Third time there. It gets better and better. The place is pristine and immaculate. The staff is friendly and super helpful. The food is SUPERB! My favorite is anchovy pizza and it was to die for. This coming from a tough critical pizza lover. Enjoy

Really nice place, pizzas great and the workers were insanely nice and chill

We love The Pizzeria in Bay Shore great menu, excellent service and superb food. Max at the bar is usually our preferred seating she’s attentive and always on top of her game she never forgets your beverage of choice and always has a great smile. Keith is an excellent server who never forgets you and is always concerned that you receive excellent service truly an asset to the Pizzeria family of great quality restaurants. Here’s a tip try the bar pie and the meatball parmigiana, we are sure you’ll love it. PS the Babylon location is also a great stop with Brandon in charge. Paul and Barbara.

The food and the pizza is off the charts. What a great establishment that knows what they’re doing making pizza the New York Way. Love love love this place. Good food, good atmosphere great staff.great place for singles, friends, couples very comfortable for all.

My family and I had a great experience the other night, so much so I thought I should share!! Our server was wonderful I believe her name was Amanda. She was very kind while also being very insightful answering our questions. It was our first time at The Pizzeria and we will be back again. As we were walking out Joe the guy behind the counter made sure before we left we were completely satisfied with our experience. You do not see so often the kind of environment that is created by their workers!!

Busy place, great and yummy selections. Very casual with a lot of take out, moderate amount of seats.

Food was great. Service was excellent. Would come back in a hearbeat

Best of both worlds with the big, foldable NY style, or BIG CHEW Detroit with the crispy edges! Slices or pies, dine in or take away. Check out the NY "Trifecta" style with the criss-cross of three sauces.👍👍 The staff is super friendly.🙌

Everyone is so nice in there and the pizza is delicious! The Uncle Benny slice is THE BEST!!!! 😋

You know how you “”say it just don’t taste like it use to” well I’m renaming this place to Pizzeria of Brooklyn . Will not disappoint recently moved to Bayshore after 2 years found this place tried several dishes including the pizza and my over all review “ Love it Love it.. and love is in the taste . I don’t know the owners but I’m willing to bet that they had Sunday family dinners that brought joy and wanted to share that joy of a great Sunday dinner with us Thanks you for making quaintly food at a reasonable price ..

Was excllent oliva was energetic pilote and overall a good server

Delightful staff and food. Will definitely be back next time I'm in town.

Jamie S and Alexa were superb at not only pizza holding, efficiency, but also people skills. 10/10 for both! The best workers i have experienced yet, on top of her job and great attitudes. Jamie was so sweet and loved our loud group of gals and Alexa was very helpful with our thirst and cleanliness of our mess we make. They both brightened our day and filled our buckets!!

My wife and I visited as part of the Food Done It food tour. My wife has a gluten allergy and Dan made sure she was accommodated with pizza that she could eat. The food was great and the service was amazing.

Had a family event Saturday, Jill the bartender/serve was amazing, she handled our large table as we as 6 other tables and the bar. Very happy and impressed

One “small” (pun intended) issue, but not enough to take any stars away because the pizza is that good! I’ve had delivery and picked up a bunch of times and the service has always been top notch. Regular, specialty slices, rice balls, and wraps are all amazing! Ordered the garlic knots tonight and was kinda shocked at the size! My 3 year old asked if he can have a peanut 😂 Maybe add another knot? Looking forward to my next order!

Great pizzeria! Big portions and wonderful service. Rolled away happy!

+2

This is one of my favorite pizza places on Long Island. The food is great everything is super fresh. Everything is also very clean. Unlike other pizza places where they are complete dumps and don't care about cleaning anything. Not this place, this place is manage extraordinary.

I am a huge fan of The Pizzeria in Bay Shore, food and service is always spot on. That said I have to share an example of how great they are. Since it is brutally hot here, I went in to get a cold brew and asked for a separate cup of ice due to the heat. I got a large cup of ice because of the heat. Just a perfect example of the service that you receive at The Pizzeria!

This is second location I have had the pizza. Just as good as the Lindenhurst one. Great pizza!

There is a wide selection of scrumptious foods on display when you first walk in. It was hard to choose but I ended up getting a chicken wrap and rice balls. The wrap was an easy pick as it looked like fine art with that slight drizzle of balsamic on top. The rice balls are not a usual pick of mine but since they were fresh out of the oven I gave them a shot. I'm glad I made the trip because everything was delicious.

