Nice to know when you go out to eat you are not only getting high quality of the food all so the prices are extremely reasonable. You can tell the owner truly cares about his customers his food. overall great experience. We strongly recommend TV for a nice reasonable pizza and food delivery. But also recommends him for catering. He has catered numerous parties for me and I have yet hear one person complain about the food.

Loved the pizza, loved the meatball and eggplant parm!! Next time we're up in Goshen we are definitely going back and trying other good. Owners were absolutely gems of people! Service was excellent and honestly felt so comfortable being there.

Very excellent food & welcoming atmosphere. We had fettuccine Alfredo with chicken & an absolutely top notch chicken parm dinner (highly recommended). Erin made us feel right at home. Can’t wait to come back and try a new dish.

Authentic pizzaria in a super cool small town. Grab a full pie, they make their own sauce, the crust is delicious. Pick up a Caesar salad, homemade croutons, and some chicken tenders for the kids. Staff is super friendly and welcoming.

I ordered their Ceasar Salad with Shrimp and it was one of the best salads I have had in my life. The employees there were so welcoming and down to earth and they shared their nine year old Aloe plant with the restaurant decor, a true gold star in the restaurant. Their pizza and regular menu items are amazing as well. Altogether Amore's is an excellent place to eat at or order from.

Consistently fantastic pizza! Great NY pizza with a light garlicky finish on the crust. They also have sensational Stromboli's and hot heroes, along with delicious traditional Italian dishes. Today I had an off menu sandwich monstrosity, the "Fat" sandwich, this beastly hero was a cheese steak with mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders and gravy... it was down right amazing. Lastly and frankly most interestingly... the cupcakes. I've honestly never before been to a pizzeria that sells cupcakes let alone the artisan delicacies Amore's bakes. I'm always sure to try a new flavor when I stop by for lunch. Amore's is by far my favorite pizza spot in Goshen.

Excellent food. We had the Shrimp Insalata (twice). Very friendly staff, and enjoyable experience. The owner/chef obviously takes great pride in his work and restaurant. We haven't had the pizza yet, but I understand it is outstanding as well.

We just moved to Goshen from NYC, so of course, we tried many Pizza spots here. After sampling a white slice (excellent touch of herbs on the cheese) and a regular slice.... We have arrived. The city pizza fix is minutes away. Brian is awesome. Friendly, funny and even insightful (he pointed me to the local hardware store as well). Truly great pizza. We immediately went back for a pie. Thank you Brian. Thanks for real pizza in Goshen!!!

Some of the best pizza i've had in the Hudson Valley. Light and fluffy crust with a perfect crisp texture! Not enough pizza places nail the crust, what a pleasant surprise. Definitely coming back!

stopped by on our way home from Lego land, the food was amazing we were pleasantly surprised. Service was amazing, Will be back on our next trip.

Amazing place with amazing environment, the food was delicious and the people was very kind and welcoming. Thank you for this good experience!

Amazing pizza! Today we ordered cheese pizza, we ordered a extra large and it was huge . We got it delivered to Legoland , where we were staying . Customer service was amazing and im very pleased , im glad i chose to order from here . The delivery was very fast. Ive never tasted pizza such crispy and cheesy. 10/10 . Thank you for owners ! So happy with order.

We love amore's! The garlic butter crust is so craveable! Quality ingredients and always tasty! This is always our go to for pizza night! They also have yummy specialties and run awesome family specials, perfect for last minute dinner when I don't feel like cooking. I'd also recommend their beef patties! Yum!

Simply delicious pizza. We had a small gathering and had a variety of choices. The cauliflower cheese pizza was my favorite. I would have never known if someone had not told me it was cauliflower. The garlic knots were really good, they were soft and not doughy. The Buffalo chicken pizza was fantastic not too spicy. The staff was super courteous and the owners very nice. Definitely made sure we were all satisfied. I highly recommend this place for all your pizza cravings.

Great pizza shop! Excellent food and service! Support your local business!

The pizza was great, loved the garlic crust!

My daughter said this was the best gluten free pizza she has ever tried. The regular one was so good too. And freshly made garlic knots. Our kids are all different. One does not eat gluten, another stays away from dairy, and the boys are just picky. They have made us a dairy free gluten free pizza. Everything was very tasty.

