Michael Lehrman

I am mostly giving this trendy spot in soho five stars because it has what is now my favorite Martini in nyc. The umami Martini has replaced the Corner Store sour cream and onion Martini as the most interesting in New York. It comes with a spoon of caviar and kalamata olives and is divine. The ceasar salad and meatballs here are top notch. Delicious spaghetti pomodoro. Cacio and pepe was good but not Via Carota level. The bar downstairs is a fabulous place to enjoy the Martini. The outdoor sidewalk seating is ideal for a late lunch on a sunny day.

+4

Annadean Findlay

Sartiano’s has become a tradition for me and my girls - we try to come at least every three months (sometimes more!) and it never disappoints. The Dirty Umami Martini is hands down the best martini we’ve ever had in our lives. I even celebrated my birthday here, and it was perfect! :D We always bring friends visiting New York too! Charlotte is an incredible server - so friendly, welcoming, and she even remembered us, which means a lot in a city like New York with so many faces to keep track of. That personal touch makes every visit feel special. Every dish is consistently amazing, but the House-Made Focaccia is a must-try (you’ll honestly die, it’s that good). Their gluten-free options are also excellent - thoughtful and delicious. Sartiano’s is one of those rare spots that feels both special and reliable. Every visit is memorable. Highly recommend!

+1

Salvador Osorio

Stopped by for a quick lunch and we loved it! The spaghetti sauce is to die for. Service was quick and friendly. Sat right outside and enjoyed the hustle and bustle while we took a moment to settle down and recharge. Would definitely come back. Dinner looks like it would be phenomenal.

Natalee Stacey

Wow. Amazing delicious food. This place is beautiful and has amazing food. We ordered the beef tartare which was amazing for an app, and the octopus. For the dinner we got the Lumache and the pork chop and oh my god the flavors were phenomenal. I kept eating and eating until it was done even though I got full after a while. Truly an amazing restaurant and I would highly recommend it to everyone. I want to try all their dishes. You have to go here. WOW!

Mads M

Amazing food, service and ambiance. Cute spot for date night or with a small group. Highly recommend the focaccia, meatballs and crab pasta. The picante martini was the best I’ve ever had!

Jordana Ponticelli

I went here with my family for the first time, and overall we had a great experience. We started by sharing a salad, and even though I am not a big fan of salads, I ended up loving it because everything tasted very fresh and flavorful. I then ordered the gnocchi, which was very filling but tasty. My brother and dad shared a veal parm that was definitely more than enough for two people! I tried some and thought it was the best veal parm I’ve ever had. For dessert, we split the tiramisu, which was presented beautifully, with an elegant look on the plate. It tasted very different from the ones I had in Italy and was just okay, definitely not the best I’ve had. The service was decent, our waitress was really nice throughout most of the dinner. However, toward the end, she disappeared for a little while. The atmosphere was upbeat and lively, with festive holiday decorations and a bustling bar scene that made it a fun place for a family dinner.

+4

Georgia Panagiotakos

I only had coffee at Sartianos, and it was excellent—rich and well-balanced. Staff was great. While I was there, I took a peek at the downstairs space for dinner, and it’s absolutely beautiful. The ambiance looks inviting and elegant, and I would definitely love to come back for dinner. A great spot to enjoy both a quality coffee and a future meal!

+7

Anika Naneyshvili

We just randomly walked into Sartiano's for a quick lunch. The place itself is pretty nice and spacious. Service was good, and the coffee was great ! I got a latte with oat milk, and that was pretty amazing. But on the food side, it was just okay. My husband got some kind of "breakfast burger" and he wasn't really impressed, and my daughter's cacio e pepe pasta wasn't so great either. During the day, it seems like a nice spot to just grab a cup of coffee with a friend, but honestly, it probably gets better during dinner hours.

+4

Michael Straky

- Service was great. Our server had a lovely personality and was knowledgeable about the menu. Support staff was also very efficient. - Food was average and nothing special, especially considering the prices they are charging. - We were given the worst table in the house, directly next to the host stand and stairs, despite us celebrating a birthday. - We were told our table wasn’t ready when we checked in, only to be sat at the table directly next to the host stand that was empty fifteen minutes ago when we had walked in (so it was ready). - Apple crostata dessert was embarrassingly small.

Fernanda Bressan

Nice vibe, good food and flavors. Mediocre service. Waited for server to re-appear to order wine as food got cold. For the price, would expect more attention to details.