Miss Monticello Diner
Coffee · Monticello
Deals available
Be flexible, save more
Be flexible, save more
About Miss Monticello Diner
Miss Monticello Diner offers a warm and inviting dining experience, serving up classic American diner fare with a focus on quality and variety. Customers rave about the friendly service and the cozy atmosphere. We're known for having something for everyone, from hearty breakfasts to satisfying lunch...
Miss Monticello Diner offers a warm and inviting dining experience, serving up classic American diner fare with a focus on quality and variety. Customers rave about the friendly service and the cozy atmosphere. We're known for having something for everyone, from hearty breakfasts to satisfying lunches and dinners. Signature dishes and a tempting selection of desserts, including homemade cheesecake, are highlights. Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a leisurely meal, or a great cup of coffee or tea, you'll find it here. With options for outdoor seating, takeout, delivery, and dine-in, we strive to provide a convenient and enjoyable experience for all.
What Customers Say About Miss Monticello Diner
Miss Monticello Diner is a highly-rated spot known for its friendly staff, excellent service, and tasty food. Many reviewers highlight the breakfast options and affordable prices, especially compared to NYC. Jennifer is mentioned as an outstanding server.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: The diner is a great alternative to hotel dining, especially if you're staying at nearby resorts like Kartrite. Plenty of parking available.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Explore the area around Miss Monticello Diner
Miss Monticello Diner is located in Monticello, surrounded by cultural and historical points of interest. Here are some of the most notable places nearby.
Historical Heritage
- St. John's Episcopal Church and Rectory (A 234m) — church building in Monticello, New York, United States Lugar inscrito en el Registro Nacional de Lugares Históricos
Parks & Gardens
- Monticello Amusement Park (A 921m) — park in the United States of America
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Miss Monticello Diner
Miss Monticello Diner Monticello Reviews
I've lived in Monticello for years but for some reason never got around to trying the diner. Well, I finally did last night & I was not dissapointed! I tried the country fried steak with sausage gravy. It was delicious! There was a lot of gravy on it which I didn't expect but it still tasted fine. I had some broccoli and home fries on the side, they were yummy as well. The service was great too; the employees were kind. This is a nice little place, I would definitely be returning in the future!
A charming diner that offers classic fare and a familiar diner atmosphere. The pancakes are outstanding!!! All of the staff were lovely, but Jennifer especially stood out for how kind and attentive she was. Our family will definitely come here every time we're in town.
Really good food and our waitress was super friendly. I had an mushroom & ham omelette, home fries, cheese grits, and a single stack! My only complaint would be that the home fries were a little bland. Definitely, a must try if you’re in the area!
I really enjoy going there. You never have to wait. The coffee is great. The service is awesome. They go out of their way to make you feel comfortable. I had laryngitis and she told me that tea, lemon and honey would help, but I had already ordered coffee. I told her I know I should be drinking that but I love my coffee. She kept making sure our coffee was full. We never had to remind her to get something. Everything was excellent and the prices are reasonable. The food was great and nice portions. When we were leaving she even told me I hope you feel better. We'll be going back soon.
Stopped here for a farewell breakfast after a family trip and man, are we happy we did! I swear I think everything was scratch made - the biscuits were flaky and amazing, the gravy was flavorful without being overly salted, the home fries were perfectly crispy, and geez, one of the fluffiest pancakes I've ever had! Every person at the table was happy with their choices and the service was attentive and friendly. The next time we're back in this neck of the woods, we'll make it a point to stop back in!
In the area for camping and the group makes a stop here for breakfast on the way back - my first time there personally but I see why the stop by here on their way back. Friendly, accommodating, and solid food. If you're looking for that small town diner vibe, this is it.
I am partial to miss monticello diner, because I grew up with this establishment. Very friendly and warm atmosphere.
Now, I have been a resident of Brooklyn for almost 35+ years, but I grew up in the area. Took a random day trip to Monticello with friends, and before returning home, we stopped at this beloved little diner. The food was delicious, the portions were large, and the service was full of hometown love. No place like home.
