Best jerk chicken ever and it's not even close. Tender and spicy. Been trying everywhere else but keep coming back for more than a decade.

Awesome pizza anytime of the day. Great prices too. Nice decor and easy to takeout, very glad this place is around.

I just ate there and it was so good the pizza was good I recommend you to go there and they also have free delivery.

How is it you guys don't deliver if I call your store I don't want yo pay with a credit card Iwant to pay cash i have 2 babies its inconvenient for me to have to go to the location every time good food though.

Great pizza. Awesome jerk chicken! Decades old neighborhood business owner.

Great pizza, friendly staff, and the freshly baked cookies are awesome too!

Great food, best jerk chicken fast service. I recommend everything

Great choice for pizza and wings. There chicken wings and pizza comes in plethora of flavors.

Best pizza place in the city. I've been to over 20 pizza places in NYC, this place is still at the top. Thank you, Tony!

What an outstanding place. As tourists the workers were helpful and extremely generous allowing us to try the local chicken. Gave advice on the local area as well. Old fashioned customer service at its finest.

This little place serves delicious foods you have to wait for. This is not McD, with prepared meals. Yes it says pizza on the sign, but oh so much more. Into big burgers that for some could take two days to eat with steak fries? Jerk chicken? Awesome. No, I'm not going on, you go order and have a seat, then enjoy! Oh yes, one of the best pizzas on this side of Eastern Parkway too.

My new favorite neighborhood spot for slices and whole pies, great prices and flavor is on point. Sauce, cheese, and most importantly the crust is superb. This place deserves a 5.0!

Tony's pizza is amazing. They have a variety of pizza to choose from. They also sell food like jerk chicken, garlic bread etc. You are allowed to call in and make an order and the people that work there a very friendly. Your order does not take long to get. They are very fast paced.

The place is clean and quiet. The pizza is delicious the staff is great and respectful. I love to buy pizza over there. Thank you for taking care of us may God blessed you and your family. I hope you open soon.

Love the personal cheese pie so perfect and it’s good for 2 or to eat by yourself❤️❤️

Tony's is great!! I mostly go for the Jerk chicken. Yes, that's right JERK CHICKEN. Their jerk chicken is awesome and a lot better than some of other restaurants that I've been to. I also love their red velvet cookies!! If you are looking for quality jerk chicken and pizza this is ur spot.

Tony, thanks for your continuous service by bringing good pizza to the neighborhood. Also, my son is loving the pie you hooked up for him to bring to FL!

I was visiting friends who had a few pizzas from Tony's. The bacon cheeseburger pizza was the most delicious pizza I have EVER had!!! (I am a BIG girl who has eaten her share of pizza!) I live in Manhattan, and I plan on taking a trip to get this pizza!

The pizzas are always hot out of the oven. Great crunch on the crust. The taste is amazing. Love the customer service from the staff. The jerk chicken is a must. 🔥 🔥 🔥

Since moving out of Brooklyn I miss this place more than ever! Best pizza in Crown Heights. Tony is a good man and really cares about the community.

Favorite pizza spot in Crown Heights. Not only is the pizza good, but their pasta options (especially their baked zitis) are phenomenal. Friendly staff behind the counter, too.

Grilled chicken Caesar salad is a must have. Oh man, I've eaten it for a full week straight. Amazing. Good pizza also.

The pizza is always AMAZING, no matter what kind I get or what time I show up. Their service is quick and efficient -- service with a smile, most times. It's always amazingly busy in here and totally worth the wait.

Good food Good service been a costumer for long can't complain at all

What a great place. I have known the owner for many, many years. A really nice kind person. The pizza is delicious as well as the food. The service is great.

The pizza is delicious! They also make pasta dishes as well as jerk chicken. Great variety of foods! The service is already great and friendly!

The food is excellent delicious.

10/10, I randomly stumbled upon this place while visiting New York and I think I might be in love with it. I got the jerk chicken plate with Mac and cheese with a side of greens…everything was absolutely delicious! Safe to say that this place is not shy with portions, I had enough left over to bring back to Texas with me. If you’re in the area, please take my word for it and try it out. You will not be disappointed!

Tony's been in the community for as long as I can remember. There pizza has that classic old world taste if anyone can remember what real pizza taste like. They also make Panamanian Style Jerk Chicken. Yes you read what I said. It's delicious!