Possibly one of the best pizzerias we have on long island hands down. The staff was friendly and helpful. I recommend this pizzeria if your looking for something good.

My boyfriend and I had a lovely dinner there last night . Our waitress Elizabeth was friendly and accommodating to all our requests, even going a step beyond ! She could give classes on hospitality . The food was light and tasty , perfect for a summer night . And the ambience was comfortable and fresh , loved the open dining room . Our first time there, and we will be regulars !

Update- still delicious and the best spread in town. The atmosphere is unmatched and adds to the community feel downtown! Bomb dot com. Everything is delicious, even the breakfast.

Date night always after a long day after work! Wonderful staff! And the pizza never goes to waste! So yummy!

I stopped by the Bayshore pizzeria about a month ago, just a little before closing after my son’s baseball game, and I have to shout out Olivia for her amazing work ethic. She was juggling everything running the counter, cleaning up, helping customers without missing a beat. Even with so much going on, she stayed polite, professional, and efficient. You really don’t see that kind of dedication and hustle much anymore. Olivia made the experience a great one, and she definitely deserves recognition for the great service she provided!

Food was really great! Ordered the mezzi rig and calamari and it was delicious. My only gripe was that when we ate there were a LOT of flies around near the bathroom i wish they had fly traps or some fans around. Other than that the restaurant is beautiful and the food was delicious

This new place is excellent! The pizzas are all delicious, and the outdoor seating is nice also! It's a nice looking restaurant.

Great pizza and good vibes all around. This spot has become our go to spot for quality slices at affordable prices

OMG❣️ great pizza, delicious sauces, friendly staff. Great atmosphere, very relaxing. Try the chicken bacon ranch, bruschetta slices omg so good.

Absolutely delighted with our experience at this pizza spot! My boyfriend and I ordered takeout, and everything was delicious. The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfectly. The crust had just the right amount of crisp, and the toppings were generous and full of taste. What really stood out, though, was the outstanding service. We were helped by a very friendly guy, who I think was named Dan, and his attentiveness made all the difference. He had such a positive, welcoming attitude. It's clear that he genuinely cares about customer satisfaction, and that made our takeout experience even more enjoyable. We'll definitely be back thanks to the fantastic food and exceptional service! Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great pizza and a top-notch experience.

Top notch pizza! Stumbled upon this place while in Bay Shore and I would make the trip back any time. Cheap, and delicious pizza!

The pizza was excellent here the place is also very nice, clean, and the bathrooms are very elegant for a "Pizzeria" grear atmosphere friendly staff. Highly recommend wish they had a location closer to my home.

This place did not disappoint! Was visiting friends and we stopped by here, amazing selection. Recommend the Thai Slice

Mia Victoria Jackie and Olivia are the best workers out there. So kind and friendly. Place was bumping with music. Great vibes!

The pizza was delicious and they had amazing selections to choose from. My favorite was the meatball burrata and then the Chicago pepperoni paired with an espresso Martin! The vibe is great. A great place to meet with friends. Pizza, coffee and drinks. What else could you ask for!?

+2

We ordered a pizza kit to support West Islip soccer. The Pizzeria staff were so amazing to work with, we made 1 pie and used the other dough for garlic knots. It was amazing!!

The best part of the Chicken Caesar Salad wrap was the chicken. I ate only that. I did not care for the salad or the wrap. The almond and chocolate “Balthazar” croissants were delicious. Now I do not have to go Downtown to get them. The La Colombe cold brew is excellent, especially with milk and ice. The vibe is “Lower Manhattan meets Fire Island”. What an eclectic crowd!

I went here twice for the great pizza, and I do not regret to choose this place. First, I went here with my parents after visiting Fire Island, and they enjoyed the pizza here. It was Sicilian and the taste of dough was fantastic. FYI, the pizza I uploaded is not Sicilian, I just regret not to take the photo of it.

We ordered the vodka crumble pie and cheesy garlic bread, and it was AMAZING. The garlic is roasted and it's so mellow and delicious. I'm sad I didn't order another one!

Great location. Very clean spacious modern restaurant. Authentic pizza with modern twist. Good value. Service could be more customer friendly.

The pizzeria has amazing gluten free pizza and fantastic cocktails. I've ordered from here plenty of times and have not been disappointed. I recently went to dine-in and it was a pleasant experience, as always the food was delicious and the drinks were just as good! I highly recommend going to the pizzeria if you are in the bay shore area :)

Great place, great food. We usually get pizza and a meatball parm to go but stay once in a while. Food is ready in 20 minutes or usually less. Plenty to choose from on the menu. They have specials for game day too.