Nice place great waiter no a long wait for dinner
Food was great , it's a dinner, we had a great time staff were fabulous.
Big Portions. Clean , staff was wonderful. Every time I go to Catskill vet. I come here to eat !!! Rice pudding fabulous
Loved everything about this place. My husband had the country friend steak and I had the Tuna Melt, hands down the best we ever had.
Small diner ate here for breakfast. And TBH was kinda shocked at the prices. I’m so used to NYC prices and this place was affordable. Family ordered banana walnut pancakes, chocolate chip pancakes, big breakfast - 2 French toast, 2 eggs, 2 bacon, and 2 sausage links. Also had coffee and lemonade. Everything was great. Lil man loved his chocolate chip pancakes. Heads up the pancakes are huge. We ordered a short stack (2 pancakes) for each kid and they couldn’t finish them. Wait staff was super friendly and attentive. Sat us down right away and took our orders. Good came out quickly. Inside was typical diner sitting. Nothing special or off. Wouldn’t mind coming back for breakfast again if we’re in the area.
Huge portions, great variety. Felt like I was eating at Grandmas house while sitting in the back section (which was a great feeling)
Great place, quality food! Recommended!
This place was a delight! We were looking for a few choice places to eat at and we love trying diners! This diner was delicious. Everything we ordered was fantastic. My twi year old wanted to try and eat everything and she's so picky. Kuddos to you guys for doing the diner experience right!
Great food and experience. We have never been there before and it was worth stopping on our way home. We live 3.5 hours away and definitely going to take a road trip just to eat there again.
Amazing hot chocolate and lava cake. The staff is very friendly too :)
Had very generous portions with a good price! Everything was delicious. Out waitress Jennifer, was super friendly and helpful! Would come back again.
We’ve been coming to Miss Monticello for years, and it never disappoints! The service is always warm and welcoming, and the food is consistently delicious. The staff makes you feel right at home in a friendly, cozy environment. It’s our go-to spot whenever we’re in town. Highly recommend!
Delicious breakfast and waitress was friendly and patient with our orders, very attentive. We will definitely come back next time we revisit Kartrite Resort.
I wish I could give them more stars. My family went to the kartrite resort and stopped into this adorable diner for dinner on our first day. Everyone LOVED it there. We even returned the next day before coming home. The waitresses were incredible and the food was out of this world!!
After a few years of marginal to poor diner experiences we go into them with low expectations but this place not only exceeded those it blew them out of the water. The food is very good, the portions are for real sized people with real appetites and the prices were surprisingly good. We were there for both breakfast and dinner over the course of two days and both meals were great. The service is quick, the servers are very friendly and the manager on duty (owner?) was also very friendly and attentive. We have added this to our list of places to stop when we're traveling through the area and we will be back for sure.
I went back to Miss Monticello Diner. I remember when I use to luve there. The service and food still great.
I Guess we Can say we were luck to find this hidden gem Everything about it was great There’s no reason why anyone shouldn’t come here they have everything for the entire family ‼️ This is rare to find. Yet we left the establishment very satisfied with the Feel at home satisfaction 🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆 Keep up the good work Miss Monticello Diner👍
This is a very good place to eat.Very good portion,very generous.Wonderful food,the eggplant 🍆 is out of the world delicious.Sprimp and grits is very good.Big sprimp.We stop here offen.Never been disappointed.Friendly staff,helpful.I would give this Restaurant a 10.And prices are reasonable for all you get.Bathrooms are clean,the whole place is clean.
The mozzarella sticks were to die for!! Great diner, good food, nothing special but everything you can except.
Had breakfast here twice while staying at Kartrite. Not a long drive from the resort. Food and service was excellent.
Loved this place! Swung through during my travels since I was staying in town for the night. It wasn't very busy at all and they were still super fast and always doing something. No sitting around at this place! I enjoyed the atmosphere and short conversations I had with the wait staff. Oh, food was great too! I had the lox & onions omelette and a killer slice of apple pie for dessert. Menu is massive. I spent a long time looking through it.
