Belinda Cermola

We’ve been here several times and it was just amazing every single time. Food is delicious and fresh. Not only can get grinders or sandwiches. You can get all sorts of pasta deliciousness. They have olives. They have so many meats that you can buy also. Make sure that you stop at this place. It’s not posh but it is New York and wonderful.

+6

Robert Birmele

The heart of Arthur Avenue Must stop and enjoy the food and atmosphere. David's eggplant parm is the best, period. Nothing has changed. We shared a Mike's hero, it was great Also have a glass of the homemade red wine 🍷

+1

Tara Ryan

We stopped in for dinner and were able to get a table. The eggplant parm is super delicious. I tried the carbonara and it wasn’t personally to my taste. The service was friendly and swift.

Taste Bud

What a great place this is. This is the true "little Italy" in the 5 boroughs. Authur ave in the bronx still has some real gems with great Italian food. Mike's is one of them. Located in the back of the aurhur ave market, you can get everything from great Italian heroes to antipasto. We had their regular antipasto and their seafood antipasto. Both really good. I wish the seafood antipasto had a little more seafood, but it was still good. Shout out to the service, great job!

Rosa O

The sandwiches are okay. Italian combo had two peppers for an entire sandwich...really? Flavor was mediocre at best. Which is disappointing for the price and legacy this place has. Meat platter had two smallest pieces of fresh mozzarella. The rest were refrigerator dried meats and cheeses. Not very appetizing for $14. They have good cheese but I can go to Casa Della Mozzarella where they sell better sandwiches and don’t try to cheat you from mozzarella and good meats. Honesty and treatment of customer is more important.

Lenny B

It has a beautiful Mercado feeling with tons of Italian food, old-fashioned meat market, and deli, but it's very touristy with lots of tourists instead of native New Yorkers, so want to avoid all the tourist attraction, people arrive early, food is great.

Beverley Simon

While the atmosphere is good and the service is great, nothing compensates for rats in their 8/27/25 health inspection and the high prices. There are a few other close places with rats in inspections. Find another area of the city to dine. I may be back after a couple clean inspections

mc cassa

My negative review is to share the high prices of the same product, compared to : De Cicco, Local Deli, and Balducci’s, and how a product is treated. I purchased a provolone because it is not made there but imported. I was charged 21.36 for provolone auricchio where the same , exact product, same size is 13.00 at all the places I mentioned. Thinking that by driving to Arthur Avenue would save money? It’s not the case. One more upsetting thing , more than the price, a while ago, I saw a worker, by the back door, using gas in a metal barrel to ‘ affumicare the provole, when I showed my disbelief he said ‘ that is how I am told to do it’. The team is friendly, very friendly and nice. Some clients may not care about prices or eating mozzarella fumed over gasoline, but for those who care, there are choices!

Alex W.

The Spanish male employee here has a very bad attitude towards customers. I tried a sample of cheese there, and he asked me why I was eating it without asking.l gave him $1 for rude service.The service is absolutely terrible. This place is not worth spending money on. There are much better Italian markets around with better service. (The person with the blue hat in the picture) STAY AWAY FROM THEM!

Anissa Osorio

I was so excited to order a sandwich from here the other day. I’ve been coming since I was little and always loved it. Unfortunately, the chicken in my order was old, discolored, and smelled rotten. It was really disappointing and honestly concerning someone could get seriously sick from that. I’ll definitely think twice before ordering again. Honestly, just look at the photos again disgusts me.