First time there. Service was awesome and the pizza was so good... She didn't know I do reviews. But I definitely recommend you go there and try it out. I will be going back. It's so hard to find a good pizza place in Orange County, NY...

Best pizza in town !!! I highly recommend the pene vodka chicken pizza ❤️

Decided to select this pizzeria based on the reviews after a great outing with the family. The pizza was excellent- fresh seasonings and a well balanced crust that melts in your mouth. The wings were also quite tasty and the sweetest gesture was presented to lighten the spiciness so my daughter could enjoy it as well. Great staff and service. I would say it's the town's best kept secret especially since we are from NJ. Well definitely dine here again if we are in the area.

Family favorite. We love the pizza, it's delicious and reasonably priced. We usually add garlic knots to the order. Everyone is nice here. You can dine in or sit outside weather permitting. There is parking in front and across the street. Highly recommend.

This is a must if you’re staying or finishing legoland. Pizza was fantastic! You can taste the garlic in the sauce. The wings were delicious. Erin and the team there took our order closer to closing hours and promptly got our order together. Not only was the food ready when we picked up but Erin made sure we had what we need to enjoy our food back at the hotel. Great food, Great Service, can’t ask for more…especially when you have a hungry bunch waiting.

Excellent taste, good portions and kind staff! We tried almost every salad and pizza slices, they were all delicious. The tomato sauce and dough were amazing! Very good example of New York style pizza.

Just moved to Goshen from the city, and we were looking for a good pizza spot. Looked at a few places and ultimately chose Amore's for carryout. They didn't disappoint. I picked up a large cheese pie, some wings, and garlic knots. Brought it back home, and the family ate it up. The pizza dough had a good crunch and chew, which complimented the cheese and sauce nicely. The crust was also lightly coated with what I think was some olive oil and garlic. The wings were well portioned and cooked perfectly. And the cheesy garlic knots tied everything together nicely. I would definitely recommend this place. Thanks Amore's

The pizza and garlic knots are delicious! We had plain and vodka sauce slices. Great place to come with kids, too! Service is quick and great as well. Def enjoyed our time here.

Great little gem in a small town. Everyone knows everyone, and they even treat the "outsiders" like myself with friendly smiles and wonderful conversation. The pizza smelled and looked good, but I got a pasta meal, chicken piccata. Large portions with so much flavor. Their garlic knots were on point. Would definitely visit again, and I highly recommend.

My son has discovered a new pizza haven! My son loves this pizza because the crust is garlic flavored. I ordered for a pepperoni pizza and a Caesar salad with shrimp, they are both great! I highly recommend.

The pizza here is soooo good. The seasoned crust is my favorite part! Garlic knots are also amazing and you won’t find better service. Great owners, wonderful atmosphere, a must stop in your rotation of eat out or takeout selections Edit to add: eggplant parm hero and white pizza are my fave. Must try.

The absolute best pizza place around! The food is amazing and the prices are great. Everything I have tried from here so far has never disappointed. Highly recommend ordering from this place for your next pizza night 🍕

I drive for a living and stopped in here tonight because of the great reviews and boy am I glad I did. The pizza was one of the best slices I’ve ever had. The guy behind the counter was very friendly too. They don’t take credit cards and my bill was $8 and I only had $6 in cash but the guy said it was alright. I will definitely be back to Amores when I’m in this area! Thanks so much!

First time ordering here after my friend recommended it. Coming from someone who is use to city pizzerias i have to say that my expectations were exceeded and this was by far one of the best pizza I've eaten in the upstate area. Food was done at given time and I didnt have to wait. Also cooked to perfection. You can't beat the prices for their quality pizza. This is my new go to spot.

My sister has been going to the gymnastics school next door for 4 years and you can't help but smell the aroma as you walk through the lot. We make it a point to eat here after class and we are never disappointed! The smell matches the taste perfectly! The pizza is perfectly cheesy, the sauce not too sweet not too acidic, and the crust is perfectly thin. The garlic knots are next level and a must have sidekick. My favorite thing about this place, besides the food, is the owner. I love watching him make the pizzas and he never fails to ask you how everything was when you dine in. This is definitely a hidden gem and hands down my favorite pizza place!