The manager took my order even though some of the toppings weren't on the menu, and the pizza was delicious ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Is it weird to say they have the best Mac n' Cheese?! It's stringy and creamy and just really good. I usually get just that or maybe add a slice of the vodka sauce pizza. Also they have a bunch of sauces including jerk and hot sauce you can add for extra flavor.

I order from here all the time and love their menu, so much different choices to choose from. I recommend the American cheese burger with the fries is so good. Oh and don't forget about their famous Jerk Chicken. :) I only order mostly online since they delivery to my location.

Violet Heart

Staff is always super friendly... the pizza is pretty good as well

jean joachim

🤩

+2

Robert Soderstrom

We’re new to the neighborhood and decided to try Tony’s pizza. Ordered a special made pizza and it was great. Quick service, too. We’ll try it again for sure!

Dominik Rutherford

Went for a regular cheese pizza pie and buffalo chicken pie. Had to wait 15 minutes, no problem. Very fun atmosphere while waiting. Got the pizza after the 15 mins. Both pies were delicious. Price is cheaper than when ordering over uber eats.

Tyler Garrison

I've been ordering from Tony's for awhile and every time I receive the exact same quality and consistency that I've come to love. Penne Alla Vodka with Chicken is my go-to however I've also had the chance to try the cheese pizza and garlic bread. Chicken in the Penne Alla Vodka does not come breaded but they have honored my request for breaded the one time I requested it. Pizza is good, although I've only had it once so I don't feel qualified to say much more on that front. Their garlic bread is not what I normally expect. They go very heavy on the garlic and what I assume is paprika so it's definitely a unique experience as far as garlic bread goes. Truly up to the person eating it if it's for them or not. OVERALL: A great, consistent, wallet-friendly option especially when ordering in for the night. Thanks for the great food!

Jefriman Johari

The best pizza place in Brooklyn. Authentic taste and best of service always. I would go for their 🍕. And trust me, the Jerk Chicken is out of this world! I also had the Mac and cheese and great chunky fries.

Amanda Bernardine

I order from Tony's personally and for my job...his jersey chicken is amazing as well as his pies. His shop is a Brooklyn staple the feeds the community to care.

Sasha Abramson

One thing I will not stand for is tonys hate. This place is my favorite pizza and pasta in nyc. There I said it. They haven't even raised their prices.

Yani

I ordered 6 Parmesan wings, Mac & Cheese and broccoli. The wings were rocking! There was a semi thick sauce on the wings which was amazing. The wings were decently sized and packed with flavor. NOW, little did I know that this Mac & Cheese was going to feel like an explosion of perfect creaminess in my mouth! The first bite was almost immediately followed by the thought of 'there's just no way this take out M&C is this good.' LOL! The entire meal was great. Oh the broccoli was slammin' with the wing sauce too. --TWO ETERNAL DAYS LATER ::Sponge Bob reference:: I ordered Chicken Parmesan & Ziti and my roommate ordered a full side of the Mac & Cheese....wait for it... YES, the M&C was just as amazing as the first time! What a satisfying surprise. The Chicken Parm was ridiculous, I mean just finger licking good. This has to be one of the best take out orders I've had in a while. I would for sure recommend this place and hope that each time you order it taste just like the first.

Decent food. Staff attentive. Owner a bit surly on occasion.

Pizza is great wait time was not bad. My go to for delicious authentic pizza

The price of the pizza varies based on who "rings up" the order... however, the delicious tastes of this pizza does NOT disappoint

Good pizza for the area . Nice variety jerk chicken is not bad either.

Good pizza in the neighborhood! Priced accordingly. But the atmosphere isn't that great for eat in.

Pizza is very good and they serve a lot of other foods, Caribbean cuisine too.

The Pizza is delicious, even when it's cold. And the Jerk chicken was surprisingly amazing.

Really good pizza. I had a Sicilian slice this time and it is worth the money.

This Place has come a long way. It used to take forever to get food and sometimes the orders were wrong. I don't know what happened but it's great now. Prompt service and the food is better. Best Pizza on Nostrand! Try the Chick Ranch Pie everyone loves it

Always quick service. When I go after school, it's usually pretty empty. About 3:00pm. That being said, some days it fills up pretty quick with students from MECPS down the block. The pizza's good. They have a ton of menu options that I've never tried e.g: wings, pastas, sandwiches.

