Pizza Joint

Brandon Hughes

Pizza was delicious. The crust I'd ordered was the thicker crust. It was not too crispy or too soft. The toppings weren't sparse and the sausage was zesty. The atmosphere was clean and pleasing. My children also enjoyed it.

David Dixon

I have spent most of my life as a chef and even managed a pizza shop. Excellent customer service skills!!! and excellent pizza!!! If you like classic old school pizza this is the spot!!

Gary Pittman

I have been wanting to try Slice On Broadway for a while now, but usually when we order pizza it’s because we don’t have time to run and pick something up. So the no delivery in our area is too bad, but on 1/19/25 at 1:30pm we picked up two large pies, one cheese and one pepperoni. Drove them 25 minutes home and I was shocked at how well it handled the trip. Some pizzas are a soggy mess after 25 minutes in a box, but this was perfect 👍… The sauce is a little bit sweet, the crust was delicious and the amount of pepperoni was just right. The 3 younger fellas working were all extremely friendly and even gave us a pepperoni roll for my 13 year old son and I to share on the way home! That alone made it a return trip regardless of the pizza. So great pizza, great customer service and pricing is comparable to other local shops. We’ll definitely be back 👌

John Elmer

Nice Slice! The cheese pizza was delicious! The crust was thin and crispy. I liked the sauces. Service was quick and warm! Loved the mural on the wall. I’ll go there again ( note- this is my granddaughter s first review with me! She is a big help)

Bosede Ritchie

This is by far the absolute best pizza outside of NYC that I have eaten. I feel like we are back home....PERFECT! Bill Smith was very welcoming upon entry and made us feel at home during our dining experience.

Jasmine Pearson

Besides the pizza being sooooo good … the staff there are really nice and welcoming I will most definitely b back and recommending all my friends

Kristopher Magee

Slices Pizza and Robinson is great. They always have my order ready on time, and it has never been messed up. The pizza is delicious, and everyone’s friendly when you walk in.

Peter Y

Amazing service and excellent pizza. Stopped in for a slice of pizza in between classes today. Love their pizza!

Macy S

Shut up, this place is SO good (and cute as hell). Slice on Broadway fills a New York style pizza void that this area has. Everyone was friendly, food was fast and hot, and the slices were huge. Get the garlic knots, too!! Great for lunch while shopping, but I will definitely be making the 40 minute drive up here just for the pizza though.

You know when you show up to a place and realize you’re at THE spot? That’s how I felt when arriving here at the Robinson Slice on Broadway shop. First impression when I laid my eyes upon the actual establishment? What a beautiful display of teamwork and accountability. From GM to dishwasher everyone was working frivolously and so passionately. There are no ego’s here, but a sole unity of one mission, to make the greatest pizza in North America. And I haven’t even talked about the pizza yet! On this day, I gave the newly Sicilian pizza a try with pepperoni as topping of course. After I had my first bite…do you know the scene in Ratatouille where the evil food reviewer tries the ratatouille and gets a flashback of eating his mom’s ratatouille as a kid and becomes so happy? I felt like I was 7 yrs old after one bite. I would get married here, not to a woman but to a whole Sicilian pizza. Would come back here.

This place is awesome. Great sauce, great crust, can't really go wrong with any of the options since they've nailed the most important components. I do wish they featured the square slices in the case more often. I go about 2-3 times a week and almost never see them. If you do see the grandma pie or the sicilian square, get it. Don't even feel guilty about adding it to what you already wanted to order. Do yourself a favor and get either (or better yet, both) of those slices. Barring the quality of the food, the service is also great. One moment that struck out to me was when I overheard one of the younger employees (late teens, probably still in highschool) spending extra time on the phone while taking a customer's order. Apparently, the customer racked up quite the total because of all the toppings that they wanted, but then the young man who was taking their order noticed that the customer was basically ordering the equivalent of one of the specialty pizzas on the menu, so he steered the customer in that direction and effectively saved them a lot of money by doing so. I don't know about you, but for me, that makes this place worth visiting regularly.

The employees at slice are so nice and down to earth people. Good was great and they seem to have a fun time working together. The guys I interacted with were extremely cool. Great staff, great service!

Greeted by the team when I walked through the door. Food was ready at time promised and the quality is always tremendous. It’s my favorite pizza in the city! I recommend their Margherita pie or the Luca hoagie. Can’t go wrong with anything you choose.

I was slightly disappointed when comparing my experience at this place with my hundreds of visits to pizza shops across the United States… This place is too clean and the atmosphere is way more wholesome than what I’m accustomed to… So many pizza shop guys are just downright creepy, but these Young man gave off a vibe of good nature and enthusiasm! So different from what I’m coming from! So that’s why I only give the atmosphere a three star… As to the food? Oh my God G I don’t think I’ve ever tasted pizza this good.! And the service definitely five stars! Very polite very straightforward no nonsense. Why can’t we have more workers like this in the United States?

Amazing experience at Slice On Broadway! Great selection of pizzas with creative combinations and classic favorites. The service was fast and super welcoming. A perfect place for a quick bite or a chill dinner with friends. Highly recommend!

Slice On Broadway is hands-down one of the best pizza spots in Pittsburgh! The crust was perfectly crisp, the toppings were fresh, and every slice was packed with flavor. The staff was friendly and the vibe was fun and casual. I’ll definitely be back for more!

