Sarah W

Found on Seed Oil Scout and so glad we did. We loved the pizza and salad. Felt great afterwards. No blah feeling. We received excellent service (I’m forgetting her name but she’s a sweet gal from Dominican Republic). The atmosphere and music are lovely. Only maybe a dozen tables but we were able to get seated right away on a Saturday afternoon. Highly recommend.

Jesse Boone

It was amazing wood-fried pizza. Highly recommend. Different flavors too than the usual suspects; I had a delicious eggplant, basil, pepper, and tomato one. Our waiter was friendly and prompt even though he looked like the only one on the floor on a busy night. (This was the gentleman working Monday evening, October 13.) We were impressed by his professionalism and the entire experience.

Jinhee Park

Marinara on the pizza was fresh, tasted very clean and like real food, no weird chemical artificial tastes. Dough complemented the toppings well. Spinach arancini was ok- there was nothing wrong with it, just personally didn’t prefer the mildness of it so I should’ve just chosen a different menu. Waitress was attentive and quick to know what you needed without you trying to make eye contact for ages.

Kymble Johnson

I was visiting New York and one of the few foods on my bucket list was good, Neapolitan pizza. This place did not disappoint! My favorite was the hot honey pepperoni - the roni was freshly sliced and thick. I also really enjoyed the prosciutto and arugula. Aside from the food, the service was great, and the vibe was perfect: polished, calm, warm, and comfy. I would definitely recommend to anyone wanting authentic Neopolitan pizza in the Hell’s Kitchen area.

+7

Enoch Eshetu

I did some research back home in Minnesota before coming, and Capizzi totally exceeded my expectations. Hands down the best pizza we’ve had everything tasted incredibly fresh, came out fast, and was super satisfying. You can really taste the quality of the ingredients. It made for a perfect date night with its cozy, dimly lit, lowkey vibe. I’m already planning to come back next time I’m in NYC. Highly recommend!

Luke Adams

Fun place we found randomly one night and luckily they had an open table. Place has less than 10 tables. Service was friendly and efficient and we enjoyed our pizzas. We ordered the burrata appetizer and it was very good, but it was similar to our pizzas, so we probably wouldnt order again.

Mayu M

Had lunch here before a Broadway show and it was a great choice! The place feels like a little escape to Italy. Calm, cozy, and friendly staff. The pizza was light and flavorful, with toppings like mushrooms and onions that made each bite different. Very delicious! We ended up staying for dessert too. Tiramisu was perfectly sweet and bitter. Loved it! We will definitely be back to this hidden gem.

+1

Stuart S.

It's hard to say enough about a place that is so great. The pizza is fantastic, the atmosphere makes you feel like you're in a dining room in Italy. The service is attentive and helpful. First the pizza, made in a wood fired brick oven, they only make a 12-in, it's enough for one person. It's pretty rare you go someplace to get pizza and the ingredients they use for the toppings are top of the line.... But that is the case here. The pepperoni is hand cut, it curls up on the edges and has wonderful flavor. The mushrooms are portobello but not too big and cut just right so they are noticeable on the pizza but correct texture. The crust is thin but still has texture, it's a bit crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Seriously one of the best pies I've had in memory. This is not $1 on the corner of New York Pizza, this is wellcrafted, balanced and fresh pizza. You also won't believe how fast it comes out, it literally takes less than 3 minutes to cook the pizza and it gets to your table in a few minutes more. You probably think the same thing I do about tiramisu in the United States. I have a favorite, it's in Chicago and very traditional Italian. This is pretty close too. The mascarpone is a thick layer, the lady fingers have texture, and the coffee doesn't overwhelm yet is present. The whip cream is real and very lightly sweetened. They say they make it daily, from the flavor and the appearance, they definitely do. Don't miss adding this to your table. I also thoroughly enjoyed a nice chilled bottle of sparkling Aqua Panna, and Motetti beer. Definitely from Italy. The atmosphere in the restaurant is very comfortable I would say a bit Italian rustic, It doesn't try to be something it's not and is far from a modern blank slate. The service was casual yet proper and made me feel like I'm a regular although it was my first time eating ( but not my last!) With nothing short of thousands of dining options in Manhattan, this is a standout for sit down yet casual pizza. It would be a very worthwhile choice. Go support Joe and the family, I don't think you'll be disappointed.

