Ian Miller

Good food, large portions, nice outdoor seating and an attentive waitress. Definitely a place I would go back to! The personal pizzas 🍕 are $16/each and are about large enough to feed 2 people!

Tara

I ordered this tasty caesar salad pizza wrap from the pizzeria made to perfection. Their service is awesome and welcoming. Their food is just as delicious. Both pizza and pizza wrap, I have ordered so far made to perfection!

Barsnobs

Amazing pizza, amazing environment, clean and sleek and comfortable. New and sheek. They know how to make a pie and serve a drink at the right price. I recommend the old fashioned and a bar pie for sure. We will be back. Tell em Barsnobs sent ya

John G

Some of the best thin crust pizza I have ever had. So many flavors in the pizza! Nice and clean restaurant. These are “personal” pizzas—they are HUUUGE!

Mimi Sorrentino

I had the best chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce, and it was nothing short of spectacular. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and the sandwich was cooked to perfection. My friend enjoyed an amazing chicken salad, which was fresh and full of flavor. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service made our visit even more enjoyable. A fantastic spot for a delicious meal!

Liz

My boyfriend and I had a great experience here on several occasions. Our first time we had 2 appetizers and some slices - ALL delicious. Another time we went with friends and ordered meals (not pictured) and the food was fantastic. It’s the perfect place for a quick bite or a dinner. The outside seating was perfect for the summer and the staff are very friendly. We would highly recommend!

Eric Proctor

THE EPITOME OF DELICIOUS! 😋 Took me back to Italy, the pizza is SPOT ON. Wow. I couldn’t think of anything else while inhaling my slices except how happy I was. Atmosphere is excellent. Place was very busy but very efficient and friendly. Lots of people coming in for lunch and roomy for everyone to stay. My first time trying them, they’re going on my food map, would 10/10 buy again.

Denise H.

Truly an upscale experience for pizza. The food is absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is lively and tastefully decorated. Our waiter was very helpful and attentive. We will definitely be back to try more options on the menu.

Cynthia Morris

O.M.G... my Bay Shore neighbors!! We have found GOLD!!! We do not have any good pizza on this side of Main Street but this gem right here is IT!! Service was wonderful, the pizza delish and one of the nicest looking bars in the neighborhood. Will def be back for happy hour! Only bad thing is they are walking distance from my home and there goes that weight control.. UGH!! Must try, must support our local business! 5 stars all around.. I'm too excited for this place. Excellent location for those headed to the ferry! Stop! Have a slice and a drink and enjoy the rest of your day!!

+8

Decent grandma slice.... and the eggplant with arugula, peppers balsamic slice pretty good. Place is a pretty noisy party atmosphere on a Friday night. So if you like quiet its probably not a good place to go to sit and eat unless you're OK with not hearing yourself think or not bring able to talk/hear someone at your table. Grab and go or stay and enjoy the pub type atmosphere.

Ame Chicas

great food but service is a bit rude. Place has great seating though

Lou Blang

We love all of the slices and specialty pies, but your gluten free crust is at the bottom of our selection. Get a decent cauliflower crust and we will be back more often!

Rani Goldman

Dined in- and have been loyal since opening. The quality of the chicken caeser wrap has gone down. Soggy wrap, dry, hard chicken. Disappointing after just 3 years. The service also has decreased. Our waitress was kind, but never checked on us once. (In all fairness, we moved from seating to the bar). My husband’s meal was so unappetizing looking and he took maybe 1 bite. The bartender heard his disappointment, but never once said: “I overheard you. How can I make this right?” Only AFTER my husband said: “You saw me, why didn’t you say anything?” did he attempt to correct it. He did take it off our bill. The waitress also completely forgot our to-go item, but apologized for that in the end. Not complaining, just explaining. Service has gone down. Too much expansion too fast? We will still come and eat the pizza, as we enjoy it, but guys- c’mon! Educate your staff to anticipate the guest’s needs. You’re doing great, but can do better!

Daphale Stonecress

I really love the food here but I have an issue with gluten and can't eat most of it anymore. I noticed that whoever is in charge of the gluten free stuff usually cooks it wrong. Either the pasta is overcooked and falls apart or the pizza is burnt on the crust and underdone on the bottom. I often have to take it home, cut the burnt parts off and then pan fry the bottom, which gets it to taste a lot better. If the restaurant just put a little olive oil on the bottom of the gluten free pie, and cooked it a little longer on a lower temp, it would come out perfectly.

Pizza on BOGO night was almost uneatable. Tasted like a reheated frozen pie. Babylon spot is great but genuinely have never had a slice of pizza that bad in my life.