Mark Worstell

We went there on a Friday night and arrived about 5pm which barely beat the rush. They have a nice selection of fresh fish from what I understand is flown in. They also have an oyster bar. We started out with fresh shucked oysters. We also ordered the shrimp fritters which is one of our favorites. The food is always hot and fresh and comes out in a reasonable amount of time. The only items we wish would be different is the fact that one has to order food and drinks at the counter, then find an open table. Food is then delivered by runners. On busy nights those poor runners are trying to find the order numbers to match the food. It was good when they came by and quickly removed empty plates, but they also should be trying to upsell drinks when they are running low. The other item that we consistently encounter here is that the apps literally come a few minutes before the food. We wish they would have a dedicated apps line cook so that hot apps would come out more quickly and people have time to finish before the meal arrives. Overall, great place!

+1

Max Monroe

Definitely a gem in Newburgh that everyone needs to try. I've been coming here for year, to both locations, and have always had a great experience. Weather permitting, patio seating is a must. Sunday brunch is amazing and their regular meals are equally great. They're also the best place to get oysters on the half shell. The brunch cocktails on Sunday hit the spot with the crab cake benedict where during the week I kind the fried scallop taco or mixed fish and chips.

+8

Carl Tha Prez

Really good food! Buffalo Cauliflower is ridiculous! All the fried options are done just right and not greasy. They also have good seasonal and house cocktails and the carrot cake is a must try!

+4

Lee Halbig

Absolutely perfect food and service. They treated me and my wife as if we were the only customers in the whole place. The food came out fresh, hot, and quick! Go see Tin Fish and I'm sure you will leave as happy as we were.

+3

Melanie J Watkins

This was my first time dining here. We were seated & greeted immediately. We caught them during the Sunday brunch, but they also have a few items from the regular menu to choose from. I ordered the fish/shrimp & my husband ordered the fish n chips. Everything was hot, fresh, perfectly seasoned, and with a nice presentation. Loved everything! Generous portions as we had to take the rest In to go boxes. We will definitely be back!

+3

Friendly staff, quick service, nice restaurant. My son has an egg allergy so it's nice. They had a grilled options. Food was flavorful and fresh. However, for the price there should be bigger portions, my son is 2 years old and he ate an entire adult entree minus the slaw.

Debbie Moore

My husband, daughter and I went for lunch. It wasn’t very crowded. You go up to the counter and order. They have delicious slaw and fries. The fried fish was decent. I ordered red snapper. It was not cheap and I was very disappointed. It had very little flavor and was very dry. I would go back for the fish and fries. The shrimp and clams are both very good, but the snapper was a big letdown.

Ashley Rose

For the price, the portions are too small. One filet isn't really a platter, especially since fries are not included and the cole slaw is only a few ounces. My bread pudding was dry, had the texture of day old bread, and the flavors clashed so I wouldn't buy it again. The fish was cooked perfectly and had great flavor, as you would expect from a restaurant that specializes in fish. The clam chowder has great flavor, but is very runny with minimal ingredients, making it primarily liquid. Service was painfully slow... it took me 10 minutes to make it to the register with only two orders ahead of me, and the food didn't come out for twenty minutes. That's excessive considering only my fish needed cooked and it was only one filet.

DE Carbone

Order at the counter, take your number and seat yourself; they bring food to you. Nice, large space with outdoor seating. Friendly & helpful staff. We had stuffed mushrooms, clam chowder, fish & chips, orange roughy fillet. Everything was fresh and hot, small-ish portions, chowder was a bit watered down. Will return to try other menu items.

+1

Hate to rate service low as it is NOT due to the people working there. They had prices listed menus and came out to the line to give us menus. Then at the counter when we ordered they tried to charge each of us $3 more than the menu stated. Tried to say they were old menus but even at the counter the price was what we were seeing and these were specifically made for Lent..and it is during Lent so how old could they be? Finally took a little off our total but make sure you watch what they try to charge.

Mark Martinez

Ordered to go. Friendly service but what happened to the portion size? Haven't been there in over 9 months and the the fish and chips is not worth the price anymore.

Jason and Regina Stephenson

We love, love the Sunday brunch that is still advertised on the website but the restaurant isn’t doing anymore apparently. We’ve been in several times, including today, hoping for the Brunch menu since the website hasn’t been updated. Their regular menu is ok, brunch menu is fantastic.

None Required

Was very disappointed to learn that the prices and listings on the website or nowhere close to what you actually get in the restaurant. The grilled fish combo is advertised as salmon, swordfish and snapper but what you get is salmon, mahi and tilapia. Also the price it's much different online than what it is in store buy a little over $2. The fillet of salmon is extremely thin but the mahi and tilapia were decent. Also for the prize pretty disappointed that it doesn't come with fries you have to pay another $3 for those. I can go to just about any other fish place coast to coast and fries or another sideare apart of a platter. At the end of the day the food didn't taste bad but it's definitely not anywhere near worth what they are charging. The German chocolate cake was pretty good and in line with what I've seen other restaurants charge for dessert. It's casual serve so you order from the counter and then people bring your food and check on you periodically. Everyone we encountered seem friendly but I removed a star for service not because of the people but because of the inconsistency from what is online versus in-store as I don't view that as five star service.