The Pizza Shop

Name: The Pizza Shop
Address: 3918 Main St, Warrensburg, NY 12885, Warrensburg, NY, 12885, US
Telephone: +15186233070
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.7

Pizza · Warrensburg

4.7 · 407 reviews Google

Deals available

Be flexible, save more

The Pizza Shop

Your name

Your phone

Your email

We'll send your confirmation and prize here

Date & Time

Party size

Special requests

Free for you. The reward awaits you at the restaurant.

Reservation received!

thepizzashopwarrensburg.com

About The Pizza Shop

At The Pizza Shop, we're proud to serve up delicious, locally-sourced pizzas made with the freshest ingredients in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Our customers rave about our signature dishes, including perfectly crafted thin crusts and flavorful meatball subs. With outdoor seating available and a convenient location, it's easy to make us your go-to spot for lunch or dinner. From solo diners to families and groups of friends, we've got something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for pizza, wings, or a fresh salad, our friendly service and welcoming space will make you feel right at home. We're wheelchair accessible from top to bottom, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a meal with us.

What Customers Say About The Pizza Shop

The Pizza Shop in Warrensburg is highly rated for its New York-style thin crust pizza, described as some of the best in the area. Customers consistently praise the fresh ingredients, friendly staff (especially Corey and Patrick), and clean environment. The wings are also popular.

Popular Dishes

pizza (20) wings meatball sub Ceasar salad meatball platter BBQ chicken slice Buffalo chicken slices margarita

Best For

Families Tourists Locals Quick Bite Casual

Tip: Try the pizza! Many reviewers say it's the best in the area, especially the New York style thin crust. The plain, BBQ chicken, and Buffalo chicken slices are highly recommended.

Features

🌳 Outdoor 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery ♿ Accessible 🍽️ Lunch 🌙 Dinner 🥗 Vegetarian

🎯 Casual 🛋️ Cozy 🤫 Quiet ✨ Trendy 👨‍👩‍👧 Family 👥 Groups

Frequently asked questions about The Pizza Shop

The Pizza Shop is located at 3918 Main St, Warrensburg, NY 12885, Warrensburg.

The Pizza Shop offers pizza cuisine.

The Pizza Shop has regular opening hours. Check their profile for updated schedules.

The Pizza Shop offers the following services: dine-in, takeaway, delivery.

The most recommended dishes at The Pizza Shop based on customer reviews are: pizza, wings, meatball sub, Ceasar salad, meatball platter.

The Pizza Shop is ideal for families, tourists, locals, quick bites, casual dining.

Try the pizza! Many reviewers say it's the best in the area, especially the New York style thin crust. The plain, BBQ chicken, and Buffalo chicken slices are highly recommended.

407

Reviews

The Pizza Shop Warrensburg Reviews

4.7

407

5★

82%

4★

13%

3★

2★

1★

Reviews (23)

claudia vallette

This place is great has the best pizza around !! Crust nice and thin, sauce excellent and plenty of toppings...love it !!!

Candie Buglio

Me and my husband were visiting lake.George on a glamping trip and we stopped in to get a large pizza and a large italian very delicious.The bread on the sandwich was unbelievable.The staff was very courteous, and the place was extremely clean.I wish we had a pizza shop where I live like this

Alyssa Rivera

The pizza was so good, came out the oven quick, and the people working there were so sweet. They served us the pizza and checked up on us after as well.

Adam McGinnis

Very good pizza! If you are making the return trip from Montreal to points south, Canepa's Pizza Shop is a much better option for a bite to eat than stopping at a rest area or getting fast food. The plain, BBQ chicken, and Buffalo chicken slices are highly recommended.

Daniel

Happened to be driving through and wanted something right off the highway. Did not expect to have some of the best pizza I've ever had. Tried regular, buffalo, and margarita slices. Thin, crispy, and easily rivals NYC's best pizza spots. Highly recommend.

Michael Welsh

The best pizza in the area. Having lived most of my life in NYC its always difficult to find a true NY style pizza. Canepa's is it. Best pizza north of Albany by far.

dimitra rougala

Absolutely impressed with this place! We stopped here on our drive back home and everything we ordered was amazing. The meatball sub was loaded, flavorful, and perfectly sauced. The wrap was fresh, tasty, and super satisfying. And the pizza Truly delicious , great crust, great toppings, and cooked just right. Such a great find on the road. We’ll definitely be stopping here again! 🍕✨

Tamara Grimaldi

I grabbed a pie tonight on my way home from work , best pizza in this area by far . Thanks Canepas for an excellent pie ! It’s soooo good , the crust is amazing . I’ll be back .

