Ron

The panino was excellent and I would absolutely come back to try more! I heard the (owner?) takes frequent trips back to Italy so not sure if he's always around but he's a very nice guy. The pizza and pasta could use more marinara because it was very good but a bit dry. Nevertheless, everything was fresh, seemed authentic, and was reasonably priced (slightly more than expected).

Michael Canales

For two margherita slices a full pie of pepperoni and two carbonaras. Everyone enjoyed everything. Visiting from Texas and glad we stopped by here. My son said was best pasta ever. The place is small inside but there is area out side to eat. Prices are reasonable. Overall nothing to ding the place, I am very pleased.

Tom S

Great pizza spot. Tiny but who cares for a few slices to go. I went with a sausage slice and a mushroom slice. Very unique pizza. Crispy crust, fluffy dough, fresh sauce and cheese, and plenty of toppings. I was already very happy with the food but the fact they had a great drink selection, including kombucha, really made me love this place. Thanks for the great meal!

Ms. Tran

Such a cute place! Hidden gem. Roman. Authentic. Deserving of its good reviewed. Glad we found it.

Sandra Ribes

Food was delicious, we ordered warm pasta and pizza. Really affordable for the great quality and Location.

Alan Varghese

Great homemade prepacked gelato and sorbets with some really good looking and delicious pizzas. It is to go but there are some seats just outside. Prices are decent and they also have plenty of salads and pasta options. Will definitely come back. They also have a nice coffee collection and assorted canned drinks for sale.

+16

Ijeoma Okpara (I'jay)

Hey there, allow me to take a moment to tell you how awesome my experience was at IL Baretto today. Firstly, the eatery was very clean and well organized, the cashier was welcoming, polite and informative, he (Alberto Tartari) was more than willing to recommend a few items which I was more than happy to try. I love pizza alot and have tried alot from places like Domino's, Little Ceasar, Pizza Hut, and Papa John's but today I can confidently tell you that I tried the BEST PIZZA IN NYC. lol That said, if you looking to have a good time and just experience an authentic Italian flavors in Pizza, Sandwiches, Salads and even desserts, feel free to stop by IL Baretto anytime, I know for sure that I will be going back. 😉 *There are no indoor dinning at this time. So please come prepared to either takeout or use the outdoor dinning. 01/25/22- Indoor dinning now available.

+7

Balpreet Kaur

Strong espresso, delicious pizza with light crust which is pretty close to perfection and friendly customer service. Thank you so much.

Food Critique

Love love this simple Italian home cooking. The simplest food is the best. I had octopus with salad (picture below) It’s just so delicious and healthy. The ‘ear’ pasta is al dente and tasty. The place is casual and small so it’s better to make reservation. Very popular among the locals, it had outdoor seating. I have yet to try their wine collections. Can’t wait to go back.

Gary Wilson

Really pricey at $5 a slice. Soft, puffy, tasty focaccia type crust. Very good sauce flavor. Cheese should be cooked more. Coverage is a bit skimpy.. too much crust. I'll give it an 85.

The Mets Drive Me Crazy

Truly sad when you hear great things about a place order delivery and they never provide the food and don’t answer the phone. Sucks ordering a meal for your family and after almost 2 hours they never did anything. This was on friday the 26th

C D

Everyday I would walk by here and see numerous people come out with pizza boxes. It appeared very popular so I decided to stop in today. I was sadly disappointed. The margarita pizza had no flavor and it wasn't what I expected. The pepperoni pizza was a little bit better but not by much. It was pretty average. Nothing to go " oh my god" over. I saw other choices so hopefully those taste better and maybe in time I'll try them again. But initially, my first thought was I would not be back.

Richard Hong

I really wanted to like this place. It's close to my apartment and might have been the ideal place to pick up a quick dinner. I was entranced by their pictures of lasagna. The product is nothing like it's representation--it's layers of pasta and some cheese, no meat, probably microwaved. This place might be okay for pizza (which looked to be sitting out for while) but it's really nothing more than a quick, cheap, not that good, lunch spot for those unfortunate enougt to work in the neighborhood. Don't go here.

Melissa

Very disappointing. The pizza looked and tasted like it was day old.