Colosseum New York Pizza
Pizza · San Jose
About Colosseum New York Pizza
En Colosseum New York Pizza, en el corazón de San José, te invitamos a disfrutar de auténticas porciones de pizza al estilo Nueva York y otros platos reconfortantes que te harán sentir como en casa. Abiertos hasta tarde, somos el lugar perfecto para saciar tus antojos nocturnos en un ambiente sencil...
En Colosseum New York Pizza, en el corazón de San José, te invitamos a disfrutar de auténticas porciones de pizza al estilo Nueva York y otros platos reconfortantes que te harán sentir como en casa. Abiertos hasta tarde, somos el lugar perfecto para saciar tus antojos nocturnos en un ambiente sencillo y acogedor. Ven a descubrir por qué nuestros clientes nos valoran con una nota de 4.4/5: ¡te esperamos con los brazos abiertos!
What Customers Say About Colosseum New York Pizza
Colosseum New York Pizza is praised for its authentic New York-style pizza, crispy crust, generous toppings, and reasonable prices. Many reviewers, especially those from the East Coast, vouch for its quality. Some recent reviews mention a decline in quality and new ownership.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: Order the pizza for a taste of authentic East Coast flavor, especially if you're craving a New York-style slice. Be aware that some recent reviews mention a change in quality.
Features
What to see nearby
Data from Wikidata
Frequently asked questions about Colosseum New York Pizza
Colosseum New York Pizza San Jose Reviews
Pizza is delicious ingredients are key to this place I usually get pepperoni or the all meat, garlic knots, chicken wings and fries are the best and for dessert chocolate covered or dusted with powder sugar are the Cannolis bottom line everything is good!!
Best NY Style pizza in the Bay area! I’m from Philly and I miss legit pizza!! I will literally drive down from San Francisco just to get a pie from this place. Great job!!!
Perfectly soft crust, melty cheese, rich sauce, and generous toppings, I loved every bite.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ “The best veg pizza I’ve had! Even I love non-veg. Fresh toppings, perfectly baked crust, and just the right amount of cheese. Flavorful, satisfying, and definitely worth coming back for. Highly recommend to all pizza lovers!”
I tried the wings at Colosseum Pizza Store, and they absolutely blew me away! Perfectly cooked—crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside—and packed with flavor. Whether you’re a fan of classic Buffalo or something a little spicier, they’ve nailed the seasoning and sauces. Easily some of the best wings I’ve had in the area. Highly recommend them as a must-try alongside their pizzas!
One of my friends recommended this place to me and I ordered 10 large pizzas for a house party. Hands down the best pizza I ever had in the Bay Area. The crispy crust is out of world. The topping portions are generous and prices are very reasonable. The staff are super friendly. I highly recommend this place for anyone who loves a quality pizza, you will not go wrong.
I recently started coming here, and since my first time a month ago, I keep going back!! Originally came for slices, they have pizza ready and quickly warm it up. One time they only had cheese slice and added pepperoni since that's what we wanted. Slices can be expensive, two slices and two pops costs $18. I finally grew a brain and got a large half cheese half pepperoni which has 8 large slices for $33, so l recommend doing that. One thing that also made me want to order a full pizza is that the slices aren't evenly cut. One time I got a slice and it was huge another time I got a slice and it was smaller than the first one. Ordering a whole pizza is the way to go! It's a no frills kinda place, seating on the inside, parm & red pepper shakers for you to bring back to your table. Some TVs and a Statue of Liberty to remind you of NY hehe. Overall, I love love love this place!!! I love how thin the crust is, it makes it so easy to eat, I ate up my portion of the cheese half no issue. Just writing this review is making me crave it so bad. Highly recommend this for NY thin pizza! Not doughy and you won't be weighed down after eating it!
I have no idea what some of these reviews are talking about. As a fellow New Yorker, this is by far the BEST pizza I have had since moving to California in 2015. The taste is perfect, great cheese, it passed the fold test with flying colors, and if you don't like a bit of grease, go eat at your local garbage mom and pop california pizza shop. This is THE pizza spot in San Jose. The atmosphere is just like walking into a real pizzeria in CNY. Tony and his wife were warm and welcoming. We had a great conversation about NY before I wver tasted their pizza. Once I smelled it, i knew this was it, and famn was I right! I will be here every week!
Huge pizzas at a fair price. Simple ordering with only Medium or Large sizes. Takeout only (03/13/23) with no fees online. Food: I ordered the "All Meat Pizza" and "Colosseum Pizza" both were very good and well salted. The pizzas are much larger in size compared to other pizza spots I have been to. Overall, I'll come back to try some of their other specialty pizzas. Their flavors were on point!
We religiously order from here every single Friday and we live in Fremont. Having been born and raised in NJ, I can put all my experience and taste buds behind the fact that this pizzeria is - hands-down- the best pizza in East Bay for those craving a truly authentic east coast slice! Thanks for always making our Friday dinner!!
Something has changed here. This used to be our go to pizza place and the best pizza place nearby. Over the last 2 months or so staff has changed and quality has gone downhill. I assume there's new ownership and sadly we likely won't be back. Just doesn't taste the same :( looking at recent reviews I'm not the only one who noticed the changes
Just picked up pizza and a calzone today. Everyone in my family noticed the change in flavor from previous owners. The new pizza dough taste awful. Not sure if the new owners tried to cheapen the original recipe but it sucks now. I used to order from here more than any other pizza place. The pizza crust tastes like cardboard
Have they changed owners? I don’t see the normal staff that I’m used to. Plus the pizza has been bad since the old staff left. Not going back. Very sad, it WAS the best pizza in the South Bay. Can’t wait for Slice House to replace this joint.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
Explore Your Area
IBU Taproom and Bottle Shop
Phở Kim Long
Venus Cafe
Bombay Chaat House
Mini Taqueria
Venta de Antojitos y Hamburgesas
Parktown Pizza Company
Stuft Pizza Milpitas
Ima's Kusina
Olive Garden
36 Photos
Explore Colosseum New York Pizza's photos
About Colosseum New York Pizza
How to get there
761 E Capitol Ave, Milpitas, CA 95035
San Jose, CA 95035
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Upcoming Events
San Jose Giants vs. Ontario Tower Buzzers
21 Jul. 2026, 18:30
Excite Ballpark
The Sound of Music (Touring)
21 Jul. 2026, 19:30
San Jose Center for the Performing Arts
San Jose Giants vs. Ontario Tower Buzzers
22 Jul. 2026, 13:00
Excite Ballpark
The Sound of Music - Closed Caption Performance
22 Jul. 2026, 19:30
San Jose Center for the Performing Arts
church in Milpitas, California
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Colosseum New York Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Colosseum New York Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Colosseum New York Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Colosseum New York Pizza
10% Discount
At Colosseum New York Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu