Murray's Pizza
Pizza · South Otselic
About Murray's Pizza
At Murray's Pizza, we're passionate about serving up delicious comfort food in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Our signature dishes have earned rave reviews from customers, who praise our perfectly crafted crusts, savory sauces, and generous toppings. From classic New York-style pies to hearty Sici...
At Murray's Pizza, we're passionate about serving up delicious comfort food in a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Our signature dishes have earned rave reviews from customers, who praise our perfectly crafted crusts, savory sauces, and generous toppings. From classic New York-style pies to hearty Sicilian-style pizzas, every bite is a testament to our commitment to quality ingredients. With live music, sports on TV, and a full bar, we've become the go-to spot for both locals and visitors alike. Our friendly service team is dedicated to making every dining experience special, whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely dinner with friends.
What Customers Say About Murray's Pizza
Murray's Pizza is a gem in South Otselic, known for its exceptional pizza, especially the NY style and Sicilian. Customers rave about the fresh, homemade ingredients, unique wing flavors, and friendly atmosphere. The owner's passion and effort are evident in the quality of the food and service.
Popular Dishes
Best For
Tip: If you like NY city style pizza, you will love this place. The Sicilian crust is also highly recommended.
Features
Frequently asked questions about Murray's Pizza
Murray's Pizza South Otselic Reviews
I still dream about this pizza. It was one of the best I’ve had in ages — thin yet perfectly crunchy, with a savory, toasty crust. The meat was juicy, and the melty cheese exceeded all my expectations for quintessential New York pizza. But that’s not all. We ordered a variety of dishes, and each one was exceptional. The garlic bread was soft and bursting with flavor, while the chicken crust bread was utterly satisfying with every bite. But the pasta I had was the true masterpiece — hands down, the best I’ve enjoyed in years. It was smoky and savory, with a subtle undertone of heat and sweet, achieving that perfect balance of being both light and rich at the same time. I don't know how the chef does it. I honestly didn’t expect to find such a high-caliber pizzeria in this part of New York. Coming from the city, I’m accustomed to a wealth of best dining options, yet this place easily stands shoulder to shoulder with the top-tier pizzerias in the competitive New York market. I learned that the chef/owner had previously worked in some of the finest restaurants in the city — his story reminded me of "The Bear," which tells so much about him! This place truly has soul. You can feel the love and care he puts into every dish for every customers, and it’s clear he has a close bond with the locals and the community. You just don’t find places like this anymore. This town is lucky to have this pizzeria as a local gem!
Best Pizza in the area! I've enjoyed the New York Style Crust multiple times; got the Sicilian Style today and it's amazing. Airy artisanal crust reminiscent of really good ciabatta and high quality toppings. The garlic knots, throat punch wings, and Mango Habanero wings were all excellent as well. Thanks Mario!
We have been coming to Murray’s for about a year and every time I order I ask if they have dessert, and they say no or not yet today they surprised me with a Brookie, brownie , thank you Murray’s your the Best& put a huge smile on my face
Stopped in after fishing. Enjoyable and then some. I will be back
I still dream about this pizza. It was one of the best I’ve had in ages — thin yet perfectly crunchy, with a savory, toasty crust. The meat was juicy, and the melty cheese exceeded all my expectations for quintessential New York pizza. But that’s not all. We ordered a variety of dishes, and each one was exceptional. The garlic bread was soft and bursting with flavor, while the chicken crust bread was utterly satisfying with every bite. But the pasta I had was the true masterpiece — hands down, the best I’ve enjoyed in years. It was smoky and savory, with a subtle undertone of heat and sweet, achieving that perfect balance of being both light and rich at the same time. I don't know how the chef does it. I honestly didn’t expect to find such a high-caliber pizzeria in this part of New York. Coming from the city, I’m accustomed to a wealth of best dining options, yet this place easily stands shoulder to shoulder with the top-tier pizzerias in the competitive New York market. I learned that the chef/owner had previously worked in some of the finest restaurants in the city — his story reminded me of "The Bear," which tells so much about him! This place truly has soul. You can feel the love and care he puts into every dish for every customers, and it’s clear he has a close bond with the locals and the community. You just don’t find places like this anymore. This town is lucky to have this pizzeria as a local gem!
Best Pizza in the area! I've enjoyed the New York Style Crust multiple times; got the Sicilian Style today and it's amazing. Airy artisanal crust reminiscent of really good ciabatta and high quality toppings. The garlic knots, throat punch wings, and Mango Habanero wings were all excellent as well. Thanks Mario!
We have been coming to Murray’s for about a year and every time I order I ask if they have dessert, and they say no or not yet today they surprised me with a Brookie, brownie , thank you Murray’s your the Best& put a huge smile on my face
Stopped in after fishing. Enjoyable and then some. I will be back
This is hands down the best chicken bacon ranch I've ever had! The food was cooked to perfection thin crispy crust all homemade toppings this place is amazing I will be back soon. Awesome, awesome awesome!!!
Idk how they only have 4 stars - (edit- after reading the reviews, there are 1 stars that people gave. Anyone that likes pizza, take those with a grain of salt and give this place a chance. Maybe the 1 star reviews don't know what pizza is supposed to taste like.) Best pizza in the area by far, friendly people running a local small business. Wings are bangin'
The absolute best pizza I’ve ever had , if you like NY city style pizza , you will love this place, awesome feel and scene ! I just had the pizza , so that’s all I can comment on , but I imagine the rest of the food is just as good ! Check this place out , you will not be disappointed !
Very nice little pizza shop. Reasonable price. Good pizza with a thin crust that holds form with toppings.
Unique theme and good food and drink!
Not your basic pizza and wings. Food never disappoints. Owner is great! And the mushrooms on his pies are incredible
What a find we stumbled upon! We had the riggies pasta with peppers, mushrooms, and onions in a thick, spicy tomato cream sauce. It was downright gourmet! The garlic knots are homemade with fresh garlic. Who would have known a place like this existed in such a rural area. Cool atmosphere, and good music as well!
We ordered a white pie and an order of garlic knots Saturday night. The wait time on the order was super quick (25 minutes) and everything was hot when we arrived. The pizza was delicious and I am excited to try the Sicilian crust next time. As good as the pizza was, the garlic knots were even better. Honestly next time we will be ordering a double order because sharing was difficult. I loved how they were smaller and had some crunch and texture to them. You could actually see and taste the garlic which doesn't always happen at other places. Next time we will definitely order in as their beer options look fantastic!
The Pizza is delicious which is all I've had, but my friends also tried various wings and absolutely love them. The owner and staff are really nice and they really put in a lot of effort (with great results!) to give it a nice atmosphere.
Whenever we’re in town, dinner at Murray’s is a must! We’ve sampled most of the menu and the food never disappoints. Fresh quality ingredients reflect the passion of the owner in delivering an exceptional product. The atmosphere, service and conversations all contribute to having a pleasurable dining experience. Always looking forward to our next visit.
Murray's is a great little secret! Good food, fast and pleasant service, awesome background music while you visit!
Best pie around.. hands down. The pizza was top shelf.. toppings were perfect, but the crowning jewel was the sauce and crust. I got a Sicilian pizza with peppers, spinach, meatballs, and gorgonzola cheese. Truly one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I 100% recommend them. The wings were splendid.. not as hot as I expected though. Still had a wonderfull flavor. Give them a call or drive over and give some love to a new business in our small town with the best food around.
First time ordering and what a wonderful gem we have in this lovely place. Love the decor....any place that has a pic of Waylon and Willie is ok by me! I got the Meatless Wonder pie and it is excellent! perfect crust! Now I have to try the other pies!
What a great place. Amazing food with unique dishes every day! What a great addition to South Otselic. A beautiful area for a drive if you e never been with great food and drinks. Occasional bands with great music. Wonderful friendly owners.
What a great place. Amazing food with unique dishes every day! What a great addition to South Otselic. A beautiful area for a drive if you e never been with great food and drinks. Occasional bands with great music. Wonderful friendly owners.
Murray's is a great little secret! Good food, fast and pleasant service, awesome background music while you visit!
What a find we stumbled upon! We had the riggies pasta with peppers, mushrooms, and onions in a thick, spicy tomato cream sauce. It was downright gourmet! The garlic knots are homemade with fresh garlic. Who would have known a place like this existed in such a rural area. Cool atmosphere, and good music as well!
Very nice little pizza shop. Reasonable price. Good pizza with a thin crust that holds form with toppings.
You will not be disappointed food is fantastic no matter what you order not to mention the pizza but that alone will keep you coming back
The Pizza is delicious which is all I've had, but my friends also tried various wings and absolutely love them. The owner and staff are really nice and they really put in a lot of effort (with great results!) to give it a nice atmosphere.
Whenever we’re in town, dinner at Murray’s is a must! We’ve sampled most of the menu and the food never disappoints. Fresh quality ingredients reflect the passion of the owner in delivering an exceptional product. The atmosphere, service and conversations all contribute to having a pleasurable dining experience. Always looking forward to our next visit.
