Matt Michels

To all NYC visitors, get on the subway to Brooklyn and go over to this place for pizza you just really can't find roaming around Manhattan. This was the BEST NY pizza spot my wife and I tried while we visited the city in August 2025. We tried 10+ different spots. The vodka margherita slice here is honestly one of the tastiest slices of pizza we ever had. Perfect combination of cheese, tomato sauce, vodka sauce, and basil. Do not skip that! The plain cheese slice was very solid too. The guy working (I think the owner) was amazing and we felt very welcomed.

Jorge Picado

100% recommended. First time for me, and I'm in love with that pizza, we got half buffalo chicken and halfmeat lovers pie and their fries with the special sauce, also their lemonade and hibiscus tea. We devoured that food, we enjoyed it, and we are definitely coming back. The staff was very professional. Keep it up the good work, guys.

Robert MacGregor

Excellent slice, best in the neighborhood. Classic plain cheese is amazing here, lots of cheese and perfect balance of crispy/chewy crust. Margarita (pictured) also solid. EDIT: I wanted to update this now that I’ve been in the area for a while and ordered from Union St Pizza several times. This place really rocks. Amazing value. The classic pies and slices are great, but so are the more non-traditional varieties like the white pie as well as Sicilian and Detroit style.

moises acosta

Real NYC pizza spot. Thr Pepperoni Grandma with the Hot Honey 👨‍🍳😘. Also had a plain slice to give it a fair rating (the basis for all pizzerias). Cheese was cooked well, moist but not oily. Tomato sauce had the right amount, not too sweet, and the crust was superb. Great undercarriage, zero flop. 7.8/10 on the one bite rating scale. Customer service could be a tad nicer tho. Chic wasn't so happy that I decided to add a second slice after I initially came in for just one.

+2

Angie hutchinson

Good pizza made with a lot of love and care and amazing customer service. The guys here are super sweet and courteous . I would eat here everyday if the good food didn’t make me gain weight lol 🤣

Kelsey Vega

An absolute treasure of a pizzeria. The square pepperoni is out of this world. The sauce is excellent, the flavor is on point. It's my go-to for a celebration or treat. The round pepperoni with hot honey also delivers every single time. I recently had the penne vodka pasta dish and it was so great, it pushed me to finally write this review. I've never had anything less than delicious from Union Street Pizza and I hope it never closes!

Tian Nan

Good place! Like my chicken pizza! Taste great! Come at Saturday 2pm, no line here at all. Get order immediately and seat inside. Big place inside you can definitely seat here. Water or soda are also available. Just beside the R train subway entrance. 3 dollars for cheese pizza, the rest at 4 or 5 dollars a slice. Whole pie is 19-25 dollars.

Emanuel Aron

Conveniently located just outside of the Brooklyn bound R train station, this pizza spot is great for a slice or a pie and it’s open late (till 2-3am). Had the pleasure of meeting the owner Aiden (sp?), he’s a super chill guy. They do a Detroit-style pepperoni slice, pictured, they get the cheese all the way to the ends so it’s nice and crispy. I really enjoy the “cupperoni” style pepperoni. While that slice was great, I really enjoyed the spicy supreme slice, also pictured, which was sausage, pepperoni, onion, and jalapeño. The honey added the perfect amount of sweet to that spicy slice. I’m also a fan of their logo. Great no frills pizza spot!

+1

Sophia

Ordered from uber eats. Everything arrived on time and hot. as you can see from the photo, they really skimped on the pepperoni. pretty disappointing... mozzarella sticks were crunchy and flavorful, the sauce was ice cold but no biggie, I just warmed it up in the microwave. cannoli's are pretty good (B+)

Ifeoma U

Okay, final edit. I've had this place rated 5 stars, then 2, now 4. I've had a few off experiences, including pizza arriving "messy"/missing toppings and badly burned pizza, but for the most part this is a solid joint. Expensive ($35 for a large pepperoni pie) but good. I'll leave my old photo, but also re-upload the photo I had of when I first ordered and was impressed. The majority of orders are like the "good" pizza.

R F

I am baffled by all the reviews praising the sicilian pizza. I wanted to trust them so we decided to try it out. The crust was hard and seemed overcooked, even the center of the crust seemed stale somehow? The sauce was sweet, the "hot" honey wasn't hot and made it even sweeter. The best part was probably the pepperoni... and that's it. The pizza just... was not it. I am very disappointed.

Angel mel

Ordered a buffalo chicken pizza and i did not ask for onions on it, i called them back and i told them we dident ask for onions and was told that their menu says it contains onions when it clearly says ONLINE menu and the paper Menu that it doesnt have onions, the owner wanted to debate with me saying their all the white pies contains onions, Due to a food allergy it couldnt be eaten and they dident wanna fix it for us unless we tip the driver again, Horrible service i dont recommend ordering here. You might want to be more clear on your menu details especially when it comes to people with food allergies.