My teens (children & their friends) LOVE Tonys! Great neighborhood atmosphere, like Cheers, where everybody knows your face. LOL. Tony the owner is soooo cool and Adam is outgoing and always with a smile. I'm Caribbean American, but Italian Tony's Pizza has some of da best, Da Best Jerk Chicken !! If you haven't, you need to try it this weekend!!! Trust Me!😃😉

Always delicious! I will say it's best to pick up the pizza yourself. I once had a delivery with the top of the box pressed on the pizza due to the delivery person placing items on top of the box. Other times I received an extremely cold pizza that had to be immediately reheated due to long delivery times. It seems that during busy times, they don't always cut the pizza in consistently even slices.

amazing food!!! i got mozzarella sticks and a cheese slice, and both tasted amazing, especially the marinara sauce that came with the sticks. the pizza was cheesy and warm, but i did knock off one star because the wait for the mozzarella sticks was a little longer than expected and there's no seating for that long of a wait. besides that, i do enjoy their food and will be coming back soon!

Paula J Pollard

They are a little slow I waited almost an hour for my food, that's the reason for the 4 stars. BUT in the end it was WORTH it! My meal was delicious that gets 5 stars. And the cashier never missed a beat. Even though she appears to be stressed from the revolving door of customers she took each customer in stride. And trust me some of the customers were annoying, (they were annoying me and I don't even work there 🤨) AND she still had a smile for ya when she rung you up. Now that's customer service! I'll be back. 😊

Farin Chowdhury

Freshly made pizza's and the staff is really good. But the crust is too "stretchy", maybe that's why I don't find it so perfect.

Trey Writer

Tony's has a great menu with a very patient & nice staff. I got the buffalo chicken salad and it was very good. I also got the small jerk chicken order but i ate that before i could take a picture lol, def a go to spot for food especually pizza, pasta and subs. They got 4 stars because i haven't tried their pizza yet , that's it!

Food is great but watch out for the cashier with the glasses he will try to over charge / overtax you, he usually wears a hat with the glasses

The wings and pizza are good; however, I made the mistake of ordering the chicken parm. The pasta was bland and tasteless and the chicken was unseasoned and dry.

Dirty (floors) the day that we visited and mediocre pizza that was reheated. Unprepared to receive the number of customers that they had, or any people at all really, at the time that we were there, which was ironically fairly busy. Good selection of (non-alcoholic) beverages though and seemingly decent enough service. Relatively forgiveable, but don't know if I will bother to give it a second chance another time.

Food is good but of you're the gatekeeper and point of contact, your attitude and demeanor should be pleasant. That girl that works the register is totally rude and pointless. How dare you throw my food in a bag and drop the back on the counter in front of me? Then when I ask you for garlic knots you tell me you dont sell that when the manager whom I just spoke with clearly told me we make garlic knots fresh. If you cant do your job right then why are you there? Again your the face of the brand. Think about it....

They did not put my order in after I paid and it took forever for me to get my food. By the time I got it I was no longer hungry, just angry.

Pizza was ice cold and tasteless, might have been the least seasoned food I've ever had in my entire life.

Lowest quality pizza I've found in Crown Heights; there are much better pizza places in the neighborhood.

I ordered from them through the Slice app last week on Wednesday October 28th. It was a good experience until I tasted the food. The mozzarella sticks were very good which was a happy surprise since it's easier to find bad ones at pizza joints and fast food spots. The problem was the actual pizza. I enjoyed the toppings but had to scrape them off to eat them because the crust was inedible. The crust at the end was too hard like a cracker and the crust under the toppings could NOT be cut by my teeth or my knife.

Ben Reilly

Just had their pizza and it's decent. Not bad, not good. Just there. Pretty expensive for just a large plain cheese pizza too. The reason for the 3 stars is because when I was in line waiting to pay, a guy behind the counter tended to someone else standing behind me. So you already lost a customer out of me from the rudeness. Dropping my review down to 2. Owner/manager can apologize in comments for small things such as order being wrong, but not for rude customer service? No one should have to put up with overly priced mid pizza with terrible customer service.

Lisa Modica

Ordered margarita pie this evening $35 pie. It could’ve been hot and it was ice cold definitely not worth it disappointed that was a lot of money for a cold pizza

Pizza good but there attitudes suck the girl that works there n the short mexican guy suck very rude

ordered to go and they forgot my drink, pizza was cold, and tenders were soggy. wouldn’t order this again

Very disappointed. The bacon on the pizza did not taste good,it was soggy and tasted horrible and the wings was very dry.Before it used to be crispy and taste good… but now it tastes horrible.

Awful and rude. I ordered from semless, my food was ready 2 hours later and on top of it, they made me pick it up. What's the point of getting your food delivered then ? And then they refused to give me napkins and cups.

Cooks made my order wrong & all of the workers got an attitude when I complained. The girl that works the register is really rude and unpleasant. Did not want to make my order over just through my money on the counter instead. Will never eat there again.

HORRIBLE. NEVER GOT MY FOOD. AND THEN GONNA CALL ME AN SAY DORRY NO DELIVERY GUY. YOU CAN COME PICK IT UP ETC. AFTER I ALREADY PLACED THE ORDER SMH HOURS AGO. HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE. NO WONDER THEY HAVE A BAD REPUTATION IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD.

That food is ehhhh sometimes OK most of the time bad when you call to order it's like a huge task you have to keep repeating your self even when you talk slow and loud it's always a different person but the same crappy attitude I wouldn't even bother there is so many pizza places around there with the same crappy pizza.

I ordered a cheese burger deluxe well done. Burger was still pink. All they had to say was sorry they busy. I lost $9 and had no dinner that night to eat. This has happen twice. Very rude and not professional with handling customers problems with food. They lost me as a customer!!

It was considered a good place . Until today . Ordered a bake zitti and they put my bake zitti in the oven with the plastic on , which the plastic cover melted into my food & was horrible to eat and dig plastic pieces out my food . Also , I ordered a beacon cheeseburger & they gave me a regular burger . While having me wait 30 min for the food for it not to be right . Last time I'll be going there and getting food .

The majority of the people writing reviews are either family of the staff or tourists because the pizza is HORRIBLE...An embarrassment to NY pizza! Canned tomatoe sauce on bread w a little cheese sprinkled on top...thats what they're selling

THE MOST SLOPPY AND DISGUSTING MADE PIZZA IN BROOKLYN . STRAIGHT TRASH. CHEMICALLY MADE CHEESE & LOW QUALITY CRUST . MADE FOR TEENAGERS. GO DOWNTOWN BROOKLYN FOR HIGHER QUALITY

One thing I hate is wasting my MONEY!! This is the 2nd time they messed up on my order…. 1st I should say they owe me as the owner stated over the phone from the 1st time now here we go again with the same mistake just backwards, then have the nerve to say they can just put this in this like anybody have the time to just walk back down there for their mistake. I will no longer spend my money with them cause I definitely had enough….. GOOD LUCK YOU ALL

I ordered a meatball parmesan with spaghetti and to my surprise it was the most horrible dinner I ever odered😡😠 The meatballs taste like cardboard and was stale as hell with no taste at all, the spaghetti was oily and the cheese was like clumps and you couldn't even chew it and really no sauce was on it😡🤔 This dinner was truly one of the worst I have ever odered and I couldn't believe that this place would service garbage like this to a customer!! I would never order from this place ever again or refer anyone there!!!! This was a learning lesson for me!

I ordered my food at 6:18pm for delivery, only a few blocks away, and received it at 9:10. This was after 3 phone calls to the restaurant. Two calls assuring me it was on its way then hanging up on me mid-sentence. And during the final call they started blaming me for ordering it through Seamless and that I would have to talk to the company because they did not have my order there. The employees then passed the phone around to each other talking over me when I tried to explain what was going on and I eventually spoke to someone (I'm assuming a manager of some sort) who actually sounded like he was listening and wanted to help. He found my order, apologized and said he never received the fax and would send my food over immediately. After nearly three hours, my food arrived and I did not receive a reimbursement, just two simple chocolate chip cookies they were probably throwing out at that hour of the night anyway. I reached out to Seamless and they tried to contact the restaurant but they did not answer. In the end, the pizza was just okay nothing special, the wings are decent - quite large and hot. I understand technology errors, and that was not my problem, it was the horrible customer service lying to me that my food was "on its way" when really they didn't even know my order existed. They seem to communicate with the "customers are always wrong" sort of attitude.

That star is for getting this tasteless pizza with marinara sauce flopped on top and very little cheese even though I requested no marinara and pesto instead. Instead of receiving the jerk wings I requested, I received some awful tasting buffalo wings ugh! Carlos was very respectful and polite. He promised to give me a credit for my next order! I seldom order out and this promise of a credit for jerk wings, just doesn’t make me want to order from Tony’s.

I am not a person to write reviews, but this ecperience was so horrible I had to write about it. This is a local pizza place that I would go to on a regular basis as well as order for delivery. The regular staff that I normally deal with have always been super nice to me. I called to place a small order for pick up this time because I was in a rush and wanted to get my daughters something quick. Tony the owner answered the phone and I placed my order. I called back because I forgot to ask how long it would take and he told me I quote " are you serious? Did you just call to ask me when to pick up this order. This small order? Are you serious. Listen its ready come and pick it up why dont you just come in and pick it up its very busy its very busy just come and pick it up its ready. I called back to speak with him to let him know that I was a long time customer that has ordered large meals before and he cut me off and said im just going to cancel your order and hung up on me. I cannot believe that an owner of a business would talk to his customers that way. I guess he doesnt care who he keeps as a customer and just deals with whoever is there that day. So unless your placing big orders dont bother. Unless its good enough for him he really doesnt care. If he can speak to me that way imagine how he is treating his employees. If I could give zero stars I would. I guess I will be ordering from the pizza place on Franklin from now on. You just lost a good customer over a disgusting attitude.

Supreme pizza has no meat on it. Charge more for a proper supreme or just call it onion pepper pizza

jUjU

Order name June A. You guys are refusing my refund from the order I made from slice when the delivery driver deadass delivered my food messed up

CAPTAIN BOSSLIFE

ORDERED 2 SLICES OF BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA GUY WAS GONA PUT SAUCE FROM A BOTTLE ON THE COUNTER I ASKED WAS IT BBQ OR BUFFALO HE SAID BBQ I GET HOME DID A FEW THINGS ROUND THE HOUSE WHEN I WENT TO SIT AN EAT I OPEN THE BOX TO FIND MY PIZZA COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE SPENT $9 JUST TO THROW IT OUT NOT EVEN ONE BITE WAS TAKEN NEVER GOING HERE AGAIN

Nikki G

I was starving and omw to Pitkin to grab a slice. Couldn't wait, and I always wanted to try this spot, so I stopped here. Horrible. The staff is very condescending. I paid $4.50 for a Margherita slice. Oh well, but at that price, what Italian restaurant in the world does not have Parmesan cheese. I was told that Parm is $9 a pound and too expensive to leave out for customers to put on slices. Insane! The staff was complaining about the community to each other and how ppl only come in for slices. So sad. Go to another area or franchise a pizza chain if you do not want to sell slices. Also, straight out the oven, and the slice was still room temp. Won't be back.

YouDontKnowMe OH

I placed an order through ubereats for extra pepperoni and extra cheese. I received my order and it only had regular pepperoni and cheese and this has happen twice. So I call the restaurant and let them know and the manager said all she can do is refund the money but she said that before when an item was missing and I didn’t receive the refund and I had to call her back the next day and place another order just to get the missing item. While I was on hold waiting for an answer about what will be done with the missing cheese I heard one of the workers which I then found out was the owner said seriously over extra cheese. That is not the point the point is I paid for an order and did not get what I paid for but yet this restaurant does not care at all as long as they got the money. I called back and told them Uber eats cannot refund me the money for the missing cheese and they was acting like they didn’t care and was saying they are really busy and was rushing me off the phone. I spoke with the owner and manager of this location at 850 Nostrand.

Regis Vasquez

I really wonder how a New York pizza spot can be so bad. I asked for a buffalo pizza and got This is $1 slice pizza spot selling pies

Josh B

Well I went in and asked about vegetarian slices the guy behind the counter said the vegetarian. I said oh what about the margharita? He said well there’s no meat on it is there? In a gruff tone. That’s rude. It’s like you tell me, I don’t work here so that’s why I’m asking. I just froze dumbstruck mumbling about possible animal fats, should have walked out. So I get a margh slice and it’s trash, the tomato bits taste slightly sour and it wasn’t even warm, like keep it in the oven till it’s piping how am I sitting down to a cold slice in the restaurant?? Also very oily. I had also gotten a small jerk chicken. The bottom most pieces of which were slimy and congealed, I was nervous giving that to my dog never mind eating it myself! 😢😱 Seriously not sure what’s going on here. Rude service, subpar quality, cold oily pizza. Never coming here again for my pizza, stick to kosher pizza on Kingston or Brooklyn dop in park slope. Please train your staff to provide humble, polite service. You cannot tell me does it look like there’s meat on that? Unacceptable. Now I drank a bunch of kombucha. If I die of food poisoning in the next day or so, note this location as responsible. 😭