Pilar Johnson

Received excellent service as we were deciding what to order - the Milanese chicken sandwich was recommend and he was good, I would have liked a bit more sauce but overall we both enjoyed it and it was enough to share for 2 people.

Loren Beckmann

My husband and I had our baby shower here. It was a wonderful experience. The owner was so helpful planning the menu and making sure every guest had more then enough to eat. All of our guest’a special needs were met without issue and everything tasted fresh as if it came straight of Italy. Dessert and coffee rounded out the meal. Overall, it was an amazing day and the staff at Pecoraro Latteria made it all happen. Great food and a beautiful space to celebrate our new baby. Our event was in December of 2024 and our guest continue to compliment us on how wonderful the event space was to this day.

+1

Andrew Suri

Amazing spot for a quick healthy delicious fresh bite! Ingredients were fresh and the menu options were authentic. Ordered the Pollo and loved it, would highly recommend. Portions were also considerably large!

Simon Heather

Great little dinner spot - top notch, home style Italian with a twist for reasonable prices. Just as tasty but better prices than Lilia. Check out the spicy vodka nduja paccheri. Absolutely amazing.

Katie Jay

I had the pleasure of hosting three separate bridal/baby showers at Pecoraro Latteria over the course of the past year. It probably sounds crazy to use the same venue three times, but after hosting the first shower, there was really no sense in going anywhere else. We had approximately 50 people each time and had the entire restaurant to ourselves. The food was the star of the show. This wasn’t a typical shower menu where you get some forgettable, perfunctory meal. The food was more akin to what you’d expect for a special occasion date night. We had passed hors d'oeuvres for the first hour, followed by a three course sit down meal, and then coffee and dessert. I worked with Claudio to come up with the menus, he was wonderful and put great care into every detail. Our guests included older, picky ladies right from Italy, and they unanimously gave the food a five star review, it was well worth the trip to trendy Williamsburg for them. The service and cocktails were excellent as well. Overall Pecoraro Latteria is a terrific place to host an event, a breath of fresh air from the usual catering hall.

Christi Balaki

Wow super unexpectedly good Italian food. Great pizza (4.5/5) that was loaded with cheese, sauce and flavor. Very good and well flavored (4.5/5) bolognese pasta, and a good (4/5) vodka sauce pasta.

+6

Isabella Espinosa

Really cute brunch spot, waiter was super sweet and helpful. We got 3 dishes to share between 3 friends and the portions were perfect. The pesto pasta is one of the best i’ve ever had!! The pancakes were also exquisite. Pizza was good but not nearly as good as the other two. The eggplant was also very yummy. Would go back - really reasonable prices.

Kendall Clas

I’m not one to write reviews very often, but I couldn’t NOT write one for this restaurant. Everything was perfect. The focaccia appetizer was by far the best appetizer I’ve ever had in my life. The pistachio pesto was amazing. The chili vodka sauce was the perfect level of spicy, the pasta tasted fresh, and the house made mozzarella was tasty. The service was great, and the vibe was chill and cozy. Highly recommend the pistachio cannoli for dessert.

CCG G

Delicious food and desserts. Great selection of appetizers and entrees. The ricotta gnocchi was absolutely amazing. The service can be slow (I saw only 2 people working the floor) so just keep that in mind. They also have a little grab and go section.

+2

Arthur T

Stopped by Pecoraro. We were sat immediately for dinner. Three of us ordered: metro pizza $24, toppings fell off, very wet pizza chicory caesar $15 paccheri $26 fettucini bolongese $26 Staff was friendly. Flavors were good for the most part. Wasn't the biggest fan of the pizza. Nice ambiance inside.

+9