Jose Cornejo Colato

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I stopped by Tony’s Tacos today around 3:20, and I just have to mention how kind and professional the worker at the counter was! While I waited for my order, he offered me a drink without me even asking — such a thoughtful gesture that really stood out. I didn’t catch his name, but he had an amazing attitude and great customer service. It’s little moments like that that make a huge difference. Thank you for the great experience and for making my wait so pleasant! 💛🌮✨

Anastasiya Karach

Great Place for Delicious Tacos and Good Vibes 🌮✨ Such a wonderful spot to grab tasty food and enjoy time with friends! Their carne asada tacos are absolutely amazing — full of flavor and perfectly cooked. I also love their non-alcoholic margaritas and the way they serve tacos in neat little paper holders — such a nice touch! The staff is always friendly and super fast. Last time I came with my friend and my dog, and one of the guys at the counter (I wish I remembered his name!) brought a bowl of water and a treat for my dog right to our table. He even helped clean up afterward and kept a big smile the whole time. I truly recommend this place — great food, great people, great atmosphere! 💛

Shop Local Huntington NY

I have been to plenty of places in Huntington and this is truly one of my favorites! The food fresh, tasty, and never disappoints. I have tried a bunch of tacos on the menu but my favorite has to be the scarpetta tacos. The margaritas are incredible and $2 Tuesdays is the best deal you can find. The last time I visited, Grace and Jay both helped me out and were so welcoming. I have told so many of my friends to try out this place and I love everything I have tried!

Sheyla chicoma

Shannyn at Tony Taco in Huntington is absolutely amazing! She’s so friendly, attentive, and makes you feel welcome the moment you walk in. Her service is quick and professional, and she always has a smile that brightens your day. She truly goes above and beyond to make sure everything is perfect. If you go to Tony Taco, ask for Shannyn — she’ll make your visit even better!

Sophia Busa

I don’t usually write reviews, but I had to give a shoutout to Nick at Tony’s Tacos. Every time I come in, he’s one of the friendliest and most genuine people behind the counter. You can tell he actually enjoys what he does, and it really shows in the way he treats customers. It’s rare these days to find someone who gives consistent, top-notch service, but Nick does every single time. He’s one of the reasons I keep coming back. Give that guy a raise (and maybe name a taco after him).

Amy B

Incredible food! So much flavor oh my god! Try all their sauces if you can and go Mon - Fr between 4-7 for happy hour. Double margs for $9!! Also the staff is so kind and considerate! Makes you forget you’re in NY!

Ashley Hill

My boyfriend found this place on instagram and has been wanting to try it so today we went and I am so happy we did. My server Lucy was extremely helpful and knowledgeable of what was on the menu. We will be back there soon!

+2

Paige Williams

the chicken parm taco, was so good! The shrimp taco was also good, but the shrimp could use a little more seasoning. The street corn was also very good! But their churros are to die for!!! And the frozen margaritas the blue razz, so good!! Only issue is there not a lot of seating, at all!

LongIsland Foodtastic

We've eaten here a few times now, and it is delicious! These aren't your average tacos, they are unique in every way! Short rib with mashed potatoes and peter luger sauce?!? Yes, please!!!!My favorite is the Smoked Salmon taco, everything you enjoy about the Brunch dish in a taco! The Street Corn is packed with flavor, and covered with a creamy delicious sauce...already missing it! By the way, I highly recommend trying one of their margaritas (they are not light!) The Churro (filled with Dulce de Leche) is the perfect ending (and it comes with Nutella for dipping). In the winter they had a Spiked hot chocolate that comes with the churro...I hope they bring it back! Don't feel overwhelmed, they have different categories to narrow down what you're craving. For example, I was feeling seafood, so I went to the seafood section (easy enough, lol) It is small inside, so it can get packed easy. They have a long high table against the windows, and 3 tables for two inside. They also have outdoor seating with heat lamps(for winter days).

+1

Deepnain Kaur

Simple, fresh tacos with hearty fillings and good seasoning. The atmosphere is casual and friendly, making it easy to enjoy a quick meal. Nothing overly fancy, but exactly what you want from a taco spot.

Insoo Om

These are the best non-traditional tacos around, blending Italian and American flavors with a Mexican twist. I've been dining here for years and continue to be impressed by the quality and variety, which keeps expanding each time I visit. It’s clear the owners select only the freshest ingredients for their dishes. I wish I could eat here every day. The prices are quite reasonable considering the quality. My favorite is their Surf and Turf, Peter Luger-inspired taco, paired perfectly with a refreshing watermelon drink. I also can't forget their crispy churros to end the meal on a sweet note. They serve delicious margaritas too. Owners Mike and Julia are incredibly friendly, and their dedication has led to the opening of several other locations across Long Island. Writing this review makes me crave more of their tacos!

+2

Ashley Perez

Small space with about 3 tables and 4 bar chairs inside. Outside there's about 4 tables. Hyped up place with overpriced tacos. Costumer service was friendly and helpful. Food was pretty generic and not worth the price. Few interesting taco options but nothing worth the wait or the price. Expect long waits and no where to site due to the over hype. There's better options in town for real tacos.

Robert Muffaletto

I came in excited to try this place, but left feeling let down. The portions were much smaller than expected, especially considering the high price tag. I was hoping for bold, satisfying flavors, but instead, the dishes were surprisingly bland and overly salty in some spots, which didn’t do them any favors. For what I paid, I wanted something special, but the experience just didn’t deliver. Overall, it was more of a miss than a hit—a pricey, underwhelming meal that didn’t live up to the hype.