The pizzeria in Bayshore is the best spot, there hasn’t been a dish I’ve had there that has not been good. I would suggest the pizzeria chicken and the clam pasta they are both so fresh. Plus Brandon is the best most skilled and personable bar tender I’ve ever had. Ask for his NY sour you won’t be sorry!

Highly reccomend The Pizzeria! A great addition to the best town to eat out. 😉 Great service. Pizza was perfect. It was hard to decide which slice to get. We can't wait to go back. Great looking bar. Dining was casual.

This is a such a lovely place to go for a nice dinner. We tried their pizzas, appetizers and salads and we were all very satisfied. Definitely a restaurant to go if you are in the area.

Stopped by The Pizzaria of Bay Shore and had an awesome experience. I tried a semi deep-dish regular slice and a square slice with sausage and hot honey—both were incredibly savory and delicious. The cold fountain drinks hit the spot, especially on a warm day. The staff really stood out—Olivia and Victoria were tag-teaming the counter and couldn’t have been more friendly and welcoming. Even with the place buzzing, they kept things moving and maintained a clean, organized space for everyone coming in. My family and I sat in the outdoor seating area, which had a great vibe—relaxed, upbeat, and perfect for enjoying a slice. Outstanding service, great atmosphere, and seriously good pizza. Definitely recommend if you’re in the area!

The server Ashley E at the bay shore location had outstanding service and made our dining experience even better! Food was flippin delicious!!!!

I wanted a chicken parm hero for lunch and was told to go here, and boy am I glad that I did. I was immediately greeted by the very friendly Cassie! She took my order, and 10 minutes later out it came. It was big enough for two meals! Thank you!

We bought the pizza kit for the St. Patrick’s school fundraiser. Had a blast making the 2 pizzas and eating them too! Instructions were easy to follow. Will definitely participate again!

We buy pizza every week and receive great service; my daughters love it.

Jamie S was amazing. We are new to town and everyone was warm and welcoming. Pet friendly outdoor dining too. Rocky was happy

Keith was a 10/10 server, he was very on top of our table, constantly made sure we had refills and napkins, and was honestly hilarious. Great food, better service!

Sooooo happy we tried them! The crust holds up and the taste is delicious! Was not a fan of the old location but everyone needs to make this our new local spot!

Absolutely incredible experience at The Pizzeria of Bayshore! From the moment you walk in, you can tell this place is special — the restaurant is beautiful, spotless, and has a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel comfortable right away. The service is truly top-notch. Every staff member I interacted with was friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, making sure everything was perfect throughout the visit. And the food… outstanding. Everything not only looks amazing when it comes out, but tastes even better. You can really tell they care about quality and presentation. They also have a bar with fantastic drinks that pair perfectly with the meal. Honestly, I’ve been to a lot of pizza places, and this one blows all the others out of the water. If you’re looking for phenomenal pizza, great drinks, and exceptional service, The Pizzeria of Bayshore is an absolute must-visit. I can’t wait to come back!

Charine Andersen

We love Olivia, because of her we made the tradition when the kids are home to come here on Sundays. Olivia is attentive, and knowledgeable of the menu. The food is generally consistently great.

Loretta Jiran

I want to give a huge shout-out to The Pizzeria & Staff especially Olivia for their incredible kindness and service. On the day of my Dad’s wake, I accidentally placed a catering order for the wrong day. When I showed up to pick up my order, they didn’t make me feel bad for my mistake. The staff immediately stepped in and had the team whip up my full catering order within 30 minutes! In such a stressful and emotional moment, they truly saved the day. Olivia’s kindness meant so much. Thank you for going above and beyond! I’ll be forever grateful for their compassion and understanding. -Loretta Ferraro Jiran

Yuriy Fishman

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore never disappoints. The pizza is always fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked — you can really taste the quality in every bite. The staff are incredibly friendly and make you feel welcome from the moment you walk in. Service is quick and attentive, whether you’re grabbing a slice or sitting down for a meal. It’s clear they take pride in what they do. Easily one of the best pizza spots around!

Min Hee Yang

Their pizza was one of the best pizzas we ever had. No wonder why they were so high in ratings. The food, service & the atmosphere were top notch. Our server, Ashley, was so sweet and attentive and made us feel welcomed. We aren’t from this area but will definitely come back when we visit this town again!

Carolyn Bellacera

I was so pleasantly surprised when we ate here. The house salad was delicious and the pizza was so tasty. And our waiter was just so accommodating. Would definitely come back here. Try this place. It's wonderful!

Michelle C

Stumbled upon the Pizzeria while going to a show. The place is super cute , Jaime our waitress was a doll. The food well hot damn run don’t walk! We had the arancini in vodka sauce, the aunt Danielle pizza and the pesto chicken sandwich. The vodka sauce was 10/10. The chicken sandwich was perfect you could smell the basil

Ann Pigate

The best of everything! Food, service and vibe! Our server Amanda was great as always. “The Hero” Chicken Vodka sauce is my go to. Our favorite spot in town!

Ian Miller

Good food, large portions, nice outdoor seating and an attentive waitress. Definitely a place I would go back to! The personal pizzas 🍕 are $16/each and are about large enough to feed 2 people!

Tara

I ordered this tasty caesar salad pizza wrap from the pizzeria made to perfection. Their service is awesome and welcoming. Their food is just as delicious. Both pizza and pizza wrap, I have ordered so far made to perfection!

Barsnobs

Amazing pizza, amazing environment, clean and sleek and comfortable. New and sheek. They know how to make a pie and serve a drink at the right price. I recommend the old fashioned and a bar pie for sure. We will be back. Tell em Barsnobs sent ya

John G

Some of the best thin crust pizza I have ever had. So many flavors in the pizza! Nice and clean restaurant. These are “personal” pizzas—they are HUUUGE!

Mimi Sorrentino

I had the best chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce, and it was nothing short of spectacular. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and the sandwich was cooked to perfection. My friend enjoyed an amazing chicken salad, which was fresh and full of flavor. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service made our visit even more enjoyable. A fantastic spot for a delicious meal!

Liz

My boyfriend and I had a great experience here on several occasions. Our first time we had 2 appetizers and some slices - ALL delicious. Another time we went with friends and ordered meals (not pictured) and the food was fantastic. It’s the perfect place for a quick bite or a dinner. The outside seating was perfect for the summer and the staff are very friendly. We would highly recommend!

Eric Proctor

THE EPITOME OF DELICIOUS! 😋 Took me back to Italy, the pizza is SPOT ON. Wow. I couldn’t think of anything else while inhaling my slices except how happy I was. Atmosphere is excellent. Place was very busy but very efficient and friendly. Lots of people coming in for lunch and roomy for everyone to stay. My first time trying them, they’re going on my food map, would 10/10 buy again.

Denise H.

Truly an upscale experience for pizza. The food is absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is lively and tastefully decorated. Our waiter was very helpful and attentive. We will definitely be back to try more options on the menu.

Cynthia Morris

O.M.G... my Bay Shore neighbors!! We have found GOLD!!! We do not have any good pizza on this side of Main Street but this gem right here is IT!! Service was wonderful, the pizza delish and one of the nicest looking bars in the neighborhood. Will def be back for happy hour! Only bad thing is they are walking distance from my home and there goes that weight control.. UGH!! Must try, must support our local business! 5 stars all around.. I'm too excited for this place. Excellent location for those headed to the ferry! Stop! Have a slice and a drink and enjoy the rest of your day!!

+8

New pizzeria and clean. Great decor and good location. Love the outdoor sitting. Service was quick but they lacked smile and not too friendly. Food is also good so no major complaints here. Come visit them.

+6

We really enjoyed the fun menu at this pizzeria! They had different crust options, and pizzas with a sweet and salty vibe. I never thought of hot honey as a pizza topping, but it was a nice surprise. They also have more traditional pizza options, and a build-your-own pizza option as well. Not in to pizza? No worries! This restaurant offers plenty of other options! Plus, the vibe is really cool, with an indoor/outdoor dining area that’s perfect for warmer days in this beach community.

+6

Solid pizza, crust can use improvement however. But overall solid place, reasonable prices, good customer service. Followed instructions

Went yesterday for the first time. I've fallen out of love with pizza over the years, but this place may have rejuvenated it for me. Had the Trifecta slice, which was delicious and may be the best pizza I've ever had. The garlic knots were definitely the best I ever tasted. I like that they offer coffee and pastries. Giving them a 4 because it's early and the pastry choices didn't appeal to me. Also, no hot chocolate for my sister, as she's not a coffee drinker like me. I would like to see a potato and egg hero added to the menu, my favorite. The only vegetarian hero I could get is eggplant, which I despise. We bring our dog everywhere with us, so it would be nice if they would put chairs out in the future.