Not your basic pizza and wings. Food never disappoints. Owner is great! And the mushrooms on his pies are incredible
We ordered a white pie and an order of garlic knots Saturday night. The wait time on the order was super quick (25 minutes) and everything was hot when we arrived. The pizza was delicious and I am excited to try the Sicilian crust next time. As good as the pizza was, the garlic knots were even better. Honestly next time we will be ordering a double order because sharing was difficult. I loved how they were smaller and had some crunch and texture to them. You could actually see and taste the garlic which doesn't always happen at other places. Next time we will definitely order in as their beer options look fantastic!
Idk how they only have 4 stars - (edit- after reading the reviews, there are 1 stars that people gave. Anyone that likes pizza, take those with a grain of salt and give this place a chance. Maybe the 1 star reviews don't know what pizza is supposed to taste like.) Best pizza in the area by far, friendly people running a local small business. Wings are bangin'
This is hands down the best chicken bacon ranch I've ever had! The food was cooked to perfection thin crispy crust all homemade toppings this place is amazing I will be back soon. Awesome, awesome awesome!!!
The absolute best pizza I’ve ever had , if you like NY city style pizza , you will love this place, awesome feel and scene ! I just had the pizza , so that’s all I can comment on , but I imagine the rest of the food is just as good ! Check this place out , you will not be disappointed !
First time ordering and what a wonderful gem we have in this lovely place. Love the decor....any place that has a pic of Waylon and Willie is ok by me! I got the Meatless Wonder pie and it is excellent! perfect crust! Now I have to try the other pies!
Best pie around.. hands down. The pizza was top shelf.. toppings were perfect, but the crowning jewel was the sauce and crust. I got a Sicilian pizza with peppers, spinach, meatballs, and gorgonzola cheese. Truly one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I 100% recommend them. The wings were splendid.. not as hot as I expected though. Still had a wonderfull flavor. Give them a call or drive over and give some love to a new business in our small town with the best food around.
We liked the pizza, they seem to have a different spin on wing flavors or i just don't get out much. I see some bad reviews for this place, if your one to base your visits on other people's reviews, you shouldn't. "Everything that is good isn't good for everyone," We thought it tasted good and like trying new places. We will go again,
We liked the pizza, they seem to have a different spin on wing flavors or i just don't get out much. I see some bad reviews for this place, if your one to base your visits on other people's reviews, you shouldn't. "Everything that is good isn't good for everyone," We thought it tasted good and like trying new places. We will go again,
Mushroom pizza and "Bruce Lee" wings. Food looked great, but way too much salt on both. There is no way that anyone could have enjoyed the food with the amount of salt that was on it. This makes me think something happened and the wrong seasoning was put on the pizza and wings? Way too much salt, very disappointed. I may give them a try again because I have heard good things, which makes me think something out of the ordinary happened when the food was prepared.
Mushroom pizza and "Bruce Lee" wings. Food looked great, but way too much salt on both. There is no way that anyone could have enjoyed the food with the amount of salt that was on it. This makes me think something happened and the wrong seasoning was put on the pizza and wings? Way too much salt, very disappointed. I may give them a try again because I have heard good things, which makes me think something out of the ordinary happened when the food was prepared.
Sign in to leave a review
Sign inRemove ads and manage your menu
No se encontraron idiomas
Explore Your Area
Cazenovia College Dining Hall
Bloomin' Cup
Arby's
Taco Bell
The Nest Tavern
Nin's Restaurant
The Fort
Friendly's
Gilligan's Island
Dunkin'
2 Photos
Explore Murray's Pizza's photos
About Murray's Pizza
How to get there
1576 State Rte 26, South Otselic, NY 13155
Highlights
Services
Dining Options
Restaurant Info
Amenities
The Neighborhood
Location
1576 State Rte 26, South Otselic, NY 13155
📍 Explore the Neighborhood
Gaming
🎮 Earn Points While You Explore!
Play Find Me and redeem points for discounts at Murray's Pizza and other restaurants
Earn Points at Murray's Pizza!
Play Find Me and redeem rewards here
Earn extra points and redeem them for rewards at Murray's Pizza
🏆 Rewards at Murray's Pizza
10% Discount
At Murray's Pizza
Free Appetizer
On your next visit
VIP Table
Premium experience
to redeem rewards and earn points
📋 How Do Rewards Work?
Play Find Me
Every 100 score points = 1 reward point
Collect Points
Workers earn 2x points per game
Redeem Rewards
Discounts, free food and VIP experiences
Is it yours? Claim it FREE!
Remove ads and manage your menu