Anil Singh

Just go and get some bagels. It’ll be worth it. Fresh coffee, fresh bagels, what else can you ask for. Clean and upbeat inside with an awesome staff full of smiles on their faces and plenty of energy.

+1

Sean Motise

Great place. Bagels and all their sandwiches are awesome. Many bagel flavors to choose from. Very clean place. Quick service. Gets you in and out fast. Just not on Sunday because there's a wait.

Kathleen Burke

The freshest bagels, and goods I’ve ever had. The pictures are of a whole wheat everything bagel with bacon, egg and cheese and the other is an egg everything bagel with veggie cream cheese. Everyone gets better and better. The staff is quick so kind barley ever a wait, great prices and Evan is so sweet while making bagels and talking to customers . If you haven’t tried eastdale bagels you’re definitely missing out on something amazing 🤩

Chris Corman

First time but certainly not the last. I can't say in words how yummy these bagels are. Pitchured here is a various assortment of today's grabs. The Tuna salad was off the charts. The poppy seed melted in my mouth. Please give this establishment your business

Franz

It's a good little bagel shop in that area, the bagels are done right in the water bath. The New Yorker breakfast sandwich is really good. The bagels remind me of the bagels from NYC. The only negative is they don't have jalapeno bagels, they do have jalapeno cream cheese, but its not the same.

madhuri gaddam

I saw they are making bagels at the store itself in front of us, cool about this thing. Me and my friends too 2 everything wheat bagels with olive cream and jalapeños cream cheese and another garlic bagel with 2 Over well eggs and jalapeño cream cheese. The taste was okay, I don’t think my sandwich has enough cream cheese in it. Okay about it.As it was raining today, I wish it had at-least few little tables inside the store.

Michelle Neidkowski

We love Athena Gyro, and have been wanting to try this bagel shop for months hoping the food would be equally amazing. We visited last Sunday and although it was busy & hectic, it was worth the wait and service was attentive and polite. The interior is small and they are serving a large volume of customers, so yes it’s confusing if people are waiting to order but we had no issue being served. We had two bacon egg and cheese on an everything egg bagel and my son had a muffin and a croissant (neither of which I tasted) but both looked delicious. The bagel sandwiches were divine and quite filling and generous with the bacon. The bagels themselves were chewy and it was a really good sandwich. Perhaps next time I will order ahead, but I would like to try their bagels on their own. It’s been hard to find a good chewy bagel since moving to Dutchess a few years ago. These were pretty close to hitting the mark and I can see why they were packed on a Sunday morning.

Emily dorothy

These bagels are ok. They’re more dense and chewy which I’m not a fan of but the fillings are always good, I like their cream cheese and the bacon sausage and lox is super good but the bread just isn’t up to par for me 😔 Also $16 for TWO bagels is insane like a bacon egg and cheese should not be $8 this is highway robbery like it’s not $8 for a BEC in NYC these are super overpriced I was so shocked when I saw the total. But I guess they’re the only ones doing bagels in pok so they can do what they want .

Nancy

This place is too small for the volume they have... Chaotic the moment you step in, no idea if it's a line for food or waiting for food... Just no flow bc it's too small. Good bagels but annoying to get one. Everyone has to talk over the next person. Couldn't hear what the guy at the register said and I was a counter top away from him ... They need a new layout.

Michele Samuels

3 strikes and you're out. The first time I ordered from here everything was great but since then 3 times (in a row) I have ordered food (delivery) only for my item (the same thing each time) to be missing the ingrediant I paid extra for. It's too bad because the bagels are pretty decent but I am tired of not getting the thing I ordered/paid for made correctly. And it's not like my delivery person can open my food and check to make sure so I only find out when it's delivered to me and to reorder the item would not only cost me more money but then take another hour to get to me. No thanks.

danika galvin

Called at 1:45 to make sure they were still open. They said yes, they close at 3. Ordered for pickup wit a pickup time of around 2:30. Drive 30 minutes away and got there at 2:30 to find out they closed early and staff left. Doors were locked, no one was there but construction workers. And to make matters worse this is not the first time this has happened. Very disappointed.

What a disappointment. Been here multiple times and always liked their bagels and sandwiches. However, I will not be returning. Yesterday I went in with my wife, and it was the usual busy, maybe even more than normal. We placed our order and stood back to wait, knowing full well it'd be a while. After 35 minutes I went to check on our order because we saw so many customers getting their orders who had come in after us. The young worker started to look for our order slip, and then eventually found the order bagged and on the shelf for online order pick up. I said to him, you are calling out order after order to those ordering on site, why was my order placed and not called out. He said "we're busy", with an attitude, as if I shouldn't be asking. I said well that's not acceptable, the food is now probably cold. He replies with more of an attitude stating "It was a mistake, sorry". So I got my cold food and attitude from Eastdale Bagels. I get it, it was busy, and mistakes are made all the time, but to give me an attitude? What happened to customer service? I am a patron, and patrons are what keeps businesses alive, yet it was if this young gentleman blamed me. Never again, I do not go to businesses that treat their customers as if they were the problem. This young man was nasty and offered me nothing in return for the inconvenience they laid upon me.

Lauren H

Literally remove GF from your menu. Offering frozen bagels at a place that is made to order is ridiculous. Do better

Noway

Remove 'gluten free' options from your menu. The owners should be embarrassed by the offering bagged, frozen bagels that you can get at any grocery store. Cant wait for them to add a copy and paste comment showing how much they dont care. Just go to Empire Bagel in fishkill, they at least have a great GF roll option. I love watching the star rating go down because of their blatant lies just to get people to come there. And Eastdale sucks as a whole.