Decent grandma slice.... and the eggplant with arugula, peppers balsamic slice pretty good. Place is a pretty noisy party atmosphere on a Friday night. So if you like quiet its probably not a good place to go to sit and eat unless you're OK with not hearing yourself think or not bring able to talk/hear someone at your table. Grab and go or stay and enjoy the pub type atmosphere.

Ame Chicas

great food but service is a bit rude. Place has great seating though

Pizza 3.5 Got a regular slice, buffalo slice, and some knots. Pizza is decent, but as far as really good pizza places on LI go, this is average. Knots are kind of small and lacking in butter and garlic Really clean place with outdoor seating, so if you're looking for an atmosphere to go with your pizza, round up to 4.

Lou Blang

We love all of the slices and specialty pies, but your gluten free crust is at the bottom of our selection. Get a decent cauliflower crust and we will be back more often!

Rani Goldman

Dined in- and have been loyal since opening. The quality of the chicken caeser wrap has gone down. Soggy wrap, dry, hard chicken. Disappointing after just 3 years. The service also has decreased. Our waitress was kind, but never checked on us once. (In all fairness, we moved from seating to the bar). My husband’s meal was so unappetizing looking and he took maybe 1 bite. The bartender heard his disappointment, but never once said: “I overheard you. How can I make this right?” Only AFTER my husband said: “You saw me, why didn’t you say anything?” did he attempt to correct it. He did take it off our bill. The waitress also completely forgot our to-go item, but apologized for that in the end. Not complaining, just explaining. Service has gone down. Too much expansion too fast? We will still come and eat the pizza, as we enjoy it, but guys- c’mon! Educate your staff to anticipate the guest’s needs. You’re doing great, but can do better!

Daphale Stonecress

I really love the food here but I have an issue with gluten and can't eat most of it anymore. I noticed that whoever is in charge of the gluten free stuff usually cooks it wrong. Either the pasta is overcooked and falls apart or the pizza is burnt on the crust and underdone on the bottom. I often have to take it home, cut the burnt parts off and then pan fry the bottom, which gets it to taste a lot better. If the restaurant just put a little olive oil on the bottom of the gluten free pie, and cooked it a little longer on a lower temp, it would come out perfectly.

Vodka Chicken Parmagiana ( the chicken wasn’t fully cooked thru stiff) The Honey Pep Slice ( burn see picture)

vodka pasta used to be so good and now you guys barely any sauce, doesn’t even taste as good and it’s just dry.

least favorite place on long island to wait for uber. imagine waiting 20 minutes plus for an order, and they don’t apologize for the wait. rude, non caring typical service. i uber all around long island never going back here

I usually enjoy ordering from here as I live a few minutes away, however every time I come in for an order, I say hello with a smile and there are two employees in particular who just stare and are always not polite. My family enjoy the pizza, but I do not feel welcomed there, and would rather send my husband to pick up the food. I have always recommended this spot to many hospital staff, but now I will stop going out of my way to do that. I hope the owner read this, as service starts from the top, and a warm welcome to all customers should be the standard.

Girl who took my order by phone couldn’t answer the simplest questions, such as whether or not bread came with the order. Put me on hold twice for a long time to get answers. I stood at the counter for quite some time waiting to pick up; no one asked if I was being helped, despite aboyt ten waitresses and counter help being right there, with only one table outside and no one at the bar. Too many young girls and boys giggling and too busy to pay attention. I paid with a gift card and had $10 leftover but left it there because I’ll never go back. The food was good but the experience was not.

Weirdest people working behind the counter, girl with blue hairs and piercings very nasty. Even the manager don't know how to deal with people, always had a bad experience at this location

this place is a rip off. They charge me for two large pies one pepperoni, one plain we picked it up $55 wasn’t worth it.

I will NEVER come here again. The bald man at the cash register was indifferent and made me wait 30 minutes because of the order delay, then told me to cancel it. The most incompetent business I have ever seen.

It looked so good but one bite… no flavor . The only thing that was good was the pizza slice & it was a 5/10. You can’t pay me to eat here again . The vodka sauce was definitely canned Ragu. My whole family thought it was terrible . UPDATE : they stated they would give me a full refund and management personally reached out. Thank you Cliff & Zach I appreciate your kind gesture & time .

Pizza on BOGO night was almost uneatable. Tasted like a reheated frozen pie. Babylon spot is great but genuinely have never had a slice of pizza that bad in my life.