Pizza is great here. Always have lunch here every day I can. The teriyaki chicken slice is my favorite. Very nice owner and staff. Real family atmosphere when you are dining here. I recently got The family deal( pizza and 1 dozen wings and soda.).. The wings are amazing. Everything is great here.

Got the chicken teriyaki pizza today and believe me I was not disappointed,sooo good

Delicious pizza! Perfect crust and flavorful sauce. Service from Brian and co was great. We were a large group of 5 adults and 3 kids and enjoyed their pizzas, garlic rolls and wings. Will definitely stop by on our way back and forth from manhattan to Catskills / Hudson valley area next time.

I wish I could give 6 stars for Service - After making the mistake of ordering food at LegoLand I decided to leave the family at the hotel while I tried to find edible food for the three of us. I stumbled across this place and was absolutely floored by the generosity of the staff. Instead of making me buy individual slices, they let me take a whole pizza that *was* intended for slices at regular price. I wish I could explain the difference in quality between their food and the stuff available at LegoLand, but trust me when I say - this is great pizza at a fantastic price. The garlic knots, Neapolitan pizza, and old-school Sicilian pizza are delicious, nearly worth the 900mi drive to Goshen on their own! No joke - when I got into the elevator to head to our room at Legoland, another guest smelled the delicious aromas of the fresh pizza and garlic knots and said "Man I wish I'd have done that instead of going to the bricks family restaurant." If you're staying at LegoLand and want a Pizza or three, give these guys a call!

Pizza was really good (when you have to lightly pat oil off your pizza with a napkin, you know it’s going to really good, and not some dry cardboard) and the servers were friendly. I asked for just three garlic knots instead of the serving size of six and they didn’t charge me for them although I told them to do so.

I had a slice of their grandmas style pizza and it was out of this world! I can’t remember the last time I had a slice that good. The sauce is chefs kiss, just the right amount of garlic and the crust was the perfect texture. If you stop in that’s the slice to get!

Always a great place to eat. I purchased the pizza kit to make at home with my son. All went well. Delicious as always. Thank you Amores for the great quality of food you are known for. if anyone like chicken teriyaki pizza. You have to try Amores. Its excellent here.

Have ordered from here a few times now and the food is always delicious fresh hot and consistent every time definitely one of the best in town❤️

Just amazing crispy pizza and polite quick service. Definitely one of the best slices in the area. I love it

I had a problem with my first order, but the restaurant went out of their way to make it right. I appreciate their efforts in the result was a very tasty and beautifully presented dish. I will definitely be going back again.

A real New York style slice. Home made dough, home made sauce. The owner is a really genuinely nice person, and he hand tosses every dough. One of the best pizza joints I’ve been in in a while.

We had a wonderful experience tonight at Amore’s Pizza. The pizza was amazing and they were able to make personal dairy free pizzas for our kids. I spoke with the owner on the phone prior to coming and he reviewed all the dairy free, allergy friendly options. As a group we had two personal pizzas with dairy free cheese and sausage, a chicken bacon ranch pizza, a buffalo chx pizza, and a loaded philly cheesesteak pizza. It was all delicious, especially the crust! Absolutely recommend Amore’s.

Excellent service, the food and pizza is spectacular and there is also variety in the menu. Highly recommended

Pizza 'good'. Nice taste. Not thin. Marinara sauce very tasty. Meatballs good.

Really enjoyed my visit. The pizza was great and the staff was very friendly. The garlic butter crust is awesome 👌

I tried something new a cauliflower pizza after seeing an advertisement on the wall inside of Amore’s. If I didn’t know it was Cauliflower I would have never guessed. Also made me feel better about cheating on my diet. Thanks for the new experience, it was delicious!

Pizza was so delicious and flavorful. Service was wonderful. We are from out of town but would absolutely come back when coming through again.

Me and my wife came here for valentines day and wow the dishes that were recommended were awesome .

Friendly, fast service. Delish food and fair prices. Highly recommend for a bite to eat either dine in or take out.

