to it. The decor, lighting, and live singer create a nice atmosphere and it definitely feels like it’s aiming for an authentic Italian dining experience. It’s a great-looking space. Unfortunately, the experience didn’t quite live up to the appearance. The restaurant was extremely crowded — to the point where it felt like the tables were on top of each other. We waited about 30 minutes just to have our order taken. We were asked if we wanted salads but never received them, and my date was never asked if she wanted another drink. The food was decent but overpriced for what you get. The chicken parm was pretty good, but the $20 shrimp appetizer came with only three shrimp, which was disappointing. The $15 slice of cake was also very small. There was an additional $3 charge for using a credit card, which felt unnecessary. Service was inconsistent. The table next to us had their leftovers boxed for them, while we were simply handed a box. The check was brought without a pen. Small details, but they add up. Overall, Casa Nostra looks the part and has a nice vibe, but the service and value didn’t match the price point. We left feeling underwhelmed and probably won’t return

Carol Schules

Our food was delicious as always. We have dined here many times in the past. However, we were very disappointed with our server tonight. He was very abrupt and seemed to want to hurry us along. There were plenty of empty tables and no customers were waiting and he was not busy. He never came to our table to ask if everything was okay and if we needed anything. At the end of my meal, I asked for a box for the remainder of my food (which he did bring). My husband and I were just sitting for a few minutes talking, letting our food digest. The waiter came by, pointed to my take-home container, motioned for me to put my leftovers in and basically for us to move on and get out. Again, as I said, there was no one waiting for the table and plenty of empty ones. The waiter we had could use some training in servicing the public and hopefully attain some better people skills. As always, we left a good tip.

Ariele Tillery

FILTHY employee & operating practices. We have been frequent costumers for YEARS, food has always been great. Tonight we ordered pizza, half plain, half pepperoni, sausage & mushroom. It was made incorrectly (onions) okay, no problem, we called & they required us to bring it back, however we already served the plain side to the kids. When we returned the 4 slices of incorrect pizza…THEY PUT IT ON THE SERVING COUNTER. The same 4 slices that were already in my house for 20 minutes, touched by my 3 year old son who stole some pepperoni off one and my friend who was in the process of taking onions off her slice before my husband realized it was incorrect. We assumed it would go in the trash. They put it on the back counter until we left and then we watched them take it out the box and put it out to serve. We went back in and called them on it and the response was “oh, I didn’t know you guys touched it”….. Sir, you don’t know what the hell we did to it for the 30 minutes we had it. Why would you reserve pizza someone else took home already! Super Disgusting. What other corners are being cut? ….

Angela Rojas

I was really looking forward to trying the restaurant, but I had quite a surprise. I went with my partner, but she was feeling unwell, so I ordered just a soup, and my partner ordered a chicken fillet dish. She wanted to encourage me to eat, so we ended up sharing her plate. When we asked for the check, they charged us $10 for sharing. It's worth noting that I felt discriminated against and uncomfortable during my dinner. I'm sharing this because it's not fair to charge $10 for sharing my plate with my partner. Finally, they never informed me that they would charge for sharing a dish, and they didn't offer me any choice in the matter.