Jordana Lobo

My husband was craving raw oysters, so we did a quick pit stop , everything was delicious and we had a great time enjoying some tasty food.

+7

Carter Nystrom

After dining in other local restaurants, this was a breath of fresh air. It's a cute place viewing a harbor area with amazing food and fast friendly service. You're not bombarded by obnoxious too loud music and half- drunk customers. The cuisine was truly first rate. Bottles of wine are not insanely priced, which is not something that is normal where we come from. Our new Eureka favorite!

Joe Trimble

Great food and amazing staff. We asked a lot of questions about the building and they knew most of the answers. Cute little place to go any time of day. Staff was open and honest about the kitchen closure during lunch to dinner transition and still happily welcomed us for drinks.

Hannah Rock

Every single thing we ordered was tastier than the last. A truly delicious experience. All 3 of us got seafood dishes and they were all incredible. The curry dressing is out of this world.

Abbylee Priebe

Absolutely wonderful! Great service! We had fish and chips, coconut prawns, the rueben, and chicken burger. All fantastic!!

Olivia Walz

This is my absolute favorite place to dine in Humboldt! My husband and I love it so much we come almost weekly and always bring guests here. Food is always great and consistent. The service is always homey and we love the views. We even got our engagement photos done inside/outside the restaurant! We love it so much and is a staple in the community.

Kailey Grass

We were driving through and decided to stop for an early dinner, we loved it! No wait time since we arrived around 5pm. We were seated right away and our food got to us pretty quickly! My husband got the chicken parmesan linguine special and I got the chicken Caesar salad. We also got bread and clam chowder to warm up since it was pretty chilly out today! Great service and food, and such a cute location. We can’t wait to come back to Eureka and explore some more!

Bunny M

Come here on a Sunday morning, the way it was around 20 minutes. They took your name down and Will call you. The waitresses are very nice and polite. They provide you all the sauce you need before you even need to ask. The famous Humboldt Bay oyster here it’s so fresh and delicious. Also ordered a chicken fried steak and prawn omelette. Everything was super delicious. Highly recommend

+3

Location Authentic old fashioned Victorian style building. Grilled halibut was excellent. Hubby says burger was great! Yummy sourdough bread too :)

Alika Young

Let’s start with the food…amazing. I think it might’ve been the best Caesar salad I’ve ever had. I also had the small fruit plate & it was super fresh. I think it was grown locally but that’s just a guess. My partner had the French dip sandwich, which he liked but it was just meat & bread with the au jus on the side. He’s used to a horseradish or some type of condiment on the sandwich. I was confused by the service at first. On to the service, I thought the young lady who sat us & brought the drinks was our waitress but I now know that she was the hostess (my fault). Our waiter was good though. He checked in & did everything else that a waiter is supposed to do. The atmosphere was ehhh, but I’m not a fan of older buildings, etc. I sensed good vibes though, so that’s all that matters to me. Overall, I’d visit again whenever I’m in town. Solid 7.5/10.

Kimmie Bear

Loved this historic building location right near the waterfront. Tried the huckleberry lemonade and it was yummy. Dinner was north coast clam chowder with sourdough bread and I would totally come back for that. Followed by the fish and chips, that were really flavorful. Very enjoyable experience.

Erin Clark

This place really was middle of the road for me: for the food, everyone that was with me (there were 5 of us) had good food, and my side was super good - but my sandwich was terrible (it was dry, and it didn't have a good flavor. My mom tried it too and literally spit it out.) It sucks spending $19 for a sandwich (plus drink) and only eating the side and the bun! The service: the hostess was great, she helped me when I asked for more water and when I wanted to pay, but our waiter literally just took our order and brought food. It was crazy it took so long for our food because they weren't busy at all. I feel like this place is hit or miss - you may have a great experience, or you might get unlucky like me and just order the wrong thing. Good luck!

I had been a very frequent customer at Cafe Waterfront for many years until Moriah took over as bartender and treated me as inconsequential because I don’t drink alcohol. I always tip well and treat staff with the respect and kindness they deserve so honestly it hurts my feelings to be treated dismissively because my tab isn’t as substantial. I had gone when she wasn’t there and was treated well so was trying again but today she actually ignored me for several minutes after I sat down and then quickly took the order of another person who had just sat down. I walked out…too bad, I honestly love the music and atmosphere, so I miss it.

Nicolas Gei

Walked in with my girlfriend around 4:00pm (dinner service hadn’t started) and it took 3 different servers walking past us for us to be asked if we’d like something to drink. Not by our server, By the bartender. No hello, just a cold do you want anything to drink. The young blonde lady needs an attitude adjustment or perhaps a lesson in basic manners. Definitely not recommending even with the “old building charm”. We settled out with a 0 tip and took our money to Brick & Fire where we dropped 25% tip because the service and food was miles better than this dying old establishment. I never leave reviews but this garbage service warranted it.

Brig Bachrach

Absolutely horrible. The glowing reviews on here feel like this place is paying for good ratings. $31 for six pieces of frozen shrimp bathing in a room temperature watery butter sauce with a 1/4 cup of rice and about 10 steamed, unseasoned vegetables. Other highlights included the scallops, which were chewy and overcooked. The French onion soup which was soggy croutons sitting on warm onion water and clumpy cheese. And the unflavored, unseasoned, fried oysters. It’s astounding if this place has repeat customers. Update from the day after: 3 out of 4 of us who ate here got food poisoning. Stay away.

Chandler Mangiameli

Food was absolutely terrible. Grilled oysters were bitter and mushy/slimy. Snapper was overcooked and tasted like nothing but burnt fish. The calamari was also not edible. Sent all the food back, besides the bread and salad, and was stuck with a $110 bill for 2 people. Seriously I would not recommend it. Ended up eating in n out on our anniversary after paying a lot for food we did not eat.