+7

Shivendra Rai

One of the best pizzas I have had in the states. It looks so vibrant and fresh plus you have the best manager and staff. They have the old fashioned way of making the pizza which looks fascinating and tastes amazing. No post eating complaint and it hits your stomach well. There were vegetarian options and they can customise some of the items. Loved the ambiance and the service. We had a Margherita and one of their classics with peppers, mushrooms & onions. You pay for the experience so no complaints

+2

Erin Robinson

An excellent spot for a delicious dinner in the city. I dined solo and the atmosphere was perfect for people watching. The service was excellent and very attentive, without being overbearing. I will say I regret not ordering the Caesar salad after seeing the other tables get it.

Our first time at Capizzi was 2012 and it was great then & still is Dec 2025 ! \nPizza is amazing - so is their Caesar salad - it's cozy and service is great.\nIf you want Authentic NY Italian pizza …

Our first time at Capizzi was 2012 and it was great then & still is Dec 2025 ! \nPizza is amazing - so is their Caesar salad - it's cozy and service is great.\nIf you want Authentic NY Italian pizz…

Our first time at Capizzi was 2012 and it was great then & still is Dec 2025 ! \nPizza is amazing - so is their Caesar salad - it's cozy and service is great.\nIf you want Authentic NY Italian pizz…

Amazing food and excellent service! We had dinner as a family and everyone loved their choice of pizza and dessert. Great atmosphere with a quaint vibe. Highly recommend!!!

Amazing food and excellent service! We had dinner as a family and everyone loved their choice of pizza and dessert. Great atmosphere with a quaint vibe. Highly recommend!!!

Amazing food and excellent service! We had dinner as a family and everyone loved their choice of pizza and dessert. Great atmosphere with a quaint vibe. Highly recommend!!!

Amazing food and excellent service! We had dinner as a family and everyone loved their choice of pizza and dessert. Great atmosphere with a quaint vibe. Highly recommend!!!

Amazing food and excellent service! We had dinner as a family and everyone loved their choice of pizza and dessert. Great atmosphere with a quaint vibe. Highly recommend!!!

Amazing food and excellent service! We had dinner as a family and everyone loved their choice of pizza and dessert. Great atmosphere with a quaint vibe. Highly recommend!!!

The service was nice. Friendly staff. My order was ready when I arrived. It is a cozy intimate old style restaurant. I had the loaded pizza which was delicious. I was surprised that I only received…

I ordered the fully loaded pie it was wonderful. I have to say it was the best pie I have had in a long time. The atmosphere was great the service was impeccable. Even though I had ordered it for t…

This is a fantastic pre-show dinner spot. Delicious pizzas, fresh salads, and a perfect cannoli dessert.

Awesome pizza, totally worth the wait! We got the classic margharita and the one with eggplant. Both were on point!

Food Was Amazing. You Know you can't go wrong with New York pizza restaurants and this one was good. Caesar salad was Amazing Very good dressing. All the pizzas were delicious they had a good selec…

Good pizza appetizers and drinks . Prepare to wait in line .Ordered margherita pizza,arancini spinaci rice balls and tiramisu for dessert delicious.

It was an amazing surprise. Food great (we are Italian) and people very friendly. Better than Keste for quality and price.

It was an amazing surprise. food great (we are Italian) and people very friendly. Better than Keste for quality and price.

It was an amazing surprise. Food great (we are Italian) and people very friendly. Better than Keste for quality and price.

Our Arugula salad and the works pizza was delicious! The pizza crust was perfect. The crust was not soggy, greasy or burned. It was some of the best pizza I have had the pleasure to eat. I substit…

Our Arugula salad and the works pizza was delicious! The pizza crust was perfect. The crust was not soggy, greasy or burned. It was some of the best pizza I have had the pleasure to eat. I…

Our Arugula salad and the works pizza was delicious! The pizza crust was perfect. The crust was not soggy, greasy or burned. It was some of the best pizza I have had the pleasure to eat. I s…

Our Arugula salad and the works pizza was delicious! The pizza crust was perfect. The crust was not soggy, greasy or burned. It was some of the best pizza I have had the pleasure to eat. I subst…

The food and the service were so good and i really enjoyed being there. I will surely be back again. The waiters and waitress were very generous and welcoming and also polite. Next time I come I will…

The food and the service were so good and i really enjoyed being there. I will surely be back again. The waiters and waitress were very generous and welcoming and also polite. Next time I come I wi…

The food and the service were so good and i really enjoyed being there. I will surely be back again. The waiters and waitress were very generous and welcoming and also polite. Next time I come I …

Really nice italien place, the staff was very nice and friendly and the pizza was yummy. We even got the sparking water for free.

