Farin Chowdhury

Freshly made pizza's and the staff is really good. But the crust is too "stretchy", maybe that's why I don't find it so perfect.

Trey Writer

Tony's has a great menu with a very patient & nice staff. I got the buffalo chicken salad and it was very good. I also got the small jerk chicken order but i ate that before i could take a picture lol, def a go to spot for food especually pizza, pasta and subs. They got 4 stars because i haven't tried their pizza yet , that's it!

Ben Reilly

Just had their pizza and it's decent. Not bad, not good. Just there. Pretty expensive for just a large plain cheese pizza too. The reason for the 3 stars is because when I was in line waiting to pay, a guy behind the counter tended to someone else standing behind me. So you already lost a customer out of me from the rudeness. Dropping my review down to 2. Owner/manager can apologize in comments for small things such as order being wrong, but not for rude customer service? No one should have to put up with overly priced mid pizza with terrible customer service.

Lisa Modica

Ordered margarita pie this evening $35 pie. It could’ve been hot and it was ice cold definitely not worth it disappointed that was a lot of money for a cold pizza

jUjU

Order name June A. You guys are refusing my refund from the order I made from slice when the delivery driver deadass delivered my food messed up

CAPTAIN BOSSLIFE

ORDERED 2 SLICES OF BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA GUY WAS GONA PUT SAUCE FROM A BOTTLE ON THE COUNTER I ASKED WAS IT BBQ OR BUFFALO HE SAID BBQ I GET HOME DID A FEW THINGS ROUND THE HOUSE WHEN I WENT TO SIT AN EAT I OPEN THE BOX TO FIND MY PIZZA COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE SPENT $9 JUST TO THROW IT OUT NOT EVEN ONE BITE WAS TAKEN NEVER GOING HERE AGAIN

Nikki G

I was starving and omw to Pitkin to grab a slice. Couldn't wait, and I always wanted to try this spot, so I stopped here. Horrible. The staff is very condescending. I paid $4.50 for a Margherita slice. Oh well, but at that price, what Italian restaurant in the world does not have Parmesan cheese. I was told that Parm is $9 a pound and too expensive to leave out for customers to put on slices. Insane! The staff was complaining about the community to each other and how ppl only come in for slices. So sad. Go to another area or franchise a pizza chain if you do not want to sell slices. Also, straight out the oven, and the slice was still room temp. Won't be back.

YouDontKnowMe OH

I placed an order through ubereats for extra pepperoni and extra cheese. I received my order and it only had regular pepperoni and cheese and this has happen twice. So I call the restaurant and let them know and the manager said all she can do is refund the money but she said that before when an item was missing and I didn’t receive the refund and I had to call her back the next day and place another order just to get the missing item. While I was on hold waiting for an answer about what will be done with the missing cheese I heard one of the workers which I then found out was the owner said seriously over extra cheese. That is not the point the point is I paid for an order and did not get what I paid for but yet this restaurant does not care at all as long as they got the money. I called back and told them Uber eats cannot refund me the money for the missing cheese and they was acting like they didn’t care and was saying they are really busy and was rushing me off the phone. I spoke with the owner and manager of this location at 850 Nostrand.

Regis Vasquez

I really wonder how a New York pizza spot can be so bad. I asked for a buffalo pizza and got This is $1 slice pizza spot selling pies

Josh B

Well I went in and asked about vegetarian slices the guy behind the counter said the vegetarian. I said oh what about the margharita? He said well there’s no meat on it is there? In a gruff tone. That’s rude. It’s like you tell me, I don’t work here so that’s why I’m asking. I just froze dumbstruck mumbling about possible animal fats, should have walked out. So I get a margh slice and it’s trash, the tomato bits taste slightly sour and it wasn’t even warm, like keep it in the oven till it’s piping how am I sitting down to a cold slice in the restaurant?? Also very oily. I had also gotten a small jerk chicken. The bottom most pieces of which were slimy and congealed, I was nervous giving that to my dog never mind eating it myself! 😢😱 Seriously not sure what’s going on here. Rude service, subpar quality, cold oily pizza. Never coming here again for my pizza, stick to kosher pizza on Kingston or Brooklyn dop in park slope. Please train your staff to provide humble, polite service. You cannot tell me does it look like there’s meat on that? Unacceptable. Now I drank a bunch of kombucha. If I die of food poisoning in the next day or so, note this location as responsible. 😭