Jewells Pepmeyer

This place is AWESOME!!! I totally love their spinach, tomato, garlic pizza. Their crust is crunchy and delicious! I'll never go anywhere else. They are wonderful~

23 82

This place is awesome. Great sauce, great crust, can't really go wrong with any of the options since they've nailed the most important components. I do wish they featured the square slices in the case more often. I go about 2-3 times a week and almost never see them. If you do see the grandma pie or the sicilian square, get it. Don't even feel guilty about adding it to what you already wanted to order. Do yourself a favor and get either (or better yet, both) of those slices. Barring the quality of the food, the service is also great. One moment that struck out to me was when I overheard one of the younger employees (late teens, probably still in highschool) spending extra time on the phone while taking a customer's order. Apparently, the customer racked up quite the total because of all the toppings that they wanted, but then the young man who was taking their order noticed that the customer was basically ordering the equivalent of one of the specialty pizzas on the menu, so he steered the customer in that direction and effectively saved them a lot of money by doing so. I don't know about you, but for me, that makes this place worth visiting regularly.

Alex Wolk

Greeted by the team when I walked through the door. Food was ready at time promised and the quality is always tremendous. It’s my favorite pizza in the city! I recommend their Margherita pie or the Luca hoagie. Can’t go wrong with anything you choose.

Sam Martz

You know when you show up to a place and realize you’re at THE spot? That’s how I felt when arriving here at the Robinson Slice on Broadway shop. First impression when I laid my eyes upon the actual establishment? What a beautiful display of teamwork and accountability. From GM to dishwasher everyone was working frivolously and so passionately. There are no ego’s here, but a sole unity of one mission, to make the greatest pizza in North America. And I haven’t even talked about the pizza yet! On this day, I gave the newly Sicilian pizza a try with pepperoni as topping of course. After I had my first bite…do you know the scene in Ratatouille where the evil food reviewer tries the ratatouille and gets a flashback of eating his mom’s ratatouille as a kid and becomes so happy? I felt like I was 7 yrs old after one bite. I would get married here, not to a woman but to a whole Sicilian pizza. Would come back here.

Brian W.

I usually order from the Carnegie location, but I’ve picked up from the Robinson Township location a few times since they opened a year or two ago. Friendly workers, fast service, excellent pizza every time. New York style pizza is my favorite - and Slice has some of the best I’ve ever had!

This place is pretty good! The toppings are fresh, and there are many options! However you have to pay extra for each topping. Our pizza had pesto, and was extremely tasty especially with the olives and salty cheese. The dough is very crispy and reminiscent of New York style pizza in the heart of NYC. I would give this a 8/10!

March'25 - A simple cheese slice yummmyyyy. Don't forget to add both of their pizza seasonings (Italian and pizza). I'm a fan. April'24/Dec'23- Just have a cheese slice here. Yummy New York style big slice!! October'23- Yummy margherita!!! It's fresh mozzarella, basil and EVOO. Go for it!! I didn't like the Cheesy Garlic knots because they were dipped in a lots of cheese but there was hardly any garlic flavor. If they were stuffed with cheese, they might taste better. Also, luckily, I ordered garlic dip otherwise it would have been super dry. Gonna try "Rico's favorite" next time and update this review.

geetika soni

This place is pretty good! The toppings are fresh, and there are many options! However you have to pay extra for each topping. Our pizza had pesto, and was extremely tasty especially with the olives and salty cheese. The dough is very crispy and reminiscent of New York style pizza in the heart of NYC. I would give this a 8/10!

marc thompson

Pizza Rico was delicious. I would definitely order again.

Sagar

March'25 - A simple cheese slice yummmyyyy. Don't forget to add both of their pizza seasonings (Italian and pizza). I'm a fan. April'24/Dec'23- Just have a cheese slice here. Yummy New York style big slice!! October'23- Yummy margherita!!! It's fresh mozzarella, basil and EVOO. Go for it!! I didn't like the Cheesy Garlic knots because they were dipped in a lots of cheese but there was hardly any garlic flavor. If they were stuffed with cheese, they might taste better. Also, luckily, I ordered garlic dip otherwise it would have been super dry. Gonna try "Rico's favorite" next time and update this review.

About the Place: Located in Robinson Township, this pizza place benefits from a good location. However, despite its convenient position, the offerings are rather lackluster. About the Food: The pizza slices are regular and decent, but they fail to offer anything exciting or exceptional. The same sentiment extends to the pepperoni roll, which was also just okay. Overall, while the pizza place benefits from its strategic location, the uninspiring food options earn it a two-star review.

Pratik Naik

About the Place: Located in Robinson Township, this pizza place benefits from a good location. However, despite its convenient position, the offerings are rather lackluster. About the Food: The pizza slices are regular and decent, but they fail to offer anything exciting or exceptional. The same sentiment extends to the pepperoni roll, which was also just okay. Overall, while the pizza place benefits from its strategic location, the uninspiring food options earn it a two-star review.

Daniel Gaertner

Everyone hyped me up about this pizza but I was kinda disappointed. But, some are telling me it must have just been a bad day there. It tasted fine but I was not a fan of finding whole chunks of tomato in the sauce. Was I just there on a bad day? Is the chunky sauce a normal thing? Because if I could get this with a smooth sauce without any of the loose chunks in it, I'd be willing to try it again.

Joseph Manbevers (Joe)

I've never been there, walked in for an Uber Eats order. Walked straight up to the counter and the one guy, (let's call him Michael), rudely said: "He can help you at the register." They are also blasting rap music so that's a little weird too but whatever. I'm like ok that was weird. I walk up to the register and other guy (let's call him Zach) asks "What can I get you?" And I say pick up for blah blah blah Uber Eats. He told me a couple more minutes so I sit down and sit on my phone. As I'm walking out with the pizza "Michael" says "yeah get outta here buddy" and I squint my eyes and slowly turn my head around and look over my shoulder and all I see is a random lady looking at me with a shocked face which confirmed what I had just heard. I just kept walking. Not ever going there again lol. Not even for Uber Eats pickups.