Really nice italien place, the staff was very nice and friendly and the pizza was yummy. We even got the sparking water for free.

Really nice italien place, the staff was very nice and friendly and the pizza was yummy. We even got the sparking water for free.

New York City boasts a plethora of dining options, but this charming, intimate spot stands out for those seeking classic Italian cuisine. You'll find generous servings at prices that won't break th…

We had time to catch one taste of ny pizza, and we picked Capizzi! So glad we did! It was just past the lunch rush, and we had wonderful service. the small cozy restaurant gave us a nice seat to pe…

Love the salads, the flatbread with olive oil, and the margharita pizza!! We go every time we are in nyc! Get there on the early side or be ready to wait outside.

Amazing pizza and super waiting staff. Only 10 tables with first come first served, so don’t leave it too late to taste authentic pizza and great vino!

Last nite in NYC and wanted a pizza, salad & wine to relax in our hotel room. Place was so cute now wish we had dined in. Owner was there and so nice. Pizza cooked right in front of us and got …

The restaurant has a very romantic /cozy atmosphere. The service was efficient and quick. My pizza was a bit too salty but tasty. There were plenty of prosciutto for the topping. Two pizzas, a Diet Coke, and a beer plus service charge was $77.

Alireza Hashemi

Amazing service and atmosphere with kind and attentive staff. We tried two different pizzas and flatbread with olive oil. The flatbread was not a perfect pairing but I liked it. The pizza lacks a bit of char in my opinion to make it a perfect pizza, the toppings are high quality though. Totally recommended.

Pizza was delicious the way pizza should be made. The Caesar salad was tasty with its fresh cheese. Limited menu but they know there Pizza. Service was great very attentive. ambiance was very pleas…

pizza was delicious the way pizza should be made. The Caesar salad was tasty with its fresh cheese. Limited menu but they know there pizza. Service was great very attentive. Ambiance was very…

Pizza was delicious the way pizza should be made. The Caesar salad was tasty with its fresh cheese. Limited menu but they know there Pizza. service was great very attentive. Ambiance was very pleas…

Pizza was delicious the way pizza should be made. The Caesar salad was tasty with its fresh cheese. Limited menu but they know there Pizza. Service was great very attentive. Ambiance was very pleas…

pizza was delicious the way pizza should be made. The Caesar salad was tasty with its fresh cheese. Limited menu but they know there pizza. Service was great very attentive. Ambiance was very p…

Excellent location in the middle of town. kind staff and a cozy environment. The cannoli is a lovely way to end the dinner, and the margherita pizza is wonderful and fresh. Strongly advised.

We came here right at 5 on a Friday night and were the first people in the restaurant for dinner. We were promptly seated and ordered a pepperoni pizza and a broccoli rabe sausage. The peppero…

Had a 15min wait for a table but it was worth it. Quality wood oven pies here and very friendly service. Not the cheapest pizza in NYC but still feel it was worth the money.

Andrés Gil Arana

The dough was dry for me, but that’s a personal preference. The ingredients were fresh and the service was excellent! A great, reliable option in the area :)

The worst meal I've had in NYC. Food was terrible, overpriced for how bad the pizza tasted. Service was incredible awful, slow, and our waiter forgot our drinks until we had to remind him by the ti…

Ordered a regular pizza for delivery. Ended up with a watery, soggy, undercooked mess topped with lumpy, waxy cheese. Might’ve been frozen beforehand. Called the manager twice, but instead of deali…

Gustav N

Well, ok service but Pizzas are not good at all. It gets even worse when they serve it on metal/aluminum plates that are wobbly. This mean that the plate easily moves when you push the knife back forward to cut a slice of pizza. We have to chase the plate around the table. Avoid this place.