Menu
Papa John's
PosDo

© 2026 PosDo · v3.0

New Hyde Park

Papa John's

★★★★ 3.5 · 0 reseñas

Papa John's

Pizza · New Hyde Park

3.5 · 243 avis Google
locations.papajohns.com

Ce que disent les clients de Papa John's

Papa John's in New Hyde Park receives mixed reviews. While some customers praise the great experience and fresh ingredients, many report issues with service, undercooked pizza, incorrect orders, and inconsistent quality. Some find it a good value for the price.

Plats populaires

pizza (18) cheese pizza (3) meat pizza bone-in chicken wings garlic knots garlic stuffed cheese pizza

Idéal pour

Sur le pouce Solo Locaux

Tip: Order ahead for pickup, especially if you're on your way home. Be sure to check your order for accuracy before leaving the store.

Services

📶 WiFi 🅿️ Parking 🚗 Delivery Accessible 🍽️ Déjeuner 🌙 Dîner
🎯 Casual

Questions fréquentes sur Papa John's

Papa John's est situé au 909 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, New Hyde Park.
Papa John's propose une cuisine pizza.
Papa John's a des horaires d'ouverture. Consultez son profil pour les horaires à jour.
Papa John's propose les services suivants : à emporter, livraison.
Les plats les plus recommandés chez Papa John's selon les avis clients sont : pizza, cheese pizza, meat pizza, bone-in chicken wings, garlic knots.
Papa John's est idéal pour manger vite, manger seul, les locaux.
Papa John's in New Hyde Park receives mixed reviews. While some customers praise the great experience and fresh ingredients, many report issues with service, undercooked pizza, incorrect orders, and inconsistent quality. Some find it a good value for the price.
Order ahead for pickup, especially if you're on your way home. Be sure to check your order for accuracy before leaving the store.
243
Avis

Avis sur Papa John's New Hyde Park

3.5
243
5★
44%
4★
17%
3★
7%
2★
5%
1★
27%
Avis (21)
neha sharma
neha sharma

Great experience.. best customer service. I ordered non veg pizza by mistake but still they give me a new pizza..

Veni, Vidi, Comedi
Veni, Vidi, Comedi

Solid pizza, but service needs attention The pizza here is consistently great—always hot, flavorful, and satisfying, which keeps me coming back. That said, the service could use some improvement. During a recent visit when I was the only customer in the store, the staff continued focusing on tasks like putting stickers on boxes instead of immediately greeting or taking my order. It felt like the priority wasn't on attending to the customer right away, which made the experience a bit frustrating. I understand staff have multiple responsibilities, but in a quiet moment like that, a quick acknowledgment or prompt service makes a big difference. With the food being reliably good, better front-of-house attention would take this place from solid to excellent. Overall, I'd still recommend it for the pizza, but hope they can polish up the welcome for walk-ins.

San “Paranoid”
San “Paranoid”

Great experience & quick service. Good deals. Will be coming back. Dominis will forever be my first choice tho. Try to catch up Papa Johns.

Even Keel
Even Keel

It depends who is working and if they are really busy, but my visit on 3/13/20 went well. They cooked and put all the toppings I ordered on the right side and spread evenly. Pizza and ingredients tasted fresh. For this price, it can't be beat by the family owned places who charge double the price for the same quality taste or sometimes worse. They are the best place to get pizza in my general area.

Kirankumar Nayak
Kirankumar Nayak

Too hot to sit inside. Food is good and can improve. The price is high compared to other pizza houses .

Jesse Yuan
Jesse Yuan

Gets the job done when you’re hungry. Don’t compare to coal fired or brick oven pizza but what do you expect for $13.99 large pie with 5 toppings. Friendly store with ample parking. I usually order on the app and pick ip on way home.

Meredith Weston
Meredith Weston

Delivery came late, instructions to leave by door & driver ended up calling and having me come to door to pick it up. Not the most horrible thing in the world or if that is standard for Papa John's, but I was in the middle of working and had to drop what I was doing to answer when a simple text or e-mail would have alerted me to it being delivered and at the door.

Eric Go
Eric Go

It’s Papa John’s Pizza, you see the commercials and expect to get something similar to that. This place will make you a subpar pizza and make you wait an exorbitant amount of time for your order because the staff are deliberately estimating incorrectly to make you wait. Order ahead for pick up? Surprise! You arrived in 20min like they told you to and your order hasn’t even been prepared yet. Staff will quote “2 minutes” at the counter even though your pizza isn’t in the oven. Papa John isn’t in the picture anymore but even he would be disappointed in this sad excuse for a pizza franchise. Don’t waste your time, order elsewhere or heck, just eat a frozen pizza from the grocery store.

M
Maya B

I’m really disappointed! I spent almost 50 bucks and accidentally sent my food to my job instead of my home.. because I order a great deal and they couldn’t redirect my food for me. I’m 4 mile from my job in the car it’s 10 minutes away. I walk to work!! I know people don’t make mistakes like this all the time. I was willing to tip him for the time.. very disappointed in the service

Amrit Pal Singh
Amrit Pal Singh

What a waste of money? A new guy working by himself on the store and doesn’t even know how to slice the pizza, let alone cooking it. Raw dough and toppings buried under a thick layer of cheese.

NA
NA

The customer service is horrible. When you are picking up your order, you ask to give ur order, but they just look at you and don’t answer. Extremely DISRESPECTFUL. Took half of my time. Horrible service.

Marie Dominique Michel
Marie Dominique Michel

It is sad because I used to love papa johns. Now Pizza is barely cooked , the crust is like soft dough, spicy garlic sauce was missing ultimately.