Have been here twice back to back and I'm so impressed. I travel with my job and stuck eating out all the time. I got the chicken parm the first day, the breading and sauce was great and today fajitas, yes fajitas at a "dinner". Best fajitas I've gotten in a long time. The portions are big as well. The staff is so friendly. I recommend this place if you want a great meal at a reasonable price with a cool dinner atmosphere. And they have a nice beer selection and the menu has something for everyone. Love this place already.
A truly wonderful experience that exceeded all my expectations. The genuine warmth and professionalism here make every visit feel like a special occasion.
We stopped in here after meeting with a customer. I was pleasantly surprised by this place. The food was incredibly good, the server was very attentive. The location was clean and well kept despite the retro feel. Highly recommend.
We come here to eat every year when we visit Kartrite. The food is delicious, TONS of options, prices are reasonable, and servings are plentiful. We look forward to our annual visit all year long. Old dinner atmosphere that stirs up nostalgia. Love it!
We came in on a rainy morning and enjoyed a warm cozy breakfast. The staff was very friendly, the food was delicious and their homemade cheesecake was amazing!! It was like a basque style cheesecake. We were a big group of seven, but were promptly seated and they made it easy to split the bill. Highly recommend!
Nice spot. Nothing fancy just nice people and good food. Ordered a blt and the country fried steak with mash. Everything was spot on. Prices were great. Don't have to pay an arm or a leg for good food. We didn't have to wait to be seated but the place did get busy fast.
A classic American diner spot only a 10-minute Uber from Resort World Catskills I was pleasantly surprised by this diner. The interior beauty harkens back to the classic American dining experience with a hint of extra class found in the wooden liveries and warm lighting. My coworkers and I came in for a late lunch and had a seamless experience that came with well informed recommendations on the menu from the polite waiter whose name unfortunately escapes me. The food was excellent, a healthy mix of classic Breakfast diner options with other home stay meals that were very fair portions for the price.
Loved the experience here with our fairly large party of 17 people! We got hungry for lunch after a hike in the area but were unable to agree on a single cuisine. Decided to try this diner after reading the reviews. Lots of options - everyone found something they like, from bison burgers 🍔 to rice and lamb shank 🐑 to Korean steak tacos 🌮 to grilled haddock over rice 🐟 to wraps to breakfast fare. Highly recommend the Korean tacos and the lamb shanks, they stood out with their beautiful executions. Would love to return!
Looking for a place with a variety of foods with my dining party. Diners are always a good choice because there seems to be something for everyone. Of course, the question is if the food is good. Well, I can confirm it is. The place is a little small, but not uncommon for some diners. But, we were seated quickly and the service was decent. Most importantly, the choices for breakfast were good. I had a delicious omelet with potatoes. I don’t often go out for breakfast. But, the food her was quite tasty. Prices were reasonable compared to other places. A definite consideration for me the next time I’m going for breakfast or brunch.
A real diamond in the rough. We were staying at the Kartrite and didn't feel welcome so we ventured out to find this gem. We found plenty of off street parking. We were greeted by a cheerful waitress. Our food was genuine and homemade. The special board is daunting (20 choices) and the menu is busier yet!!! My wife had the chicken tortellini alfredo which was rich with milkfat. I had their philly cheese steak which was in house shaved steak on a fantastic fresh crusty roll. We also had a kids meal which consisted of spaghetti, a homemade sauce and a 6 oz hand packed meatball. Our portions were overly generous and we met another family who also left the resort looking for an alternative.
I loved this place and I only came here because the first two diners that came up on my GPS were both "permanently closed". Lucky me! I had great service and my food was delicious. I am a bit of a creature of habit and if there is French Onion Soup on the menu .. I HAVE TO GET IT. It was delicious — and not just the cheese but the soup itself. I also had a bacon cheeseburger and cheese fries. Good lord, I was stuffed, but it was sooooo good. Check out my photos! So glad I ended up here.
