Christina Colby

I am a food snob, probably because I am an amazing cook and cook everything from scratch, including pizza. That being said, I was very impressed with their food. It's very rare I find a restaurant that I actually like. Nothing worse than eating out and thinking to yourself, I could have cooked this better myself at home. I'd give them 10 stars if I could. Thank you for the amazing food!!

ernest w

I have to say my new favorite place to get a Grilled chicken salad, But I can say from others experiences. The food is always amazing, hot fresh, and ready to go. Two thumbs up 👍

Ryan Moyer

I am finishing up a year of working a contract in Watertown. I love pizza and pretty much tried them all in the area. I will say definitively, that Tony’s is by far the best in the area. Its levels ahead of the rest. Once I discover it, I probably had Tony’s at least once a week my entire time here. Tony’s dough and crust are always perfectly baked, the sauce has a little zest to it and really kicks the pie up a notch, and the toppings are generous and always delicious.

Leah Mangum

The best pizza in Watertown! Service is always exceptional and prompt. We make a point to visit almost every week. Many people take out, but we’ve enjoyed sitting in the restaurant enjoying the relaxing atmosphere.

Raymond Mutchock

This little spot came highly recommended. Brought the family for dinner and I can say we were not disappointed! The pizza was delicious, the wings were crispy, and the Stromboli was something that will keep us coming back. The staff was friendly and the food came out quick. I highly recommend giving this place a shot.

Matt V

I’m not sure but I’m pretty sure Tony’s Pizzeria and OIP are the same thing. It sure when the name change happened but regardless of the name this place has very delicious pizza and wings. You have to try the almond cookies. Food is made fresh and is made fast.

Rebecca

Awesome place! Their pizza is good and so are their strombolis!(What you see in the photo). I love their bread and sauce 💕💕💕. Very reasonable prices. Service was nice too. It didn't take long to get our food. I just wished they used basil. Italians cook with basil. 🇮🇹

William Hahn

OK experience, food took about 20 mins to get meatball sub and chicken wing. Meatball sub was good with the parts that had meat sauce and cheese but alot was just bread which was not good. Wings were excellent 👌

Joel Roate

I’m going to be honest — the food here is fine, no complaints there. But I will not be coming back because the environment is not safe. This place shares a restroom with Colonial Laundromat next door, and that restroom has turned into a hangout spot for drug addicts. I literally saw people shooting up and doing drugs in the bathroom right next to where families are eating pizza. The door is wide open between the pizzeria and the laundromat, so people just walk back and forth. No one is checking, nobody is stopping it, and the staff act like they don’t want to get involved. If you’re a parent or bringing kids here, be careful. This isn’t just about being “uncomfortable,” it’s a serious safety and health issue. There are needles in the bathroom, people acting high and aggressive, and it does not feel safe at all. It’s crazy because this could be a good business, but until they secure the restroom and clean up what’s going on, I wouldn’t recommend eating here. Food means nothing if the environment is dangerous.

Wing Thing

This was my first time there. I had bought a sandwich which was charged over $15 for. Etheir the order had been missed took or the person dismissed my change. I had walked there and didn't notice till I had gotten home. I was disappointed. So I can't give it a good review, and I doubt I'll ever return.

Jamee Montondo

I ordered a hot chicken cheesesteak with the works. Got it home and there was no sauce at all on it. My husband ordered medium wings and no sauce on those either. So now I’m afraid if I order a pizza it’ll be just dough because they don’t know how to put sauce on things that are supposed to have it.

Heather Bates-Williams

We placed an order for $170 in pizza, wings and cheese sticks and a sub. They sent the wrong flavor chicken wings and didn’t send an order of the cheese sticks I ordered. I called to let them know within 4 minutes of receiving the delivery and was told “they said they put it in there” when clearly I didn’t have it. Then was told they were too busy to look into it. I paid cash. They didn’t rectify the mistake they made. I will not be ordering them from again!