Amici Pizza

You want a Grandma slice that you will fall in Love with? This is the place!! The Best Grandma slice in Staten Island and I know Pizza !! Take it from the Brooklyn guy this is the real deal. They dont travel out of their area for delivery so get up and get in your car or pedal your bike because its worth it !!!!!

This is a review coming from a picky Sicilian. Their vodka sauce is out of this world and so is their eggplant parm. Eggplant is always thin and never has seeds. Anything you get with vodka sauce is great. The portions are more than generous and the prices are very fair. Great customer service. My go to pizzeria every time. Delizioso.

Best meatballs in town, garlic bread is a 10, and stuff shells are amazing

Long time customer of Amici’s. Food is delicious and always arrives hot. Best delivery of Italian food in the area.

Best meatballs! All of the food I’ve gotten from here has been great..comes with fresh hot bread as well. Great place!

Raychel Rivera

Best meatballs! All of the food I’ve gotten from here has been great..comes with fresh hot bread as well. Great place!

Vincent Lam

Pretty solid slice. Going by the barstool rating, I give the cheese slice a 8.5

Dan Quattrocchi

Good pizza , friendly staff and very consistent.

Ralph

Best meatballs in town, garlic bread is a 10, and stuff shells are amazing

CBE

Long time customer of Amici’s. Food is delicious and always arrives hot. Best delivery of Italian food in the area.

Real Mccoy

You want a Grandma slice that you will fall in Love with? This is the place!! The Best Grandma slice in Staten Island and I know Pizza !! Take it from the Brooklyn guy this is the real deal. They dont travel out of their area for delivery so get up and get in your car or pedal your bike because its worth it !!!!!

Tracy Callaghan

This is a review coming from a picky Sicilian. Their vodka sauce is out of this world and so is their eggplant parm. Eggplant is always thin and never has seeds. Anything you get with vodka sauce is great. The portions are more than generous and the prices are very fair. Great customer service. My go to pizzeria every time. Delizioso.

Joseph Caputo

One of the best pizzerias I've ever ordered from on the island. Every order arrives hot, well-prepared, and on time (most of the time, they're earlier than they originally estimate). The food has never been bad. They're now my go-to.

Hannah Youssef

My friend and I have ordered from Amici two times now without a disappointment. They have various gluten free options which was exciting for us! The vodka sauce is delicious, more creamy than tomato, which we personally enjoy. The wings are breaded so they have a great crunch. We haven't tried the gluten free pizza yet but are looking forward to it. So happy we found it!

Pretty good grandma pie. Maybe just a bit salty. Still I say worthy of 7.6. Potentially a better score if our knucklehead boss didn't call in a late addition to our order. This caused the pie to be left sitting in the box awhile. You'll have to find on the street parking.

I usually order from here on a regular basis. Nothing crazy, just either one of their large pies plain, pepperoni, buffalo, etc. Their pies are usually pretty good. In fact, probably one of the better pies around my area. However recently they dont seem to be listening to their customers. Whenever I order a pie, I order it well done… always. But the last few months, the pies never come well done even though it is clearly written on the receipt in bold red letters. I have held off, thinking this would correct itself, but unfortunately it hasn’t. If one is going to pay $20.00 for a plain pie, or any pie, listen to your customers and make the pie the way they request. Not just rush it out the door because you are busy. And while I am talking about the receipt, what’s with the $1.00 delivery charge? Not sure why I never noticed it before and I know it’s only a dollar, but that’s not the point. Covid is over bro, stop nickel and diming your customers. The place is always packed and it’s always a long wait for a pie, so I think you can afford to pay your employees enough without tacking on an extra dollar to everyone’s delivery. I’d rather pay more for the food than see a extra delivery charge on my bill. At least make me feel a little bit like I’m not getting screwed. Next time I’ll just deduct it from the drivers tip. I’m sure the drivers will just love that!

brendan kane

Pretty good grandma pie. Maybe just a bit salty. Still I say worthy of 7.6. Potentially a better score if our knucklehead boss didn't call in a late addition to our order. This caused the pie to be left sitting in the box awhile. You'll have to find on the street parking.

