Firaz Ashraf

Visited on a Friday night in the winter, was not very busy. The food however was amazing. Had the pastrami sandwich, Reuben and brisket cheesesteak. Really happy tried in that order but have to say for me the Reuben stole the show with the condiments and cheese as well as toasted bread. The cheesesteak was a little spicier but also a bit salty , still very good but had we started with that could not have finished it all. Will be back!

+2

Andrea Novoa

David’s Brisket House in Brooklyn is one of those timeless New York gems where tradition, flavor, and community meet over a single perfect bite. From the outside, it looks like the kind of old-school spot you could easily walk past until the smell of smoked meat pulls you in. Inside, the atmosphere is simple and unpretentious, but what comes out of that kitchen is pure craftsmanship. The brisket is tender, smoky, and rich, with just the right amount of fat melting into each slice. Piled high on rye bread and served with a side of nostalgia, every sandwich feels like a piece of New York history. What sets David’s Brisket House apart is the legacy behind it a Muslim-owned Jewish deli that has been perfecting this art for decades. It’s a story of cultures blending beautifully through food, and you can taste that harmony in every bite. Whether you go for the classic pastrami, corned beef, or the signature brisket, the flavors are deep, balanced, and completely addictive. Each sandwich comes stacked to perfection, juicy and smoky, with that old-school deli charm you can’t fake. There’s something special about how the team treats you too no rush, no gimmicks, just genuine hospitality. It’s the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name and newcomers are made to feel like family. Every visit feels familiar, comforting, and real. In a city overflowing with trendy new restaurants, David’s Brisket House remains a true New York institution humble, soulful, and unforgettable. If you’re looking for the best brisket sandwich in NYC, this is it. A taste of Brooklyn’s history, served warm between two slices of rye.

+1

Such a great lunch at this local institution with a storied history dating back to the 1960’s. I went with their lunch combo, which came with a nice, warming Moroccan soup that really hit the spot. The brisket was super tender and outstanding, especially with that flavorful jus. Exactly what you want from a place like this. I’ll definitely be back next time to try the pastrami.

Had the lunch combo of pastrami on rye, knish, and Moroccan Harira. Soup was better than I expected (took a few spoonfuls before realizing I forgot the picture)…knish was flavorful but a bit difficult to eat since it was cut in half horizontally and only had a fork to attempt to cut it into bite size pieces. Sandwich was good, with a good portion of pastrami. Bathroom was out of order so couldn’t review that. They can seat a good amount of customers, with booth style seating, and the location looked clean. Customer service was great, with a staff member bringing the food over to the table (just didn’t expect that).

This is hands down the best brisket we have tried in Brooklyn! We had a fantastic experience and will definitely be coming back. One of the best parts was that there were no lines and no crowds, making for a very relaxed meal. The staff was incredibly helpful and welcoming from the moment we walked in. Also, a special shoutout to the gravy they serve on the side—it is absolutely delicious and brings the whole meal together. If you're looking for top-tier brisket without the typical NYC wait times, this is the spot!

Syed F Hossain

Meat quality, taste and texture is grade A! Not many halal spots serve these old school deli sandwiches. I would ask for less mustard if you’re eating with pickles so it’s not too over-bearing :)

Mark STEVEN

I don't usually comment on food, but this time I made an exception. The pastrami, corned beef, and brisket are delicious. The tender texture is perfect. I bought a three-meat sandwich and it was the best decision I've ever made. I hope they continue like this, and I'll be back very soon. Thank you, thank you very much. I feel great having tried such a delicious sandwich. The price is reasonable, better than Katz's

Emily Lynn

Ordered for pickup, food was hot and ready right when expected. I ordered the pastrami sandwich. Yeah this place is expensive but the meat is melt in your mouth and the flavor is amazing. Best pastrami sandwich I've ever had. Hands down. Will come again

Reema Doleh

Everything here is delicious. You can’t go wrong with the pastrami, brisket, or Reuben. Staff is super helpful if you have any questions.

