Kristen D

Delicious quick slice! The Neapolitan and the grandma slice were both delicious and the cheese calzone was packed with delicious and fluffy cheese!

Peyton Marshak

I had a hankering for pizza one evening in Bushwick and this place popped up, and let me tell you this place does pizza right, large slices, great crust, amazing toppings. No frill or fancy slices like you see all over social media nowadays, just simple good pizza. Great neighborhood joint that I will be returning to at some point.

Kristian Johnson (Kris)

This place is amazing and truly a slice of Sicily right here in Brooklyn. Everything here is reasonably priced and tastes amazing. Be sure to try their cannoli’s and pizza. It’s traditional to have a glass of wine with your meal and they have good house wine options for a reasonable price.

Tiara

One of the best pizzas I’ve tried!!! I was their first customer of the day and everything was so fresh and warm, which to me is the key for a great pizza

BoldfaceX

This place is a real gem encrusted in my old stomping ground where good food was hard to find in the 80s. In my opinion, "The best pizza in Brooklyn". Do not order through Grubhub, or you will regret it. I made that mistake. The delivery person had the box in a backpack, vertically, yes, and here is an image to prove it. I was angry with Fazios for not making an effort, but they are not the ones to blame. Sorry for hanging up on you. ❤️... They have their own driver.. I messed up on this one. Love you FAZIO'S!!

J. B. (Joa_NYC)

I'm in love with the Neapolitan slices, the tomato sauce is soo sweet and rich in flavor that blow my mind. The crust is so crispy and good is a must go place. I have lived 15+ years in the neighborhood and lets be honest you do get good pizza here and there but this level of quality, price and deliciousness is above everywhere else. I eat here every week and some times 2 times per week.

+1

Jason Priest

I popped in here while visiting a friend in the neighborhood. The pepperoni Grandma slice was really delicious! It was served super hot... had to let it cool off just a bit before eating. I'd definitely stop back again!

Justine Yeo Bircher

Got a slice of Neapolitan pizza and a slice of Sicilian pizza, a small drink, and paid about $11. Pizza tasted incredible, and two slices was almost too much. My favorite of the two was the Sicilian one. The focaccia bread was simply scrumptious. 🍞

julia safrin

Got a $4 slice of cheese pizza here to go. Pretty delicious. Plenty of seating if you want to dine in too.

Jess

This is one of my favorite pizza spots and I’ve been ordering regularly for years. I don’t know who was cookin’ pies tonight but the quality was not consistent with the Fazio’s I’ve come to know and love. The crust was like a cracker instead of the sophisticated crusty bread it typically is and the pie both looked and tasted like someone knocked over a bunch of cheap dry herbs into the sauce – the McCormick explosion was the first thing I noticed when I opened the box. Whatever new direction is happening in the kitchen, I sincerely hope Fazio’s can course correct and return to the caliber that built its customer base. Allow me to put it this way: I love putting people onto this place, locals and out of towners a like. If I had a guest from out of town (read: a place with an inferior standard of pizza) over tonight after talking up how this is a top New York slice and this is the pie I had to offer them, I’d be deeply ashamed as a New Yorker.

Daniel Pino

Layout/atmosphere *Old fashioned menu signage; four tables; TV; one counter with stools by oven, the other by front window; tables on sidewalk under the awning Food/drink *Pepperoni Sicilian slice - OK; pepperoni cups; liked the outer crust but the sauce & the saltiness or spice of pepperoni didn’t mix well *Tomato, Ricotta & Basil Sicilian slice - OK

Eric Rivera

Customer Service-Great Price-$$ Pizza- It looks better than it taste. The Sicilian was ok. Dough was stale and over cooked. The pepperoni was great though. Sauce was underpowered. Cheese was fine. The regular slice was definitely better than the Sicilian. Although the dough was stale as well. For a neighborhood joint, this pizza is great. Should you drive to this place. Simply, NO.

+5

dumb head

Really wanted to like this place. “B” health code. Very hard, always burnt crust. Margarita sauce is forgettable. Garlic bread uses garlic from a jar. Lentil soup is so profoundly watery. Before you think I am critical, try these things for yourself. I was shocked at the terrible quality. As for service, the workers are just so unfriendly. I understand customer service is no small feat, but these workers are not neutral, they just hate you. I have decided to never again return.

A W

This rating is for their delivery and it’s a terrible experience. I just ordered a cheese pizza with some added sausage, onions and mushroom. Upon delivery their delivery man wouldn’t ring the doorbell even when I asked and he said he didn’t understand English so wouldn’t even try so I went downstairs to get it which is not the worst. The worst part is when I open the box all the cheese and toppings already completely slid onto one side of the box and the whole bottom of the pizza is completely soggy from the cheese water, and also couldn’t really taste any flavor from the tomato sauce since it is also diluted by the melted cheese water. You can see in the close up picture the cheese water + tomato sauce made pools of liquid on top of the pizza which half slid onto the bottom making the pizza wet. Overall just felt like eating soggy bread and cheese with some wet toppings. Maybe it’s better to get it directly in store but I don’t recommend their pizza for delivery.