C.A.D

I usually order from here on a regular basis. Nothing crazy, just either one of their large pies plain, pepperoni, buffalo, etc. Their pies are usually pretty good. In fact, probably one of the better pies around my area. However recently they dont seem to be listening to their customers. Whenever I order a pie, I order it well done… always. But the last few months, the pies never come well done even though it is clearly written on the receipt in bold red letters. I have held off, thinking this would correct itself, but unfortunately it hasn’t. If one is going to pay $20.00 for a plain pie, or any pie, listen to your customers and make the pie the way they request. Not just rush it out the door because you are busy. And while I am talking about the receipt, what’s with the $1.00 delivery charge? Not sure why I never noticed it before and I know it’s only a dollar, but that’s not the point. Covid is over bro, stop nickel and diming your customers. The place is always packed and it’s always a long wait for a pie, so I think you can afford to pay your employees enough without tacking on an extra dollar to everyone’s delivery. I’d rather pay more for the food than see a extra delivery charge on my bill. At least make me feel a little bit like I’m not getting screwed. Next time I’ll just deduct it from the drivers tip. I’m sure the drivers will just love that!

Gluten free penne vodka is delicious and legit better than the regular. But for two orders of it to come out to just under $40 is actually insane

Great pizza but this is about the tenth time I ordered on their website, received an email confirmation and then an hour later I call and the order did not go thru. Please update your ordering process so the orders are not coming thru via fax. Now I'll be waiting 2 hrs for a pizza.

Pizza is really good but super salty for some reason and I ordered GrubHub and they don’t tape the boxes closed and the lid blew open when I grabbed it. A lil uneasy eating it. Need to tape that box Amici

Frankie B

Pizza is really good but super salty for some reason and I ordered GrubHub and they don’t tape the boxes closed and the lid blew open when I grabbed it. A lil uneasy eating it. Need to tape that box Amici

Landon Dyer

Gluten free penne vodka is delicious and legit better than the regular. But for two orders of it to come out to just under $40 is actually insane

C. P.

Great pizza but this is about the tenth time I ordered on their website, received an email confirmation and then an hour later I call and the order did not go thru. Please update your ordering process so the orders are not coming thru via fax. Now I'll be waiting 2 hrs for a pizza.

Grandma pie was not very good. The dough was unchewable, like rubber and cardboard. Threw It out. I do love their regular pizza. Maybe it was a bad day for grandma pie.

Ordered delivery this evening, got a chicken and bacon slice which was good and a grandma pie since many people seem to say it was good. Unfortunately our experience was nowhere close to some of the positive reviews. The cheese and sauce were okay although on the saltier side and the dough was the major issue. The dough was tough to bite, very chewy and very saturated with oil especially in the middle and actually made us all feel unwell aftewards. Delivery was quick and slice was good however would never get a grandma pie here again.

Radoslaw Brzegowy

Ordered delivery this evening, got a chicken and bacon slice which was good and a grandma pie since many people seem to say it was good. Unfortunately our experience was nowhere close to some of the positive reviews. The cheese and sauce were okay although on the saltier side and the dough was the major issue. The dough was tough to bite, very chewy and very saturated with oil especially in the middle and actually made us all feel unwell aftewards. Delivery was quick and slice was good however would never get a grandma pie here again.

Annie M

Grandma pie was not very good. The dough was unchewable, like rubber and cardboard. Threw It out. I do love their regular pizza. Maybe it was a bad day for grandma pie.

Just wasn’t good. Got a grandma pie and mozzarella sticks. Grandma pie just tasted like 3 different ingredients as opposed to a good slice of pizza. Imagine baking bread separately, heating up sauce separately and throwing cheese on top in the end. Mozzarella sticks- crazy over salted. Ate 2, threw 4 out. Waste of 8.99$ Sorry guys, won’t be back.

Vladimir Goussev

Just wasn’t good. Got a grandma pie and mozzarella sticks. Grandma pie just tasted like 3 different ingredients as opposed to a good slice of pizza. Imagine baking bread separately, heating up sauce separately and throwing cheese on top in the end. Mozzarella sticks- crazy over salted. Ate 2, threw 4 out. Waste of 8.99$ Sorry guys, won’t be back.