Diana

I had a fantastic experience at this pizzeria! A friend recommended it, & I'm so glad I took their advice. Earlier in the week, I accidentally left a slice behind, but when I called, the staff were incredibly kind & offered me credit. Today, I returned with my family to dine in, & we received a warm welcome. The staff are truly some of the sweetest people I've met, especially the gentleman who honored my credit. I wish I gotten his name. The food is amazing, with a great price range that beats my neighborhood pizzeria in both quality & value. Definitely a new favorite spot🤍

Marisa Crowley

Firstly, I’ve gone to Sal’s Pizzeria ever since I was a kid since I used to live in Sayville so it was always a go-to place! I came here way before they did their renovations, and it was a lot bigger a long time ago when they first opened! I’ve always remembered their pizza being absolutely outrageous and delicious!!! Anyhow Aegeans Pizzeria by the sun vet mall was my all time place and on the top of my list, but unfortunately they closed so about a few months ago I went back to Sal’s to see if they were still good, as I haven’t gone there in years! I went here with my boyfriend, and I’ll tell you they definitely changed up their set up, and must’ve did some renovations since it’s a lot smaller now than it was a long time ago. The pricing is pretty good and decent, and the atmosphere is pretty nice and simple just to sit down and have a quick little lunch or dinner. The staff are good, and rather very quick! My boyfriend usually gets the BBQ Chicken Pizza, and I usually get my Traditional/Regular Pizza. Both are absolutely delicious, and delightful and it tastes the exact same as I used to remember it, and it’s always stayed consistent with its pizza! The crust is always nice and full, and the pizza is never soggy but crispy! Sometimes we’d get takeout and eat in the car, whilst it’s still warm!!! Overall, I recommend on getting this place! It’s the best pizza place around, and there’s no other pizza place like this near by so this is my top favorite! Otherwise I’ve been to Umbertos, Gino’s, The pizzeria, Pepperoni Grill, Satellite, and etc which all weren’t good otherwise Sal’s never fail to disappoint me, and their pizza is PERFECT!

ColeB05

This is the best pizza you can get on long Island If you need a good Pie This is the place

David V

Great food and great prices. First time back in NY since 08 and the pizza did not disappoint. Huge slices and the pizza and knots were amazing.

Lo 2

Ordered a pizza pie for delivery and was very satisfied with the timely manner it arrived and the pizza was GREAT! No up charges for delivery. I wish I had more cash on hand cause I would’ve tipped the driver more. Will order again and definitely will try other items off the menu.

M Hofer

Has been one of my family's go to pizza for over 20 years. Never had a bad or less than perfect pie yet. Food is great and the owner talks with you like he has known you since birth. He actually remembers when my kids were babies, how great is that! It is one of the most pleasant and friendliest eateries to enjoy. I have also been using their catering services and let me tell you, they do not disappoint. The prices and quality of food is beyond amazing. People have asked me if I made the food myself. When you love what you do, it shows in the service and the food served. Highly recommended.

Cliff

Fast and friendly service, good volume for the music in the background . Food was hot, maybe a just a little too hot. Pizza has a good texture and a good number of speciality pies to choose. Perhaps the only little issue is they dont seem to have fountain drinks like fruit punch or lemonade, only bottled choices. The seating arrangements are good with different configurations for various party sizes. Would definitely come back again.

d curran

Usually come here a few times a year. Sicilian slice tasted off. The crust had a funny aftertaste. The meat slice was good. Tables full house at 2pm weekday.

Skyblazer

In my opinion the place is just plain awful and overpriced. They are all kinds of slices of pizza they did not look enticing in the least. I think three slices were 11 something I'm not sure exactly. It looked to me as if the slices were sitting around for quite some time.

Taylor Denatalie

Absolutely awful. Disaster of thick dough, undercooked. Mushrooms were raw, It was so disgusting we threw the whole thing out Just a pile of dough with raw mushrooms

Diann Butler

I order from Sals a few times a month. I'm done. I ordered eggplant parm tonight with very light sauce. Asked for the rigatoni al dented. The person that answered the phone asked me what does that mean. Obviously, no training. So the pasta was fine and the eggplant was soaked in sauce and mushy. Totally inedible. I cleaned on Saturday about 6pm and asked for a manager. Someone got on. I said I am asking for nothing, just wanted to give a heads up. Not even an apology. Horrible service. Never again.

Jay Love

First and last time buying spent almost $100 on garlic knots hot wings ect. and both pizza pies did not taste good like they were sitting as if they were meant for slices but was given to me garlic knots didn’t like and if that’s not the case none the less all 6 people did not like it including me I’m dissatisfied and disappointed this is my opinion