Danya Khaa

Just delicious ! Pastrami sandwich was amazing ! A lots of meat and some pickles just what we need. You have to go there. The lady who served us was so kind.

I gave a bad review not for the place but for the delivery service,they told me my lunch was delivered to address about 10 miles from me sent a picture of my food sitting on the ground if you do or…

I gave a bad review not for the place but for the delivery service,they told me my lunch was delivered to address about 10 miles from me sent a picture of my food sitting on the ground if you do …

I ordered a corn beef sandwich & a pastrami sandwich. It was delicious- it really was a good meal

Yea whoever said scr*w Katz in these reviews was right. The pastrami sandwich is just as good if not better than Katz for half the price. Sure, it's in the middle of nowhere, but get out there, peo…

Clean atmosphere, great cuts of pastrami that melt in your mouth! Customer service is amazing, very friendly and helpful.

My cousins raved about this restaurant. I tried it today for the first. loved the pastrami and gives it a plus for not being too salty. Thickness of the meat was just right and very tasty. I also h…

The pastrami sandwich and Reuben were among the best I've ever had. The staff were very warm and kind. But I ain't even kidding about the sandwiches: fresh bread and the best meat... no floss neede…

Ordered via Grubhub so didn't get to see the ambiance or service but the food came so quick and traveled so well. Ordered pastrami sandwich and brisket sandwich ... both are incredibly flavorful. N…

Very friendly and top notch service. The sandwiches that my wife and I ate, were out of this world yummy and delicious. The pastrami and brisket are both melt in your mouth good. The owner was very n…

Very friendly and top notch service. The sandwiches that my wife and I ate, were out of this world yummy and delicious. The pastrami and brisket are both melt in your mouth good. The owner was very…

Fantastic Brosket sandwich at David's. Thanks guys, you were so welcoming after a somewhat unnerving journey. The food was absolutely amazing.

Fantastic Brosket sandwich at David's. Thanks guys, you were so welcoming after a somewhat unnerving journey. The food was absolutely amazing.

Fantastic Brosket sandwich at David's. Thanks guys, you were so welcoming after a somewhat unnerving journey. The food was absolutely amazing.

Returning pastrami lover and food consistently is superb. The meat is perfectly seasoned, very tasty and the perfect texture.Although this is a no frills type restaurant the staff is very kind help…

Returning pastrami lover and food consistently is superb. The meat is perfectly seasoned, very tasty and the perfect texture.Although this is a no frills type restaurant the staff is very kind he…

Returning pastrami lover and food consistently is superb. The meat is perfectly seasoned, very tasty and the perfect texture.Although this is a no frills type restaurant the staff is very kind help…

Brisket Beef sandwich (Sandwiches) $17.99 1x Brooklyn cheesesteak sandwich (Sandwiches) $12.99 1x Pastrami sandwich (Sandwiches) • Regular $17.99 Everything solid

Brisket Beef sandwich (Sandwiches) $17.99 1x Brooklyn cheesesteak sandwich (Sandwiches) $12.99 1x Pastrami sandwich (Sandwiches) • Regular $17.99 Everything solid

Sam Toliver

The meat quality is excellent from texture to taste. Knowing that it’s halal I had no doubt that it would be bad. I ordered coleslaw on my sandwich but got a thin layer of slaw, barely tasted it. Pickles were great as well.

Jefe Birkner

Truly excellent sandwiches in a basic, utilitarian space that harks back to the neighborhood's pre-gentrification vibe. You need to decide for yourself whether it worth $23+ (including tax/ small tip and cc fees) for a sandwich that weighs in just a shade under 5 ounces including bread. It's a basic counter service place with a few chairs that produces a modest selection of truly amazing sandwiches. They prepare the brisket cut of beef in several ways, that they call Pastrami (smoked), Corned Beef (cured and poached), and Brisket that I think is simply roasted. The philosophy is find something that you do exceedingly well, and focus on that. They are worth a trip across town, it really is that good. Why not 5 stars? The service is friendly, and prompt, but there isn't much service, and the atmosphere is clean, but kind of "dumpy", all of which works for that stretch of Nostrand, but doesn't really reach 5-stars in my book.

