4/19/25 Slice Pizzeria is easily the best pizza in town. My family moved up to Cortlandt Manor from NYC and takes our pizza pretty seriously. We’re thrilled Slice opened up! The pizza is always fresh and the crust is always perfect. They have your classic slices and pies and also have fun takes on pizza like the “drunken chicken bacon ranch (CBR)” - a must try! Same with the hot honey pepperoni. There is plenty of parking because it’s next to Trader Joe’s and Lowe’s with a big lot. You honestly can’t go wrong here. Highly recommend this pizza spot if you’re in the area.

+1

MAN O MAN is this pizza good! This may be one of the best pizzas ive ever had after living here for 22 years. Everything about it is delicious, the prices are great, and the atmosphere in the store is top notch! You need to try this place out!

We were traveling up the Taconic and happened to find this gem. So many different pizzas to choose from. Everyone loved the style they got. The staff was friendly and welcoming. Definitely looking forward to our next trip by!

Thank you very much for being so kind. About 20 of us came to eat pizza and they served us very kindly. It's a shame we live far away. If we lived close by, I would be in this place every day.

Pizza was delivered hot and fresh. Feta salad was crisp and delicious!

Sitting at Starbucks I watched them scrub and power wash the floor of their not large eating area for longer than an hour and a half. They then proceeded to detail clean their mop bucket. I would eat off of the floor and drink out of the mop bucket. 10/10 A+++ would hire them to clean a crime scene.

Nick

MAN O MAN is this pizza good! This may be one of the best pizzas ive ever had after living here for 22 years. Everything about it is delicious, the prices are great, and the atmosphere in the store is top notch! You need to try this place out!

Bryan Manning

We were traveling up the Taconic and happened to find this gem. So many different pizzas to choose from. Everyone loved the style they got. The staff was friendly and welcoming. Definitely looking forward to our next trip by!

Queens flushing

Thank you very much for being so kind. About 20 of us came to eat pizza and they served us very kindly. It's a shame we live far away. If we lived close by, I would be in this place every day.

Christopher Dahl

Best pizza in Yorktown hands down! Benny is an outstanding pizza man. He never disappoints!

Justin Colon

Sitting at Starbucks I watched them scrub and power wash the floor of their not large eating area for longer than an hour and a half. They then proceeded to detail clean their mop bucket. I would eat off of the floor and drink out of the mop bucket. 10/10 A+++ would hire them to clean a crime scene.

johnny khalid

Just moved to Yorktown Heights from Yonkers a few months back tried a few pizzerias out here but nothing hits like Slice Pizzeria does they have different varieties of pizza my favorite one is the vegetable slice it hits the spot for me I highly recommend Slice Pizzeria anyone looking for good pizza you guys definitely got a customer in me keep doing your thing

Dj Jimsoundz

Large pie is very small. Tiny slice, we NYkers aren't used to this. Taste good tho. Close to Ignazios in Brooklyn. Stretch that dough out and give us a proper 18 inch large pie. What we got was like a 12 inch pie!

Large pie is very small. Tiny slice, we NYkers aren't used to this. Taste good tho. Close to Ignazios in Brooklyn. Stretch that dough out and give us a proper 18 inch large pie. What we got was like a 12 inch pie!

Make sure that when you pay, you are informed before you pay, that you are being charged a fee for using your credit card. It is illegal to not post that fact. Last time I patronized Slice Pizza, they did not indicate that they were charging this fee. Otherwise the food is good, and the price is reasonable.

Victor Hernandez

Make sure that when you pay, you are informed before you pay, that you are being charged a fee for using your credit card. It is illegal to not post that fact. Last time I patronized Slice Pizza, they did not indicate that they were charging this fee. Otherwise the food is good, and the price is reasonable.

Lisa-Marie

I downloaded the app as I was rushing to work. I ordered a wrap. Pretty simple. It defaulted on accident to delivery. So I went in immediately and let the girl at the cash register know that I was going to have takeout instead of delivery. I asked her how long it would take and she told me 30 minutes. I understand the places are busy but they had two tables with a couple people at each table and they already had their food. I was a little confused by the time constraint. I went and sat in my car. I gave them 15 minutes. I figured that was all it needed to take to put a wrap together. I went back in and the girl checked in the back and told me it was going to be another 10 or so minutes. They had 15 pizzas in the display case. About three people making pizzas. One guy was feeling little cups of dressing and then there were two or three other people walking around behind there. I'm sure everybody had a job. When my wrap finally came out after telling the girl that I was on a time constraint and that's why I ordered it ahead of time while driving there, The man that handed it to me did apologize. The wrap was amazing. It was a very good. If you are going to be a app-based, fast food or even restaurant You should make sure that those orders are done in a quick manner. The reason why people use app based ordering is for convenience and so that when they get there their food is ready. The time stamp on the receipt was at 4:45 pm and I did not get my wrap until 5:20 p.m. All in all the place was clean, the people were courteous and the wrap that I ordered was very well put together and tasted wonderful. I will probably go back to give it a second try and maybe even eat some pizza. They had a great selection.