Love my Food
Love my Food

We gave this store multiple opportunities before we gave a bad review. Today has been the worst service. Ordered 2 pies, bone-in chicken wings and garlic knots. The toppings look like it was thrown into the air and had it land on the pizza. It was cooked so fast the bottom was burnt and the toppings were raw. When I told them I ordered the wings they said they don't have. The wings were replaced without my knowledge into boneless wings that were so dry. I'm sick of the service they provide and how they treat people. My last and final time eating here. I would highly discourage anyone to ever order from here.

Abey k
Abey k

I got 2 large pizzas cheese pizza was ok meat pizza very less meat. Asked the guy at counter for some chili flakes he gave me 1 pkt I said 2 pizza and 1 pkt he said it cost us money. His attitude was like you are getting pizza for free from here. Papa John's corporate office don't care about customer reviews or concerns. The attitude is like If you want you buy or else go somewhere else. It's a shame big company papajohns is ignoring customers.

PRIYA PRIYA
PRIYA PRIYA

I ordered small cheese pizza there. When I go there to pickup my order. I asked for chilli flakes packets. One of the man at the counter give me one packet. Then I asked for another packet and he said one packet for 0.45 cents and he was not looking happy when he gave me another packets. It’s a very bad experience there. Not suggested to go there.

Jerry Poole
Jerry Poole

This place was horrible. The lady at the register did not speak English. Clearly I wanted to shack Ronnie , which only comes in one size. I ordered a small pie with pepperoni and all she did was kept saying macaroni.

Abdul Qadir
Abdul Qadir

Pizza was not cooked and the guys are super rude. Even they gave me open box of pizza and asked me to close by myself. Be careful guys they are not clean worst branch.

Ciara M
Ciara M

My go-to location nearby for quick eats. Unfortunately several long strand of hair were baked into the cheese of a pizza pie. Employees with long hair should cover their hair or at the very least tie it back. Disgusting ...🤮

Shilpa Kaur
Shilpa Kaur

Very subpar undercooked food. We got the garlic stuffed cheese pizza with spicy sausage and pepperoni. Wasted some 31$ for the undercooked pizza. There was hardly any cheese in the stuffed crust. It had raw dough at places and some parts were burnt. We also got the chicken wings which tasted better but were so tiny in size that it was not worth the money.

Faisal Rana
Faisal Rana

Every time comes overhere they make me disappointed so much. Right now I'm so mad. They made my pizza 2nd time and they made it wrong again. 2nd time they didn't add mushrooms. Very bad service people works here bearly speaks English.

Mr. K
Mr. K

This pizza was supposed to be a whole Black olives, green peppers, onions, Jalapeño peppers and pineapple. All you see here is pineapple and jalapeño. This time it was a lady making the pizza. The crust side is such a waste. They did not cover the whole dough with toppings and cheese.

Connectez-vous pour laisser un avis

Se connecter
👑 C'est le vôtre ? Réclamez-le GRATUITEMENT !

Supprimez les pubs et gérez votre menu

Explorez votre quartier

Plus de restaurants à New Hyde Park →
📸

20 Photos

Explorez les photos de Papa John's

Papa John's
Papa John's
Papa John's
Papa John's
Papa John's
+15 Plus
📍

Informations sur Papa John's

Comment s'y rendre

909 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040

Chargement de la carte...
Papa John's
Appuyez pour l'itinéraire

Points forts

💬
Nombreux avis
243 avis
💰
Économique
Niveau de prix
👨‍🍳
pizza
Type de cuisine

Services

🍽️ Déjeuner
🍾 Dîner
🍰 Desserts
🥡 À Emporter
🚚 Livraison

Options de restauration

🥡 À Emporter
🚚 Livraison

Infos Restaurant

Statut
Vérifié par le propriétaire
🕐 Horario Hoy
11AM-1AM
Note
3.5/5
💬 Avis
243
💰 Niveau de prix
$
⏱️ Visite typique
People typically spend 15 min here
📞 Téléphone
+1 516-437-8000
🌐 Site web
locations.papajohns.com
📋 Menu
Voir le Menu

Équipements

📶 WiFi gratuit
🅿️ Parking
Accessible en fauteuil roulant
💳 Cartes de crédit
📱 Paiements mobiles
🏘️

Le Quartier

Emplacement

909 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040

📍 Explorer le Quartier

Weather
25°
Météo mise à jour toutes les heures · Emplois et événements actualisés quotidiennement
🎮

Jeux

🎮 Gagnez des Points en Explorant !

Jouez à Find Me et échangez des points contre des réductions chez Papa John's et d'autres restaurants

🎮

Gagnez des Points chez Papa John's !

Jouez à Find Me et échangez des récompenses ici

Gagnez des points supplémentaires et échangez-les contre des récompenses de Papa John's

🏆 Récompenses de Papa John's

💰

Réduction 10%

Chez Papa John's

1000 pts
Disponible
🍽️

Apéritif Gratuit

Lors de votre prochaine visite

2500 pts
Limité
👑

Table VIP

Expérience premium

5000 pts
Exclusif

pour échanger des récompenses et gagner des points

📋 Comment fonctionnent les récompenses ?

1

Jouez à Find Me

Chaque 100 points de score = 1 point de récompense

2

Accumulez des Points

Les workers gagnent 2x points par partie

3

Échangez des Récompenses

Réductions, nourriture gratuite et expériences VIP

Appeler
Laisser un avis sur Google
👑

C'est le vôtre ? Réclamez-le GRATUITEMENT !

Supprimez les pubs et gérez votre menu

Connectez-vous et jouez

Vérifiez votre email !

Pas de mot de passe — nous vous envoyons un lien par email

Nous vous avons envoyé un lien d'accès

Vérifiez votre dossier spam si vous ne le voyez pas