Samir Nawaz

Halal brisket spot in brooklyn. Prices are basically the same as Katz deli, so on the PRICEY side. Pastrami was good, fries & pickles were good too. Nice old school diner vibe and service was great. Lunch prices seem really good. They do have 3 sizes of pastrami sandwiches so you don't really have to spend almost $30 for a sandwich but an authentic pastrami sandwich would be the XL.

+10

Very decent brisket sandwich, not too salty nor wet and plenty of meat flavor. Quick and efficient service. Could've had more meat considering the price.

Very decent brisket sandwich, not too salty nor wet and plenty of meat flavor. Quick and efficient service. Could've had more meat considering the price.

Very decent brisket sandwich, not too salty nor wet and plenty of meat flavor. Quick and efficient service. Could've had more meat considering the price.

Very decent brisket sandwich, not too salty nor wet and plenty of meat flavor. Quick and efficient service. Could've had more meat considering the price.

Very decent brisket sandwich, not too salty nor wet and plenty of meat flavor. Quick and efficient service. Could've had more meat considering the price.

Very decent brisket sandwich, not too salty nor wet and plenty of meat flavor. Quick and efficient service. Could've had more meat considering the price.

Overpriced for the quality of food. The rye bread tasted like sourdough. Service was good. But the taste was mediocre

Overpriced for the quality of food. The rye bread tasted like sourdough. Service was good. But the taste was mediocre

Overpriced for the quality of food. The rye bread tasted like sourdough. service was good. But the taste was mediocre

overpriced for the quality of food. The rye bread tasted like sourdough. Service was good. But the taste was mediocre

Small place but friendly service.\nPastrami and Brisket are both delicious, but I always seem to like Pastrami best:)\n\nOnly cons were the tiny bathroom to wash hands, and trying to find parking a…

Small place but friendly service.\nPastrami and Brisket are both delicious, but I always seem to like Pastrami best:)\n\nOnly cons were the tiny bathroom to wash hands, and trying to find parking a…

I ordered this via delivery, so can't speak to the actual restaurant or service, but the food was great!\n\nI decided to try something new, since I was in Brooklyn, and I feel like deli sandwiches …

Ordered a pastrami rueben for delivery. The pastrami was nice and tender, but could have used more seasoning/flavor. The ratio of the sandwich ingredients was perfect, and the portion was hearty. I…

Terrible. It's like whoever is making sandwiches is from a planet that has no concept of a sandwich. I a grilled chicken with peppers and onions on rye. Not one condiment, not one seasoning. The ch…

Quaint. Service is affable. Allows you to sample, which led to our purchase of the both supple slices of Corned Beef and Pastrami. Although the Brisket was equally tender, it had NO FLAVOR, NONE, zil…

Quaint. service is affable. Allows you to sample, which led to our purchase of the both supple slices of Corned Beef and Pastrami. Although the Brisket was equally tender, it had NO FLAVOR, NONE, z…

Kamillah Harrison

Came after seeing a tic tok video…… I gave a a 4 and my family gave a 2…. The Russian dressing was not good at all. The good thing is that they have a bathroom that was pretty clean ….. oh I was hoping that they had an area to establish the pray but nah, wishful thinking. I think I’ll stick with Katz over David’s going forward . Good thing we didn’t take the train because we would’ve been angry

Sここなっちゃん

The food was too bad! Bread was hotdog’s potato bun. And still cold. Not even toasted. The steak was the driest, cheapest meat. Potion Very small. Definitely overcharged!! This sandwich $17!!!!! Worst one in NYC!!!!!

Om Ar

It’s a scam to order to order whole fresh barbecue brisket as posted in first pic and then get this dry brown deli meat leftover sandwich. Specially when you’re on Keto diet too