Tim Corbett

Our first time here, and a wonderful experience. The hostess went out of her way to seat us outside where we wanted to be. The server Joey was friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. The food was tremendous, especially my wife's pork chop. It was nearly 3" thick, cooked perfectly with a pineapple glaze. She said at first that she would never finish it, but loved it so much that she ate it all. Very nice atmosphere inside and out. We will definitely be back. Awesome dinner

Patricia

My son and I stopped here for lunch while in Webster. What a nice place! I had a burger and he had a chicken sandwich. Both delicious and well presented. The place was as clean as a whistle and our server Jayden, was very friendly and competent. A great experience!

+2

Chris Konya

After an awful reservation mishap from another restaurant in the area, I called Cobblestone on Main in hopes they could accommodate my party of 12 last minute. They were able to make some arrangements and were confident enough in their staff to make it happen on a busy Saturday night. The fairly priced drinks were delicious and the food was exceptional. The service was outstanding and made us feel like we were the only people in the restaurant when that was far from the case. Anytime I’m in Webster this will my first choice and should be yours, too. Pictured: French Onion Soup and Chicken Parm

Melissa Stio

I loved this place! Went here on a whim around 6:45 on a Friday night and we were seated immediately. Service was quick and efficient! My "I Deserve a Drink" and crispy chicken sandwich were delicious and my boyfriend loved his pasta dish and generous pour of the Pinot Noir. I also loved the cozy golf vibes of our dining room! Very clean and welcoming. Would definitely recommend!

Elisabeth Gross

Went for dinner and drinks here, everything was absolutely amazing. I got the bone-in chicken with Brussel sprouts and potatoes and it was so delicious! We also got the pork belly tacos for an app, and those were so good!! The bathroom was also super clean and cute! Everyone loved everything they ordered. Our waitress was Haley and she was great!

+3

Lisa Powers

This was our first date night out in a while and this place was the most perfect place for a night out! First, it’s beautiful! They renovated this place and it’s so nice! Very spacious and tastefully decorated. There was a small wait (20 mins) for a table for two. Our server was very nice. The food was amazing! We had a wonderful time and plan to come back. It is on the pricier side but nothing too crazy for a night out. We had an appetizer and we both had a seafood option for dinner and I had a cocktail and we spent $100. It was really good quality for the price. We will be back.

+2

Webster, NY

6/5/21: I visited Webster with my friends. We thoroughly enjoyed our time. The staff were very nice & professional. The food was very 😋 tasty! Huge portions meant only finishing half & taking half home. That means some of the main dishes are half price if you get two meals from 1 main dish, such as the succulent steak 🥩 main dish, which was delicious. & Accompanying asparagus was crunchy & also easy to chew. I liked the 🥔 soup & the 🥗 too. The atmosphere & actual building from the mid 1800s were a delight. The customers all seemed to be happy & enjoying themselves like we did.

+11

David Dais

Went here for dinner this past Saturday with my wife. The food was okay but the service was ls awesome. I ordered a cheeseburger and it was good, but the bacon was so squiggly and probably cooked for like 5 seconds. Had to remove it from the burger and took off most of the cheese as well, so it was really a hamburger. My wife ordered a chicken sandwich and it was ultra garlicky and she could not finish it. The server though was right on point and I wish I got his name. Overall 3 stars for the food but 5 stars for the service. I would maybe go back again since it could have been an off night for the cook.

+1

Miss Alisha

Came in for a dinner on a Friday, we were seated quickly which we were thankful for. We waited a while for our server to approach us but upon first sitting we just thought they were busy. After ordering drinks another table with a different server was sat behind us and was tended to immediately, no biggie our server returned with our drinks and we ordered. The server for the table behind us came to grab their order and was introduced with specials which my husband immediately spoke up and said he wish he knew they had a pork chop special as he would have ordered that instead. Our food came which was amazing everything was cooked perfect and we had no complaints. After eating we were never offered refills on our drinks which we just opted for the check instead of having a few more cocktails and enjoying the atmosphere, we waited for a long time for the check to where the table behind us that sat after us paid and left before we received the check. We left satisfied with the food but less with the service.

Tanya Schaeffer

Live and learn, the food was way more expensive than it's worth. This place is for the snooty patooty that wants to feel impressed they can eat there. I couldn't pre-order dinner until 4:00 and I was going on vacation and only wanted to leave my order so I could pick it up on my way out. I ordered scallops, it showed six and I got five. Do they not know how to count or did someone help themselves? Meals2Go would have been a better choice.

Michael Leusch

Restaurant was almost empty, took over an hour to get our food for a table of four. The two chicken parm dinners were cold, like they had been sitting a half hour before they were brought to our table. Waiter didn’t seem to care one bit. We’ve eaten here many times in the past and had a great experience, won’t be coming back after tonight.

Kay Marie

In town, wanted a new place to eat and decided on The Cobblestone for some take out and a relaxing night. However, I did not think my night would turn out with my vehicle, clothes and floor of the lobby soaked in soup because the bags weren’t properly packed and the soups were literally just strewn about every which way. Everything is covered… the bag completely fell apart as I was walking in the the hotel I am staying at. My fingers are sticky as I write this! Absolutely absurd and a waste of money. I don’t even care to eat because I’m so livid.

+9