Menu
Notaro
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

Notaro
Photos

Notaro

Italian · New York

3.8 · 83 reviews Google
www.notaroristorante.com

About Notaro

Notaro is a Italian restaurant in New York. Rated 3.8/5 based on 83 reviews on OpenTable. Casual Elegant.

Frequently asked questions about Notaro

Notaro is located at 635 Second Avenue, New York.
Notaro offers Italian cuisine.
83
Reviews

Notaro New York Reviews

Reviews (50)
T
Teddy “Teddy” F. Bils
D
Dorline Bosboom

Had Thanksgiving dinner here. The food was great and the price is so worth it. Quality is superb

L
Louise

Best little restaurant in Manhattan. Easy on the wallet and wonderful on food, service and ambiance.

P
Petar Mitev

Delicious food...but more important is the Great service!!!! I Highly recommend this neighborhood- must visit!!!!

A
Andrea Berger

reliable neighborhood place, family atmosphere, well prepared standard italian dishes

R
Rosemary Mackey

Excellent food in a cozy setting. Perfect place when you need coddling after a hard day at the office.

C
Chervone St Croix

Great service, nice portions. Food tastes great.

W
Wayne

Wonderful service and excellent food! Wish I could come back for more.

M
Michael Abdelkodos

Very nice restaurant. Good food and service

M
Mike Guritz

Tasty and accommodating! One of our favorites!

M
Manuela Collante

Very nice staff!

J
Jose Chauca

Nice place for drink

j
joe notaro
N
Natalya Chukhno
J
Javier Vera
M
Marina Royzis
K
Kiernan Collins
C
Cemarly Rodriguez
J
Jay Patel
C
Christopher Winn

Excellent service! Our waiter was attentive without being nosy. Great prix fixe menu at reasonable prices. The only downside was the coffee was not good. Almost tasted like instant. But overall the best restaurant experience we had while in NYC!

I
Isaac H

My Husband and I absolutely love this place. The food tastes authentic, and the service is wonderful. We always sit in the section near the bar, and the server for that section is great. He also doubles as the bartender. I would highly recommend this place for a romantic dinner for two, or a group dinner with your closest friends. They have a really good Pre-fix menu that will fit anyone's budget.

D
David Villegas

Been going here for years, food never disappoints. Not too pricey (good prix fix menu) and the staff is very friendly and accommodating. Nice and cozy atmosphere. Even has a fireplace :)

J
Jonathan Sheehan

Went with my gf for date night, very inexpensive prices and the food was delicious. The prixe fixe menu gets you a 3 course meal for around $25. What we enjoyed most was the small/ quiet feel, not noisy at all which is hard to find in NYC

Z
Zach Etschman

This place is great, we were visiting from Boston and would recommend this to anyone visiting or from the area. Some of the best service we have ever had, food was great and the prices are good too! We would definitely come back next time we are in the area

K
K Lewis

Great food at a great price. This is one of the only prefix meal spots that doesn't serve dry heat lamp food. It's fresh and great

A
Alonso Tejeda

Actually is very Good" The food they have is amazing, the service is friendly! Lunch prix-fix and Dinner prix-fix oso.! You should go, and have a nice romantic dinner !

R
Ronald Ruiz

Loved the sauces they use for their pasta dishes and great owner with amazing stories to tell . Recommend this to everyone who wants a good meal and welcoming environment .

A
Avril Murphy

Had a lovely meal at this restaurant last night the food and wine was 1st class as well as the service. Great value for money too. Highly recommended

t
tom de groot

Outstanding ingredients and flavor served with only the best service. A gem known for it's cozy atmosphere and great location near NYU.

C
Cyndi Cardinale

Great choice for Italian in NYC. Fettuccine with baby shrimp, spaghetti carbonara and veal tortellini were all excellent! We will be back for sure!

M
Magical Cleaning Service LLC

I love going there, the food is amazing , Angelo which is the manager, is always very attentive with us and the desserts are to die for, highly recommend this restaurant.