Food was very good! We came in with an hour to closing, they were very accommodating and helped us decide what was best for our family. All the way down to cutting some slices smaller for our kids and putting the finishing sauce on half of the crust. He also offered some helpful suggestions for places while we were in town.

Ordered a family meal to go, for a Friday it was done quickly. Even after a drive home the food was great. My kids were very happy. Highly recommend the Garlic knots and wings!! Here years later and the garlic knots are still the best! even the baby gets down.

Absolutely cool pizza place. The employees were super nice and the food was outstanding. Highly recommend!!

All the food was super delicious and the staff was soo friendly!! We’ll definitely be back next time we’re in town!

Everything is great here! We order from them often. Great pizza, garlic knots and the best mozzarella sticks! They have a cute area outside in the back you can sit and enjoy lunch on a nice day. Inside is great too. Family owned business by really great people. Lots of great choices on the menu!

Best google search ever! After an exciting day at Lego Land and being out-of-towners with a child who has food allergies, the quest for an allergy-friendly restaurant was on. We turned to Google and found a true gem: Amore’s Pizzeria. Upon arrival, we were a bit skeptical due to its unassuming exterior. However, our doubts vanished the moment we walked in. We were welcomed like family, and the staff was incredibly attentive to our extensive list of allergies (egg, dairy, and tree nuts). The young lady at the front took the time to consult with the owner, Brian, to ensure everything would be safe for our son. The result? Delicious wings and an allergy-friendly pizza that our son declared as the “BEST pizza he’s ever had in his life.” Amore’s Pizzeria didn’t just serve us a meal; they provided a memorable experience filled with warmth and exceptional food. Brian, your dedication and hospitality were truly appreciated. We are seriously considering moving to New York just for Amore’s! We will definitely be back, and we’ll be sending fellow Lego Land visitors your way. Cheers to Amore’s Pizzeria!

Absolutely one of the best pizza places around! The pizza is always fresh, flavorful, and made with care. The crust is perfect, the ingredients taste high quality, and every slice feels homemade. The staff is friendly, welcoming, and makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit. Whether you dine in or take out, the experience is consistently great. You can really feel the passion behind the food. Highly recommend to anyone who loves real, delicious pizza!Keep going Sam !!Don’t give up ❤️

I had an amazing experience Amore’s pizza place! From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm and inviting, with friendly staff who made us feel right at home. The service was quick without feeling rushed, and everything came out fresh and hot. The pizza was absolutely outstanding — perfectly crisp crust, rich and flavorful sauce, and generous toppings that tasted incredibly fresh. You can really tell they use high-quality ingredients. Every bite was balanced and delicious, whether you love classic flavors or something more unique. What really stood out was the consistency and attention to detail. The cheese was melted just right, the crust had the perfect crunch on the outside and softness on the inside, and even the sides were top-notch. If you’re looking for a place that delivers both incredible taste and great service, this is it. I’ll definitely be coming back — highly recommend!

We ordered from Amores Pizzeria for the first time and it ended up being our very first meal after having our baby — delivered right to the hospital! It wasn’t planned, but they were one of the few places open, and let me tell you they absolutely did not disappoint! We ordered a Caesar salad, a chicken parm hero, and chicken tenders, and everything was delicious. The chicken parm hero was STUFFED and so satisfying. Delivery was quick, and they even reached out to clarify a question, which we really appreciated. Highly recommend Amores — we’ll definitely be ordering again!

We've lived up here 2 years now. Always looking for the best pizza around. First time getting pizza from here. 100% our new spot. Everything was 10/10. My toddler ate all of his food which is rare lol. And they even helped me out to the car with the food since I had my toddler was with me. We will be back very soon!

