Caylea

An amazing meal! We loved everything about Jeffrey’s Grocery. Super warm and friendly service that was attentive throughout the meal (honestly rare these days). Each dish was fantastic and so flavorful. Cocktails were stellar. The mussels were the best I’ve ever had. And you MUST get the Caesar salad!!! Only thing we would have skipped was the bisque (a bit underwhelming). Seriously, give this place a try! The vibe was great even on a Sunday.

+1

nimrod

We had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. The service was outstanding, and the staff made us feel welcome from the moment we arrived. We came in the afternoon for oysters and wine, and everything was fresh, delicious, and beautifully served. A perfect spot to relax and enjoy great food and great service. Highly recommended!

Kenzie C

Came here to celebrate a bday and it was great dinner choice. Being inside was such a vibe and the food was delicious! We got the crab dip, tuna tartar, lobster pasta, and steak frites. The portions were great and well worth the wait. The cocktails were also superb. Would definitely come back for another occasion!

BusyBurdie

Really fun spot for lunch or brunch!!! Love their fish and chips Friendly service Rodin was our waiter he was great thank you ❤️

+1

Guy C G.

The food and the service were fantastic. The menu has a range of options at various price points and the setting is nice, especially if seated outside. There is seating inside, however, it can get very busy. Overall, it was a great experience and I can highly recommend it.

Robert Marmorstein

My wife took me here for…I forget why lol. This place is incredible. We had the oysters, the smoked whitefish salad, the burger, and the lobster roll. Every item was better than the last. The oysters were fresh and incredible, the smoked whitefish salad slapped, the burger was insanely flavorful, and the lobster roll was so fresh, light, and perfectly seasoned. Garlic bread ruled and the cocktails were also great! Can’t wait to go back!

Tarek Farahat

Excellent food and warm authentic service. We loved the food. Lobster Roll was excellent . We also ordered spaghetti with lobster, as well as some oysters, and both were equally delicious. Service was great and very attentive . The place is dynamic with the bar being the “center of gravity” Not my first time ..and I would go again.

+3

Vivianne Barretto

Loved this restaurant. The vibe is casual. I had the Croquetes, which were delicious and the Clams, which tasted super fresh. Their Cocktails are pricey but very good. I sat outside but the inside is very cute with a nautical theme. The service is good. It's not cheap but considering the quality of the food, it's reasonable. I would definitely come back.

+4

Samuel L. Pittman

I’ve been going to Jeffery’s for 3 years—my favorite restaurant in NYC. From the sweet staff, to the cocktails + oysters + lobster pasta —Jeffrey’s is the best of the West Village, Manhattan, and NY. I highly recommend any of the oysters, the TLC martini and the lobster pasta. The crab dip is also amazing. Bar seating is super convenient and the ambiance is unmatched! Truly such a great experience, with wonderful food!

+2

Dipti Singh

We came here for Mother’s Day. They let me know ahead of time stroller parking was limited, but we fit just fine with our travel stroller. Our experience was great. We checked in early for our resy, while we waited the hostess came outside to give my husband and I water and said happy Mother’s Day and updated us on how much longer. Some of the items on the menu were sold out and we hope to try next time. We ordered oysters, shrimp, the lobster roll, and the burger. It was all sooooo good we love it. The cocktails were really good too! This place has great vibes and good cocktails and is especially so fun on a pretty day. We will definitely be back!

Haley Holmes

Oysters are what brought me in and oysters are what will bring me back. It’s about quality, not quantity. My server Nathan deserves a shout out! I went with his recommendations and y’all he was spot on: the lobster spaghetti had a tons of meat in it-the pasta was married to the sauce and I’m kicking my feet writing about it. The crab dip was a great addition to our oysters, definitely try with their homemade hot sauces <3 I heard that the Tuesdays fish tacos are really good too 👁️

Beata Zdanowska

Very cool, hip original NYC vibe place! Great brunch food and still pretty decent prices for the sizes! Loved it !! Best french fries I had in a long time! And one more thing: super friendly, efficient and pleasant staff !! A gem 💎

+3

Deb L

Great service, and a nice cozy environment. The food is pretty good, albeit a bit pricy. We were there on a Thursday, and got half a dozen oysters, the special (clam pasta with garlic bread), as well as the lobster spaghetti. The York peppermint patty at the end of the meal was a nice touch too.

Grace Liu

Such a vibe and experience! We only had the raw bar platter so might be bias, but the crab leg is not as fresh and juicy as I wish. Their French fries is a must for me though!