Rachel & Dave Prehoda

Awesome experience! Pizza was fantastic. Corey served us really well today. It was a blessing to meet Corey and Patrick today. Highly recommend.

Shannon Rafferty

We've enjoyed the pizza here twice now. New to the area and trying different places always a bit scary. Canepa's has been consistent each time We've ordered.

Vicki West

Pizza is one of my favorite foods and I have no doubt in my mind that this is the best pizza I have ever had. The murals on the walls were beautiful and made for a nice atmosphere to have family dinner! The awards in the windows are not just for show!

Megan Mckiernan

Place was absolutely amazing, staff was super friendly, & the food came out so fast! The food was delicious. We ordered the four seasons, best pizza within miles!

isaac sapp

Stopped in for a quick lunch while on vacation. The pizza and wings were amazing. The only thing negative to say is how they sell drinks. You have to but it by the bottle from the reach in cooler. Seems like they are more geared towards take out. But like I said the food is great and the facility is nice and clean.

Jeanette McMullin

We got the white veggie only dressed in red! Superb! Perfect thin crust, nicely garlicy cooked just right. Real good pie. Staff was nice, place is clean.

Anhdao Zabarsky

Pizzas are delicious! My husband and I were in the area for July 4th weekend and stopped here for dinner. No wait for dine-in, but they were busy with lots of takeouts. My husband got the meat lovers and I got the margherita. Both were delicious. We love the thin and crispy crust! The Staff were very friendly and attentive. Stop by for tasty pizzas and if you want to avoid the lake George crowd.

Theresa St. John

Nice little pizza shop. Family owned. Loved the murals on the walls. We tried 2 slice/soda special. Local favorite was a great flavor. Also had bbq chicken slice. Very thin crust - nice and hot. Will go back again when I'm in the area.

SaBrina Bardin

Everything about our experience was amazing. Easily the best tasting dough that I've ever had.

Steve Mason

Stopped by during a busy spell and the staff was nothing but smiles and friendly customer service. Very welcoming atmosphere. Aaaand then came the PIZZA. Best pizza I have eaten in quite some time. Comes highly recommend. Definitely stoping back soon!

Share Nobel

Walking in to warm and inviting service with extra smiles is a great first experience dining at Canepa's. The art on the walls is a wonderful touch. The food was hot, fresh and fast coming out on top of being delicious beyond words. I will definitely recommend and come back for more. 10 out of 5 stars but Google doesn't give me the option to go above and beyond like the staff here.

MR Heuer

Their crust is perfect in my opinion. Thin, crispy, but not so crispy that it's hard. Slices fold just the way New York pizza should. I think there's more variety the closer to noon-one o'clock in the day when they fill the case for the lunch crowd, but you'll find something tasty no matter when you stop in. They have other offerings besides pizza, but haven't tried any (except the tiramisu).

Samantha Seeley

At Pizza shop, they understand that family is everything, and that's why they put so much effort into making sure that every pizza that leaves their kitchen is made with the freshest ingredients and cooked to perfection. Their dedication to quality and service is unmatched. We ordered 6 Pizza for a specific time with double cuts as we were serving to kids. We did call in when they opened up Shop to give them time to prepare around other orders that would surely be coming in for the day. Pizza was on time, fresh and ready to serve. It made feeding 40 simple easy and fast!

HawaiiantrixieB

Very good pizza. New york thin crust. Bone in chicken wings were crispy and flavorful. And we actually received the extra blue cheese we requested. We order 3 pizzas and a Ceasar salad, meatball platter, 2 kinds of bone in wings. Only thing for us. Chicken Ceasar salad was a little dry with the Ceasar dressing. Perfect foldable slices!

Kurt Stadtmuller

The pizza here is great, closer to a solid NYC pizza than Tommy Guns- HOWEVER- I dont know who under this "new management" thought what they call "garlic knots" is acceptable- theyre garlic nubs. If you want to sell those, call them garlic bites, even though that's being generous. You have an excellent product/flavor profile, but I was borderline pissed off to open my $7 garlic knots and find 12 sad little cherry tomato knots. Have some pride as NY pizza makers, FFS.