We were in town for business and looking for a restaurant not fast food, Boy oh Boy did we find an amazing place!! Our server was cheerful and helpful with recommendations! The food was so tasty and …
We were in town for business and looking for a restaurant not fast food, Boy oh Boy did we find an amazing place!! Our server was cheerful and helpful with recommendations! The food was so tast…
We were in town for business and looking for a restaurant not fast food, Boy oh Boy did we find an amazing place!! Our server was cheerful and helpful with recommendations! The food was so tasty an…
Best Diner in Monticello!!! Great staff, really good food. Going into Miss Monticello is like going home (in the best sense).
Best Diner in Monticello!!! Great staff, really good food. Going into Miss Monticello is like going home (in the best sense).
Best Diner in Monticello!!! Great staff, really good food. Going into Miss Monticello is like going home (in the best sense).
Was a little concerned there wasn't many choices open for breakfast in the area, but I figured it must be the off season, so we just picked this place randomly but what a pleasant surprise! Service…
We traveled to Kartrite and decided to tried this dinner as breakfast take out rather than eating at the hotel. \nWe were NOT disappointed at all!!!\nBreakfast was delicious and tasty!!!!! \nOrder …
Small diner ate here for breakfast. And TBH was kinda shocked at the prices. I'm so used to NYC prices and this place was affordable.\nFamily ordered banana walnut pancakes, chocolate chip pancakes…
Small diner ate here for breakfast. And TBH was kinda shocked at the prices. I'm so used to NYC prices and this place was affordable.\nFamily ordered banana walnut pancakes, chocolate chip pancak…
Miss Monticello Diner has been a work highlight when in need of a lunch. My go to has always been the veggie breakfast burrito. The food is fairly priced, parking is plentiful, and I always have le…
Miss Monticello Diner has been a work highlight when in need of a lunch. My go to has always been the veggie breakfast burrito. The food is fairly priced, parking is plentiful, and I always have le…
Tasty food, great prices and friendly service. The pancakes were some of the best I've ever had!
Very cute and super friendly service. Our server was very nice and helpful. The coffee is also very good.
This diner has been one of the best in a long time we have found. We were greeted once inside our server was Jennifer she was outstanding, courteous, warm,quick and knows how to advocate for her boss…
This diner has been one of the best in a long time we have found. We were greeted once inside our server was Jennifer she was outstanding, courteous, warm,quick and knows how to advocate for her bo…
This place saved us from from the horrible dining options at Kartrite Food was amazing Diner was clean and easy to get to from our location The waitress was friendly and met all our needs
This place saved us from from the horrible dining options at Kartrite food was amazing Diner was clean and easy to get to from our location The waitress was friendly and met all our needs
This place saved us from from the horrible dining options at Kartrite Food was amazing Diner was clean and easy to get to from our location The waitress was friendly and met all our needs
QUICK FRIENDLY TAKE OUT service The Spanish waitress with the glasses is ON POINT with her customer
We Came here in the morning to get some breakfast after having a crappy night staying at the super 8 hotel down the block. the food was good, the service was excellent, the waitress was very nic…
We Came here in the morning to get some breakfast after having a crappy night staying at the super 8 hotel down the block. the food was good, the service was excellent, the waitress was very nice …
The food, the staff, and everything was awesome. Eleven of us were in Monticello at a nearby resort for 48 hours. We had dinner. Amazing! We came back for breakfast. Even better! Then we de…
The food, the staff, and everything was awesome. Eleven of us were in Monticello at a nearby resort for 48 hours. We had dinner. Amazing! We came back for breakfast. Even better! Then we deci…
My family and I were staying at the Kartrite Resort and decided to come here for dinner since it was close to the resort. Atmosphere is your typical mom & pop diner. Food was decent. I ordered a chicken fajita panini, it was good but the chicken was very thin. I felt like I was eating more bread than chicken as you can see from the photo I provided. Overall food was good, nothing out of this world. Friendly staff.