I downloaded the app as I was rushing to work. I ordered a wrap. Pretty simple. It defaulted on accident to delivery. So I went in immediately and let the girl at the cash register know that I was going to have takeout instead of delivery. I asked her how long it would take and she told me 30 minutes. I understand the places are busy but they had two tables with a couple people at each table and they already had their food. I was a little confused by the time constraint. I went and sat in my car. I gave them 15 minutes. I figured that was all it needed to take to put a wrap together. I went back in and the girl checked in the back and told me it was going to be another 10 or so minutes. They had 15 pizzas in the display case. About three people making pizzas. One guy was feeling little cups of dressing and then there were two or three other people walking around behind there. I'm sure everybody had a job. When my wrap finally came out after telling the girl that I was on a time constraint and that's why I ordered it ahead of time while driving there, The man that handed it to me did apologize. The wrap was amazing. It was a very good. If you are going to be a app-based, fast food or even restaurant You should make sure that those orders are done in a quick manner. The reason why people use app based ordering is for convenience and so that when they get there their food is ready. The time stamp on the receipt was at 4:45 pm and I did not get my wrap until 5:20 p.m. All in all the place was clean, the people were courteous and the wrap that I ordered was very well put together and tasted wonderful. I will probably go back to give it a second try and maybe even eat some pizza. They had a great selection.

Amy Wilkerson

I ordered two slices and some pasta. The slices were good but the pasta was not. 1st of all I ordered pasta primervera with angel hair and Fettuccine Alfredo. I got angel hair with marinara sauce. The Fettuccine Alfredo was OK but bland. If it wasn't at 15 minute drive from my house I would have went back to get my correct order. Not my first time at Slice but it will be my last time ordering any pasta.

I ordered two slices and some pasta. The slices were good but the pasta was not. 1st of all I ordered pasta primervera with angel hair and Fettuccine Alfredo. I got angel hair with marinara sauce. The Fettuccine Alfredo was OK but bland. If it wasn't at 15 minute drive from my house I would have went back to get my correct order. Not my first time at Slice but it will be my last time ordering any pasta.

Amanda

*UPDATE* As you can see, the owner or whoever runs the email responded to my review. Most likely just to save face and make it seem like they care. Their excuse was that "when the pizzas are very hot, the cheese and toppings can shift during delivery, especially if the drive is rushed." 1. The order was for take out. Not delivery. I sat there and waited a while for it. Then drove 2 miles to my house... no more than 10 minutes away. The pizzas did not move around in the back seat of my car. The box of pizzas did not fall over. They remained in position the entire drive. Unless any of those events occurred, the pizza couldn't have "shifted" during the delivery. No matter how hot they were (which they weren't.) They were cold by the time I brought them home. So instead of saying that their workers were too lazy to take the time to make the pizzas properly or to make me a new one after their mistake, they gave me this foolishness. 2. As instructed, I reached out for a potential refund (for the overpriced garbage food that I received,) and they completely ignored my email. After saying that they wanted to "make things right." Obviously, they just wanted to seem sympathetic in front of the general public, when really they could care less if their staff is sending out pizza that looks like this. Their pizza honestly sucks. I can count on my fingers how many times I’ve had a good slice of pizza here. So I’m not saying it’s not impossible to catch them on a good day. But bottom line is their quality is very inconsistent. Decent selection of pizza which look appetizing until you receive it. The cheese on the grandma slices are never cooked throughly. My most recently experience was a few weeks ago. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, a cheese pizza, and two orders of garlic knots for a birthday party. I ordered it for take out and waited for it. This was a Monday night so they weren’t even that busy. The garlic knots were the only things edible and tasted “good.” The pizza was a mess. Pepperoni pizza came out like this (refer to the picture) and was disgustingly greasy. It looks like they messed it up (the pepperoni and cheese were all shifted to one side) and they were too lazy to make a new one. Which is ridiculous. This is people’s time and hard earned money being wasted and spent. I believe the order was like $50 in total. Overpriced, inconsistent garbage. Too bad it’s one of the few local pizza places in the Mohegan lake area. Make your own pizza at home or find somewhere else (not that you would find anything else decent in this area).

Simply reviewed travels youtube

Ordered a slice of pepperoni and their spicy meatball instead, they gave me something completely else. Then I went ahead and asked them to change it. They gave me an attitude about it. They changed the slices and they gave them to me cold . When I specifically asked for a crispy, they gave me a cold. Slice . Don’t go there when it’s busy like around 6 o’clock bad time . not good service.

craigcatolane

We gave this place and try and it was great. Pizza was very good and I enjoyed the Chicken Caesar wrap. I will definitely order from here again. Update 12/17/2022: Just ordered two wedges and they were delicious! We’ve tried many different things from Slice and they have all been very good. Glad to have such a great place to eat in town. Update 11/12/2023: After ordering from Slice for almost a year, I’m sad to say that this I will no longer order from here. The quality has gone down substantially and my order is never correct. Today my pizza was missing half of the toppings and all they had was excuses. I have looked past many of their mistakes recently but I think I’m all set with Slice.

