Mark Nash

The moment you walk into Il Posto, the atmosphere is warm and inviting. The service is always spot on from the wait staff to the busboys. All very attentive. Many selections...and the food is simply delicious. The music on the weekends, make a dining experience feel like you're at dinner/theatre. All rounded off with delicious desserts...all make for a fine dining experience. When in the dining room, there are so many regular patrons...there is a reason they're always there! Myself included.

Anna Coletti

This past weekend, we celebrated our baby girl's christening at IL Posto in Bergen Beach. It was absolutely perfect. The owner and staff went above and beyond to accommodate us and our guests. They were so attentive. Our guest wanted for nothing. On top of having great service, the food was outrageous. All my friends and family were raving to me the next day about how good the food was. I could not be happier with how everything went. They made us feel at home and to me that was the best part. I highly recommend having your next event there. Thank you Jeff and the IL Posto staff. I can't wait to have my next party there!!!

Julie Amelkin

Nice, authentic Italian food. Attentive and friendly staff.

Lexxie Arroyo

Service, atmosphere, and food!" Fantastic" is an understatement! I was on a trip returning home to Brooklyn visiting my mother. Authentic Italian cuisine, and seafood. Strongly suggest. In my opinion, they're hard competition. I have eaten at the finest. Locally & Internationally. I have to give a well deserved 5 stars across the board🌟

Misty Lake

Now it's a very nice place to come to. Recently purchased by the owner of Maria's Ristorante Italiano. Jeff is the best and the food is always delicious.

+5

James Caragiulo

The food, service and atmosphere were all top notch! It's a hidden gem in a beautiful and quiet residential neighborhood.

James Q (Calais79)

My family and I go here whenever we want a fancier meal without strict dress code or difficult to get reservations. I highly recommend the lamb chops, I order them every single time. I've literally never had lamb chops as good as they are here, even when I prepare them myself. My wife nearly always gets the T-bone steak and it is a fantastic, massive piece of steak. The veal is also extremely good. For dessert I recommend the tartufo, it's excellent and just the right amount of you want a large dessert and perfect to share on a date for a smaller portion. My only real critique is that the music can be a bit too loud on some nights, sometimes a live singer and sometimes a DJ. I find it a bit difficult to hear one another speak at the table sometimes; however, if you plan to have a few drinks and dance to some disco era music maybe it will be a plus for you. They have a full bar as well. There is usually street parking nearby, it's a mostly residential area in a pretty low-crime neighborhood.

We came here for a Date Night dinner and some entertainment ,which was cute There is a hidden service fee of 10.00 that was placed on our bill ... sneaky AF Menu is not accurate on the II Posto website ....prices are way higher Older decor and not to discriminate but older clientele One table had to beg for it to be cooler which was finally done Another women wore her coat on her head all night like a ghost ( pic below ) Waiter was nice as we had 2 .One did not speak English ( the dessert and coffee guy) The food was just as bad We started with drinks 17.00 ea for a martini and a Jack on the rocks !!!! The artichokes were not it fresh Jarred marinated with some hot breadcrumbs on top The fried calamari was a tad chewy and the marinara sauce tasted like a tin can The seafood salad was calamari rings 3 med shrimp sliced in half and a bit of a scallop. The ceaser salad was cafeteria style , dressing, and small bagged stale croutons We had shrimp parm it was ok and Ninos special 46.00 , do not bother 3 pieces meat chicken and Veal. 2 bites each If ypu want a side of pasta instead to veggies and mashed potatoes its 7.00 ( very small 4 bites ) we did nit order but looked at other tables Dessert has no price listed but was good as well as the coffee Prices are way too high for this food . Pizza joints have better I was so disappointed as I wanted to like this place We spent a lot of money for just OK food . I feel as if we were taken advantage of in some way . What a waste of money. I do not expect anything to come of this . Please look at my other reviews as I am truthful and know my food ! This was not geared to people who know , this I can tell you I hope this helps some people

Tony DiFerdinando

I was looking for a restaurant to celebrate a family event and the choices are limited on Monday night. A neighbor told me about Il Posto and raved about your food. I came in and there was only one other table taken. We were seated and for a party of 6 got 5 slices of bread. After ordering appetizers and our meal asked for more. Were told it was coming. Some appetizers had sauces- asked for more bread for dunking- got 5 pieces of rock hard bread. The main courses were delicious except for a filet mignon that was purple inside despite asking for medium rare. My grandson couldn’t eat it and the server waved back when called but only came after everyone else finished their meals. The game on his cellphone must have been more important. I don’t mind paying for something I receive. The bill came and the’ service charge ‘ / gratuity was 15% . Now a gratuity is a thank you for services rendered- Got the minimum service which didn’t deserve a thank you. If your restaurant isn’t packed , which had 4 tables at the most, the servers should be more attentive.

Irwin Nayman

I placed an order with Il Posti through a delivery app. When the food arrived as a jelled mess in its container, I contacted the restaurant. We concluded that the delivery driver was probably responsible for the appearance of the food, so I didn't request a refund or credit from the restaurant. I ordered from Il Postio through a delivery app again, but the restaurant cancelled the order. When I questioned their reason for doing so, il Posto did not respond. Apparently, the restaurant doesn't care about customer service.

Samantha Lawrence

Food was tasty but I found a huge piece of plastic in my food. I already started chewing it, spit it out to realize it was plastic. So disappointed.