Good food, good prices, comfortable atmosphere.
I've only eaten breakfast here, but everything is always good. Most of all, I appreciate the warmth and hospitality from our Sunday morning server.
This place is very very very good! Their food is great! You tell them exactly what you want and you get what you ordered. You don’t have to send your food back like any other place because they get your order correct the first time! Again this is the best diner in the area, hands-down! If you have a chance to eat here you definitely want to take advantage of it!! Again, this is the best place in town to get a Great meal. You will NOT go away hungry or upset because the people are great. The food is great. Everything is great about this place!
Before the ‘Rona, this diner was always lively to the point of being cacophonous. Now every other booth is kept vacant, and a table obstructs the entryway, so it feels unwelcoming. The ceiling’s shellacked rafters have distinctive cuts which catch the light. As for the food, it times past the food was decent and fairly priced. During this review only milkshakes were consumed. There is sufficient parking in the diner’s lot, or on Broadway itself, though it is limited to two hours during daytime.
Good food, decent portion and cordial service. I recommend this diner in this small town. Oh, because we were a party of 6 automatic gratuities were included in the price.
This is the only place where they had ok food. Kids steak tasted like it was previously frozen. My food didn't have enough pastrami only had 1 strip of it rest was over loaded with liquid cheese and to much sauerkraut. Drinks were made from powder mix.
The old lady that's the waitress is a grumpy and mean old lady. I saw her talk down on a customer just because he thought his order came with a soup " I told you it didn't, what don't you understand …
The old lady that's the waitress is a grumpy and mean old lady. I saw her talk down on a customer just because he thought his order came with a soup " I told you it didn't, what don't you understan…
The old lady that's the waitress is a grumpy and mean old lady. I saw her talk down on a customer just because he thought his order came with a soup " I told you it didn't, what don't you understan…
Food was delicious!\nServices was friendly and fast \nUnfortunately I didn't take any pics, but we all enjoyed our breakfast \nGood coffee\nPancakes were good (and the serving was plentiful)\nKids …
there's something wrong with the water there. it smelled and tasted awful. 2 hours after our meal husband got very ill.
Perfectly good diner breakfast with expected portions and expected price. Service was good. Coffee was better. \n\nHere's the thing though: the parking lot is shared by what I assume is a private r…
Gravy biscuits were very tasty but above all, cannoli was amazing. Fill on site, made to order! Very fresh and great cream- try if you are a big fan of cannoli but coffee wasn’t so great unfortunat…
We ate breakfast there on Saturday, 03/12/22 while we were staying at Kartrite Resort. We choose to leave the resort and opting for dining at other restaurants because the food was terrible at the…
We enjoyed eating dinner here. clean and friendly and the food was good. Very good homemade desserts.
Service was good but food was mediocre at best. Was definitely planning on leaving 20% for our server but she had already added gratuity to our written check.. I felt that was odd for a diner and a little offensive. There were 7 of us (3 young children) and nobody finished their food (and not because we weren't hungry).
Not sure what all the great reviews is about. The food was meh and the only thing gluten free is a bun. Not toast! Food is not fresh and quite unappealing with cheapness! Not cheap in price either for what you get!
Typical diner good burger and great service
It's a diner, nothing more. Food is good and reasonably priced.
A great little diner in Monticello. Typical diner fare. HUGE portions, tasty breakfast. I had one biscuit with sausage gravy, glad I only ordered one, it was a Huge biscuit! Over easy egg on the side with hash browns. Delicious. The other person in my party had blueberry pancakes with bacon. Three HUGE pancakes stuffed with blueberries, nice crisp bacon. Big menu, typical of a diner! I'd go back!
The service was good and really liked the french onion soup. However my food wasn't spectacular and was pretty meh.
Just a regular diner. Service was very good. The lentil soup was very good; the rest was mid. The spinach pastry tastes more like chard. The trout was a bit overcooked. Seemed to be local favorit…
Our fountain drinks tasted like petroleum. Salad was quite tasty. My daughter's macaroni and cheese was rancid (the server raced out from the kitchen to take it back, but we had already tasted it and were quite disgusted). My wife's Chicken had been cooked a number of times, it seemed. My grilled cheese and fries were a safe bet and hit the spot. Our server was kind and attentive; she did her best. The bad food items were removed from our bill without us asking. The place is a diner. The atmosphere was exactly as expected. The food was definitely priced higher than was appropriate. Sad to report that Miss Monticello is worth a miss.
Old school Diner with average diner food. Did not have an electronic register, deal with paper checks in case you are traveling for your company you may have issues with expenses. Pricing wasn’t bad but the service was not good. Waitress had a bad attitude from simple questions about the menu and were more concerned with speaking about their personal life than helping paying customers. Will never stop here again.
Service was fine but, the food nothing special. I made better breakfast at home. We ate some food because we were really hungry. Never again!
Meh. Waitress got a bacon, sausage & cheese on a hard roll wrong. NO EGG. LMAO. How do you mess that up? I had the Eggs Benedict… It didn’t come with home fries or anything. We also had 2 cups of coffee and it was 30 bucks.
This place is very spectacular, benevolent and immaculate. But unfortunately the potato’s r very disappointing it made me very sad and my steak bary bary dry and over cooked. Mannnn very sad :( docking off a star sowwyyy. But immaculate service I do be liking that one very very good. Thank you come again. Oh my goodness not safe ☹️
Have been a patron for years and noticed however a decline in cleanliness and the owner seems stressed. Hopefully he is ok but I guess it is difficult owning a business nowadays. However there is no …
Went there for breakfast. Got 3 eggs home fries with bacon. Food was TERRIBLE. Potatoes had NO FLAVOR, NO ONIONS OR PEPPERS. Tasted as if it was plucked from the ground. Bacon. Over cooked with the exception of one stripe being a little under cooked. EGGS, was also lacking flavor. Hate being picky, but how can you mess up breakfast?
We were seated fast and got our drinks relatively quickly, but then waited 20 minutes to place our order and we’re never approached again. The table directly next to us sat a few minutes after we did and had their order taken in a timely manner. Unfortunate because we were looking forward to the food. Edit: Great response from the owner Made me feel great lol..
thought it would be a decent place to stop in saw ppl in there where as other places in that town looked empty, ordered 2 sodas , 2 bacon cheeseburgers and fries , sodas were flat , burgers weredry overcooked the burgers were 14$ each and did not include lettuce or tomatoe , you got a pickle & a dallop of coldslaw that was cabbage & mayo the puckle was so dry i couldnt squeeze any juice out to add to the slaw only thing that was edible was the small fries the waitress asked how things were before we took our first bite proberbly knew how it was before she served it , so attitude was not nice we'll just say and leave it at that , my rec, is go to wendys
Don’t let the 4 1/2 stars fool you. This place is horrible if you come in with 4 people or less. We came in because we wanted an old school diner feel and we were starving for breakfast! Now I’ll give them they were busy, and we were seated right away. The waitress came over in a matter of minutes and took our drink order. We ordered two coffees, a soda and an orange juice. After she brought our drinks she asked if we were ready to order and we were. We ordered two biscuits and gravy, and a side order of sausage links. My husband ordered 2 eggs a side of bacon and home-fries. Our friends ordered a meat lover omelette and her husband ordered a short stack of pancakes and a side of sausage patties. We’re very patient people, but the waitress never came back and asked if we needed any refills. She never came back and explained what was going on. We waited for an hour! Watching people get their food, eat pay and leave. They were so worried about the larger tables that they left our food under heat lamps, or that’s what we’re assuming. Finally after an hour we were so upset that my friend’s husband finally went up to the owner and said something and her response was to come over and refill the coffees offer another juice. She called us a liar because she said the other people came in before us. And her waitstaff sometimes gets the orders mixed up on larger tables. And we’re exaggerating on when we came in, she’s the one that seated us. We tried to explain to her that no, we know what time we came in and sat down. And she said that she doesn’t believe it’s been more than an hour and we’re lying. But right after we complained our food came out and this is where it gets very upsetting. We were still going to enjoy our food even if it was an hour late. But it came out ice cold. The waitress lied and said be careful it’s very hot. My husband is a cook and knows. His food was ice cold! So was my husband’s friends! This is why we believe our food was done and sitting back in the kitchen. We immediately got up and were walking out. The owner was in the front and said you got your food. And we told her that it was ice cold. And she said oh now you’re saying it’s ice cold. We said yeah because it has been done and just sitting back there. Never tried to apologize for the sub par service just told us to have a nice day sarcastically. I will never eat here again. Crappy service! I don’t even want to give them one star! I’d give them 1/4 star if I could!