S
Stephen Freeman
D
Damien Riehl

Decent food. Not busy. Didn't knock my socks off, but it was a solid experience.

C
Cleiton Souza

Great food, good place, good music. Recommended!

S
Sayre Swarztrauber

Good food. Good value. Very good place for a conversation

S
Sharon Mathews

italian comfort food. lovely fireplace. gracious staff.

P
Pelin

Nice atmosphere and tasty minestrone.

J
Joey G

Good food , helpful staff

A
ALACRÁN HERNANDEZ

Pues es lugar muy elegante y buenos servicio

B
Belen Lazaro
S
Shel Small
a
alaric garcia

THE PERFECT PLACE AFTER A LONG DAY AT WORK. Staff will make you feel very comfortable and pleasant that you will feel right at home. Food prices are inexpensive, and most of the food its homemade. Delivery service its alright but I understand that everything its cook at the time you place your order, no frozen food. Portions are decent per individual. If there's a problem with your delivery they will fix the mistake right away.

D
David Bobrow

Food is excellent service is excellent if you prefer to eat at home they do deliver enjoy

E
Emily Zachar

a neighborhood favorite - great prix fixe deal and delivery too!

D
Desiree

The service was good, even though we were the only people there they didn't feel overbaring or awkward. The food however is really just average. The gnnochi was good but there was too much cheese and too little sauce. The calimari wasn't seasoned but the batter was nice. Two of our mussels were dead (unopen) but the portion size was good so it wasn't a huge issue to us. Not a bad experience but I'm not sure I would rate it as highly as the other reviewers.

J
Juan Munoz

Food was a bit overpriced, and portions lacking. The ambiance was also a off. The music was to pop-y, TV at the bar sad sport, and the cover of the outlet plug was missing. I will say the service was great.

j
jesse wexler

Terrible. The food took well over an hour to be delivered. The portions were laughable and when I called to ask why the $10 salad was served as a small side salad and why the $13.95 lasagna was so small I was told I was wrong. I was told I am not a customer and that their customers love them. I reminded him that I had just spent about $60 then he hung up on me. Great service. 7 years of living in Manhattan and this place is the new low.

M
Mary White

It was Christmas Day and my Birthday . We ordered on line. So very disappointed . The chicken cutlet was tough and the veal dish was awful.. It a bad choice to order .

R
R Belmer

A very disappointing experience. The quality of the cuisine is below average and the price/ quality ratio is outrageous.

L
Louis Silversin

Food was not fresh and tasted very bad. I should have sent it back.

Sign in to leave a review

Sign in
👑 Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Explore Your Area

More restaurants in New York →
📸

Gallery

📸

No photos available

Photos will appear here when synced from Google Places

📍

About Notaro

How to get there

635 Second Avenue

New York, NY 10016

Loading map...
Notaro
Tap for directions

Highlights

💬
Well Reviewed
83 reviews
👨‍🍳
Italian
Cuisine type

Restaurant Info

Rating
3.8/5
💬 Reviews
83

Amenities

💳 Credit Cards
🏘️

The Neighborhood

Location

635 Second Avenue

New York, NY 10016

📍

No Local Information Available

Local articles, weather, job opportunities, and events will be displayed here when data becomes available.

🎮

Gaming

🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!

Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Notaro and other restaurants

🎮

Earn Points at Notaro!

Play Find Me and redeem rewards here

Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Notaro

🏆 Rewards at Notaro

💰

10% Discount

At Notaro

1000 pts
Available
🍽️

Free Appetizer

On your next visit

2500 pts
Limited
👑

VIP Table

Premium experience

5000 pts
Exclusive

to redeem rewards and earn points

📋 How Do Rewards Work?

1

Play Find Me

Every 100 score points = 1 reward point

2

Collect Points

Workers earn 2x points per game

3

Redeem Rewards

Discounts, free food and VIP experiences

Call
👑

Is it yours? Claim it FREE!

Remove ads and manage your menu

Sign in & Play

Check your email!

No password needed — we'll email you a link

We sent you an access link

Check your spam folder if you don't see it