Alligator Way

Great Old School Tasting Pizza! Huge Slices for only $5! And, extras only cost $1 each!!!

Isa C

The slices are huge but delicious! It’s five for one jumbo slice and four is ONLY 20$ I was worried about change but don’t worry. The guys are nice and if you misspoke they won’t get annoyed

g2rizo

Love this tiny 🍕 pizza shop that makes fantastic huge delicious pizza they been around for a long time a great place to have a unforgettable pizza experience wheelchair 🦽 accessible no stairs to enter they even have a small section with table and chairs against the wall the people taking your order are good listeners and make your pizza fast and perfect. Also the price is right for the size.

+6

Monica Siliezar

$5 for a super slice. The guy at the front is very kind. The location is easy to get to, parking was okay. Can’t beat the price!

Sergio Penalver

I've been coming here for over 20yrs when I visit home. By far the best pizza... these slices are huge. And the Pie is ginormous. Great prices and family-friendly location. This has been a staple in the Bronx Community for close to 27yrs. I'm proud to call this restaurant home.

Juice Ali

Came to the Cross Bronx Pizza Shop with my Family and ordered 2 Large Pies with Extra Cheese and I have to say the price was good the Extra Toppings was a little bit Overpriced but it was good I’ll come back to but from them again

Broken Penguin Liver

Pizza was absolutely huge and delicious. Compared to 20 Oz soda, it's huge. And only for $4.75 a slice. The small pizzas by barclays center are more expensive than that and they're tiny. Honestly, going there again soon

Manny Badillo

Best Pizza in NY no questions about it. For a classic NY slice you want to come here slices are so delicious and it’s also the biggest slice. If you think I’m lying take a look at my pic

Tim

Great pizza!!!!! Slices so big you could use it as a umbrella. Stop here if your driving threw NYC super easy to get to from I-95. Awesome!!!! slices $4.50. Cash only

Mike C

Big slices, great flavor, not crazy expensive. There's a reason this place has been there for years. One slice is hard to finish by yourself unless you're super hungry. The guys that work there are such nice people, great place to stop in for a slice, just bring your appetite 😁

C.M. Mendez

Everybody needs to try this little hole on the wall. 5.00 dollar slice can be cut in half and the slices will still be bigger than most places. Ohh yeah they are actually really good.

Elvis Costello

The neighborhood is wild around there as there was some due throwing up demonically right outside. The pizza was really good though, I’ll definitely come again. Excellent

Ivy Hernandez

It’s a lot! You are full before finishing your slice. Two people can eat from one slice. Very thick crust, so it’s A LOT of bread! This shop doesn’t take cards or Apple Pay as form of payment. Needs a good cleaning and a refreshing paint job the place looks old and dingy; it’s 2026 give the shop a face lift. Taste was ok but felt I was repeating the sauce and cheese was of cheap quality. Service was friendly and we were served immediately. Over all if you like thick heavy bread pizza you’re in for a treat if not split the slice with a friend or in my case I shared with two that’s how big it was.

Yvonne Leon

No air conditioning. Guy was all over. Pizza ok not something to provide a better score.

Small Stephaa

The key to a pizza is the sauce and cheese right? By the pictures i posted you can tell what kind of pizza it is. All i was eating was cheese and dough and can’t forget the main ingredient GREASE! Pizza size is amazing very big but they need to do better with the sauce !