Ordered chicken post pie. Very small for the price ($17.95) it came out burned. I could not eat it. I thought they made their own pies. It was a pie they bought frozen at the supermarket. How do you serve food when you see that it was burned
The service is horrible and the staff are rude, especially when it's packed.The food is extremely overpriced and mediocre at best. The reply to my review at the bottom of this demonstrates the maturity and respect of the diner's management: "It MOST be packed for a reason." They can't even reply with proper grammar. The reason it's packed is that there are only two diners in this town, and Tilly's Diner is much better.
Frustrating Experience with Inconsistent Service Policy The food here might be amazing, but I wouldn't know because I wasn't given the chance to find out. The server told me I couldn’t be served at the bar until a table opened up for a party of three who arrived just before me. To make it worse, that group had to wait twenty to twenty-five minutes for a table to open up! It makes no sense—I shouldn’t have to wait to be served at the bar if there’s space available. With some sadness, I’m leaving a negative review. Hopefully, it’ll prompt them to rethink this ridiculous policy.
The diner's popularity is questionable, given the unsatisfactory dining experience. The biscuits and gravy, a staple, were dry even with extra gravy. The children also expressed dissatisfaction with their meals. Service was lacking; the waitress required significant guidance, and the atmosphere was not conducive to a welcoming environment. The staff's behavior, including excessive socializing and unprofessional conduct, detracted from the dining experience. Overall, the quality of service and the appearance of the staff were below expectations.
I dont normally have pastrami with my oil soaked rye, but damn. This is the nastiest oily greasy mess I've ever been served. I could squeeze the rye and oil drips out like a wet sponge. The meat is so bland, I wonder how old is it. How do they have the audacity to call this pastrami? No napkins, utensils or hope. No, I see no reason to return.... if it had any more oil, the U.S. would invade your kitchen and take the cook into custody to eliminate competition.
I ordered an eggs benedict but with no egg and add an extra piece of ham (I swear this is not a complicated request if you just think about it for more than 2 seconds), and they gave me a plate with the ingredients..... I ordered from the diner so I wouldn't have to do all this; f I wanted to make this myself, I would have gone to shop rite and pay less than a third of the price, just to get this same thing. I know everyone has a coma whenever I ask for breakfast food with no egg, but this has to be the dumbest thing I ever seen
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
Millbrook On The River
Panera Bread
Danny D's Burgers
Fosterdale Country Cafe
Custer's Last Stand
River's Edge
Annie's Soul Food Kitchen
Ciao Bella
The Eldred Preserve
IL CASTELLOS PIZZERIA e RISTORANTE
163 Photos
Explore Miss Monticello Diner's photos
About Miss Monticello Diner
How to get there
405 Broadway #1, Monticello, NY 12701
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
405 Broadway #1, Monticello, NY 12701
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
church building in Monticello, New York, United States
park in the United States of America
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Miss Monticello Diner and other restaurants
Earn Points at Miss Monticello Diner!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Miss Monticello Diner
🏆 Rewards at Miss Monticello Diner
10% Discount
At Miss Monticello Diner
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu