Scott Stevens

Truly excellent Italian fare! Enjoy the fine restaurant if you happen to be in Brooklyn! I shared a wonderful dinner with my son and sampled several of their specials... all were fresh, flavorful and tasty. We will return for another meal.

J Ponce

The service was top notch, absolutely ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️. They have a retractable roof and sting lights that curate a very cute, fun and friendly atmosphere. The food was delicious. We had the Brussel sprouts, spaghetti and the tiramisu. The drinks were also great.

LL C

I'd had this place on my list for a long time and finally got the chance to visit! I was not disappointed. We were seated on the outdoor terrace (which was pretty loud and cold, because of the AC). Volume aside, the food was amazing! Standouts: the tiramisu and corn pasta. A great neighbourhood spot, though a little pricey!

A Google User

We had our rehearsal dinner at Cafe Spaghetti and it exceeded our incredibly lofty expectations. We selected here after having a wonderful dinner, so we knew how good the food and service were. They still managed to absolutely blow us away with the level of service and quality of food. The meatballs, eggplant parm, and rigatoni were especially big standouts. We can't recommend having a rehearsal dinner (or even just a meal) highly enough

Alexis Eftink

This place is incredible. We had recently come back from a trip to Italy and didn’t think we’d ever eat the kind of food we got there. Cafe Spaghetti blew us away. It gives the quality and authenticity of true Italian in a cozy Brooklyn location. Highly recommend for a date night and to wow guests from out of town. The staff are also extremely kind. We waited only a little bit of extra time for our reservation (only about 5 minutes), but because of that, we were gifted with a very generous slice of tiramisu. Thank you Cafe Spaghetti for the heart you put into your food and service!

Ahmed Monessar

Cafe Spaghetti on Carroll Street is an absolute gem. The food is amazing—top-notch in every way. The service is warm and attentive, making the cozy atmosphere even better. It truly felt like I was at my grandma’s house, with that comforting, homey vibe that’s hard to find. This is a place I’ll never forget, and I’ll definitely be back again and again!

John Remus

Celebrated a birthday dinner here. Food was great. Atmosphere was excellent. We were seated in the back patio area, which was cooler than indoors, so you may still need your jacket. And all the staff were very friendly. Staff overheard me wish Happy Birthday and went ahead on their own with a candle and wishing Happy Birthday, too, when we ordered dessert.

Francisco Tovar

Service, food, cocktails and decorations are amazing! This gem of a restaurant is packed with flavor and everyone that works there was wonderful. As soon as we walked in the staff helped us find a spot for 2 in the patio, we had reservations but for the bar, fortunately enough, the hostess hooked us up! We had a wonderful experience, the server was really knowledgeable of the menu, the Amari and digestive list was great. We started with a tomatoe-pesto clarified cocktail and a Punt e Mes tonic while having olives, burrata and spiedini. Sunny and wonderful day, the whole patio was filled with families smiling, friends having a great time drinking cocktails and kids playing with an Italian scooter that’s part of the patio decor. The restroom is a tribute to Maradona in his Napoli days, from pics to Napoli scarf and pics from the old days, you can tell the attention to details they have in this restaurant. We had the Fussili grosso genovese ragu, this was unforgettable in the beat possible way! and finish with a tiramisú and a cold Braulio. Definitely coming back to have more Pasta-Amari indulgence!

+4

perle75nyc

The best Italian I’ve eaten recently. Upon entering, the chef greets guests warmly and the staff are all very friendly. The dining room is very small but they have a lovely outdoor seating area in front. The restaurant also has a cozy backyard with colorful table umbrellas, perfect for sunny days. Reservation are difficulty make because of the popularity but definitely worth the trouble. I was able to eat most of the items on the menu over two days. I enjoyed every bite from antipasti to dessert including the espresso. All of the dishes were perfectly cooked and very tasty. Definitely worthy of a return visit.

+33

Ozgun Saran

Cafe Spaghetti sits on the other side of the BQE, in the Columbia Street Waterfront District, and it’s absolutely worth the trip. Chef Sal Lamboglia puts out excellent dishes — you really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. But if you’re only going once, the eggplant parmigiana and the tiramisu are absolute must-tries. A charming neighborhood gem with standout Italian comfort classics.

Eunice Kim

Everything we tried was good. The baked clams weren’t that chewy and came with bread so that was nice cus the bread and sauce are always so good. Everything is slightly salty but good. My sister got this pasta with crab meat and there was a good amount of crab meat. The orecchiette had really good flavor but tasted slightly overcooked. The gnocchi was mid. Would get the crab pasta again cus it tasted better as I continued to eat it. Brussel sprouts were good and the crostini was good and had lots of hazelnuts ;) would get the salad again. Service was okay. They’d like you to place your whole order instead of breaking it into parts. We placed our apps in first and then someone came and asked us what we’d like and then clarified their preference. Family friendly. Lots of kids when we went and was a little loud but service was great with kids. Someone dropped their cup of water and they were really accommodating and kind.

+7

Shereena Thames

The service was good!!!! The hostess was nice and the waitresses were very attentive. I had the garlic twists which was fresh and hot. And the tiramisu was really good and greatly portioned. The only downside to me was for the price of the casarecce( crab pasta) , it felt a little underwhelming. Not really up there in terms of seasoning and flavor as well. .

Mildred M.

We had high expectations and found ourselves a bit disappointed by the food. the burrata appetizer just ok, the linguini with clams in white sauce dry, few clams, disappointing, overall ok.

+2

Came here once while it wasn’t busy and it was really good. Decided to come again for dinner on a Saturday night (it was busy) and it was very disappointing. We had to ask for bread over 3 times to 3 different people , once we got it the bread was stale. We got the chicken Milanese and it was cold , the layer of breading was so thick, that was all you could taste. Thought I was eating fish at one point because they must have fried in the same oil. Very sad seems like they can nit handle the volume.