Lauren Miranda

My bother was always talking about the pizza here and how great it was. I’ve been struggling to find good pizza in the area, so he ordered me a pie and had it delivered to my house. The driver was sooo sweet and friendly; really good with communication! The pizza was amazinggg, so close to the pizza I had growing up in Mahopac. We got the chicken parm. Super yummy! ☺️

Donna Small Loverso

You must visit this sweet little pizzeria and say hello to the owner "Sam"! We happened to be in the area for a doctor's appointment and we were getting hungry and we happen to be in Goshen which is a lovely town!!!! It's so beautifully renovated and we happen to find this little restaurant with great reviews call Amore's pizzeria and restaurant. What made our time there valuable was meeting the new owner Sam who has been wanting to open a restaurant for many years! He's so ambitious and willing to learn and take good care of people that's what will make a very successful person in business!!!!! His pizza was so delicious and crunchy and we ate every bite, I had the Caesar salad also and didn't leave a piece behind. We wish you the very best Sam this year in your new pizzeria and when we come into the area we'll be stopping by again!!! 😋🍕😋🍕😋🍕❤️. Donna and Vincent 🙏🏼❤️

Tiffany

So I was visiting my niece in goshen and drove all the way from the Bronx and we stopped in here to have a nice lunch for all of us. We got chicken parm, chicken fingers and fries, wings, chicken francese, and grandma slices. I have to say this was the best food I’ve ever tasted. I would literally drive from the Bronx to this place for their chicken francese alone! The best I ever had. Hands down! If I could give more than five stars I would! Absolutely amazing!

Diane Hyde

Ordered pizza and a dinner about a month ago when daughter and son-in-law were visiting from out of town. They both raved about the food and said it was the best pizza they ever had while in Orange County. I decided to order from the catering menu for two days after Christmas to serve to my whole family. I ordered a whole tray of the penne ala vodka and a whole tray of chicken parm and it was all phenomenal! So delicious, beautifully prepared and everyone couldn’t say enough good things. It had snowed heavily the night before but everything was ready, hot and delicious at pickup time. Amores will definitely be our go-to from now on for all our pizza, dinners and catering needs!

Christine

Great service, people and food! I have always been greeted like I was family! They make anything a very pleasant surprise. They have some great chocolate chip cookies too!

david gonzalez

This pizzeria is the best I literally went to all the pizzeria in goshen and believe me it's really good. You try the rest Now try the best. Go there or place your order they deliver.

Noa Pallejà

The service was excellent despite arriving late; the waiter treated us very well. The food was fantastic and my absolute favorite was the wings. 🙂‍↕️ Without a doubt, if we come back here, I would go to this restaurant again. Thank you very much and keep it up

Sara

We’ve been tasting all the different pizza places in Goshen since we moved here and we’ve had Amores twice now. It is the best in the area followed closely by Sorrentos. Perfect cheese to sauce to crust ratio, always cooked perfectly, absolutely awesome taste, it doesn’t even need extra seasonings or cheese. Also, their customer service is always great, the pizza is always hot and ready when we get there and the staff are so kind and work really well together. Great place!

Danny Gonzalez

Great food, service and nice little cozy place. The soup was amazing.

Justin Cunningham

Decided to try Amore's on our visit to nearby Legoland. The food did not disappoint and the service was excellent! Our family of four (two adults and two kids ages 5-10) had leftovers from the Family meal deal (Consisted of cheese pizza, salad, garlic bread, and baked Ziti) We found on-street parking out front fairly easily this particular time, meter was paid with coins. The place is a bit one the small size, but was very flexible and there was no wait for a table while we were there. They accommodated another party of 8 while we were there. They did a fair amount of carryout and delivery business, too. Overall, our family was very pleased and satisfied - we would definitely visit again.

william costa

Owners extremely nice and personable! Got the cheese ravioli and sauce was amazing! Ravioli was al dente and delicious! Pizza is great. Visiting from CT at LEGOLAND and definitely recommend this is you're in the area!!

Jenna Gillespie

Had a kid’s birthday party nearby and ordered pizzas from here. They were on time and delicious and so nice! Recommend for sure!

Tab Scott

I grew up my whole life 5 minutes down the road from amore’s and it has been my favorite pizza. I don’t live here anymore so when I do come back I make sure to stop in for a slice of chicken brocclie teriyaki. Sounds crazy but i swear it is so good. Well the last time i went in to my suprise it was new owners. At first ai was a little upset but I spoke to the new owner, sam, and he made me Chicken and brocclie teriyaki even though it wasn’t on their menu !!!!! Amazing and his sister sonia was also beyond kind. The food was great and I appreciated the nice gesture. If you’re in the area I would definitely make this your go to pizza spot.

Christina Verdi

This place is wonderful!!! Food was delicious, people were so kind and welcoming! I’m not from the area but believe me when I find myself around this town again I will be back!!!! Keep up the good work new owners you are killing it !

Nicholas Kovach

Great place to stop if you get tired of the resort food down the street. They have slices to go and whole pizzas. The pizza is delicious - highly recommend the garlic sauce on the crust. Beware that the garlic sauce is made with fresh garlic so it may bite back. There is street parking and they have tables if you don't want to get it and go. They were tossing dough the entire time we were there- thin tasty pizza was the result.

+2

David Sanders

We were extremely pleased with our experience. We each ordered a personal pizza, my spouse with banana peppers and onions, me plain. Both pizzas were made to order and both were delicious. They were cooked "just right," with tasty sauce and cheese, and tender crust. The 8" pizzas were a nice amount of food; enough to satisfy us, without being so much that we felt stuffed. Staff was really nice.

Constance Wallace

I initially left a negative review following a disappointing experience during my first order from this establishment. However, I have returned to provide an update because they truly exceeded my expectations this time. The difference in our experience was remarkable, and the meal was absolutely delicious! My children enjoyed the food so much that we are placing another order tonight, March 5, 2025. Despite living 30 minutes away, we are more than willing to make the drive for such quality cuisine. They did make an unintentional error with my first order, but they promptly asked for a chance to resolve the issue , demonstrating exceptional customer service. Because of this, we are now loyal customers. Thank you from my family to yours!

JonKeith Barnes

The owner and the young guys working tonight were amazing. My coworkers and I were the only ones in the restaurant and they treated us like we were guests in their house. The pizza with all meats was the best I've had in a long time. When he said that he was gonna put all the meats they had on it, he wasn't lying. And it wasn't too much to where it took away from the consistency with the pizza sauce and crust. Altogether it was great and I would recommend to anyone wanting pizza dining in. And they deliver too!

Esther P

Great family-friendly pizza spot! Street parking available. The pizza is very tasty and so are the garlic knots! You will not be disappointed!

Scott Silverstine

You just can't make this up. This pizzeria relies on a family pizza recipe that has been passed on by four generations. Yes this family secret covers the garlic oil brushed on the crust, the doe, sauce, the cheese combination and right up to the baking time. So knowing this I knew that Amore's was just not any hole in the wall pizzeria. And I confirmed this with my first bite into a slice loaded with thinly cut pepperoni. The toss salad was as fresh as it can get and pasta dishes looked fantastic. Lastly, try the garlic knots cause they are delicious.

+2

The pizza was fantastic, esp. the crust! The restaurant doesn't have much room inside but it has some outdoor sitting which can work well. The restroom light is a switch pad that is put further in on the wall than I normally would normally expect.

One of the pizza places on Goshen area! They put garlic butter on the crust of the pizza, yummm I highly recommend their wings too, nice and crispy, not chewy skinned wings!!

This is a solid pizza place! We ordered a variety of pizzas for our family and everyone was happy with the quality. If you want classic NY pizza, you're in the right place!

I went to Amore's Pizzeria for the first time, April 2023. I will say that it was purely to try their pizza. So I ordered a pie to go. While I waited I looked around a little bit. The restaurant is a little on the small side. I would guess about six tables. Maybe more, but not many, if there are indeed more tables. They had a television for folks who may want to watch with their meal. The restaurant seemed sufficiently clean and organized. The two people working when I was there were friendly. I suspect they might have been the owners. The price for the large pizza was not cheap. But to be fair to Amore's, no place is cheap any more. With the much higher costs of the ingredients, the price is probably fair. I can say they were a little less expensive than the restaurant I use near my home. So they are pretty good there. The pizza was ready in approximately the time as promised. I left with the pizza and we ate very close by. Three of us sampled the pizza. Two of thought it was very good. One thought it was good, but stressed that they have had much better. But to be fair, much worse as well. And did say it was good and would order from them again. I can't comment on other food offerings or table service, as I didn't sample them. But what I did experience with Amore's, was a decent little restaurant with decent pizza.

Solid pizza place, they had some gluten free and vegan accommodations safe for my anaphylactic kiddo

4.00 dollar slice and its a kiddie slice .guy seemed more interested in his phone than helping me too!

This is the worst pizza I’ve ever had in my life. School pizza and Eliios frozen pizza taste 4X better than the pizza from Amore’s pizzeria. Just moved to Goshen and thought , I’d give the local pizzeria a chance, the pizza had no flavor and tasted like cardboard. I order a Bbq chicken, Hawaiian and a regular cheese pie all completely atrocious, even the dog didn’t want it. Guess you can’t trust google reviews because somehow this placed had a 4.7 🤦🏻‍♂️

This is the best rated pizza around Legoland so gave it a try... And walked away very sad and very appreative. Sad that people in this beautiful town think this food is good, and appreative that I live in NYC with actual delicious food. Everything here -- the pastas, pizza and sandwiches -- were not only bland, but left a very bitter aftertaste. Please learn about salt and Italian seasoning. Oh, plus we waited 50 minutes for our food. One plus, the staff was very friendly and helpful. I just wish owners took a trip to Brooklyn or the Bronx one day to see how it should be done. I hate wasting money on food and this was a genuine waste. Sad.

I've given them several opportunities since moving up this way from Queens. Rather disappointing food. The pizza is never consistent. Sometimes very undercooked. Sometimes burned on one side. And the pizza at its best is very lackluster, bland and the cheese is just so clearly store bought oversalted garbage .. The chicken parm hero is very oily and the chicken - like the pizza - is seriously lacking in consistency and quality control. Some pieces are very overdone and rubbery while other pieces are floppy and undercooked. Also, you're supposed to marinate the chicken in the sauce and bake for flavor. Not drip a little sauce on top. Not very good at all. I tried the stromboli and was very impressed at the size of it for the price. Which then worried me why the price would be so low for something so big. The moment I picked it up I could tell why. It was sopping wet with oil and it had even soaked through the pizza box and bled onto my table. The contents were very poorly evened out throughout the meal, and mostly consisted of their very salty and flavorless mozzarella. The dough was cooked properly which was a surprise, but it was floppy and dripping in oil and was a complete mess to eat because of the amount of oil it dripped everywhere. Even though the crust looked like it was cooked properly, it didn't matter because of the amount of oil it was forced to absorb and the whole thing was just a two foot nightmare to try and eat. Lastly was the canoli. When you think of a canoli you think of a crispy outtershell covered in powdered sugar with a savory sweet filling. The filling however tasted of mostly ricotta cheese and really lacked in that savory sweet flavor that makes canolis a beloved treat. The shell itself was soggy and mushy, and even picking it up to eat it it just broke in a mushy and unappealing manner. Think of a cookie left inside milk for way too long minus the sweet deliciousness of the cookie. That is simply not how you make a canoli. Total junk and I'm betting these too are store bought and left in a fridge for way too long until some sucker buys one. $4.50 for a total mushy slop lacking in any real savory or sweet flavor. I understand that I have a very high set of standards for Italian food coming from Ozone Park and Howard Beach in queens and that I have yet to find truly good pizza anywhere. Pasta Della Nonna at least delivers good quality Italian food 10 minutes down the road near Chester, but good pizza and a quick bite of fast Italian eats still seems to elude me since moving to Orange County. However out of all the places I have tried, this is by far the worst... And I personally feel anyone leaving a positive review here is either family of the owners or has never once had real Italian food and therefore has no understanding of how good the simplicity of cheese, tomatoes and homemade dough can be when assembled properly and cooked with attention to detail, and clearly lacks any real standards for themselves on where they should spend their money for good, reliable Italian food. I'd give less than one star if I could. What I will say is that the people inside are always friendly and chatty, and the delivery people are always prompt. The interior is pretty dated and boring but that doesn't really matter when you're just looking for a quick slice or 2 of decent pizza. Neither of this makes up for just how awful the damn food is. Anyone who actually likes this place really needs to rethink their life choices and travel anywhere south of Orange county to get a better idea of how good pizza really is when made by people who know what the hell they are doing.