We gave this place and try and it was great. Pizza was very good and I enjoyed the Chicken Caesar wrap. I will definitely order from here again. Update 12/17/2022: Just ordered two wedges and they were delicious! We’ve tried many different things from Slice and they have all been very good. Glad to have such a great place to eat in town. Update 11/12/2023: After ordering from Slice for almost a year, I’m sad to say that this I will no longer order from here. The quality has gone down substantially and my order is never correct. Today my pizza was missing half of the toppings and all they had was excuses. I have looked past many of their mistakes recently but I think I’m all set with Slice.

Ordered a slice of pepperoni and their spicy meatball instead, they gave me something completely else. Then I went ahead and asked them to change it. They gave me an attitude about it. They changed the slices and they gave them to me cold . When I specifically asked for a crispy, they gave me a cold. Slice . Don’t go there when it’s busy like around 6 o’clock bad time . not good service.

*UPDATE* As you can see, the owner or whoever runs the email responded to my review. Most likely just to save face and make it seem like they care. Their excuse was that "when the pizzas are very hot, the cheese and toppings can shift during delivery, especially if the drive is rushed." 1. The order was for take out. Not delivery. I sat there and waited a while for it. Then drove 2 miles to my house... no more than 10 minutes away. The pizzas did not move around in the back seat of my car. The box of pizzas did not fall over. They remained in position the entire drive. Unless any of those events occurred, the pizza couldn't have "shifted" during the delivery. No matter how hot they were (which they weren't.) They were cold by the time I brought them home. So instead of saying that their workers were too lazy to take the time to make the pizzas properly or to make me a new one after their mistake, they gave me this foolishness. 2. As instructed, I reached out for a potential refund (for the overpriced garbage food that I received,) and they completely ignored my email. After saying that they wanted to "make things right." Obviously, they just wanted to seem sympathetic in front of the general public, when really they could care less if their staff is sending out pizza that looks like this. Their pizza honestly sucks. I can count on my fingers how many times I’ve had a good slice of pizza here. So I’m not saying it’s not impossible to catch them on a good day. But bottom line is their quality is very inconsistent. Decent selection of pizza which look appetizing until you receive it. The cheese on the grandma slices are never cooked throughly. My most recently experience was a few weeks ago. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, a cheese pizza, and two orders of garlic knots for a birthday party. I ordered it for take out and waited for it. This was a Monday night so they weren’t even that busy. The garlic knots were the only things edible and tasted “good.” The pizza was a mess. Pepperoni pizza came out like this (refer to the picture) and was disgustingly greasy. It looks like they messed it up (the pepperoni and cheese were all shifted to one side) and they were too lazy to make a new one. Which is ridiculous. This is people’s time and hard earned money being wasted and spent. I believe the order was like $50 in total. Overpriced, inconsistent garbage. Too bad it’s one of the few local pizza places in the Mohegan lake area. Make your own pizza at home or find somewhere else (not that you would find anything else decent in this area).

Waited an hour and 45 minutes for a pizza and chicken fingers. Granted it was a busy night but there’s no way it should take that long for something like that. Food is decent here, but definitely not worth that kind of wait. Went to another equally good pizza place in town had my food in a half hour. Third time I’ve been here and this is the third time this has happened. Won’t be making this mistake again. I recommend you don’t either.

I always love ordering from Slice... but my last 2 deliveries have not been the best. Chicken tenders looked old, I could not even break apart to eat because they were so over cooked. I also have ordered the cheese Margherita personal pie 3 times in the last couple of months and even though its correct on receipt I keep getting different pizzas... maybe just communication problem. But when you have limited time for your lunch and waiting more than an hour to get the wrong items, it is very disappointing....

Nick

Waited an hour and 45 minutes for a pizza and chicken fingers. Granted it was a busy night but there’s no way it should take that long for something like that. Food is decent here, but definitely not worth that kind of wait. Went to another equally good pizza place in town had my food in a half hour. Third time I’ve been here and this is the third time this has happened. Won’t be making this mistake again. I recommend you don’t either.

Yanilsa Lucero

I always love ordering from Slice... but my last 2 deliveries have not been the best. Chicken tenders looked old, I could not even break apart to eat because they were so over cooked. I also have ordered the cheese Margherita personal pie 3 times in the last couple of months and even though its correct on receipt I keep getting different pizzas... maybe just communication problem. But when you have limited time for your lunch and waiting more than an hour to get the wrong items, it is very disappointing....